No joke: Sen. Al Franken wants to know more about the fingerprint scanner on the Samsung Galaxy S5

No joke: Sen. Al Franken wants to know more about the fingerprint scanner on the Samsung Galaxy S5
Al Franken might be a Senator from Minnesota, but most of you might remember him from his days as a Saturday Night Live funnyman. Or perhaps the mere mention of his name brings to mind the gorilla trainer role he had in the Eddie Murphy-Dan Akroyd film Trading Places. Now a politician, Franken seems to have a thing about fingerprint scanners. When the Apple iPhone 5s rolled out with Touch ID last September, Franken wanted to hear more from Apple about whether the fingerprints obtained by the iPhone are stored by Apple.

Now, it is Samsung's turn to face the wrath of Franken. In a letter written to the company abut the fingerprint scanner on the Samsung Galaxy S5, the Senator asks a number of questions about where the fingerprint data will be stored, and if third parties will have the opportunity to (pardon the pun) get their hands on this information. Franken also points out the difference between Touch ID and Sammy's biometric feature. While Touch ID allows five failed attempts before a password prompt appears, Samsung's fingerprint scanner allows for unlimited attempts.

Franken also points out that while Touch ID is used to unlock an iPhone and open certain Apple apps, the Galaxy S5 scanner can be used in lieu of a password. That means that a hacker might be able to steal your identity and secure a Pay Pal transfer to his account by using your hijacked fingerprint data.

The Senator wants to know what Samsung's future plans are for the biometric security feature, and wants Samsung to assure that it won't do anything improper with information generated by the fingerprint scanner. If you read through Franken's letter (you can read it in its entirety on Franken's U.S. Senate website) you get the feeling that this is a serious matter for him. Identity fraud is nothing to joke about.

source: U.S.Senate (Al Franken) via AndroidCentral

Related phones

Galaxy S5
  • Display 5.1" 1080 x 1920 pixels
  • Camera 16 MP / 2.1 MP front
  • Processor Qualcomm Snapdragon 801, Quad-core, 2500 MHz
  • Storage 32 GB + microSDXC
  • Battery 2800 mAh(21h 3G talk time)



1. 0xFFFF

Posts: 3806; Member since: Apr 16, 2014

Because there's always one politician who is tasked with the job of making it look like the government cares.

23. sgodsell

Posts: 7369; Member since: Mar 16, 2013

That's why OEMS need to include front facing camera's with at least 5-8mp, then you can use your eye for a log in. Nobody leaves their eye around, also it has the added benefit of not changing as much as a finger print. Fingers get dirty, cuts, and scrape's can change the finger print. That's why they build in a margin of error when scanning. OEMS could even turn up the screen brightness when scanning an eye. So the screen would act as a light.

25. engineer-1701d unregistered

that and he whats to let people know he is not the same guy from years ago on snl and a few funny movies loved trading places, but still like they care i mean look at the thumb locks for houses and nfc locks just as easy to steel and do same if not more damage.

2. metalspy101

Posts: 105; Member since: Dec 15, 2012

android ftw

3. Sauce unregistered

The whole "fingerprints are not secure" BS is a crock of crap. Whoever says/believes that, belongs in Fairfield Hills (look it up). I'm pretty sure if my phone was stolen at a bar, concert, or any public place (or even my own home or work), the thief will not have any knowledge on how to "rip" my fingerprint and use it to get into my phone. It can't be done within 1,5,10,20,30,60,400 minutes. To do this, you need the proper materials (of which most people can't even spell without looking it up). Even then, it isn't guaranteed. If you think a fingerprint isn't "secure" for unlocking your phone or confirming App Store purchases, then you might as well all remove your pass codes on your phones and computers.

5. 0xFFFF

Posts: 3806; Member since: Apr 16, 2014

It all depends on who you are and why they want your phone. If it is just some thugs looking for a quick buck, then a fingerprint is fine for this sort of scenario. But if you are someone important and they want the data on your phone, then they will take your finger and your phone, not just your phone. Personally, I don't think an unchangeable personal identifier should be used for any serious form of security. But for casual matters, it is fine. Just remember, that the fingerprint also ties you uniquely to what is done on your phone -- good, bad, or just plain ugly.

9. Sauce unregistered

Well said. I'm sure someone of high value, interest, or security won't be using an S5 or 5S though hehe. I mean hey, for $30,000, you can hire a hit man on the Deep Web :D

4. willard12 unregistered

I wasn't aware that Samsung allowed unlimited attempts. I thought you had to enter a full password (not just pin) after a certain number of failed attempts.

6. 0xFFFF

Posts: 3806; Member since: Apr 16, 2014

Some companies do "security theatre" better than others.

8. PapaSmurf

Posts: 10457; Member since: May 14, 2012

It's five failed attempt before you have to enter an alternate password. Idk what the hell this guy is smoking.

10. Sauce unregistered

Full coverage LTE. Jealous.

12. PapaSmurf

Posts: 10457; Member since: May 14, 2012

All over Chicago, especially right next to my house since I live four blocks away from a tower lol.

13. Sauce unregistered

Lucky ass, liven' 4 blocks from a dang tower lol. I pay for LTE and get a steady 2-3 bar connection. Still good, and am grateful for fast speeds, but it tends to slack off a lot around here. (Stamford)

14. PapaSmurf

Posts: 10457; Member since: May 14, 2012

You have T-Mo? BTW, my WiFi speeds with Comcast are ridiculous.

15. benzb

Posts: 81; Member since: Jan 19, 2012

After 5 attempts, the S5 will ask you for the alternate password. However, you can press the back key and try your fingerprint again. If it's incorrect, it will ask you again for the alternate password. If you press the back key, you can try your fingerprint again. If it's incorrect, it will ask you for the alternate password. If you press the back key again, you can try your fingerprint.... you can do this unlimited times. Get the picture? The S5 does not "force" you to enter an alternate password.

19. PapaSmurf

Posts: 10457; Member since: May 14, 2012

It's partially "unlimited" but not really. Better than having the phone lock for minutes or even hours after so many failed attempts.

20. j2001m

Posts: 3061; Member since: Apr 28, 2014

its just been updated in the uk and you now got give it 30sec before you can try again and you only get 20 goes before the password is needed

7. thecellphnman

Posts: 10; Member since: Mar 17, 2010

I understand why he is asking about the scanners. I really do and appreciate it. However, this guy is a joke and I am embarrassed to say he represents my state. Just awful!

11. PapaSmurf

Posts: 10457; Member since: May 14, 2012

This guy is a complete joke and doesn't know what he's talking about. The S5 requires you to type in the alternate password after five failed attempts. (Comment #8) Misleading information like this makes me question one's knowledge on technology.

16. benzb

Posts: 81; Member since: Jan 19, 2012

Look at my comment (#15)

17. cheeseycheeser

Posts: 413; Member since: Mar 24, 2011

Why do I even care about some company/hacker potentially getting my fingerprint. It's not any different than a password (except you only have 10 options) and it's not like anyone ACTUALLY cares about me (or you). We are not important enough for some hacker to go through the trouble with fingerprints. This whole argument is basically an ego trip for 99% of people.

18. rallyguy

Posts: 620; Member since: Mar 13, 2012

NSA has already stolen it. More of a chance it leaking from them, then getting stolen from your phone.

21. InspectorGadget80 unregistered

He should also know more bout the iph5s finger sensor not just samsung

22. Ninetysix

Posts: 2964; Member since: Oct 08, 2012

RTFA eh?

24. Immolate

Posts: 310; Member since: Jun 17, 2011

Al Franken... when electing Jesse Ventura as Governor doesn't get the point across.

26. Elfmonster unregistered

1. Thief runs off with your phone. 2. Thief uses simple tape to pull your fingerprint off the phone button itself or off the screen. 3. Thief transfers your imprint for thumb pressing the button. If you don't understand this, go watch some old episodes of Burn Notice.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.