HTC patent infringement claim against Apple dismissed by ITC

HTC patent infringement claim against Apple dismissed by ITC
Back in July when Monday Night Patent Infringement was kicking off, HTC purchased a company called S3 for $300 million. The Taiwan based company wanted control over some patents owned by the company. Although not a terribly large company, S3 was responsible for graphics on computers, mobile devices and gaming consoles. Back in November, the ITC ruled that Apple had not violated any of the patents that HTC had acquired from S3. HTC decided to appeal the initial ruling. Unfortunately for the manufacturer, on Friday the ITC dismissed the appeal and although there are options, going 0 for 2 in court is usually a sign that you need to cut your losses.

The battle between the two companies started in March 2010 when Apple filed a suit against HTC with the ITC. HTC retaliated and the ITC eventually found no violation on Apple's part. In October 211, an ALJ made an initial ruling that Apple did not violate 4 HTC patents and the latter withdrew a complaint on a 5th patent. HTC asked for an appeal by the 6 member ITC to review the ruling. In December, the ITC agreed, but only for one of HTC's patents. The ruling Friday ends the filings and investigations on that one patent.

S3 had its own infringement case against Apple, possibly motivated by Apple's actions against HTC. At a time when it looked like S3 might win the case, HTC made the decision to buy the company and take over the patents. In November, the ITC ruled in favor of Apple. According to FOSS Patents, with only 5% of smartphone patents ruled as being violated by the ITC, companies are turning to the German courts, especially the Mannheim Regional Court and the Munich I Regional Court, for relief.

In December, Apple won an import ban against HTC devices that infringed on the '647 patent relating to "data tapping" or the tapping on phone numbers to call someone back. HTC worked around this by removing the offending technology and said it is rarely used. FOSS Patents sees Apple looking to broaden the scope of the ruling by getting a ruling that another patent had been violated by appealing to the Federal Circuit. Meanwhile, for the rest of 2012, we probably will not see any final rulings in the U.S. on Apple's claims against HTC since all of the former's Federal lawsuits against HTC have been stayed by the United States District Court for the District of Delaware. A preliminary ruling from the ITC is due in November on Apple's second complaint against HTC. Nothing might come up until next year in Germany where Apple has two suits filed against HTC for four patents, two in Munich and two in Mannheim.

Last summer, HTC filed a suit against Apple, claiming that the latter illegally infringed upon 9 patents Google gave to HTC for the express reason to sue Apple. Of course, it will be up to the court to determine if these 9 patents offer a stronger case against Apple than the one that was tossed on Friday.

source: FOSSPatents



22. InspectorGadget80 unregistered

As long Apple pays these greedy ass judges. HTC or Samsung can't win. WHICH I SAY IS UNFAIR in buisness practice. Apple should be ashame of themselves for not competing against someone. all they care bout is their stocks staying high.

17. Devon

Posts: 11; Member since: Oct 07, 2011

Fosspatents is for lazy writers, Florian would spam thousands of journalists with his story and writers , some are being lazy, just post it with a few words different here and there. He does sound correct, but as sprockkets said, his analysis is way off. He is a known MS lobbyis, is against free software and may not really be pro-Apple, but against Google all the way.

16. Droid_X_Doug

Posts: 5993; Member since: Dec 22, 2010

The truth will set the haters free. They just have to accept the truth.

18. paulyyd

Posts: 340; Member since: Jan 08, 2011

i think YOU need to just let it go, you got a lot of spite towards apple. maybe cause your s**tty android phone gets outdated two weeks after its launch lolz

20. dreammixer

Posts: 81; Member since: Feb 10, 2012

truth is HTC lost

15. dreammixer

Posts: 81; Member since: Feb 10, 2012

A lot of haters here...

9. Droid_X_Doug

Posts: 5993; Member since: Dec 22, 2010

And if Google's notification patent application is allowed as filed, Apple will be in a world of hurt. Can you imagine iOS without a notification function? Or, better yet, iOS with a notification function that does not display messages? What goes around comes around.

10. Adianshadows

Posts: 66; Member since: Nov 22, 2011

but then that wouldn't be innovative!!!

12. Droid_X_Doug

Posts: 5993; Member since: Dec 22, 2010

But it would be magical....

11. itiswhatitis

Posts: 423; Member since: Jan 23, 2012

Can't wait!!!

8. remixfa

Posts: 14605; Member since: Dec 19, 2008

bribe the right judge = ban the wrong product

13. stealthd unregistered

Nothing to say = make crap up

6. roscuthiii

Posts: 2383; Member since: Jul 18, 2010

Patents: The new landmines. Get as many of them as you can out there; You only need one in the right place and the right time to freeze a company in it's tracks.

5. Devon

Posts: 11; Member since: Oct 07, 2011

Can Phonearena please stop quoting Fosspatents on this stuff like these. We all know Florian hates Google so much that he gives a spin that everything is going bad for google but when MS or Apple is in trouble he downplays it. Just quote reuters then.

14. sprockkets

Posts: 1612; Member since: Jan 16, 2012

His reporting is fine, but his analysis is a bit off. Just remember the guy uses a Samsung Galaxy Note, and had an Galaxy S phone.

4. aztaxia12295

Posts: 272; Member since: Nov 22, 2009

the itc is apples female dog. HTC should sue the ITC for the last two letters in its name.

3. thnkthru3

Posts: 73; Member since: Dec 25, 2011

The game seems rigged in apples favor!

19. Lucas777

Posts: 2137; Member since: Jan 06, 2011

did u not consider they might just be right? or wud apple actually being in the right just be impossible…

24. thnkthru3

Posts: 73; Member since: Dec 25, 2011

The odds against their being "right" 100% of the time are high.The fact that apple has more money than the federal government...yet they contnuously focus on legal rather than product developement means for taking out the competition. This is what I find so annoying. I love their products but they halve already reached that "too big to fail" status. I don"t want to live in the "United States of Apple"

25. Lucas777

Posts: 2137; Member since: Jan 06, 2011

how are they not focusing on product development? they are releasing mac os once a year (more than in years past) and are releasing new ipads, iphones, and ipods every year… even rumored to be working on tv and they arent 100% of the time… just often

26. thnkthru3

Posts: 73; Member since: Dec 25, 2011

Gave you a thumbs up on your reply!

1. bvalde09

Posts: 191; Member since: Nov 22, 2011

Could we serioulsy stop this BS This is getting ridiculous and Im tired of lawsuit. FOCUS ON THE CUSTOMERS

2. gallitoking

Posts: 4721; Member since: May 17, 2011

Both HTC and Apple have a toll free number for the customer...if you need help

7. parkwaydr

Posts: 572; Member since: Sep 07, 2011

Your user icon fits you well gallito, much like that show you are pointless, annoying, and very rarely mildly humorous.

21. bvalde09

Posts: 191; Member since: Nov 22, 2011

Lol. Ok But seriously look how much money the have spent on lawsuits. Like the "slide to unlock". You are a consumer at the end right? why dont apple put that money down to give us a good device? I was expecting the Iphone 4s to be something out of the world but it wasnt. Wouldnt you agree that they could do so much better if the focus on the customers?

23. gallitoking

Posts: 4721; Member since: May 17, 2011

I only demmand that from my doctor..

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.
FCC OKs Cingular's purchase of AT&T Wireless