Cortana celebrates her second birthday as a personal assistant by adding new features
posted by Alan F. / Apr 02, 2016, 6:25 PM
Recently, it was announced that Cortana will be able to keep Android users up-to-date about their notifications across various devices. The personal assistant will also help you to send texts from your PC. Other new features include the Cortana Collection, which will appear in the Windows Store. This is a series of apps recommended by the virtual personal assistant. In addition, Cortana will now make suggestions during the course of a day. She will offer to phone in a lunch order for you, or arrange a cab or other form of transportation.
While testing alongside Siri and Google Now usually results in a third-place finish for Cortana, the other two virtual personal assistants are much older and more mature than she is. It is usually considered bad form to broadcast a woman's age, but in this case we don't think that Cortana will mind. And thanks to the iOS and Android apps, and her inclusion on Windows 10 PCs, it appears that Cortana will be around for some time to come regardless of what happens to Microsoft's smartphone business.
Posts: 312; Member since: Aug 01, 2014
"While testing alongside Siri and Google Now usually results in a third-place finish for Cortana.." hm, every test I've seen out there, for the most part, has Siri in 3rd. Even when Cortana was first launched many users found her to be more accurate than Siri. Google Now edges out Cortana for searches, but not as a personal assistant.
posted on Apr 02, 2016, 7:07 PM 5
Google now is perfectly capable of keeping track of my meetings, bills, telling me what time I need to leave, so on and so forth. Isn't that what a personal assistant does? I haven't used Cortana in some time, so I'm curious. In what ways has she grown that outstrips Google's efforts?
posted on Apr 02, 2016, 8:20 PM 4
Posts: 103; Member since: Aug 09, 2014
One thing from when I used Cortana back when I had a Windows phone (the limits 1520, which I loved, it just didn't have the app support I wanted), is that I was able to tell it to turn Wi-Fi off every time I left or arrived my work, home, or certain friends' houses. I haven't figured out how to get Google Now to do that. And that, actually, is the most important feature for me.
posted on Apr 02, 2016, 8:27 PM 1
I'm not sure, I don't believe Google has that feature. You have to explicitly tell it to do so as far as I remember. There are plenty of automation programs and android store apps that do this sort of thing flawlessly but I don't believe that's built into Google now itself
posted on Apr 02, 2016, 8:49 PM 1
Posts: 5192; Member since: Oct 28, 2013
More personal, and the location based reminders. I can say, remind me to buy milk next time I go the store. Google now wants either a time or place, And the place has to be somewhat specific, like walmart. With Cortana, it will recognize...any store, at any time. So if I roll up into walgreens at a whim, she will be like, bro buy milk. And I can ethier, accept, cancel or differ next time in store...just in case I don't want milk right now etc. Or personal type reminders. Like ok google. Next time I talk to mom, remind me to do....this. Google once more wants time and place. Cortana - will notify me when I either call send/receive, email, text her contact, to do the notification regardless of time or location. Unless I am doing something wrong, this was tested on a 1520/LG G4 side by side
posted on Apr 03, 2016, 10:12 AM 1
Posts: 169; Member since: Oct 12, 2015
What he's saying is correct. If we were to be fair I'm sure many more things would be factored in, like age, how they look, what platforms they work on, etc. However as far as 'personal assistant' features go, Cortana is built to be a personal assistant. Google Now is made to surface information you may find helpful. Basically a preemptive web/app search. Both are great in their own way.
posted on Apr 04, 2016, 8:24 AM 1
Posts: 65; Member since: Oct 03, 2015
I'm pretty sure cortana is older than 2 considering halo came out in 2001
posted on Apr 02, 2016, 8:06 PM 9
Posts: 103; Member since: Aug 09, 2014
The Contana personal assistant is 2 years old. The character is arguably older, but look at the Simpsons: the character Bart was created to be the age of ten, but he's been around for over 20 years. So the age of artificially created, non-corporeal things is not always objective.
posted on Apr 02, 2016, 8:23 PM 0
Posts: 1251; Member since: Dec 03, 2014
Well they can have all their fancy features, but as long as they only support very few languages and regions, they suck for a lot of people. Only one if the 3 that is usable in my country is Siri. And as far as I know, apple doesn't plan on bringing that to android
posted on Apr 03, 2016, 12:48 AM 0
Posts: 8; Member since: Nov 25, 2015
It has been my experience that Cortana is overall notably superior to Siri. This is from real-world, daily use, side-by side (wife has iPhone, I have Lumia 950). Google Now certainly is very good, but for everyday use that truly helps me, Cortana comes out on top. Cortana's ability to read to me incoming texts via Bluetooth headset or earbuds, AND ALLOW ME TO QUICKLY DICTATE REPLIES, is something that so far neither Siri or Google Now can do. Yes, there are add-on apps that can do similar to what Cortana can do, and some Moto phones have "Drive Mode" (which is not nearly as capable as Cortana's inherent capabilities) but Cortana's total, OS-level integration with the headsets is BY FAR superior to both Siri and Google now. Other pluses with Cortana: + Initiating texts and calls via the headset at any time (i.e. handsfree while driving, or handsfree while I'm working in the garage or out in the yard). Note that I'm saying INITIATING texts/calls/emails, not merely listening to or replying to incoming calls/messages. + Dictating quick emails into the headset as I drive. + Playing the turn-by-turn navigation instructions over headset or earbuds. + Setting reminders (time, place or person) via headset. + On-the-fly commands such as "Navigation from current location to home." + On-the-fly calls for numbers not in my contacts ("Call Lowes in Pasadena, California."). + "Open webpage Sigalert.com for Los Angeles.", which doesn't just bring up a list of links, it actually opens the webpage so I only have to glance at the phone's display to see what I need, I don't have to scan the search results list and tap on the appropriate link. Cortana understands "Open webpage (name.com)".
posted on Apr 05, 2016, 10:36 AM 0
Send a warning to post author
Send a warning to Selected user.
The user has 0 warnings currently.
Next warning will result in ban!
Ban user and delete all posts
Message to PhoneArena moderator (optional):