3D: How does it work?
Currently, there are only a few gadgets featuring glasses-free (also called autostereoscopic) 3D displays. The LG Optimus 3D and the Nintendo 3DS are probably the most popular ones and both use a special screen technology called parallax barrier. The 3DS even allows for gradual control of just how much of a 3D effect you want. In addition, both of them (and a slew of recently announced camcorders) support recording in 3D via a dual-camera setup.
Why do we see in 3D?
To understand the whole mechanism we have to go back to the basics of human vision. We see the world in 3D mostly because of our vision, which is similar to that 3D camera setup. Our left eye sees one thing and our right eye sees a slightly different picture. The eyes are spaced apart and each one of them takes a different stream of information from its own viewpoint. The brain mashes it all up in one beautifully deep 3D picture. That, of course, is aided by cues about depth from the shades and motion of objects. Similarly, the two camera sensors are placed at an inch or so of a distance and both simultaneously capture content, just like your eyes. The left camera records information for the left eye, while the right camera records its stream for the right eye. That's exactly how the dual camera setup on the upcoming LG Optimus 3D and T-Mobile G-Slate works. From here on, the brain does its thing and voila - you have 3D! But how do we then give each of the eye the respective video?
Stereoscopic imaging - gotta wear shades!
That's the magic of 3D. In the stone age of the 20th century it was simple – just get a pair of red/blue (cyan to be exact) glasses that say “geek” better than if you had it tattooed on your forehead. Those are called anaglyph and have the advantage of being the cheapest ones you can easily make from cellophane at home. The trickery relies on the two video streams edited to show one in red and the other in cyan. The glasses then act as filters – the red lens allows the “reds” stream and blocks the cyan one, while the cyan feeds only the cyans to the respective eye. The rest as you might have already guessed is brain work.
polarized lenses. Usually, we have a vertical polarization on the one, allowing only the vertically polarized content to pass through, and a horizontal polarization on the other lens, which in turn gives you the horizontally polarized stream. Hence, each of the eyes sees a different picture and we're back to the brain doing the rest. In this case, though, you have a much better quality since no color information is lost as is the case with anaglyph (red/cyan) glasses. While polarized glasses themselves are relatively cheap, your TV will need a screen with polarized coating allowing each eye to see every other line, which comes at a higher cost. The first TVs with the technology have already hit the market, but the price tag is pretty steep – prepare nearly $3500 for the first 65-inch Vizio Razor LED passive 3D TV.
- Anaglyph glasses pros and cons
Pros: Cheap, can be made at home, don't require special equipment
Cons: Some of the colors are lost, the effect is not that submersive
- Polarized glasses pros and cons
Pros: Better 3D effect, colors are represented more accurately, relatively affordable
Cons: Moving your head distorts the 3D effect with linear polarization, require special setup
And finally, some of you have (or most probably will have) 3D TVs at home, which require the fancy and rather expensive shutter glasses. The previous two types of glasses are known as passive since they don't need a power source (and that much of an investment as the shutter glasses!), but the shutter glasses come with a battery. The shutter lenses are actually small LCD screens that alternate the picture for each of the eye at rapid speed. To achieve this they simply dim and turn back on in the blink of an eye. At the same time, your 3D TV first shows the stream for the left eye while the right lens dims the picture for the right eye, then the stream for the right eye appears, while the left lens is dimmed. This alternation happens at a rate of about 120 times per second. The shutter glasses on their part are usually synchronized with the TV via infrared or RF. This allows each of the eyes to get the corresponding picture and pass it to the brain for achieving the effect of depth. You might wonder what happens to the frame rate and rightfully so. The consecutive switching between two streams cuts it in half and this is why you might sometimes see jittery video on your 3D TV.
- Shutter glasses pros and cons
Pros: Unmatched quality
Cons: Frame rate drops, Full HD support limited to TV sets with higher processing speeds (like Plasma TVs)
Glasses-free (autostereoscopic) 3D - "very nice, how much?"
But with all this said, how does the filtering of the two recorded video streams happen without the glasses? LG Optimus 3D (and the Nintendo 3DS for that matter) uses the parallax barrier technology. Parallax might sound scary, but simply put it is the effect of seeing closer objects bigger and more distant ones – smaller. What matters most is the barrier however. It is just what you would imagine – a vertical slit plate on top of the traditional screen that blocks part of the image for each eye. The technology is somewhat limited to smaller screens, but yields good results without the geekines of wearing glasses. Check out our first hands-on encounter with the LG Optimus 3D to learn more about it and get your glasses ready for some 3D samples shot with the Optimus 3D here. Looks pretty neat doesn't it?
- Parallax barrier glasses-free 3D pros and cons
Pros: No glasses required!
Cons: 3D effect strongly dependent on angle, distance
Finally, we can certainly think of a couple of ways to use 3D, but the sky is the limit in the future. And IBM's researchers are hypothesizing about holographic video calls by 2015, so we can see the future coming even faster than we ever expected. At least - with so many options - we can't complain about not having the choice, right?
1. MechaFatigue (Posts: 7; Member since: 13 Jan 2011)
nice features from LG...
LG brings 3D movie, Samsung brings Plasma TV effect while SonyEricsson brings Playstation into mobile phones. Those 3 should get credit for that.
2. clevername (Posts: 1428; Member since: 11 Jul 2008)
Another pro for parallax barrier that you neglected to mention is the ability to change the degree to which the 3d effect is shown.
3. OldTimer (unregistered)
And another con that it cuts the resolution in half
4. displayed name (unregistered)
A mention of the evo 3dwould have been nice