Regulators in India reportedly start probe over Google's misuse of Android's dominant position

Regulators in India reportedly start probe over Google's misuse of Android's dominant position
While India is the second largest smartphone market in the world, its position as a developing country limits sales of higher-end flagship phones. That is why a value based firm like Xiaomi has done so well in the country. And while Apple expands production of the iPhone in India to current models, there is a huge price discrepancy that manufacturers of Android phones are able to take advantage of. As a result, Android devices have captured approximately 99% of smartphone sales in the region this year according to Counterpoint Research. Reuters reports today that the Competition Commission of India (CCI) is looking into claims that Google is abusing this position by forcing manufacturers to pre-install certain apps on their Android phones.

The Indian antitrust regulators didn't publicly announce the charges against Google, but Reuters' sources say that the allegations are similar to a case that the European Commission brought against Google. The EC claimed that Google was forcing phone manufacturers to pre-install Google Search, Google Chrome browser and the Google Play Store on their Android devices, thus giving Google an advantage over other developers. As a result, last summer the EC fined Google a little over $5 billion. Even though Google appealed the fine, last month it unveiled two new screens for Android users in Europe that suggest third-party browsers and search engines that users can install on their Android devices.

If the CCI finds that Google violated antitrust laws in the country, it can impose a fine no higher than 10% of the company's revenue over the last three years that came from Google Search and the Chrome browser in India. Last year, Google was fined 1.36 billion rupees by the CCI (equivalent to $19.46 million USD) for what was called "search bias" and abuse of its dominant position. The company put its own commercial flight search feature on Google Search results. Google appealed this fine as well.

The probe could take as long as one year to complete

Google has responded to news of the CCI investigation by noting how Android has made low-cost access to the internet possible for millions of Indians and the company wants to meet with the regulatory agency "to demonstrate how Android has led to more competition and innovation, not less." The CCI started looking into the matter last year after receiving multiple complaints and started its investigation in mid-April, according to those knowledgeable about the case. One source says that "It is a strong case for the CCI, given the EU precedent. The CCI has (preliminarily) found Google abused its dominant position." Today's report says that Google executives will be called to appear in front of the commission, and the investigation could take a year to complete.

While Android is a free open source operating system, manufacturers must pay a license to Google for use of the Google Play Store, Google Search, and the Chrome browser. There are manufacturers who offer Android phones without obtaining a license from Google, but most of those devices are found in overseas markets. However, Amazon, which uses such a version of Android on its Fire tablets, tried the same thing with its Fire Phone back in 2014. As it does with its tablets, the Google Play Store was replaced with the Amazon Appstore. The phone was a flop; months after its release, AT&T was selling it for just 99 cents with a signed two-year contract.



1. oldskool50 unregistered

The EU is stupid. Google isnt forcing. It is a requirement of using Android. Same as with Windows. So what its preinstalled. Those other people can install their stuff too. No one wants to use their stuff because it doesnt work. Googlw stuff works. The EU is nothing more than a Govt brand used to extort money from companies. If Europe wants to compete and offer something better no one is stopping them. This argument just has zero ground. What good would a Google phone be without those apps? If those manufacturers dont wanna have that stuff, then make your own platform. India trying to do the same thing is equally as stupid as when the EU did it.

2. Fred3

Posts: 563; Member since: Jan 16, 2018

Those other developers are most likely the ones that ran to the EU complaining and making up bs cause they know the EU don't even understand what's going on.

4. XRN5AI unregistered

Other than playstore most google apps are useless for me that's why i disabled google app, chrome, duo, play music, play movie, gmail and gboard.

5. iloveapps

Posts: 867; Member since: Mar 21, 2019

But when apple is in hot mess about app store monopoly you were talking different. Typical fantard. But it wiuld be better if google is being sued about security and privacy instead of this.

8. lyndon420

Posts: 6836; Member since: Jul 11, 2012

It would be better if apple were sued because of how much they lie to their customers and overcharge them.

3. lyndon420

Posts: 6836; Member since: Jul 11, 2012

India is looking for free money that's all this is. Same thing with the EU and with their similar lawsuits. Buy a Ford and guess's full of Ford parts. Nothing is stopping these other manufacturers from creating their own operating systems and app stores. We could use more options anyway.

6. NarutoKage14

Posts: 1327; Member since: Aug 31, 2016

This is stupid. How would you access the internet without a browser? How would you access email without an email client? Google is trying to make the user experience as coherent as possible for everyone. Nothing stopping users from installing their preferred app, that's what the play store is for.

7. lyndon420

Posts: 6836; Member since: Jul 11, 2012

Well said. Thumbs up for you sir.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.