What's the holdup with Samsung Galaxy S4's Exynos 5 Octa version?

What's the holdup with Samsung Galaxy S4's Exynos 5 Octa version?
There's no doubt Samsung came up with a pretty fine chip developing the so-called octo-core Exynos 5 Octa mobile processor. It was announced at the CES expo back in January, at a presentation, which, while not an off-Broadway show like the S4 unveiling, was pretty high up their in visuals and celebs, and where even former President Bill Clinton took the stage to endorse Samsung's efforts in making the world a better place, one gadget at a time.

Exynos 5 Octa also turned out to be a rather powerful piece of silicon, besting every mobile processor currently on the market in synthetic benchmark tests, even the new Snapdragon generation by Qualcomm, which is powering phones like the HTC One or LG Optimus G Pro. Then why is Samsung not using it in its flagship Galaxy S4 more, despite that there is clearly a version of it with Exynos 5 Octa making the rounds in benchmarks and that will be sold in certain markets?

At first we thought it might be because of LTE compatibility. Qualcomm's processor are a veritable system-on-a-chip (SoC) endeavor, as they have the broadband radios built into the chipset, instead of tacked on later, like with the Exynos series. It is not easy to develop a compact and frugal LTE chip with all the filters to avoid band interference, and make it play well with the other elements of a mobile processor without affecting battery life more than needed. Qualcomm has mastered this process, making it a breeze for manufacturers to just leave the Texans take care of everything related to processing and connectivity, and focus on design and added features.

Recommended Stories
Samsung's mobile chip department, however, stated on Twitter last week that "the Exynos 5 Octa supports LTE and all 20 bands," nixing the 4G connectivity doubts in the bud. What we are left with after this statement is the previous speculation that Samsung just can't make enough Exynos 5 Octa processors to power all the tens of millions of Galaxy S4 sales that are expected to be realized, simple as that.

What's the holdup? Well, it turns out that Samsung went with the simpler and cheaper way to design 28nm chips like the Exynos 5 Octa, called gate-first, while the competing foundry TSMC designed its production capacity with the harder to implement gate-last process, developed by Intel. The problem stems from the fact that gate-first might be easier to transition to, but gives yield problems later on, especially with complex SoCs, and that's exactly what seems to be happening with Exynos 5 Octa. 

Here's the more scientific citation, eventually explained by one of Samsung's chip customers in the Silicon Valley:

Long story short, it might be a while before Samsung ramps up enough 28nm yield for Exynos 5 Octa to be implemented on a broader scale throughout its portfolio of mobile gadgets. Granted, only performance geeks would care about the benchmark difference between the Snapdragon 600 and Exynos 5 Octa chips, as today's mobile processors are already more powerful than Android needs, but this little episode might be a hint that the touted 14nm and even 20nm chips that Samsung says it has tapped out already, might remain in the labs longer than we thought, of which the main beneficiary will likely be TSMC, exactly where Apple is heading to build its proprietary A6 and A7 chipsets.

source: DanielNenny (SemiWiki), CPUBoss & Maltiel-consulting

Recommended Stories

Loading Comments...
FCC OKs Cingular\'s purchase of AT&T Wireless