iPhone Xs Max vs Galaxy Note 9, Pixel 2 XL camera comparison: which phone takes the best photos?


Last Wednesday was a fun day. I got caught out in the rain, I crawled through a mud pit, and I got to enjoy the view of the full moon rising over the sea... while my exposed ears were being cryogenically preserved by the blowing wind. But enduring all this was worth it. After all, I got to snap some great photos for the smartphone camera comparison you've landed on. Welcome!

Without a doubt, the iPhone XS Max is the star of this camera shootout. It surely has the best camera on an iPhone yet, but is it better at taking photos than the competition? To answer this question, we'll be comparing the iPhone XS Max vs the Samsung Galaxy Note 9, which has already shown that it's a formidable opponent in the smartphone camera space. And to make things more interesting, we're throwing in the Google Pixel 2 XL in the ring – a phone that's nearly a year old by now, but also one that still ranks among the best shooters on the market.

Okay, now let's take a look at some photos!

Scene 1: By the sea



A shout-out goes to my colleague Vic for helping me capture this Instagram material! 

Anyway, it looks like the iPhone XS Max and the Galaxy Note 9 did really well in this scene, and it's hard to pick a favorite. But we're leaning towards the Galaxy Note 9 for exposing our subject a tiny bit better. The Pixel 2 XL, in contrast, has literally left Vic in the shadows. It's not a very inspiring photo, honestly speaking, as the subject appears darker than we'd want him to be.

Dynamics range is also substantially better on the Note 9 and the iPhone XS Max than it is on the Pixel. Both phones have preserved those highlights in the sky really well. 


Scene 2: Flowers and colors



Among these three images, the one from the Note 9 does stand out the most, but we wouldn't call it our favorite. It's just that it looks slightly overexposed, skewing the natural colors of the plants and the grass. The Pixel 2 XL and the iPhone XS Max stick to a more balanced, more natural look, with the iPhone having a slight advantage for capturing a bit more detail in the shadows and a more faithful shade of green. 


Scene 3: By the casino



We're not sure why, but the Samsung Galaxy Note 9 delivers a slightly "flatter" image of this scene, without much contrast in it. This is easily noticeable if you compare how all three phones captured the puff and fluff of the clouds in the sky. The iPhone XS Max is again our favorite among the bunch with its eye-pleasing photo. The Pixel 2 XL comes in second place, having captured less detail in the shadows than Apple's smartphone.


Scene 4: At the opera house



Now that's interesting. It looks like the iPhone XS Max has a tendency to spice up its photos, and we won't be surprised if there's some "AI" algorithm tweaking the dials behind the scenes. Those fiery tones in the clouds cast by the setting sun look lovely against the afternoon sky, don't they? They're also a tad exaggerated, but the photo still looks impressive. 

The Galaxy Note 9, on the other hand, tamed those oranges and yellows a bit too much, maybe to expose the front of the opera house better. In any case, I'd much rather post the iPhone's photo on my Facebook wall. 

As for the Pixel 2 XL, we're once again seeing it toning down the exposure, and the results are a mixed bag. The clouds in the sky do look share-worthy, but the shadows seem too dark for our taste. 


Scene 5: The sunset



Much of the same as above is observed here in this scene. The iPhone XS Max presents us with a lovely picture prettified by a well-controlled boost in colors: the gradients in the sky and the hue of the cap look awesome. Only the skin tones are not as natural as they could have been. Meanwhile, the Galaxy Note 9 delivers a more neutral image. It is also good, but we wish the warm tones in the sky were captured more convincingly. And apologies for repeating ourselves, but the Pixel's photo should have been brighter. 


Scene 6: Dinner time



Frankly speaking, we're disappointed by all three images of this scene – though we have to admit that shooting photos around those warm, vintage-style light bulbs could be challenging to any camera. The iPhone's photo is rich in detail, but I'm not a fan of the pinkish skin tone of my face. The Note 9 couldn't focus on my face well. The Pixel 2 XL skewed the colors towards a yellowish-orange hue that's even further from reality. Who would know that a scene like this would be this tricky to photograph?


Scene 7: Pizza alley



The iPhone handled this particular scene very well. Its image is rich in detail, the signs glowing brightly are not overblown, and the overall exposure seems a lot more balanced. In contrast, the Note 9 and the Pixel 2 XL could not squeeze out as much detail from the shadowy areas. 


Scene 8: Full moon rising



Something interesting happened here: all three photos had their LED flash set to "Auto" and all three used it to illuminate the scene. All three photos looked horrible as a result, as if they were taken through a thick foggy layer, so we disabled the flash on all phones and took the shot again. What came out were these three, relatively better photos.

We have to admit that this particular scene is extra challenging, but the iPhone XS Max managed to capture it well nonetheless, with enough detail and likeable colors. But the Galaxy Note 9 is a step ahead with its clearer, more detailed image. And the photo from the Pixel 2 XL is the definition of a mixed bag. There's good detail below the horizon line, but tons of noise across the night sky makes the image unpleasant to look at. 


Conclusion


Having analyzed all of the photos above, we can conclude by saying that our camera comparison yielded predictable results – as well as one we didn't quite expect. Firstly, the iPhone XS Max takes great photos. It's not the perfect camera, of course, but it snaps lovely images without much effort on the user's side. And we're not sure what algorithms Apple has working behind the scenes, but more often than not, they do a really good job of bringing out the best parts in a scene. 

Despite the score gap, we'd say that the camera on the Samsung Galaxy Note 9 is also one holding great potential. Perhaps the scenes we chose weren't ideal for it to show us the best it is capable of? In any case, the Note 9 seems worthy of a rematch.

Lastly, the Google Pixel 2 XL didn't quite manage to impress us with its results. Its photos were largely in the mixed bag category, leaving the iPhone XS Max and Galaxy Note 9 to run circles around what's practically still Google's best phone. Perhaps the Google Pixel 3 would be an equal opponent? We sure hope so!



FEATURED VIDEO

65 Comments

62. robocopvn

Posts: 504; Member since: Mar 10, 2010

The only one thing will let me know the test result: Phonearena do a camera test on Iphone versus the others. And the result will always be Iphone on top, no matter! This is the only site to claim The Pixel 2 series are not the best phone camera out there. Period! HAHA

61. aiposh

Posts: 2; Member since: Oct 01, 2018

the current iPhones failed to beat the Pixel 2 camera, so we can only imagine what the Pixel 3's could do.

60. TMach unregistered

None of the usual judgements or comment from me but look at the link below comparing the iPhone Xs with the Xperia XZ 3 and take a view on this article..... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=muXr3ZYXDpQ

59. ssallen

Posts: 225; Member since: Oct 06, 2017

This is hilarious considering every other review shows the new iPhone still lagging behind the Pixel 2. Strange how certain sites get different, and always predictable, results...

63. robocopvn

Posts: 504; Member since: Mar 10, 2010

Because this is PhoneArenasheep, dude!

57. itznirmal

Posts: 1; Member since: Oct 01, 2018

Surprising Result! Pixel 2 wins over Iphone X in most of the other reviews. And a completely different Result here. I guess, Iphones have a special mode when being reviewed by PhoneArena!

58. Aruminiumaian

Posts: 209; Member since: Jul 22, 2017

Or PA is just telling the facts. Other websites also made a comparison like this and despite what reviewers in their articles say, in surprising number of scenes iPhone XS's output simply looked better. The one from The Verge was especially hilerious because almost in every situation iPhone's photos were more pleasant even though the reviewer was trying to tell readers otherwise.

64. robocopvn

Posts: 504; Member since: Mar 10, 2010

Because this is PhoneArenasheep house, mate!

53. path45th

Posts: 407; Member since: Sep 11, 2016

I like the colors of the clouds at the opera house for the iPhone but the pinkish skin color at the dinner is not very accurate. Overall, the iPhone produced better looking photos with punchy colors and good details. The iPhone is the best smartphone camera for 2018. Next.

52. Vagabondjonez

Posts: 163; Member since: Jan 21, 2016

Everything wrong with these devices can probably be patched in software,but whether that will happen is totally up to the OEM.

51. Chris_ABN

Posts: 206; Member since: May 16, 2018

I expected these results from PhoneArena

65. robocopvn

Posts: 504; Member since: Mar 10, 2010

I am also, mate. I even don't need to look on the body of content, we know who would win, right after reading the title from PhoneArenasheep, right?

50. chris2k5

Posts: 291; Member since: Nov 17, 2012

Note 9 got spanked

48. Budhainthemood

Posts: 104; Member since: Mar 03, 2018

Good job, Apple. This time they nailed it. Congrats to the rest, they also performed superb.

46. Pureviewuser1

Posts: 172; Member since: Mar 28, 2016

I want the next pixel to be better than the iphone and the next note to be even better and also the next iphone followed by the next pixel and so on so in the end there are better products and the consumer benefits

45. Furkan

Posts: 552; Member since: Feb 25, 2017

Who trusts you, PhoneArena? Do a blind comparison

66. robocopvn

Posts: 504; Member since: Mar 10, 2010

Sheeps always trust, I think!

42. midan

Posts: 3300; Member since: Oct 09, 2017

That XS smart HDR really gives photos which haven't seen from smartphones before. The harder the lighing situation gets the better results XS gives, dynamic range over the photos is just stunning for the smartphone where you usually see like white sky or just too bright areas.

37. YeahYeah

Posts: 255; Member since: Mar 16, 2016

Come on. This was expected. Its phoneArena

35. Darckent

Posts: 101; Member since: Sep 17, 2016

Would I ever trust a camera test from this site when using a iPhone? Would I heck.. This site is known for its Apple propaganda and lies on any other phone that doesn't have a fruit sign

41. Aruminiumaian

Posts: 209; Member since: Jul 22, 2017

Bla bla bla I get it, but at least read through the actual article then talk.

32. cocoy

Posts: 467; Member since: Oct 30, 2015

If you're keen on details, looking at the thumbnail alone without reading the article, you'll know that iPhone XS Max is the winner in this comparison.

31. cocoy

Posts: 467; Member since: Oct 30, 2015

In some comparisons (other site) note 9 & pixel 3 wins, I can't say that they favored iPhone here because i haven't seen the process of taking the shots and the way it was presented here. Some fanboys are being judgemental. As I said before in the review of this phone, the camera improvement is commendable for Apple. It is a great improvement over the last generation. The cameras of these phones are good it only depend on where ecosystem do you belong.

30. ezfidel

Posts: 63; Member since: Dec 25, 2012

That's cool that iPhone max won an all that but how come this is the only camera comparison that I've seen where the Pixel 2 lost to the iPhone xs?

29. akistz

Posts: 31; Member since: Sep 26, 2018

iPhone Xs max is shaping up to be a greater upgrade than we all thought it would be at first. Prepare some split screen features and it will be perfect

21. ShadowWarrior

Posts: 176; Member since: Aug 08, 2017

Ah the hyper obsession with photos these days. Keep piling up those hard drives, you'll look at them one day.

40. Aruminiumaian

Posts: 209; Member since: Jul 22, 2017

That's because most flagship phones are almost completely indistinguishable from each other in all aspects and manufacturers needs to do something to differentiate their products from others'. Camera is the most eye-catching features for average consumers for now, so manufacturers obsess with camera as if taking photos is the only way to use phones.

20. kiko007

Posts: 7526; Member since: Feb 17, 2016

They all look good gents. Put away your pitchforks.

11. cmdacos

Posts: 4429; Member since: Nov 01, 2016

Some of those iPhone pics are vastly over saturated. Funny how the goalposts move...

12. apple-rulz

Posts: 2198; Member since: Dec 27, 2016

Shhhhh, just apply the butthurt cream and go to bed.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.
FCC OKs Cingular's purchase of AT&T Wireless