x PhoneArena is hiring! Reviewer in the USA

Google Maps vs Apple Maps comparison

Posted: , by Victor H.

Tags :

Google Maps vs Apple Maps comparison
Google Maps for iOS is finally here! You can grab it for free on the App Store right now and end the struggle with Apple Maps, and good news is that the new Google Maps application comes with turn-by-turn navigation, and a completely reworked design.

It’s been months since Apple released iOS 6 killing Google Maps in favor of its own Apple Maps. Apple CEO Tim Cook’s official explanation was that the company wanted to add things like turn-by-turn navigation, voice integration and flyover, but while those are worthy reasons it seems like Apple just did not have good enough data for the back end. Google in contrast has spent tons of money and has a huge team working on Maps for years, and it is hard to expect Apple to work out miracles in the short time they’ve had.


Interface and design

But it is not just the back-end (we’ll speak more on this later), let’s start with the design of the brand new Google Maps for iOS. The application has been completely remade with a clean, gesture-based, intuitive interface. No useless buttons, almost all of the screen estate is used by Google Maps.

A swipe from right to the left in the bottom part of the screen, or just a two-finger swipe to the left brings up four toggles. There you can switch between maps and satellite view, turn on or off traffic and public transit indications.

When you select a particular place a swipe up from the bottom brings up the address along with contacts and user reviews, all very elegant, very intuitive and simple.

Compare this with Apple Maps, and its interface with no gesture support seems outdated (however still functional).

The maps themselves are vector-based in both Google’s and Apple’s case, and load very quickly. Google however seems to have managed to somehow optimize its app so it seems like the new Maps load even quicker than Apple Maps.

Overall, interface is a clear win for Google Maps, which shows us how Google is now more often leading the way in terms of mobile software design while Apple has to catch up.

      • Google Maps 1 vs 0 Apple Maps


Search, points of interest

Apple Maps search does not work as well as the one on Google Maps (Google Maps is on the left, Apple Maps - on the right)

Apple Maps search does not work as well as the one on Google Maps (Google Maps is on the left, Apple Maps - on the right)

What’s more important, though is search, and there Google Maps fares noticeably better than Apple Maps. Trying to lookup one of our favorite lunch spots in New York, we typed in ‘Silo cafe’ in both maps applications. Google Maps identified it and pointed us to the place without a hitch. Apple Maps? Could not even find it.

The place is on Apple Maps, though, so what happened? Two important things. First, you just have to be way more specific - Apple’s search algorithms work differently. We managed to find it only after changing the search query to ‘Silo, NY.’

Interestingly enough, search on Apple Maps is also much more context dependent. While in Google Maps you can be looking at a map of, say, Berlin (the one in Germany, not on the South Pole!) and out of the blue search for your favorite NYC lunch place, you’d get results. Apple’s app works differently.

If you are viewing that same map of Berlin on Apple Maps, the search just won’t find that New York lunch spot. However, if you are viewing a map of New York on Apple Maps, and then look up that same NY cafe, it would actually show up.

And then come less known points of interest, and challenges like locations outside the United States. We tried looking up a popular restaurant chain in Europe and Google was spot on bringing us all of the restaurants in a particular city. Apple? Could not find a single one.

The more we searched for things, the more it became apparent what a huge gap there is between Google and Apple when it comes to actual places.

Even when it does find places, Apple Maps needs more context in searches, but most often it just would not find them. All of this is a huge frustrating for users, and that’s why searching is definitely an area we see Google as a clear winner.

  • Google Maps 1 vs 0 Apple Maps


User reviews

Apple Maps integrates Yelp which is a treasure for the United States

Apple Maps integrates Yelp which is a treasure for the United States

Getting your search results isn’t always enough, though. Sometimes you lookup a place, but you still need to get a second opinion. User reviews could tell you things pictures won’t, and with Apple Maps integrating Yelp reviews, Google has a hard time competing with Apple Maps in the United States.

The accent here is on United States. Yelp is simply a great platform for the U.S., and in most cases it gives you a better user review of a place than Google Maps user comments can. However, you still need to download the Yelp app to be able to read the full reviews, and that somewhat breaks the integrity of the experience. Google Maps on the other hand has everything in one place, but everything means less opinions and less insightful opinions.

Outside the U.S., though, Yelp becomes largely irrelevant. Things change drastically in Google’s favor. If you happen to travel a lot, you’d be much better off with Google Maps’ user reviews.

Ultimately, we feel this one is a draw. Apple Maps integration with Yelp makes it the better platform for the United States, but for all other places on our beautiful planet Google is far ahead.

  • Google Maps 0.5 vs 0.5 Apple Maps


Directions and Navigation

Ironically, when you tap on the public transit option in Apple Maps it suggests you to open Google Maps for that.
When it comes to navigation, voice guidance is the raison d’etre for Apple Maps. With the new Google Maps application this justification for the existence Apple Maps becomes obsolete as the search giant has built in turn-by-turn voice navigation in its app as well.

Apple Maps suggests you use Google Maps.

Apple Maps suggests you use Google Maps.

Voice driving navigation works flawlessly on both apps, you get directions even if you lock your phone or exit the app in both Apple and Google Maps.

Directions differ slightly in the interface, but both apps do a decent job at them. However, the backend of more accurate maps and tons of more points of interest on Google definitely puts it in a much more favorable position.

Not just that, Apple’s solution does not have public transit information. Ironically, when you tap on the public transit option in Apple Maps it suggests you to open Google Maps for that. 

Cycling directions are missing on both apps.

If we try to overlook that, though, it’d be a draw.

Google Maps 1 vs 0 Apple Maps

Other features

Those four things round up what we think is essential to a maps application. However both Google and Apple have not stopped there and are adding more information to make the experience better.

First, Apple Maps. The company takes pride in its Flyover feature and we love it. It shows a 3D-like (isometric) view of major cities, as if you are looking at them from a helicopter up in the sky. You can fly around buildings, take a look from all sides, and it looks gorgeous. On the downside, the feature is only available for only the central areas of a few large cities like New York. Siri integration is also a benefit you get with using Apple Maps.

Google Maps lacks those particular features, but it brings its famous street view which seems far more useful. Street View is available in a ton of locations across the globe, and in some areas you even get inside view of restaurants and other points of interest. You also have the indoor view for around 100,000 businesses, which is an awesome addition in case you want to actually look inside say a restaurant before you go there.

When it comes to offline maps, they are a no-go on Google Maps, but once you select a route, it is pre-cached so you needn't worry about your connection dropping halfway.

  • Google Maps 0.5 vs 0.5 Apple Maps


Google Maps vs Apple Maps comparison
Conclusion

With a brilliant gesture-based interface, no distracting ads, full on public transit information that Apple Maps lacks, and voice turn-by-turn guidance, Google Maps is the best maps application we have seen up to date, hands down.

Compared to Apple Maps, it is a no brainer - Google Maps is better in virtually every aspect, especially looking from a global perspective. If you live in the United States, though, the disparity between the two narrows. It is still there, but with Yelp reviews integration, better documented locations, Flyover for many cities, the U.S. is one place where Apple Maps could be used.

Weirdly enough, we like Google Maps for iPhone more than Google’s own Android Maps application.

It is not perfect though. It does not have full offline maps support, an area that Nokia still claims its own on Windows Phone. It is also not designed to work with the iPad. We really hope Google changes the latter soon.

If you own an iPhone, though, you should definitely take a look at Google Maps. This could one day save your life, you know.




Final Score:

  • Google Maps 4 vs 1 Apple Maps

75 Comments
  • Options
    Close






posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:02 32

1. rahulcena5565 (Posts: 57; Member since: 01 Nov 2010)


Apple got Pwned.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:22 10

10. ahmed_ali_yossef2010 (Posts: 164; Member since: 26 Jul 2012)


apple fly over is awesome but when we come to information and satellite it's turn to aweful

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 19:45 1

62. rusticguy (Posts: 2828; Member since: 11 Aug 2012)


hmmm .. it's good if one is commuting on sesna which is rare as most use roads :)

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 22:22

68. Nadr1212 (Posts: 741; Member since: 22 Sep 2012)


Gee, how could Apple Maps not win with their horrible info and misleading landscape colors?!?

(I'm kidding)

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:34 23

13. SuperAndroidEvo (Posts: 4857; Member since: 15 Apr 2011)


Why do we even need a comparison? lol

Google Maps = Legit

Apple Maps = Flaky

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:34 9

14. MeoCao (unregistered)


Google Maps for iOS - Apple Maps: 4 - 1

Google Maps for iOS - Google Maps for Android: 5 - 0

The reality is hard sometimes.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 10:59 3

29. AmitMajumder (Posts: 178; Member since: 21 May 2012)


I don't understand, Why Google always give their best apps to iOS whereas Apple never gives a sh*t to Android? And its for free???

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:18 1

34. TheLibertine (Posts: 484; Member since: 15 Jan 2012)


You ever heard of "money" ;>?

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:41 1

40. AmitMajumder (Posts: 178; Member since: 21 May 2012)


How much money do they make if the app is free?

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 12:45

48. random1204 (Posts: 28; Member since: 26 May 2010)


That depends on the amount of ads in the app. Google gets paid a lot for free apps, actually.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 19:59 2

64. lyndon420 (Posts: 4559; Member since: 11 Jul 2012)


We already have a good nav app. Google is always making improvements to their services and probably have some nice updates baking for their nav app. Seeing as people were almost dieing from using apple maps, Google most likely jumped on the opportunity to help people in desperate need and at the same time try out their newest version of the app before we get it...you know...to make sure its perfect for us.

I like how the public transportation on apple's app suggests you use Google's.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 15:09

57. nnaatthhaannx2 (Posts: 820; Member since: 19 Oct 2011)


You beat me to it.
Google's Android team is really lacking when it comes to the stock apps. This new maps app is much better than the one on Android :(

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:48 4

16. Mxyzptlk (Posts: 14180; Member since: 21 Apr 2012)


Google maps has been around for a long time so it has had years of improvement. It was not perfect when it was released.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 10:03 3

18. darkkjedii (Posts: 22044; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)


It sure wasn't.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 10:23 18

24. MeoCao (unregistered)


Google was the pioneer so mistakes and errors were enevitable.

Apple is a copycat so it must be perfect or close to perfect.

You just can't compare the pioneer and a copycat.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 10:43 4

25. darkkjedii (Posts: 22044; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)


Nokia was the pioneer

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 10:57 8

28. MeoCao (unregistered)


For the global scale and investment of the maps Google is the pioneer, Nokia started making the maps after Google and the scale cannot compare to Google Maps.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:22 4

37. darkkjedii (Posts: 22044; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)


Nokia was the pioneer

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:27 4

38. MeoCao (unregistered)


can u back it up?

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:41 2

39. darkkjedii (Posts: 22044; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)


Call Nokia

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 12:00 6

41. MeoCao (unregistered)


Just called, Nokia said it was Google the pioneer.

They also said they have troubles selling Lumia 920 so leave them in peace.

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 13:29

50. darkkjedii (Posts: 22044; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)


Lmao that's a good one Meo

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 20:21 1

66. lyndon420 (Posts: 4559; Member since: 11 Jul 2012)


ROFLMFAO

posted on 14 Dec 2012, 03:50

70. bipinm (Posts: 124; Member since: 07 Oct 2012)


lol ....dude....that was awesome...

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:15 1

33. noim1 (Posts: 297; Member since: 15 May 2012)


MAkes me laugh ..how apple just makes a MAP app in just short months & call it "powerful & extraordinary"...come on they did not even mention the "Beta" tag ..

when you open the app 1st time they should have included a Disclaimer :
"The Maps app is in primary stage.we advise you to use it with caution.you might find yourself Lost or in another restaurant (if u have a DATE).If so we we cannot be blamed or b tangled in a lawsuit.Please have your eyes open & stay safe"

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 19:47 1

63. rusticguy (Posts: 2828; Member since: 11 Aug 2012)


What you don't see is Google was "developing & innovating" while Apple was just doing "Copying And Makeover" ... there's a huge difference between the two approaches so Apple Maps failure should be compared with Google Maps ... but i guess it's difficult to understand :)

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 13:46

52. AnTuTu (Posts: 1580; Member since: 14 Oct 2012)


Father is always father hence proved by Google and learned by fruit..!!

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:03 4

2. sorcio46 (Posts: 435; Member since: 27 Jul 2011)


Nailed It, Finally Google maps is back on iOS ;-)

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 11:07 3

31. noim1 (Posts: 297; Member since: 15 May 2012)


iPeople feel relief !!...Google just saved you from getting Lost .....this is a good way to show how Google works...& they r the BEST !!!

posted on 13 Dec 2012, 09:04 6

3. Nathan_ingx (Posts: 4003; Member since: 07 Mar 2012)


This must be a joke right??
iMaps compared to Google maps??? Phulezzzz...
Try this PA, search "Google" on iMaps...might actually point you somewhere!

Want to comment? Please login or register.

Latest stories