The best selfie phone: Desire EYE vs Note 4 vs iPhone 6 vs LG G3 vs Xperia Z3 vs Galaxy S5 vs One M8
posted by Chris P.
/ Nov 26, 2014, 9:11 AM
Check out the 2015 edition of our selfie comparison featuring the Galaxy S6, LG G4, HTC One M9, Sony Xperia Z3, iPhone 6, Note 4, and Nexus 6!
#Selfie
While the self-portrait predates all of us by several centuries, its modern incarnation, the selfie, is, by some accounts, barely a decade or so old. The word "selfie" has been traced all the way back to a forum post from 2002, and it wasn't until 2004 that anybody, reportedly, made use of #selfie (on Flickr). Obviously, the origins of the word are still up for debate, but the important part is that the selfie culture has gone mainstream – at least mainstream enough for the Oxford Dictionaries to not only note a whopping 17,000% spike in usage between 2012 and 2013, but to also formally recognize it as the "international Word of the Year 2013".
According to Instagram, users have used #selfie 57 million times to tag their photos as of November 2013
When we published our first front-facing camera comparison back in the beginning of this year, we noted that mainstream manufacturers, while paying attention, are not exactly committed as far as selfie cameras are concerned. We can't say that an overwhelming change of landscape took place since, but we're definitely seeing more and more consideration being given to a category that might just end up as a compelling selling point for a certain demographic. Just look at HTC and its all-new Desire EYE, with its 13-megapixel front-facing camera with dual LED flash! The 5-megapixel shooter of its definitive 2014 flagship, the One M8, is also not at all lacking, and Samsung, too, took a step forward by incorporating an unusually high-res, 3.7-megapixel front cam with the Note 4.Of course, camera resolution is far from a defining attribute when it comes to the overall quality of a snap, and front-facing cams are no exception (though more pixels here are definitely comparatively more welcome). To that end, for the purposes of this selfie camera comparison, we'll be looking at a number of variables (like exposure, color reproduction, detail) and then combine the scores into a singular value that represents the performance of each of our seven contestants. Get to know them by examining the table below.
| Resolution | Video | Features | |
| HTC Desire EYE | 13MP | 1080p@23fps | Beauty shot, Dual camera, Face detection, Voice shutter, Effects, HDR, Anti-shake, Backlight, Lens blur, slow-mo video |
| Galaxy Note 4 | 3.7MP | 1440p@30fps | Beauty shot, Burst shot, Dual camera/Dual video recording, Selfie panorama, Sound & Shot, Voice shutter, |
| iPhone 6 | 1.2MP | 720p@30fps | Burst shot, Face detection, Effects |
| LG G3 | 2.1MP | 1080p@29fps | Beauty face, Burst shot, Dual camera/Dual video recording, Voice shutter |
| Xperia Z3 | 2.2MP | 1080p@29fps | Beauty shot, Burst shot, Dual camera, Smile shutter, Image stabilization, HDR, Sound Photo, AR effects, |
| Galaxy S5 | 2.1MP | 1080p@29fps | Beauty shot, Face detection, Dual camera, Best shot, Burst shot, Image stabilization, Voice shutter, Effects |
| HTC One M8 | 5MP | 1080p@25fps | Beauty shot, Dual camera, Face detection, Voice shutter, Effects, HDR |
Outdoor selfies: daytime
The front-facing shooters of all our contestants capture well-exposed stills with minimal error for the most part, along with sufficient detail. It's not all fine and dandy, though. For example, the Desire EYE captures richly-detailed photos, but color reproduction leaves something to be desired on the whole – overly-red skin tones are an almost inescapable reality. Indeed, the EYE is outdone by another HTC device – the One M8 – which consistently netted the best results outdoors in our experience, with natural color reproduction, plentiful detail, and correct exposure. Also offering great performance across the board is the LG G3, which proves a tad better than the Note 4 thanks to the slightly more natural skin tones it delivers.
On the other end of the spectrum is the Galaxy S5's 2.1-megapixel selfie cam, which has a whole myriad of problems, including severe issues with focus, a tad too high levels of noise, and slightly washed-out colors. Thankfully for Samsung, the iPhone 6 and Xperia Z3 fared even worse: Cupertino's flagship insisted on a sickly-yellow skin tone that is altogether off-putting, while Sony's darling is almost exclusively held back by the nasty purple tinge it introduces to selfies.
HTC Desire EYE
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
HTC Desire EYE
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
HTC Desire EYE
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
HTC Desire EYE
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
Outdoor selfies: nighttime
As you can imagine, this gives HTC's selfie-centric device a very clear and well-deserved advantage, as it makes selfies in previously-unfeasible scenarios possible. This wins the EYE the first spot on our ranking in this category, but keep in mind that it's not flawless. For example, sometimes you're better off turning the flash off, as the camera software algorithms aren't sophisticated enough to factor in for bright sources of light in the far background.
Second and third on our list are the Note 4 and the LG G3, the second of which handles bright light sources during the night quite poorly. Last on the list, again, sit the Xperia Z3, the Galaxy S5, and the iPhone 6, respectively. Quite frankly, the iPhone handles color reproduction surprisingly well in such challenging conditions, but its teeny-tiny sensor just cannot capture enough light, handicapping the resulting photos in the process.
HTC Desire EYE, flash off
HTC Desire EYE, flash on
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
HTC Desire EYE, flash off
HTC Desire EYE, flash on
HTC Desire EYE, night mode
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
HTC Desire EYE, flash off
HTC Desire EYE, flash on
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
Indoor selfies: medium and low light
The prime example here is the iPhone 6, which, despite its poor outdoors showing in terms of color reproduction, feels right at home indoors. Indeed, Apple's new flagship impressed with spot-on color reproduction in both decently- and poorly-lit environments, earning itself a sizable lead specifically in the latter scenario.
The HTC Desire EYE proved to be the runner-up – its shooter, too, offers natural colors and its flash is a welcome side-kick in some scenarios (though we prefer to keep it off in others). As before, the amount of detail offered by its 13 megs is second to none.
The Note 4 and the One M8 landed next, with the former disappointing a bit after its overall encouraging performance so far. Still, the overall pale colors of the Note 4's selfies were preferable to the sometimes overpowering artifacts plugged in by the One M8 at the corner of images. Were it not for its dreadfully-soft low light and color-incorrect selfies, the G3 would have had a better chance landing near the aforementioned two, but, alas, that is not the case.
Lastly, based on the images the Xperia Z3 and the Galaxy S5 produced, it should be no surprise to see them finish last – the Z3 again has critical problems with color reproduction, while the Galaxy S5 continues to struggle with what are, objectively, two of its camera's defining "features": washed-out colors and impotent focus.
HTC Desire EYE
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
HTC Desire EYE, flash off
HTC Desire EYE, flash on
Samsung Galaxy Note 4
Apple iPhone 6
LG G3
Sony Xperia Z3
Samsung Galaxy S5
HTC One M8
Field of view and its importance
Each rectangle represents a given device's relative field of view, all things being equal. The areas have been approximated and are not 100% representative.
Whether you call it a usie, wefie, or groufie (careful, Huawei might object!), the appeal of snapping group selfies (perhaps we should just call it that) is there. Unfortunately, save for the Galaxy Note 4, no other phone on our list has the ability to shoot panoramas with the front-facing camera. And even if they all did, one could argue that having a wide-angled lens for selfies is still beneficial. Just ask Jarred Leto.
Anyways, with the exception of the HTC Desire EYE, the HTC One M8, and the Apple iPhone 6, who churn out 4:3 snaps, all other phones in our comparison shoot in a 16:9 aspect ratio when using their marketed resolution. But there's more to it – their cameras also have different (sometimes vastly) field of views, or, in other words, can capture relatively less or more of the scene in front of them in a single snap.
A clear victor emerged from our tests, and that's the One M8, challenged only by the Desire EYE – HTC is keeping it in the family. The rest are essentially stacked in pairs of two – the Galaxy S5 and Note 4 are bunched up together and occupy the third and fourth spot in our ranking, and so are the iPhone 6 and Xperia Z3 (who finish last). The LG G3 sits somewhere in the middle of those two pairs.
Video
So, video capture. First off, let's start by pointing out the two outliers here: the Note 4, which shoots in 1440p, and the iPhone 6, which is still stuck at 720p. The rest of our contestants all produce 1080p footage. The frame rate at which video is taken also differs in some cases, with the Desire EYE only capturing 23 framers per second (FPS), while most others do 30 frames.
As for overall quality, we've got to give it to the HTC One M8 (which does 25 FPS), for it juggles exposure well, renders natural colors, and captures rich details and sound. The iPhone 6, despite its 720p clips, landed second, for it, too, managed exposure expertly, all the while checking the rest of the boxes as well. The bronze was grabbed by the Note 4, which manages exposure very well, but excellently.
Next up, we have the Desire EYE and the LG G3, both of which perform equally well. Last on our list are the Galaxy S5 and the Xperia Z3, as both exhibited the same kind of issues that were impossible to miss in the previous sections: issues with focus and relatively washed-out colors with the former and aggressively-tinted (purplish) footage with the latter, which also proved to have the greatest troubles with sound recording. Take a look and see for yourself.
Conclusion and final thoughts
But details aren't everything, and the Note 4 showcased as much time and time again. Some of you might be tired of hearing this, but keep in mind that most people will be looking at your otherwise super-detailed selfies through a tiny window on Facebook, and an even smaller one on Instagram and Twitter – the three most likely destinations for your selfies, all of which compress your photos, too. This notion is further cemented by the One M8 and its relatively high-res, 5-megapixel cam. Admittedly, the M8 performs admirably, but it still does have some issues with bright light sources during the night and its shots are not immune to errors when light is limited. In other words, its high-res sensor alone was not enough to ensure the silver.
The LG G3 and iPhone 6 landed fourth and fifth, respectively, and that's not surprising, for the two offer middling performance overall. The exception here is the G3's great sound quality during video capture, while the iPhone 6 impresses with the shots it pulls off indoors. As for the last two slots, those are occupied by the Galaxy S5 and the Xperia Z3, and deservedly so. The truth is that even when they were on their best behavior, they still simply produced unpleasant photos that have little to no appeal and will likely end up in your gallery's trash bin.
And with that, ladies and gents, we conclude our overview of the present state of affairs. Discuss!
56 Comments
1. nwright94
Posts: 211; Member since: Oct 14, 2014
Note 4 didn't do bad for a 3.7 mp camera when there's others higher than it. I don't use it often on my Note, but when I do it looks great.
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 9:26 AM 12
30. steodoreben
Posts: 379; Member since: Sep 26, 2013
Have you seen the author's stank face on Samsung GALAXY Note 4 and LG G3. He's not fond of these devices. You can tell. HAHAHA! XD
posted on Nov 27, 2014, 6:03 AM 1
60. newsman
Posts: 21; Member since: Jan 12, 2015
Development of new technologies is certainly striking, I do not think so soon will create a new model, I pokamist except that this model seen last favewallpapers.com/66053-night-computer-wallpaper-laptop-keys-nikon-grey-black.html
posted on Feb 05, 2015, 12:06 PM 0
2. mixedfish
Posts: 1540; Member since: Nov 17, 2013
I've used the front facing camera 3 times, once for every new phone I buy. That's as useful as it gets.
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 9:32 AM 1
10. jaytai0106
Posts: 1888; Member since: Mar 30, 2011
Every time I use front facing camera is when my gf wants to take selfie together. Other than that, I never use it. Front facing cameras are for teens and girls....
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 11:23 AM -9
19. vincelongman
Posts: 5554; Member since: Feb 10, 2013
The main time I use the front camera is for Face Unlock
Face Unlock on Lollipop is really fast and convenient
Only problem is it doesn't work at night, but that's not as much of problem now with Trusted Places
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 3:56 PM 1
4. Derekjeter
Posts: 1427; Member since: Oct 27, 2011
Front facing camera is for ladies only. There's no need for it. I don't remember the last time I used it. My 6 plus ans my Note 4 take really good pictures. Each have their good and bad. I Love having best of both.
Side note: remember when all the android/ Samsung fans used to say the Galaxy S5 had the best camera? Lol. It never did. Not until the Note 4 did Samsung have a horse in the camera race.
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 9:41 AM 1
7. ManusImperceptus
Posts: 724; Member since: Jun 10, 2014
Actually, the S5 DID have the best camera on an Android phone in it's time. Bested the iPhone 4 and 5 as well... Only the Nokia 808, the Lumia 1520, and later the 930/1520 could put it in it's place.
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 10:03 AM 4
24. SemperFiV12
Posts: 949; Member since: Nov 09, 2010
No my friend... not "only".
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 4:56 PM 3
5. nenadmitrovic
Posts: 64; Member since: Aug 01, 2014
Lumia should be there
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 9:41 AM 3
6. ManusImperceptus
Posts: 724; Member since: Jun 10, 2014
Yeah, no need to feature the Lumia 730... After all, it only sports 5 mp with a wide-angle f2,4 aperture and superior algorithms... Lets just ignore that!
Tsk, tsk...
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 10:00 AM 8
9. pitzy
Posts: 42; Member since: May 15, 2014
have anyone listened how natural and real is the sound recorded by the note 4 and s5? there are the only phones where you can listen the wind and the footsteps on the leafs. Nice!
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 10:37 AM 1
12. ManusImperceptus
Posts: 724; Member since: Jun 10, 2014
You obviously haven't tried Nokia's rich recording tech... Nokia's stereo recording is the only one I'd trust during a concert!
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 11:44 AM 1
11. Atrixboyyy
Posts: 569; Member since: Nov 03, 2011
It's all good my Z3 wasn't meant for selfies.
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 11:44 AM 1
32. RajRicardo
Posts: 478; Member since: Feb 28, 2014
I have the Z3 :( Even the rear camera sucks :( :'( Why Sony Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy!!!!!!
posted on Nov 27, 2014, 7:37 AM 2
34. Atrixboyyy
Posts: 569; Member since: Nov 03, 2011
Lol your buggin the rear camera is amazing you probably got bad photography taste or can't shoot.
posted on Nov 27, 2014, 11:05 AM 0
36. RajRicardo
Posts: 478; Member since: Feb 28, 2014
No. I'm talking about the superior auto mode. Sony did mess it up. My friend has a MI3 and frankly speaking, it takes better photos. :( I agree that it's amazing but the algorithms are a bit messed up. Sony needs to fix it.
posted on Dec 01, 2014, 12:27 AM 1
37. Atrixboyyy
Posts: 569; Member since: Nov 03, 2011
SA is simply for people who can't or don't know how to use manual everyone knows they screwed up SA mode but that doesnt equal a bad camera. Like I said "or can't shoot". They'll never fix those algorithms
posted on Dec 01, 2014, 7:58 AM 2
13. Tycoon
Posts: 28; Member since: Nov 10, 2010
I think the iPhone now has the capability of taking pictures by using the volume buttons and I know I can do it on Android with apps such as Snap Camera and Camera Zoom FX. Yeah, I know that I can't see myself, but it's not that hard to know where my face is and since I know how to smile (or not), I generally use the rear camera so I can get a higher quality picture. I do like that high end phones are trending towards higher megapixels on the front. I'd love to see a minimum of a wide angled 5MP for the front facing cameras in 2015, but make sure that the aperture is more than adequate to ensure we get lots of light coming in for better pictures. I'd hope for at least an F1.4 aperture.
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 11:48 AM 0
20. vincelongman
Posts: 5554; Member since: Feb 10, 2013
The stock Google camera has had that for a while now, most OEM camera apps have had that for even longer
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 3:59 PM 0
14. BattleBrat
Posts: 1476; Member since: Oct 26, 2011
You call that a selfie?http://i496.photobucket.com/albums/rr325/BattleBrat/Mobile%20Uploads/IMG_20140917_111507_PerfectlyClear0001_1_zpsfheusphi.jpg
Narrow depth of field selfie, front camera of an HTC M8. Thats a selfie!
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 12:32 PM 0
23. hallihallo.87
Posts: 53; Member since: Jul 07, 2014
But a hell of a face ;)
posted on Nov 26, 2014, 4:42 PM 0
* Some comments have been hidden, because they don't meet the discussions rules.
