LG G6 vs G5, G4: should I upgrade?

LG G6 vs G5, G4: should I upgrade?
The LG G6 is out and it's definitely a drool-worthy piece of hardware. Amazing screen-to-body ratio, beautiful design, and a lot of time spent on fine-tuning its operation and performance, as per LG's own word. Surely, there are LG device owners out there right now, spending more time than one would consider reasonable staring at pictures of the new phone and then beaming over to their own G5. There's that burning question:

Should I upgrade to the LG G6?

There are always a few things to consider when buying a new phone — is your model obsolete, does the new device offer more than just bling, is it worth the investment, so on and so forth. We'll be looking at this question from a couple of perspectives — one for LG G4 owners, who should be due for an upgrade on their 2-year-old device soon, and LG G5 owners, who might be itching to try the new thing while it's hot. Let's take a look at a few key features that the G6 has going for it.

That screen!

Enormous display, small body

The LG G6 has a 5.7-inch display, yet the phone is more compact than the LG G5, which has a noticeable smaller 5.3-inch screen. Yes, this is how thin the G6's bezels are. There is absolutely no denying this — if screen size is your primary thing, it's hard to resist the temptation of buying LG's newest offering.

What if you own an LG G4? It still has a slightly smaller 5.5-inch display, while the phone is roughly the same size as the new G6, only slightly clunkier in shapes.

Dolby Vision

It hasn't just improved in size — the G6's display supports Dolby Vision and HDR10. What does that mean? Better contrast — a wider range between black and white, exposing more detail and lifelike imagery —, more vibrant colors, and dynamic scene optimization — meaning the phone auto-tunes the display to optimize viewer experience for every scene.

Big screen, awesome colors and contrast, small body. If media consumption is the name of your game, the G6 is a hard-to-resist temptation.

All-new hardware

The LG G6 comes with a Qualcomm Snapdragon 821 processor and 4 GB of RAM. In the meantime, the G5 has a Snapdragon 820, and the same amount of RAM. So, will we get a huge performance boost from the newer model? Most likely not. The 821 is built very similarly to the 820, but offers slightly higher clock speeds.

However, the newer processor supports the Snapdragon VR SDK. As you might have guessed, this is a driving force behind Google's Daydream platform. Basically, if you are all hyped about VR, you might consider upgrading from the G5 to the G6, especially since the G5's 360 VR goggles weren't especially great.

For G4 owners, the jump in hardware will be much more pronounced, as the 2-year-old flagship sports a Snapdragon 808 and 3 GB of RAM. You will enjoy a snappier performance and will get access to the aforementioned Daydream VR platform.

In terms of processor and memory, G5 owners shouldn't be hasty to pull the trigger, but G4 users should be happy to do so.

In terms of battery, we've got a 3,300 mAh cell in the G6. For comparison, the one in the G5 has a 2,800 mAh capacity, and the one in the G4 has 3,000 mAh of juice. So, the G6 may have a slightly longer battery life than its predecessors, but it's too early to tell.

Camera upgrade

The LG G5 had a dual camera module on its back, with a “regular” 13 MP camera, and a 135-degree, wide-angle snapper that had a smaller, 8 MP sensor. The G6 sports the same resolution for its main shooter and the wide-angle snapper gets boosted up to 13 MP as well. Not much to entice G5 owners to upgrade, admittedly, unless you are using the wide-angle lens exclusively.

Now, it's worth noting that the G6's camera interface features a Manual Video mode — something that has thus far been exclusive to the V10 and V20. Whether this feature will be passed down to the G5 via a future software upgrade is unknown at this moment.

For the G4 owners, the whole dual-camera sensor will be an entirely new thing. But if you're not really that into the whole wide-angle photography deal, we'd say that the G4's main camera is still pretty adequate today. We are, however, fairly certain that the chances of getting a Manual Video mode on the G4 are less than slim.

It's also worth noting that the front-facing camera on the G6 has... changed. It has an 8 MP resolution on the G4 and G5, but is slapped down to 5 MP on the G6. This is in favor of a wide, 100-degree viewing angle for selfies against massive backgrounds or taking group pictures. If you want a more “orthodox” look, without the distortion that comes from the wide-angle lens, there's a mode for that, but what it does is zoom in and crop the image. As a result, the selfies are... not the best.

Things to consider and final verdict

There are also a number of smaller details to consider — pieces of the puzzle that make the G6 as cool as it is. The camera bump has been neutralized on the G6, and its back is completely flush. Wireless charging is now available for US versions of the device. And there are a number of software features that make use of the 2:1 display ratio, which just can't be effectively passed along to the older flagships.

It's also worth noting that the G6 comes with Android 7.1 Nougat and has the Google Assistant on board — the AI that has thus far been exclusive to the Pixel devices and we had no idea whether it'd be hitting 3rd party smartphone makers. Well... it seems like it will.

Final verdict? Well, we would say that the LG-faithful that are still rocking a G4 should be happy to upgrade to the G6 — it's awesome in every way. G5 users, we feel, shouldn't be quick to jump the gun. Unless you are super-excited about the new form factor of the G6, its Dolby Vision display, its Daydream compatibility, and Google Assistant. Other than that, the G5 is still a pretty solid phone that can hold out for another year.



1. jest30

Posts: 3; Member since: Feb 26, 2017

I have G4 but will be upgrading in 2018. Hopefully they will stick to 2 major updates or else i am done with LG.

6. Highside

Posts: 197; Member since: Jan 31, 2017

An LG without a removable battery is worthless. The G6 is the end for LG.

11. Nebice

Posts: 68; Member since: Jan 05, 2015

Sadly not, i dont like the trend myself, but a lot of idiots who are fanboys of Samsung and Iphone get hyped by the "premium design" thus not using a case, dropping the phone like an idiot and getting a "cheap" replacement for 100€, also waterproof design which is useless, most phones are splash resistant anyways (rain, small water splashes), but hey "i dont care about my 800€ s**t so i drop it into water or 'need' it during a shower" biggest problem modern phones still have is that the battery becomes garbage after 1~2 years meaning you'll need a new phone which does exactly the same as your current one. all can be sold if you have people not thinking about their decisions getting hyped by useless features and forgetting about whats important.

2. Sprissy

Posts: 193; Member since: Feb 11, 2012

I have a G4, I want to upgrade but I am seriously considering the V20...but then maybe I should just wait for the V30.

3. osni01

Posts: 1; Member since: Feb 26, 2017

I had the LG G3 and currently have the G4. I love these devices, but I'm so done with LG now... The complete lack of software support and locked bootloader seriously pissed me off. I had to downgrade to Lollipop because that's the only way I can get root on the G4 >_

4. IronTech

Posts: 153; Member since: May 27, 2016

The complete lack of software support? What are you smoking, buddy? Other than Google, LG deliver the major updates quicker than the others do.

8. lallolu

Posts: 734; Member since: Sep 18, 2012

What are you talking about? Bootloader can be easily unlocked. Root is easy also.

5. Mreveryphone

Posts: 1849; Member since: Apr 22, 2014

Yes you should upgrade... Upgrade to a different brand altogether! With this fragmented specs release across different countries is ridiculous... LG drops the ball again when they had the chance to get it right... LG G6 = DOA...

7. DoggyDangerous

Posts: 1028; Member since: Aug 28, 2015

You are right. I don't understand the logic of LG. Why they made features region specific? Why no wireless charging for Asia, middle east, Europe and Africa? Why quad dac is only exclusive for Korea?

9. amasog

Posts: 552; Member since: Aug 22, 2013

Upgrade? For what? For bragging? To show the work that you own the latest gadget? LOL! Me.. Am just being practical. As long as my g3 works properly, i wouldn't not waste my hard earned money buying those latest smartphones because for me, there is no..shall i say... important or significant benefits. My g3 has all what i need and want from a smartphone - fm radio, ir blaster, builtin flashlight, removable battery.. To name few.

10. timewastermcgee

Posts: 10; Member since: May 04, 2015

Currently have a G4 and satisfied with it as the upgrades are relatively insignificant. I intend to cancel my phone insurance and if it goes, buy a G5 or another G4 depending on available deals. I figure that the $300 or so saved would be better spent on other items like a bluetooth smoker. This routine public salivation over "improved" screen resolution, sound, speed, etc is getting old. After all, I can remember the same ooos and ahhhs occurring when the first iphone or HTC Evo was introduced. Perhaps I'm just stepping back and viewing from a deeper perspective.

12. bassembm

Posts: 143; Member since: Dec 27, 2015

"The LG G5 had a dual camera module on its back, with a “regular” 13 MP camera, and a 135-degree, wide-angle snapper that had a smaller, 8 MP sensor. The G6 sports the same resolution for its main shooter " totally wrong info ,, LG G5 had a dual camera with a regular 16 MP camera and 135 degree wide angle ,, while the G6 had a dual camera with 13 MP

13. laditude22longitude

Posts: 9; Member since: Mar 07, 2017

lg g6 is literally just a big piece of glass with metal on the back

14. gijoe50000

Posts: 1; Member since: Sep 05, 2017

I have a G4 and I was looking through the specs and details here to try to give myself an excuse to upgrade. Sadly I only found reasons NOT to upgrade. Non-removable battery, smaller camera, same resolution screen. Do they even bother their arse anymore? A faster CPU and more RAM is not enough reason to upgrade. It looks like phones have hit a point where they're good enough and the next models just don't bring very much to the table anymore. If you were upgrading from a G2 to a G6 then I'd say maybe.. The only thing I dislike about my G4 is that it's the 815P model with the locked bootloader. When I do eventually upgrade I'm going to make damn sure the phone I buy has an unlocked bootloader, I miss the fun of installing custom ROMs..

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.
FCC OKs Cingular's purchase of AT&T Wireless