ITC to rule in favor of Nokia in Apple lawsuit

ITC to rule in favor of Nokia in Apple lawsuit
Apple and Nokia have been locked in a legal sparring match for over a year now. Their most recent lawsuit was filed by Apple against Nokia, alleging that Nokia infringed on 9 different patented technologies. Why can't we all just get along?

A preliminary statement from a member of the International Trade Commission indicates that they will rule in favor of Nokia, saying that Nokia's usage does "not establish a violation." The ITC determined that the patents were all either invalid, or they were not infringed upon. This means Apple won't have the pleasure of seeing Nokia's imports banned.

But it's not a one-way street. Both companies have dished their share of litigation, attempting to quash their competition's imports, and claim a piece of their market share. Nokia is still the largest OS worldwide, but Apple's iPhone is a looming threat to their business.

The ITC judge is scheduled to render a verdict in February of 2011, and it may significantly affect their businesses. If Nokia were to be found guilty of infringement, the infringing devices could be banned from import, further loosening their slipping grip on the market.

source: The Wall Street Journal via TheBoyGeniusReport



1. Alex unregistered

It's just a preliminary statement from itc, not a ruling. They made that preliminary statement so not to ban nokia from importing their devices in the meantime.

2. RVM unregistered

If Nokia lose US market, it wouldn't hurt as much as if Apple lose EU market.

3. protozeloz

Posts: 5396; Member since: Sep 16, 2010

*sight* they keep bashing into each other

4. dan_md

Posts: 66; Member since: Oct 19, 2010

Apple is treading on very dangerous grounds. I hope to hear about the case where Nokia filed infringement of its patients for mobile telephony technology citing the argument that: Apple did not develop its mobile telephony technology from Nokia, a company which developed the modern GSM technology that we know today. If Nokia wins this case, they could charge Apple for every iPhone they sold. - This was the case which provoked Apple to file the so-called infringement 9 patents discussed in this article. This is is a huge slap in the face for Apple, who less than a year ago, washed its hands for employing children in one of its factories in China. I love Apple products, but there is also a premium for ethics, mind you.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.