Battle of the shutter speeds: the longer, the better


There’s a reason why you see people using the camera in their smartphone when they’re out and about. Convenience, that’s simply what it boils down to. Point-and-shoot cameras were once the go-to things for most people, as their portable form factors made them easy to carry along with us during our travels several years ago. However, as companies improved the camera modules in their phones, we’ve seen a shift in how people take photos nowadays.

Not only have we seen an incremental improvement in quality with smartphone cameras, but at the same time, they were complemented with an extensive arsenal of shooting modes and controls to make the point-and-shoot outdated. Throw in the fact that smartphones offer a higher degree of functionality than the dedicated purpose of a traditional digital camera, it’s no wonder why most of us have stopped using point-and-shoots – reserving the precious memories for DSLRs.

You don’t need high-end phones for the best results


After spending my most recent vacation using the Asus Zenfone 2, I came away utterly impressed by what a $300 outright priced smartphone can produce with its camera. Indeed, I’ve seen better photos from other phones, but they come from premium priced, high-end phones that we’ve come to see dominate the landscape. With the Zenfone 2, however, it won me over not only by its raw quality, but also for its rich shooting modes, a useful manual mode, various filters, and a slick set of editing tools to enhance photos.

Recently, I’ve been doing a lot of low-light photography with my Panasonic Lumix GH3, which is outfitted with a prime 25mm f/1.4 Leica lens. The results, not surprisingly, are insane and amazing at the same time – thanks in part to its extra-long shutter speed adjustment. Then I started thinking about some of the recent smartphones released, in how they handle low light situations. For starters, we’re increasingly getting smartphone cameras that offer full manual modes – specifically being able to adjust the shutter speed.

Bearing that in mind, I decided to take four phones out at night to see how they handle the intricacies and opportunities presented with the dreaded low-light photography. In my experience, even the best of phones show diminished results using the automatic mode. Sure, some phones even have a specific low light mode that automatically crop the image, boost the ISO, and lengthen the exposure, but it’s still problematic because camera phones are more prone to blurring in this mode.

So, what phones did I bring for this quick comparison? Here’s what I took!

  • Alcatel Onetouch Idol 3: 13-megapixel camera
  • HTC One M9: 20-megapixel camera
  • Huawei P8: 13-megapixel camera
  • LG G4: 16-megapixel camera



You’re probably wondering about some other notable new phones missing in the list, like the Apple iPhone 6 and Samsung Galaxy S6? While I would’ve loved to include them, especially when they’re known for taking some slick looking shots with their cameras, but neither offer shutter speed adjustment natively – hence the omission for this quick test.

Higher ISO helps, but there's noticeable loss in detail


Rather than whipping out each camera in my hand and taking photos, I decided to place each one in a cradle to eliminate any sort of shaking – the bane of long exposure photography. In order to compare them using the same settings, I had to go with the ½ shutter speed with all of them, seeing that it was the option they all have in common. Another useful thing with low light photography is being able to adjust their ISO sensitivity. Therefore, you can compare the results at the same shutter speed, but with different ISO levels below.



The Huawei P8 and LG G4 are the only two in this quick comparison to offer super long exposures. With the Huawei P8, its night mode can achieve an incredible shutter speed of 32 seconds – allowing it to soak up as much light in the scenery as possible. Meanwhile, the LG G4 isn’t too far behind with its shutter speed of 30 seconds. Check out the samples yourself to see how they compare.

Every phone wants to claim that they’re serious about low light photography, but as we can see, it’s the phones with exceptionally long shutter speeds that can live up to those claims. The Alcatel Onetouch Idol 3, one that’s impressive for its ridiculous value at $250 outright, just can’t compete in this area as greatly as it can. Similarly, the HTC One M9 falls into the same category, despite the hefty 20-megapixel camera it’s been outfitted with this time around.

Long shutter speeds, solid results


Naturally, the top honors go to the Huawei P8 and LG G4, aided by their exceptionally long shutter speeds. Needless to say, it comes in handy in low light situations, as they’re able to absorb as much of the limited light in the scenery, to produce images that retain great detail. Not only can dimly lit scenes come out bright thanks to this, but there’s also some neat effects that can be achieved in the process – such as those cool looking light trails. Or in the case of the Huawei P8, its light painting mode is another unique shooting mode that’s rarely offered.



Before setting out to snap your own incredible looking photos under low light, just remember that you’ll need to keep the phone steady throughout the entire capture – to prevent blurring and whatnot. That means either propping it up by resting it against something, or placing it in some kind of holder/tripod to reach the best results. While all of these phones are more than capable of taking exceptional photos outdoors when there’s an abundance of lighting, there’s a clear telling how useful long shutter speeds have an effect on quality under low light.

FEATURED VIDEO

31 Comments

1. Crispin_Gatieza

Posts: 3122; Member since: Jan 23, 2014

This is why the Lumia 1020, 920 and 1520 deliver such dynamite results in low-light situations.

2. theguy2345

Posts: 1216; Member since: Jun 24, 2014

Yep, my last Lumias shutter speed was very slow. Hated it, because I am not a photography guy, and don't really care about my camera. As long as it takes pictures.

5. marorun

Posts: 5029; Member since: Mar 30, 2015

Well on the G4 you have both its pretty fast but can also be pretty slow :) This is what i call the best camera on a smartphone ( under android ) of the world. The S6 can go back home..

13. Shocky unregistered

These will be added to the Galaxy S6 soon enough when it's updated. 5.1 comes with a new camera API. Oh right, I forgot. You're an idiot, so of course you don't know that.

16. bur60

Posts: 981; Member since: Jul 07, 2014

You attack someone (calling him an idiot) because he said the G4 camera is better than S6 camera? (which is true). Grow up.

20. singhkaran9830 unregistered

From where did S6 came up?This complete article is about the devices which support full manual control,which s6 doesn't.The s6 has a fingerprint sensor,but the G4 doesn't.So will you bring up G4 there?probably not! Just appreciate what other companies can do other than bashing other companies.

22. ninja_master

Posts: 306; Member since: Feb 27, 2015

Your reasoning is useless on a retarded troll like him

26. Shocky unregistered

No, because he's an idiot. Have you read his posts? it's the same crap over a over again.

10. Simona unregistered

Huawei p8 wins here even g4 is brighter but is not sharp as P8 ..

21. willzzz

Posts: 36; Member since: May 27, 2015

On which test? These aren't optimal settings, these are extremes. Because the G4 can take in more light you have more flexibility in settings to increase the quality. Just because you can go up to ISO 2700 doesn't mean you have to.

24. Simona unregistered

yeah and on 2700 is too bright distorting image ..

30. willzzz

Posts: 36; Member since: May 27, 2015

Agreed. Using optimal settings (or just on auto) the G4 will almost certainly produce the better image.

15. waddup121 unregistered

Shutter speeds...ok

3. Bogdan86

Posts: 48; Member since: Oct 06, 2014

SAMSUNG add those manual settings to S5 and S6 !!!

4. ama3654

Posts: 295; Member since: Nov 27, 2012

On the way with 5.1.1 in tow, before end of month for S6/edge

6. marorun

Posts: 5029; Member since: Mar 30, 2015

We will see if its will be as good. Because the P8 dont compare to the G4 so if S6 result are like the P8....

9. ama3654

Posts: 295; Member since: Nov 27, 2012

Don't worry, Samsung is LG's daddy, and have more expertise at their disposal, besides they are specialists at making top of the range cameras around.

7. jessyi

Posts: 327; Member since: Jan 08, 2015

G4 is the phone to beat..

14. Shocky unregistered

Not really, overexposes lights in images, the video recording is not that great, bitrate is a lot lower than the S6 and the stabilization isn't perfect. Also the audio recording on the LG G4 is just awful, lots of things to consider. The LG G4 is good but it's far from perfect.

8. gazmatic

Posts: 807; Member since: Sep 06, 2012

a low light test without a lumia? zeiss + pureview = top notch low light pictures.

11. Simona unregistered

come oon that is ancient phone nobody buys it ..

25. hound.master

Posts: 1044; Member since: Feb 27, 2015

Ancient phones that still no one can beat In camera quality!!!

29. Simona unregistered

i have DSLR camera for proper photography

27. Niva.

Posts: 440; Member since: Jan 05, 2015

Even more embarassing for the new flagships they're getting pwned by 2 year old Lumias. Too bad Nokia never joined the Android bandwagon, they could've went on to own the world.

12. frankg

Posts: 173; Member since: May 14, 2014

This is why HTC is failing. All other phones where great, HTC was lacking....

17. bugsbunny00

Posts: 2262; Member since: Jun 07, 2013

the galaxy dont exist in here..lol

18. mrej201

Posts: 226; Member since: Feb 04, 2015

Galaxy note 5

19. Cheezwiz

Posts: 500; Member since: Dec 29, 2014

Was anyone else pleasantly surprised by the Alcatel shots?

23. yoosufmuneer

Posts: 1518; Member since: Feb 14, 2015

My 3310 takes better pictures. Oh wait..

28. alexvv

Posts: 165; Member since: Oct 16, 2013

i'm very dissapointed sony doesn't give users an option to play with shutter speed. crappy software but not even that option ?

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.