x PhoneArena is hiring! Reviewer in the USA
  • Hidden picShow menu
  • Home
  • News
  • Cut the cords: wireless charging is closer than you think

Cut the cords: wireless charging is closer than you think

Cut the cords: wireless charging is closer than you think
From the moment Nikola Tesla tried to erect his Wardencliffe tower on Long Island, with the intent to make a global wireless electricity system, we've tried to blast those electrons without cables.

With the incessant amount of battery-powered gadgets we use every day now, wireless charging is back in vogue, and whoever masters it first will make billions.

There are three buzzwords currently in the field – inductive, radio, and magnetic resonance charging. Let's have a look at what's on offer from each of those technologies that vouch to liberate us from the cord.

On the market now - inductive charging

Inductive charging is cheap and simple to manufacture. It is not the most practical, but a lot of companies have gone the inductive way because it is the most cost-efficient, and there are already tangible products on the market, so it will probably take off one way or another.

One of the more recent developments is Fulton Innovation's partnering with Verizon to offer wireless charging capability formed as an accessory to the carrier's LTE handsets. At CES 2011 the company showed back covers for the LG Revolution (our hands-on here), as well as for some other of Verizon's upcoming LTE handsets that will be sold as an accessory soon, and will allow you to use a Verizon-branded charging pad, also shown at the Expo.

Fulton Innovation's wireless charging back cover for the LG Revolution and Verizon's charging pad
Fulton Innovation's wireless charging back cover for the LG Revolution and Verizon's charging pad
Fulton Innovation's wireless charging back cover for the LG Revolution and Verizon's charging pad

Fulton Innovation's wireless charging back cover for the LG Revolution and Verizon's charging pad

The other new one is, of course, the Touchstone 2 for charging HP's latest smartphones and the TouchPad tablet it built after acquiring Palm. The original Touchstone will always have a place in history for being the first accessory for wireless charging, bundled commercially with a phone.

Have a look at the eCoupled offering of the Michigan-based Fulton, they even have mid-range inductive charging that works for more than a few inches, but the efficiency is quite diminished. In April Fulton should be delivering its solution to police and firefighter teams, among others.

We'd be remiss not to mention Energizer and Powermat (our review here), which was the first to offer a third party wireless charging solution, and now has affordable inductive charging bundles for the most popular smartphones on the market. It recently entered a partnership with Qualcomm to create pads for its WiPower standard, which are to be backward compatible with the existing Powermats.

WiPower is a company Qualcomm bought last year, and whose solution, using near-field magnetic resonance, allows you to just unload the charging devices on the pad, without worrying too much about the exact position. It still requires very close proximity to the charging station, so we are teaming it up in the inductive charging section, and Intel is also working on this technology. Qualcomm also entered partnership with Duracell, and plans to embed WiPower in office furniture, thanks to the alliance with furniture manufacturer Gill Industries – have a look at the WiPower capabilities from about 1:35 into the video below.

An industry standard, called Qi (Chi), from the Chinese word for energy flow, emerged last year to  completely unify and develop the inductive charging solution. More than 70 companies, including phone manufacturers like Nokia, Samsung, HTC, Sony Ericsson and Motorola, as well as carriers like Verizon, battery and accessory makers, are members now. The big moves for introducing common hardware are expected this year, as exemplified by the Verizon-branded charging station at Fulton's CES booth this year.

The inductive solutions above work only up to a few inches, and usually require you to place your phone or other gadget on some kind of a charging station, often in a certain way, which almost defeats the purpose, since you can as well plug it in, or use a dock.

But what else is there? Is there some promising technology that could release us from the obligation to plug in our smartphone, or place it around dedicated pads in order to charge it?

Upcoming technologies - radio frequency and magnetic resonance charging

There are in fact two of them – radio and magnetic resonance charging. Theoretically they are superior to inductive charging, since they offer larger distances between the charged device and the source, and can easily charge multiple gadgets simultaneously, regardless of their position.

Radio charging can work from the longest distances of all, and even without a dedicated transmitter - it can eventually harvest the radio frequency (RF) energy that is beamed all around us by various sources. The commercial viability is demonstrated best by Powercast, which has developed a dedicated transmitter for radio charging, but also demoes some RF harvesting in the video further below. The competitors are trying to diminish radio charging with a transmitter, saying that it might interfere with stuff like pacemakers and motorized wheelchairs, but the CEO of Powercast dismisses those as trash talk.

Nokia's UK team has also been doing great research into this other aspect of radio charging, RF (radio frequency) harvesting, and its goal on last check was to achieve enough milliwatts harvested from the electromagnetic radiation around us, to keep a phone on standby indefinitely, and afterwards enough to slowly charge the battery, and allow it to make a call.

And, finally, we got to magnetic resonance charging. It doesn't offer the range of RF charging, since even the promising research with great system design speed advantages by Fujitsu, reaches 10 theoretical feet distance. It is quite efficient, though - regular chargers give us 30-40% efficiency, and here we can hit twice that, so wireless charging might even be the greener technology in the end. Fujitsu expects to commercialize its solution first for cell phones and other small gadgets in 2012, and then move on to larger objects, like electric cars.

Fujitsu's magnetic resonance charging solution will be commercially ready in 2012
Fujitsu's magnetic resonance charging solution will be commercially ready in 2012

Fujitsu's magnetic resonance charging solution will be commercially ready in 2012

On the US side, an MIT assistant professor together with some colleagues, have developed a magnetic-resonance charging system of their own, which has a commercial name for it, WiTricity. It's been demoed to power a TV without cables from about five feet, and applied to cell phones also. A cool demo video for that one is below as well.

What about health concerns? The inventors and manufacturers of magnetic resonance, inductive and radio charging, claim that their solutions are tested, and don't interfere with living organisms in a harmful way, so your goldfish shouldn't be more exposed to waves than it already is. As far as we know, a year of living near a Wi-Fi router will net you the same radiation as a 20 minute cell phone call; we don't know precisely how much radio charging might emit, but it couldn't be a huge number.

We can't wait for the day to untangle ourselves from cords and power adapter bricks. Whichever technology prevails, we hope it does it soon, and we can start on making it ubiquitous, so we seamlessly charge our gizmos the minute we enter the house, the car, or at public places.

Watch a cool demo of how both magnetic resonance and radio charging, WiTricity and Powercast, respectively, work in reality, and prepare to be dazzled, since things have advanced even more from the time this video was shot a year ago.

What are your thoughts on wireless charging? Will you wait until the distances get far enough that you don't have to place your cell phone on or very near a charging station, or are you so fed up with cords that any affordable solution like inductive charging will do?

  • Options

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 08:25 6

1. AndroidTroll (Posts: 359; Member since: 05 Mar 2011)

If it weren't for Edison's damn propaganda against the smartest man who ever lived, Nikola Tesla, then everything would be powered wirelessly through the benefits of Alternating Current. On a related note...Apple sucks.

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 08:48

4. snowgator (Posts: 3604; Member since: 19 Jan 2011)

I grew up in Fort Myers Florida, where Edisons home is a huge tourist attraction. (and gawd-awful dull) His name was plastered everywhere in my home town. I am curious- what propaganda??? I really am interested.

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 08:57 3

6. AndroidTroll (Posts: 359; Member since: 05 Mar 2011)

A good place to start would be to wikipedia "war of currents". Basically, Edison was a hack of a scientist compared to the genius of Tesla. The only attributes that made Edison successful were his tireless drive employing trial and error scientific technique and his bounty of money to fuel the propaganda machine against AC. Tesla was a proper scientist who relied on careful scientific research and exploration before resorting to brash trial and error.

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 08:50 2

5. AndroidTroll (Posts: 359; Member since: 05 Mar 2011)

Interesting side note: when I posted my comment, there was no reference to Tesla in the article. It appears that after having read my comment, Phonearena inserted the bit in the intro about Tesla. At least they are taking an active role :)

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 08:33 1

2. calamazoo (unregistered)

true that, Tesla was brilliant, and way ahead of his times. heck, even our times! i'm curious about the MIT and Fujitsu research, as well as the RF harvesting, that holds huge potential... read today that some guys at MIT developed smartphone memory wiring with nanotubes that requires miniscule amounts of energy like kinetic and radio waves to function... sounds promising

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 08:43 1

3. snowgator (Posts: 3604; Member since: 19 Jan 2011)

Any article that has a Tesla reference is already instantly creditable.

This is the type of article I would love to see more of on Phone Arena- Informative, well written, and gives you enough information to understand what they are talking about. Some of these ideas are new to me, and it gives me a starting point to look into them if I want. If not, I at least now know what are some possable solutions to the charging nightmare of portable gear.

My Woman just lost her charger last weekend. ANYTHING inexpensive that would make plug in chargers expendable would be purchased as quick as it was unboxed at the electronic store. Just saying.

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 09:11

7. narley (Posts: 357; Member since: 14 May 2009)


... just sayin.

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 09:16

8. snowgator (Posts: 3604; Member since: 19 Jan 2011)

Is that the only word I messed up? Not bad by my usual butchering of the American-style English. Thanks for the quick fix. :-D

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 09:24

9. calamazoo (unregistered)

The thing is that maintaining network connection is a huge power drain, too, especially in LTE handsets like the Revolution and Thunderbolt. The screens and chipsets are getting more energy-efficient by the day though, so remote radio charging could also play a supplementary role to juice your smartphone up.

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 09:28 1

10. DIYguy (Posts: 190; Member since: 27 Feb 2011)

The finnish "power kiss" is better

posted on 11 Mar 2011, 11:35

11. calamazoo (unregistered)

thanks, first time i hear about the power kiss, seems it's not widely available, though

posted on 12 Mar 2011, 12:42

12. Cod3rror (unregistered)

If this technology advances to WiFi levels, how will they stop neighbors from stealing electricity?

I imagine they'll figure out how to password protect it, or else it's going to be a mess.

Anyways, I'm not jumping to wireless charging until it's at WiFi levels, you walk into your house/apartment, car or some building and the phone or whatever supports wireless charging starts charging.

posted on 16 Mar 2011, 11:17

13. muhsin17 (unregistered)

nikolas tesla is the most underrated scientist and inventor of all time.
he was a great visionary, a man who leaved his life for science....
his inventions are endless tesla coil, neon lights, wireless electricity, interplanatary communication, x-ray,induction motor,robotics,remote control and so on...
at a very young age his ambition was to make a turbine that could generate electricity from niagra falls..
he is the face of todays electricity and his ideas are going to lead tomarrows technologies yet his name is seldom used...

posted on 06 Apr 2011, 05:44

14. Matt FT (unregistered)

I don't think he's underrated by anybody who knows anything about electricity and 20th century technological advances, but I agree that he's no household name even if he has every merit to be. At least there is a nifty little electrical car company named after :)

As for the article, very informative.

Want to comment? Please login or register.

Latest stories