The thefts were discovered when users of Path and other apps were trying to find friends to connect with and the request led the defendants to upload the users' contact lists. The defendants all claim that they are not doing anything suspicious by uploading this data and that such uploads are necessary for the defendants to help the users find their friends online. Besides Path, the other defendants are Twitter, Apple, Facebook, Beluga, Yelp, Burbn, Instagram, Foursquare Labs, Gowalla, Foodspotting, Hipster, LinkedIn, Rovio Mobile, ZeptoLab UK, Chillingo, , and Kik.
A spokesman for LinkedIn said, Hani Durzy, said "Yes, we've seen the suit. It's baffling, because quite simply, our mobile apps do not do what is alleged in the suit." ZeptoLab released a statement that read, "As far as we know we have not been legally served with any lawsuit, and thus have no comment at this time." Twitter, Path and Kik had no comment on the suit while the other companies have yet to respond for comment.