x PhoneArena is hiring! Reviewer in the USA
  • Hidden picShow menu
  • Home
  • News
  • Modular smartphones: How it started and where is it all heading?

Modular smartphones: How it started and where is it all heading?

Posted: , by Plamen D.

Tags :

Modular smartphones: How it started and where is it all heading?

Most contemporary smartphones largely look the same – slabs of plastic, metal and glass, with large touchscreen displays, front and back cameras, and physical buttons thrown here and there for good measure. They generally last a few years, and since they can't be opened or improved with new hardware, users are usually forced to buy a new one after the advance of technology renders their handset obsolete. This design standard has barely changed over the last ten years, and its popularity can be mainly attributed to the huge success of the original iPhone that premiered in 2007.

However, another form factor has also been trying to break through and entice the mass consumer over the last several years. Compared to the common designs described above, this approach aims to lower repair costs and electronic waste, while improving on longevity and user comfort at the same time. What are we talking about? Modular phones, of course!

In this article, we'll take a look at how the whole concept started, which are the most successful attempts for modular handsets to date, and we're also going to share our opinion on what the future may hold for modular gadgets. Without further ado, lets dig in!

The history of modular design 



Unsurprisingly, the idea for modular gadgets didn't suddenly appear when smartphones came about. Anyone that is familiar with PCs and the tower cases that commonly host their components will tell you that you can easily swap parts like hard drives, graphic cards, CPUs etc. in order to keep your desktop up-to-date, so the notion of having exchangeable electronic parts stems from there.

This concept then made its way to PDAs (personal digital assistants or handheld PCs), and in 1999, Handspring's Visor was one of the first mobile devices to have such a feature. Its "Springboard Expansion Slot" allowed the Visor to also act as a GPS, phone, modem, or a camera – but only one module could be put in at a time. Despite their limitations, these PDAs were revolutionary for their time, and this innovation earned Handspring the 1999 PC Magazine Award in the Handheld category. 

The first modular phone


The Modu phone and its enclosures

The Modu phone and its enclosures


The first actual attempt for selling modular phones on a broad basis can be attributed to the Israeli startup Modu. Its eponymous phone was announced at MWC in 2008, and actually still holds the Guinness World Record for the lightest hand-held mobile phone with its weight of 40.1 g (1.41 oz). The Modu can be inserted into a range of phone enclosures (known as jackets), which furnish it with added functionalities and buttons. 

The company's attempts were certainly brave, but they were overshadowed by the "iPhone Era" that was just kicking into gear. As a result, Modu ultimately ceased operations in early 2011 and later sold several of its patents to Google.

Phonebloks and Project Ara



Phonebloks was the first smartphone modular concept to attract widespread attention. It was created by Dutch designer Dave Hakkens in 2013, and became quite popular due to the extent of its modularity – individual third-party "blok" components could be attached to a main body, essentially allowing users to create their own personalized handset.

Many people expected Phonebloks to appear as a commercial product in the next few years, but Hakkens never intended to actually build the device himself. His goal was to inspire big companies to go in that direction in the pursuit of reducing e-waste. Hakkens' ideas attracted the attention of some big players such as Xiaomi and ZTE, while startups like Fairphone and Puzzlephone were also interested in the idea. However, Phonebloks' biggest partnership came from Google's Project Ara which, as luck would have it, is the next ambitious enterprise in our article.

Project Ara was Google's bid to wow the world with modular phones. Ara was originally headed by the ATAP team in Motorola while it was still a Google subsidiary, and the tech giant opted to retain ATAP when it eventually sold Moto to Lenovo.

The initial objective of Project Ara was to introduce "a modular phone for the entire world", made for $50 in materials and consisting of a series of small, Lego-style bricks that could be attached, rearranged, and swapped out in a few seconds. However, by May 2016 the concept was ditched, and Google opted to go for a base phone that has a non-upgradable core, with modules providing supplemental features. Mountain View later decided to cancel the entire project, but may now be licencing the technology to third parties.
 

Fairphone 2, LG G5 and Moto Z



We're moving on to smartphones that actually can be purchased at the time of writing. 

Modu may have been the OG modular phone, but in 2015, the Fairphone 2 became the first truly modern modular smartphone that one can buy. The handset is a product of a Dutch startup and is built with sustainability and repairability in mind. The phone is ethically sourced, using conflict-free minerals, Fairtrade gold and recycled materials, and is assembled in factories with good working conditions. A small Phillips screwdriver is all you need to take the back off the Fairphone 2, and its seven inner modules are very easy to swap out. About 40,000 units were shipped 6 months after its release, so we can't exactly classify the Fairphone 2 as a bestseller, but finally having a smartphone with such characteristics available signalized that things might be starting to change.

Last year, things certainly did change. Two major manufacturers unveiled phone lines with modular systems. LG Electronics released its G5 flagship, which allows add-on modules or "Friends" to be installed by removing its bottom and battery, and attaching the battery to an accessory that is then re-inserted into the phone. The company also unveiled camera grip and audio enhancement accessories as part of G5's launch. This clearly was a bold move from the South Korean firm, but its gamble didn't pay off and the G5 sold poorly. As a result, LG is changing tactics and will introduce traditional handsets for this year. 

Perhaps the only successful handset series of the bunch is Motorola's Moto Z line. Granted, LG probably managed to ship more G5 units, but overall sales of the device were below expectations. On the other hand, Lenovo had been struggling to turn a profit from Motorola after its $2.91 billion acquisition from Google back in 2014, so the strong performance from Moto Z Droid and Moto Z Force Droid was a sigh of relief for the Beijing-based corporation. The phones launched with a bunch of "Moto Mods" accessories, including a JBL SoundBoost Speaker, a variety of Power Pack extended batteries, and the Moto Insta-Share Projector.

Conclusion


Is there a future for the modular design? That's a very good question that currently no one can answer. What we do know is that in order to stay "in fashion", smartphone makers need to innovate. As such, we believe that if executed correctly, a smart and sensible modular approach can be a good selling point for new handsets. LG may have bailed out, but Motorola is looking to expand its Moto Mods program in 2017 and bring indie developers and makers on board. Other companies like Alcatel and Puzzlephone will also unveil new modular phones this year, so one can't really label the concept as a failure just yet. There is also the environmental side of things - we live on a planet that has finite resources, and going modular can certainly be an important choice that could provide us (at least partially) with a more sustainable future. 

6 Comments
  • Options
    Close





posted on 21 Feb 2017, 20:40

1. joey_sfb (Posts: 6600; Member since: 29 Mar 2012)


Project Ara is Google chance to break into the hardware mobile sales with something completely wild and different. There is a 50% chance its will be wildly successfully that everyone wants one not just the geek. Geeks are 100% on the hook.

No reason was given why it was abandon after so much research dollars has been spent on it.

posted on 21 Feb 2017, 20:58

2. vincelongman (Posts: 5068; Member since: 10 Feb 2013)


The reason they abandon it was because they failed to break physics and make Phonebloks a reality

2016 Project ARA is barely more modular than the Moto Z and Fairphone, less modular than the Puzzlephone

Since the Moto Z/Fairphone aren't doing great, Google dropped ARA since it won't do great either
Most OG ARA fans had already lost interest after the 2016 IO demo

The OG Project ARA/Phonebolk concept simply isn't possible with our level of tech
We may see Google or someone else try again in the future, but I don't expect that for another 5-10 years

posted on 21 Feb 2017, 22:34

3. joey_sfb (Posts: 6600; Member since: 29 Mar 2012)


I have checkout Phonebloks website, interesting.

After some thought, i think what's good for user might not be great for people selling ton and ton of phones.

Thanks for the information.

posted on 22 Feb 2017, 04:01

4. vincelongman (Posts: 5068; Member since: 10 Feb 2013)


IMO the problem with modularity is our tech is not capable of enough modularity for average people to care

E.g. the Moto Z, Fairphone and 2016 Project ARA's modularity isn't enough to get average people interested

If someone could achieve the Phonebloks concept or OG Project ARA, I reckon average people will start noticing

But those aren't possible with our tech at the moment, and probably not for at least another 5-10 years, if not more

posted on 22 Feb 2017, 04:28

5. Arthurhkt (Posts: 582; Member since: 19 Apr 2012)


Sadly, moderate buyer won't care about it not until if Apple release a modular phone too, then the rest of the OEM will join the bandwagon as well.

posted on 22 Feb 2017, 07:36 1

6. sgodsell (Posts: 4855; Member since: 16 Mar 2013)


The real problem was the speed to the modules. Using that wired mipi bus is slow. It's one of the reasons why they embedded the display in some of the last iterations of the Ara exoskeletons. They should have used fiber optics instead. Have an in and out fibre cable (data in and out) to each module. If they would have used fibre to talk talk instead, then they could have left the display as a module.

Remember the current Ara had all the modules, including the cameras, speakers, and every other module talking on the one mipi bus. It was too slow to run the cameras, display, and every other module as well. Whereas fibre optics could easily support throughput speeds 50 times more than what their wired mipi bus could support. If your gonna do something like this, then do it right.

Want to comment? Please login or register.

Latest stories