A RIM takeover would be a bumpy ride for the buyer
The advantage to a buyer is that with much of the stock in the hands of fast moving funds always in search of a quick profit, a buyer offering a nice premium to the current price might be able to wrest away a majority of the stock, vote in a new board, and send the co-CEO's out on the pavement looking for a new job. But it is not going to be easy.
launched with no email client nor a calendar, to the delay in launching the new line of SuperPhones, it has not been a good year for RIM. And as we close the book on 2011, RIM was sued to stop using the BBX name it wanted to call its new OS (now anointed BlackBerry 10) and to stop calling BlackBerry Messenger by the long time BBM abbreviation. And we can't forget the class action suit that was filed by RIM users after an outage that circled the globe over the period of a few days, left those relying on their BlackBerry without service.
What has hurt the most though, has been RIM's decline in the smartphone market where its BlackBerry models are no longer seen as offering the latest technology. Compared with the Apple iPhone and Android, the top-of-the-line BlackBerry 9900/9930 has no front facing camera, no YouTube client (the phone's YouTube button merely re-directs the user to You Tube's mobile web site), a much less stocked online application store and no dual-core processors. These are features that iOS and Android users are currently enjoying.
So what could RIM fetch in a buyout? Evercore Partners analyst Alkesh Shah puts a value of $22.50 for the stock, even assuming that the company's handset business is worthless. Shah puts a value of $12.50 on RIM’s network, which carries global traffic worldwide and collects monthly subscription fee. RIM's patents are worth $7.50 a share and the company has $2.50 a share in cash. But even a bid in that ballpark would cost in the range of $10-$13 billion which is a lot of money to spend on a company that is falling so far behind its competitors. Amazingly enough, we reported on possible RIM takeover rumors back in 2010 and at the time, with the stock $55, we figured it would take as much as $50 billion to buy the company.
While some big tech names have been linked to a buyout of Canadian based RIM like Microsoft, Amazon and Nokia, nothing has apparently has made it through the exploratory stage. The New York Times brings up the possibility of China's ZTE adding to its position as the fourth largest handset manufacturer on the planet, a possible suitor that the newspaper has brought up before. If there is going to be a buyer for RIM, Lazaridis and Balsillie will need to be dealt with. Adnaan Ahmad, an analyst with Berenberg Bank in London, says the pair is suffering from "founder's syndrome" which makes them unwilling to take the company in new directions. The pair did cut their salary for this year to $1 each as a good will gesture to stockholders.
Usually when it comes to the takeover of a listed company, money talks. Whether it is a financial company like KKR that would buy the company, cut out the fat and leverage it to the hilt, or a company in the industry like Amazon seeking to add smartphones right next to its ultra-successful Kindle Fire tablet, once a bid is announced, it will turn into a circus. If you thought that AT&T's proposed purchase of T-Mobile for $39 billion was wild, you ain't seen nothing yet!
Whomever is interested in buying RIM has two huge bumps in the road. The first one is to somehow take the company away from its co-CEO's, and the second one is turning RIM around into a smartphone powerhouse. Both are equally difficult and there is no point in doing the first without succeeding in the second. Perhaps this is why we have yet to see a real bid develop for RIM.