Home
News
You are here

Apple and HTC ordered by Judge Koh to reveal which patents are covered by their agreement

By Alan F.

Dec 07, 2012, 7:22 AM

Apple and HTC ordered by Judge Koh to reveal which patents are covered by their agreement

"The Court has just explained that the only sealable terms of the license agreement are the payment and royalty terms. Thus, the list of patents covered by the agreement does not meet the 'compelling reasons' standard."-Judge Lucy Koh

Judge Lucy Koh is back in the news two days before she is set to overhear post-trial motions made by Apple and Samsung related to their first patent trial. On Tuesday, Koh ordered both Apple and HTC to reveal which patents are involved in the stunning ten-year licensing agreement that both parties agreed to last month. Just two weeks ago, another judge mentioned by us quite often, Judge Peter Grewal, ruled that Apple's attorney's must hand over to Samsung's legal team, an unredacted copy of the agreement.

Judge Koh did say that information like royalty rates agreed to and device pricing will remain sealed for competitive reasons. Meanwhile, the judge said that other information in the pact will not cause competitive harm if released. Therefore, we expect to see Taiwan based HTC and Cupertino based Apple to reveal which patents are covered in the agreement.

Samsung had wanted to see if some of the patents covered in the agreement were part of its lawsuit with Apple, including the '381 and '915 patents which deal with the rubber band "bounce back" effect and zooming and scrolling respectively. Samsung might have wanted to see if Apple's rarely licensed "user experience" patents was included in the deal with HTC. Apple has referred to these patents as their "untouchables" since they are usually not licensed to other companies.

source: CNET

Story timeline

This story is part of:

Apple vs HTC lawsuit (5 updates)

Now reading

4 December Apple and HTC ordered by Judge Koh to reveal which patents are covered by their agreement Judge Lucy Koh is back in the news as she has ordered both Apple and HTC to reveal which of their patentsare covered by the ten-year licensing agreement that both manufacturers signed off on; the judge says that there is no risk of competitive damage by making this information public...
21 November Apple and HTC offer to show agreement to Samsung, but heavily redacted In the never ending story that is Apple’s and Samsung’s patent fight, Apple and HTC are ready to offer Samsung a look at their recently drafted license agreement...
20 November HTC Peter Chou says media reports on the Apple patent deal fees are "baseless" HTC chief Peter Chou is in Tokyo today to unveil the J Butterfly monster of a handset (think the Droid DNA, but with microSD slot), and he had some not very kind words to say on the Apple-HTC patent deal reporting...
17 November Samsung shows interest in Apple's deal with HTC Nearly a week after the surprising announcement that Apple and HTC had agreed to a ten year licensing agreement that put a halt to all patent litigation between the two, Korean manufacturer Samsung asked a court to order Apple to turn over a copy of the agreement...
10 November Apple and HTC reach 10-year licensing agreement; deal will settle all lawsuits between the two Apple and HTC have announced a ten-year licensing deal that settles all lawsuits between the two tech companies and covers all current and future patents; terms of the deal were not disclosed and HTC joins Nokia as having entered into a global licensing agreement with Apple...