US lawmakers send letter demanding answers from Apple, Google, and Meta about nudify apps
Three US senators ask Apple, Google, and Meta questions about nudify apps distributed by the App Store and the Google Play Store.
Apple, Google, and Meta questioned by lawmakers about AI nudify apps | Image by Apple
Three US senators have given Apple and other tech companies a warning demanding that they start taking action on apps that create nude images of certain subjects without obtaining their consent. Meta was also in the spotlight on Wednesday for running paid ads for these apps on the Meta-owned Facebook and Instagram platforms.
Three senators send a letter to both Apple and Google about nudify apps
A letter sent to the CEOs of Apple, Google, and Meta from Senators Ron Wyden of Oregon, Ed Markey of Massachusetts, and Ben Luján of New Mexico, blamed the tech companies for failing to remove apps associated with the creation of nonconsensual nude images in the App Store and Play Store respectively. In addition to failing to take these apps down, the companies are accused by the lawmakers of profiting from the distribution and promotion of these apps.

Senator Ron Wyden is one of three lawmakers who signed a letter sent to Apple, Google, and Meta about nudify apps. | Image by Ron Wyden
Last month Apple changed App Store rules to eliminate apps that gave users the ability to generate nonconsensual nude images. The new rules require that any apps that allow iOS users to create AI-generated content must include safeguards to prevent abuse. This includes offering tools that allow users to filter objectionable content and block what you might consider to be aggressive users.
Apple also has stated that it will remove from the App Store without notice any apps used primarily to deliver pornographic content, or apps that lead to the objectification of real people. The tech giant has dealt with something like this before when earlier this year it removed an app that created pornographic deepfakes of real people. Apple 86'd the app one month after San Francisco City Attorney David Chiu demanded that Apple and Google remove such pornify apps from their respective app stores.

Apple reportedly removed this nudify app from the App Store last September. | Image by TTP
Such apps even showed up in the App Store's sponsored search results, and a couple of reports from the Tech Transparency Project (TTP) claimed that these apps were widely available from Apple's iOS app storefront. Despite such claims, Apple defended itself by stating that it proactively rejects and removes apps that violate its policies including apps flagged by complaints from users.
Apple explains how some of these apps were able to get listed in the App Store
Apple explained how some app developers get around Apple's stringent app reviews by adding the features that generate the nude images to apps after Apple has approved them. Senator Wyden doesn't accept this as a legitimate excuse from Apple and expects the tech giant to continue to review apps after they go live.
Instead of ramping up investment to meet this challenge, big tech companies are cutting back on the very teams responsible for protecting users from harm. I'm looking for answers about why Meta, Apple and Google are missing obvious violations of their own rules.
Senator Ron Wyden
Wyden seems to be focusing his ire on Apple and Google as he doesn't appear to be interested in going after web-based tools able to generate AI-created nude images. Google and Meta also chimed in on the letter by responding as Apple did, making comments about prohibiting the distribution of such apps on their platforms and by saying that they refuse to promote these apps.
Wyden's office said that it doesn't matter what Apple, Google, and Meta say about having rules preventing nudify apps from being installed over their platforms and advertised on social media sites. What is important to the senator are the actions these companies take in regard to this matter.
One big mystery: how did accounts with parental controls subscribe without requiring a parent's approval?
Don't expect this battle to end quickly. After all, it has been determined that even accounts created with parental controls were able to install the nudify apps without requiring a parent's approval, which is another interesting mystery that the trio of lawmakers would like to solve.
Poll
0 Votes
Who really is to blame for the release of nudify apps?
If the dissemination of nudify apps to teens wasn't so serious, many might just write this off as another congressional attack against Big Tech. To be fair, Senator Wyden is known to defend Apple on some issues. He backed the tech giant when it defied the FBI's demand for a special version of iOS that would open an iPhone 5c belonging to San Bernardino shooter Syed Farook in 2016. On the other hand, Wyden opposed Apple when he pressured federal agencies to investigate tech giants over push-notification data surveillance.
Want more to read? We're happy to oblige:
Things that are NOT allowed:
To help keep our community safe and free from spam, we apply temporary limits to newly created accounts: