Here's the leak with Nishibori's testimony that might get Samsung into court contempt trouble

Here's the leak with Nishibori's testimony that might get Samsung into court contempt trouble
Judge Koh was rather annoyed yesterday that Samsung leaked a slideshow to the press with the Samsung F700 design evidence she already refused to include in the trial. After begging her in the morning to reconsider, Samsung's counsel John Quinn might have taken the matter in his own hands, and eventually instructed the PR team to put together a slideshow with the refuted evidence, and send it to the press. If he is found to be behind that leak, he might face fines and jail time for court contempt.

We might not get that far, but looking at the slideshow below, we understand why Samsung was so adamant for this to become public, and, as Apple's lawyer Harold McElhinny puts it, trying to "polute the jury".

The slides also contain the initial testimony from Apple's designer Shin Nishibori, behind the "Sony-Jony" concepts, who refused to be summoned by Samsung any further, and has apparently left Apple and flown to Hawaii because of a "medical condition", or so his lawyers say. There he says that Jony Ive asked him to step aside for a moment and have fun thinking if Sony designed an iPhone what would it look like, resulting in the concept, based on a Sony designer's ideas shared in a Bloomberg interview in 2006.

Samsung then continues with touchscreen phone designs it had in the studio predating the iPhone, some of which, like the "IReen", have rounded corners and a sole home button underneath the display.

source: AllThingsD



24. taz89

Posts: 2014; Member since: May 03, 2011

Lol looks like we know who the judge is rooting for... I mean doesn't get any more obvious than to not allow clear evidence that is in Samsung’s favour.. She's mad cause the fact that these evidence are relevant and she has said no to them shows the rest of the world what a incompetent judges she is... With a judge like this Samsung will have to hope that the jury is not as biased.

23. marchels14 unregistered

after this its shown clearly that Samsung is treat d unfairly and that judge is in favor of apple,in the end i predict that apple will win.

20. ncv144

Posts: 126; Member since: May 04, 2012

I thought America had a free press where the press had the right to write anything they like unless its blatant lying. (I'm not American but in my country we also have free press

19. zhypher_23

Posts: 195; Member since: Jun 04, 2012

Thumbs up if you agree that Judge Posner should be the one handling this Trial FTW.

18. sp3llv3xit

Posts: 25; Member since: Sep 15, 2011

Judge Koh. Bad call. She's probably using the vibra function of her iPhone in chambers.

16. structureman116

Posts: 142; Member since: Sep 14, 2010

How is Judge Koh still presiding over this case? It is blatantly obvious that she is sitting in the bleachers on Apple's side of the field. I wonder how many shares of Apple stock she or her husband or her parents own! She is clearly trying to give this entire case to Apple.

15. aLmoravado

Posts: 2; Member since: Jul 28, 2012

Why appoint a judge of Asian descent in the first place? She might be out to go against Samsung just to show she's not favoring them because they are Asian too. I am not on either's side, but it's apparent that Samsung is being unfairly treated by the judge.

14. boblight

Posts: 84; Member since: Jul 28, 2012

Apple-Samsung Court Case : Technology's biggest soap opera. Someone should make a movie out of this next. -__-

13. groupsacc

Posts: 232; Member since: Feb 28, 2012

Let's all just take a step back from all of this and take a breather. What on earth are we doing here? A trial about who was the first to come up with rectangular mobile phones?? WTF??!!!!?!? I mean, it's given! It's only natural! Just like wheels are circle! Oh Jesus save us.

12. Packer29

Posts: 56; Member since: Sep 10, 2011

It's fairly obvious to anyone who isn't bias that judge Kohs not neutral and clearly is in Apples POCKET!

10. Ronoc039

Posts: 28; Member since: Jul 18, 2012

21. remixfa

Posts: 14605; Member since: Dec 19, 2008

that doesnt predate any of the samsung phones which were launched near that time. those phones would have "initial designs" dating back even further. That is just a rounded rectangle with a touch screen. there is not a single "apple" identifier on there, and it could be confused with any of dozens of other smartphones that were out both before and after the iphone. A touchscreen - non keyboard phone is only going to have so many shapes that work well for consumer comfort and use. Its not copying, its ergonomics. Either way, Apple was nowhere near first with the design.

9. pikapowerize

Posts: 1869; Member since: May 03, 2012

will they just concentrate on innovations?!... i like apple products and some samsung devices (appliances) if this will be finish i hope no more fight in the future.. i wish best of luck to both of them... may the odds be forever in your favor! :P

5. p0rkguy

Posts: 685; Member since: Nov 23, 2010

So the guy leaves Apple a month before the trial, flew to Hawaii and now cannot be forced on trial due to medical conditions? I don't know about you but sounds like he's being paid off.

7. andro.

Posts: 1999; Member since: Sep 16, 2011

Apple acting in the most honourable way as usual lol. It literally astounds me how many I fans still blindly defend them,its like a phrase in the matrix movie,those most dependant on and controlled by the matrix are those who will fight the most to defend it.

8. SonyFTW2020

Posts: 311; Member since: May 03, 2012

hahaha now just think if their passion was some how changed and brought to the light! They would have much more to give and say....Cant blame em for being blind and caught up becuase this company seeks to prey on the weak and faulty with simple but effective strategies that appeal mostly to the human desires...which is beauty......... not power

22. Droid_X_Doug

Posts: 5993; Member since: Dec 22, 2010

Sounds like judicial error on Koh's part. Sammy got its first grounds for filing it's appeal should it lose this round. This fight is going to go on for years.

1. taco50

Posts: 5506; Member since: Oct 08, 2009

I have to say I'm enjoying this so far. Samsung is on a crash and burn mission pissing of the judge every chance they get.

2. SonyFTW2020

Posts: 311; Member since: May 03, 2012

hahahah the proof is in the pudding! you can fool the kids but the grown folk now know what is going on... So the people that are NOT in denial please step to the samsung side of the court..LOL

17. Phullofphil

Posts: 1846; Member since: Feb 10, 2009

Everybody copied everybody including apple. its just like what a tv has to be shaped like. its a rectangle the only thing that is close is having the one buton on the device for a home button. i love android phones and iphones and soon i might get back into windows phone 8 but my point is the case should not go forward and wast tax payer money.

3. Nicksully23

Posts: 16; Member since: Dec 09, 2010

No one cares!

4. akbar

Posts: 62; Member since: Feb 09, 2012

And the judge is on crash and burn mission to make favours to Apple. Say again, why those materials were not allowed?

6. Sniggly

Posts: 7305; Member since: Dec 05, 2009

The judge is also clearly on a mission to seek out reasons to get pissed off at Samsung. I mean, look at the stuff they would have presented. It would have killed Apple's entire case that the iPhone design came completely from them and therefore they deserved the stupid design patents. Koh is actively trying to cripple Samsung's case before it even gets started. If Samsung wins, books should be written about the strategies involved, because they've been forced into a true underdog position.

* Some comments have been hidden, because they don't meet the discussions rules.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.
FCC OKs Cingular's purchase of AT&T Wireless