Editorials · Insider Reaction
Why does T-Mobile CEO Gopalan feel compelled to break something that isn't broken?
Is there a hidden reason why T-Mobile CEO (and President) Srini Gopalan is supporting T-Mobile's "digital-first" approach?
This article may contain personal views and opinion from the author.
Why is T-Mobile fixing something not broken? | Image by PhoneArena
There is that old saying, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." In other words, don't mess with success. However, I fear that current CEO and President Srini Gopalan never learned these sayings and is taking T-Mobile in the wrong direction that is anything but customer friendly.
You can't understand the magnitude of what Gopalan might be destroying without taking a look at what the carrier had accomplished under CEO John Legere, who became Chief Executive Officer and President in September 2012. Prior to Legere's hiring, T-Mobile would have been considered the weakest of what was then the "Big Four" US carriers, which included Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, and Sprint.
T-Mobile was dead last among the four major carriers at the start of 2012
Heading into 2012, T-Mobile was dead last among the four Mobile Network Operators in market share (10%) placing it behind Sprint (16%), AT&T (34%), and Verizon (34%). At the start of 2012, T-Mobile had absolutely no 4G-LTE coverage as it relied on HSPA+, which it promoted as 4G. Verizon already had a huge lead in 4G LTE and AT&T followed in late 2011. In the middle of 2012 Sprint offered WiMax with LTE.
Lacking low-band spectrum, T-Mobile's airwaves had trouble penetrating buildings and had to deal with huge dead zones in rural areas. T-Mobile did not start offering the iPhone until April 2013. T-Mobile's parent Deutsche Telekom saw no future for T-Mobile and announced the sale of the carrier to AT&T in March, 2011 for $39 billion.
AT&T would have been the largest wireless carrier in the US had the deal been approved. However, the FCC would not approve the transaction and that triggered the deal's breakup penalty, which resulted in T-Mobile receiving $3 billion in cash and $1 billion in AWS spectrum in 128 markets. T-Mobile used the cash to build out a 4G LTE network.
T-Mobile becomes the Un-carrier and starts an amazing 180-degree turnaround
The hiring of Legere to run T-Mobile was the action that turned the wireless firm into the most innovative and popular carrier. Turning T-Mobile into the Un-carrier, a shot at Verizon, AT&T, and Sprint, Legere unleashed a series of attacks on rivals (mostly on "Dumb and Dumber" AT&T and Verizon). Un-carrier moves were designed to differentiate T-Mobile from the others.
The very first Un-carrier event positioned T-Mobile as a "customer first" company as T-Mobile ended the controversial two-year contract, stopped subsidizing the purchase of new phones, and standardized the no-interest financing system (EIP) currently in use by most wireless providers today.
Under Legere, T-Mobile added popular rewards programs including T-Mobile Tuesdays. With his strong customer first approach, Legere introduced perks like:
- Netflix "On Us"
- Data-Free Streaming Music (Music Freedom)
- Data Stash (roll over data)
In other words, Legere was wildly successful at T-Mobile because he put the consumer first. And while I can't say whether the following was really part of his persona or just an act, Legere seemed to actually be interested in the devices he sold which I, as a smartphone enthusiast, thought was a great part of his quirky personality.
Consumers hate the "Digital-first" approach that Gopalan is pushing
Now, current CEO and President Srini Gopalan wants to continue the process that turns T-Mobile into a digital-first carrier. Forcing the use of the T-Life app on customers inside retail locations is not providing customers with the service that they need. The T-Life app remains buggy and the whole process has customers walking into T-Mobile stores, wondering if their issues and questions will be answered to their satisfaction.

T-Mobile investors have been swimming in a sea of red ink during 2026.| Image by Google
As my colleague Anam wrote on Thursday, Gopalan is going to force everyone at the vice president level and higher to spend two days working at a retail store, or at a care center. Will that really lead to any change that impacts customers favorably? I'm sorry, sir, but this is not going to work. As John Legere proved, to effect positive change for T-Mobile customers, changes must be made directly to customers.
Poll
0 Votes
Who or what is T-Mobile CEO Srini Gopalan putting first?
By changes, I don't mean eliminating the free Apple TV+ perk even if they are charged only $3 per month out of pocket for it. This is like taking Legere's idea of offering customer freebies and applying it in reverse.
T-Mobile was still reporting industry-leading quarterly metrics when Gopalan took over. It's interesting that Gopalan once held a couple of senior roles at T-Mobile parent Deutsche Telekom (DT) including the CEO job of DT's German business. Deutsche Telekom has expressed an interest in acquiring T-Mobile because the latter is valued higher in world markets than its parent. That financial quirk makes it difficult for the German telecom giant to use its shares in a transaction to purchase another telecom firm.
If one were to don a tin-foil hat, one could make the argument that dropping the customer-first approach for digital could drop the value of T-Mobile and make it a cheaper purchase for any buyer. And yes, Gopalan did work for DT. This sounds preposterous and no one is making any accusations. But since Gopalan took over last November 1, T-Mobile's shares have lost 22%-23% of its valuation or approximately $55 billion. Deutsche Telekom has since halted its work on a full-takeover of T-Mobile.
Gopalan might say that T-Mobile remains the Un-carrier, but I strongly disagree. There is nothing remotely positive anymore that differentiates T-Mobile from Verizon and AT&T.
There is more great content to read:
Things that are NOT allowed:
To help keep our community safe and free from spam, we apply temporary limits to newly created accounts: