Apple iPhone 12 Pro/Max vs iPhone XS/Max

And, of course, with the iPhone 12 family just announced, those are your prime candidates. While the iPhone 11 and iPhone 12 are the logical successors to the iPhone XR, if you have an XS device, you might be considering an iPhone 12 Pro or Pro Max. Which immediately raises the questions: "How far have iPhones gone in two years?" and "Is it worth upgrading to the iPhone 12 Pro or 12 Pro Max?"

Well, that's what we're here to help with! There's plenty to go through, so let's get right to it.

Apple iPhone 12 Pro

- 6.1" Super Retina XDR, Apple A14 Bionic, 5G, Triple camera

$999

Buy at Apple

The iPhones from these two generations look similar but they're also quite different. How is that possible? Let us explain. 

A major difference is obviously the new flat frame of the iPhone 12 models, which makes them slightly slimmer and, of course, differentiates them from older generations. Besides that, the camera module is perhaps the biggest difference. Now two years old, the small, bean-shaped camera bump on your iPhone XS/Max is becoming a signal that you're using an ancient iPhone. Three cameras is where it's at now if you want to stand out among the iPhone crowd. But more about them later.

At the front, the displays of the iPhone XS pair and its 12 Pro equivalent look almost identical, with the notch still taking most of the top end and the curved corners and aspect ratios remaining the same. But the displays for both form factors have not only different sizes but different OLED panels as well.

So, what has changed? Well, the display gained 0.3 inches, making the whole iPhone 12 Pro slightly larger than the iPhone XS but probably not enough to make you consider another size if you're happy with your XS. The resolution was improved to match the new size and both phones have practically identical PPI (460 vs 458), so no big upgrade there.

What benefits you are getting with the iPhone 12 Pro, however, is better maximum brightness, which is why Apple calls it XDR (from eXtreme Dynamic Range). This will result in both better use in bright sunlight and a better video-watching experience. 

Another new addition is the so-called Ceramic Shield, which is how Apple calls the newly-developed glass that sits on top of the OLED panel. It has four times better drop performance, Apple says, which should make you more confident that your iPhone 12 will survive a few drops before the screen cracks.

Similar story, as you might expect. Some size inflation between the two generations, paired with the appropriate number of new pixels. We already explained the benefits of XDR and Ceramic Shield. It's worth noting that the iPhone 12 Pro Max has the biggest display on an iPhone yet. If you're eager for more screen real estate, you're gaining about 1 square inch or 6.2% more with the iPhone 12 Pro Max.

When talking about iPhone looks we can't forget to mention colors. The iPhone 12 Pro and Pro Max come in four colors: Pacific Blue, Silver, Graphite, Gold. Silver and Gold are identical to the ones on the iPhone XS models, with the differences that the matte finish on the iPhone 12 Pros makes the light reflect differently. And, of course, they feel different to the touch. Pacific Blue is a new color you can't get on any other iPhone and Graphite is a replacement for Space Gray and it's a bit lighter gray. As usual, the Pro models are getting the more subtle, toned-down colors.

This year, Apple introduced its first chip built using the 5nm process, just like the A12 was the first iPhone using a 7nm chip. The new architecture makes the A14 not only more powerful but more power-efficient as well. If you want some raw numbers, the A14 has 11.8 billion transistors versus the A12's 6.9 billion. That's close to two times more over just two years. We're sure your iPhone XS is no slouch even today, but the A14 is the definition of next level. 

But perhaps more important than the improved performance is the addition of 5G to all iPhone 12 models. Yes, the uses for it, as well as the coverage, are far from the level needed for 5G to actually matter in your daily use, but in a year or two, the situation could be completely different.

Apple is also finally offering 128GB as base storage, even if it's just for the Pro models, which means you can save some money by not upgrading to the 256GB variant. Apple is notorious for not talking about the amount of RAM on its phones, but the iPhone 12 Pro models are allegedly getting a bump to 6GB. 

Before we get to probably the most important part of an iPhone, its camera, let's talk about...

Battery capacity is another thing Apple doesn't usually share, focusing instead on how much the phone will last. Despite that, since the iPhone 12 Pro has now reached the hands of reviewers and tinkerers, the disassembly of the iPhone 12 Pro showed that it has a 2815mAh battery. While that's less than the 3046mAh battery capacity of the iPhone 11 Pro, it's still an upgrade over the 2659mAh battery of the iPhone XS.

For real-life use, for now, we can lean on the official data, which says that the iPhone 12 Pro will give you 17 hours of video playback while the iPhone XS only 14. That's a 20% increase. But if you've been using your iPhone XS for two years, the difference in battery life will likely be a lot more than 20%.

As for the bigger models, the battery of the iPhone 12 Pro Max was revealed to be a 3,687mAh or about 500mAh larger than the 3,179mAh battery of the iPhone XS Max. While that's around a 16% increase in capacity, Apple says the 12 Pro Max offers 5 hours more of video playback time (15h on the XS Max vs 20 on the 12 Pro Max), which gives you an idea of how much more efficient the new chip is, considering the 12 Pro Max has a slightly larger display.

Let's take a look at the results from our own battery tests.

As you can see, the difference is quite stark. If you're using the smaller iPhone XS, you can gain almost 5 hours of browsing time by switching to the iPhone 12 Pro. Even compared to the iPhone XS Max, the gains are quite drastic. And if you're upgrading from the XS Max to the 12 Pro Max, you'll gain about 5.5 hours of browsing. 

For video streaming, the iPhone XS is again by far the worst performer. The iPhone 12 Pro lasted two more hours, which is basically one movie more that you can watch on it compared to the iPhone XS. The iPhone XS Max did slightly better but still a lot worse than the new Pro and is miles behind the 12 Pro Max, which gives you 3 whole hours more of video streaming. 

As you can see, the numbers for video watching are far from Apple's 17 and 20 hours for the 12 Pro and the Pro Max respectively. Apple doesn't give details about the specific settings it uses to achieve these results. Mobile network connectivity, Wi-Fi, display brightness and other adjustments will affect battery life, so your results may vary as well.

Overall, depending on how much you use your phone, the iPhone 12 Pro will last you at least half a day more, maybe even a full day if you're not on it constantly.

Charging time sees an improvement as well although even the iPhone 12 Pro has an abysmal charging time compared to the leaders in the industry. You can use our tool to add any phone to the comparison and if you add the OnePlus 8T, for example, you'll see what we mean. 

We already mentioned the obvious fact that the iPhone 12 Pro and Pro Max have a third camera but the differences go far beyond that. What's also worth mentioning is that this year, there are slight differences between the iPhone 12 Pro and 12 Pro Max cameras, a first for the Pro models.

As it becomes pretty obvious from the table above, the two biggest differences hardware-wise are the added ultra-wide-angle camera and the LiDAR scanner. The former you're probably familiar with even if you don't have it on your iPhone XS. The latter, well, it's a new addition to iPhones that gives them a better way to take in your environment and where each object is by projecting infrared dots, similar to how the True Depth camera works for Face ID. On a more practical side, it helps the iPhone 12 Pro models track objects in a dark or low-light setting and keep them in focus for an even better shot.

But while on paper the main sensors on these phones might look similar, in practice, the iPhone 12 Pros have far more capable cameras. Here are some photo features they have that the iPhone XS is missing:

Night mode alone is enough for a lot of people to go for the upgrade since before its arrival the iPhones' low-light performance was atrocious. You'll see the difference for yourself once we have camera samples from both phones. It's also worth noting that Night mode can now also be used with the Ultra Wide and Telephoto cameras. 

Moving on to video recording, the list of improvements only gets longer:

Basically, the iPhone 12 Pro models are far superior video-recording machines, so if you're an aspiring YouTuber or just like to record videos of any type, the upgrade will be worth it. 

What's even better is that Apple is bringing a lot of these features to the front-facing camera as well.

Here's what the iPhone 12 Pro selfie camera can do that the one on the iPhone XS models can't:

Two years bring you a bunch of nice upgrades, that's for sure. Now let's check a few samples!

Curiously, the iPhone XS photo has the more natural-looking colors in this scenario. The iPhone 12 Pro photo has a slight orange tint overall. We're somewhat used to iPhone photos having a similar "effect" but such a difference between two iPhones is definitely unusual. Perhaps some of the surfaces in the background tripped the iPhone 12 Pro algorithms into making adjustments they shouldn't have made.

What's noticeable in these photos is that Apple has made tweaks to the color reproduction in the iPhone 12 Pro and as a result, its pictures look more natural. Exposure levels are also tuned towards brighter shots.

When it comes to portrait shots, these initial samples look almost identical, meaning at least in normal lighting conditions, you're not gaining much from the iPhone 12 Pro.

At max zoom levels neither phone is a winner. Colors are slightly different but detail levels are pretty much the same on both photos. Not really surprising considering both sport a 2X zoom telephoto camera.

In a few samples, including this 5X zoom one, we've noticed that the iPhone 12 Pro ups the exposure significantly compared to the iPhone XS. The result is a much brighter image, which also looks a lot better. 

Selfies are surprisingly similar despite the upgrade to a 12MP sensor this year. While you will get a larger photo that will have a bit more detail when viewed at a 100% zoom, in practice the iPhone XS selfie camera seems to be just as good in daylight.

Night mode is perhaps the biggest difference between these two camera systems, or at least the one that has the biggest impact on photo quality. While for the average user Dolby Vision recordings might not matter at all, Night mode is something everyone can appreciate and make use of all the time. And, as you're about to see below, the difference is striking.

There's pretty much no need for comment here. The iPhone 12 Pro trumps the XS at night. The 12 Pro photos look sharp, they're not overly bright as some phones tend to make night shots, and the colors are rich. You'd be happy to share these pictures on social media or even print out. Meanwhile, the ones from the XS aren't really worth keeping on your phone. 

Things only get worse when it comes to low-light portraits. The difference is day and night, without exaggeration. The iPhone 12 Pro has done a phenomenal job in this scenario. The only thing the XS shot does well is to show how dark the environment actually was, which only highlights the 12 Pro's achievement.

The difference between the low-light selfies isn't as huge but it's still pretty obvious that the iPhone 12 Pro is doing a much better job.

Overall, if cameras matter to you at all, you should be quite tempted by what the iPhone 12 Pro and 12 Pro Max have to offer. Keep in mind that we didn't include any ultra-wide shots from the iPhone 12 Pro since the XS doesn't have such a camera at all. With those photos, including low-light ultra-wide ones, the advantages of the iPhone 12 Pro would have been even more obvious.

So, by now, if you happen to come here without any preexisting information, you're probably wondering what would it cost you to get one those iPhone 12 Pro models...

Well, if you've missed the iPhone 12 announcement event and all the consequent coverage somehow, you're in for a pleasant surprise. The new Pro models start at the same prices the iPhone XS and XS Max did two years ago:

Keep in mind that the new phones come without a charger in the box, only a Lightning to USB Type-C cable, so make sure you have a proper charger at hand if you want to make use of the phone's fast charging capabilities. If you need to buy one, check our Best iPhone fast chargers article.

The way we see it, there are two main reasons to upgrade from the iPhone XS/Max to the iPhone 12 Pro/Max. 

First, the greatly improved battery life. By now, you're probably looking to charge your old iPhone at some point in the afternoon. With the iPhone 12 Pro, the battery anxiety will be gone and probably won't come back for a longer time. 

Second, the better camera system. It's more diverse, it's more capable and more refined than ever. Yes, next year those statements will be true as well for the iPhone 13 Pro's camera, but that's how it goes. Night mode and the changes in video recording are something even casual users will notice.

However, if you don't have any gripes with the battery life of your iPhone XS and you don't really take photos in the dark much, let alone use AR, then you might as well hold on to it for a year longer. 

And what about 5G? After all, it's the new feature of the iPhone 12 family. Well, it's just really hard to get excited for it at the moment. Sure, if you find yourself transferring large files all the time and feel like you'll benefit from the improved speeds, go ahead and upgrade. But in 2020, it's still far from a must-have feature.

Apple iPhone 12 Pro

- 6.1" Super Retina XDR, Apple A14 Bionic, 5G, Triple camera

$999

Buy at Apple