Apple's OpenAI lawsuit leaves out one name on purpose

Apple's new lawsuit against OpenAI accuses two former employees of stealing trade secrets, the same hardware push Jony Ive now leads, yet his name never comes up in the complaint. Bloomberg's Mark Gurman reports the omission traces back to Ive's friendship with Laurene Powell Jobs, and it says a lot about what Apple was willing to risk for its next iPhone rival.

Apple's lawsuit conveniently skips one obvious name

Filed last week in Northern California, the suit targets OpenAI's chief hardware officer Tang Tan, a 24-year Apple veteran, along with former engineer Chang Liu. Apple alleges Tan used internal codenames while recruiting and that Liu pulled confidential files after leaving.



Nowhere in the roughly 40-page filing does Ive's name appear, even though he's led OpenAI's hardware design since buying his own startup for $6.5 billion, and brought more than 400 former Apple employees with him. Gurman called that omission striking.

Why Jony Ive's absence traces back to Laurene Powell Jobs

At Apple's June WWDC keynote, Laurene Powell Jobs sat front row beside Tim Cook and his presumed successor, John Ternus. She's never held a board seat, but the Jobs name still carries weight in Cupertino.



Powell Jobs is also probably closer to Ive than anyone else in the Valley, the two are considered best friends, and she's invested in his startup and design firm. Naming Ive publicly risked straining that tie while drawing sympathy for a longtime Apple face.

Who Apple's complaint actually targets, and why

There's a simpler explanation too. Ive is the visionary behind OpenAI's hardware push, but he isn't deeply involved in day-to-day recruiting or engineering, so it's less likely he took part in what Apple describes. That work fell to people like Tan.

This looks like calculated restraint, not an oversight

Apple builds cases carefully, and skipping the most famous name tied to OpenAI's hardware effort doesn't read like an accident to me. It reads like a company that weighed a public fight with one of Steve Jobs' closest collaborators, and decided against it.

I'm curious whether that restraint holds if discovery turns up something new. For now, we'll be watching how OpenAI responds.

Six-month unlimited plan is now 57% off

$90

$210

$120 off (57%)

Mint Mobile is now allowing you to get whichever plan you like for either three, six, or 12 months for just $15/mo. If you go for the six-month unlimited service, for instance, you'll now have to pay just $90 upfront instead of $210.

Buy at Mint Mobile