Sony Xperia Z1 Compact vs Apple iPhone 5s
High-end Android smartphones have been successfully competing with the iPhone for quite some time now, but despite their undeniable popularity, there's one ubiquitous differentiating feature that sticks out like a sore thumb – each and every recent Android flagship has tried to target a slightly different audience than the typical iPhone crowd. With their massive screens and excessive focus on hardware prowess, devices like the HTC One, Galaxy S4 and LG G2 have always been cherished by the slightly more geeky part of society. The same goes for Sony's full-size flagship – the Xperia Z1, which is especially imposing with its dimensions.
What could this particular market situation mean? Well, we could read this as a way for Android manufacturers to avoid competing directly with the iPhone, but why haven't they even tried to produce a smaller device with the same powerful hardware that they usually bestow upon their creations? Sure, there are the 'mini' versions of the Galaxy S4 and the HTC One, but those phones are significantly weaker than their high-end brethren. Time and time again, we've asked for an Android flagship of great strength and easily-pocketable dimensions, but our requests have remained unanswered. Luckily, here comes Sony with the Xperia Z1 Compact – an ambitious handset of iPhone-like size that not only takes advantage of Sony's beautiful OmniBalance design, but also of the latest and greatest silicon that's available to Android manufacturers. It's a phone that we're extremely excited about, so what better way to say what it's made of than to pit it against the king of compact smartphones itself? Ladies and gents, prepare to witness an epic struggle of compact proportions: Xperia Z1 Compact vs iPhone 5s!
The Sony Xperia Z1 Compact has a great design language, that's actually reminiscent of the iPhone 4/4s. With its flat front and back sides, made of glass and plastic, respectively, held together by a sturdy metal frame, the Z1 Compact looks and feels great. However, the busier design, with numerous port and slot covers, doesn't allow the Z1 Compact to elevate itself to the clean and stylish industrial design of the iPhone 5s. The significantly thinner profile of Apple's handset, as well as its overall cleaner look makes it appear just a bit more premium in the looks department. Anyway, the trade-off isn't really big, and in exchange for a slightly thicker handset, you're getting quite a few niceties with the Z1 Compact, such as a microSD card slot, and easily-accessible SIM card slot, a dedicated camera-shutter key, and, of course, water-resistance!
Not that the Z1 Compact's construction isn't of high quality, but the iPhone 5s is simply unsurpassed in this respect. You can tell that the 5s is going to be the more expensive device just by pressing the physical keys, like the volume rocker and the power key. On the iPhone, these buttons have a nice and clicky feel, while on the Z1 Compact, their movement isn't so well-defined.
In terms of dimensions, the Z1 Compact (5.00 x 2.56 x 0.37 inches) is very close to the iPhone 5s (4.87 x 2.31 x 0.30 inches), although it's a bit wider and, as we said, thicker. The slightly bigger size of the Xperia doesn't make it more uncomfortable to hold or operate with, so users who aren't into big smartphones can rest assured that both devices are almost equally small.
As we said, in addition to the bonus features of the Compact, such as microSD card slot, Sony's handset is also water- and dust-proof (IP58), which is something that the iPhone 5s can't offer. However, Apple's device does feature an excellent fingerprint sensor, which can make your device very secure and easy to unlock (by you) at the same time.
We're happy to see Sony using IPS LCD tech in the Xperia Z1 Compact. Unlike the screens used in its previous devices, this one actually has livelier colors, while viewing angles are finally reasonably good. The 720p resolution results in a slightly higher pixel density (clarity) of 342 ppi, compared to the iPhone 5's 326 ppi. That's despite the fact that the Z1 Compact also has a slightly larger screen (4.3 inches), which makes it a bit more desirable than the iPhone's 4” panel.
That said, if we have to compare these screens in terms of pure quality, the one of the iPhone 5s proves to be better in a number of areas. Maximum brightness is one of them, as Apple's finest can shine with up to 580 nits, while the Z1 Compact manages to reach the still-respectable 515 nits. In addition, the 5s can get dimmer, which is helpful when you want to read something in the dark, while its gamma is also more accurate (2.2 for the 5s versus 2.6 for the Z1 Compact).
It's once again a matter of trade-off with these displays, as the one of the iPhone 5s is considerably better, but the larger size of the Z1 Compact is a definite advantage that shouldn't be overlooked.
Display measurements and quality
|Maximum brightness (nits)Higher is better||Minimum brightness (nits)Lower is better||Contrast Higher is better||Color temperature (Kelvins)||Gamma||Delta E rgbcmy Lower is better||Delta E grayscale Lower is better|
|Apple iPhone 5s||587
|Sony Xperia Z1 Compact||515
The numbers below represent the amount of deviation in the respective property, observed when a display is viewed from a 45-degree angle as opposed to direct viewing.
|Maximum brightness Lower is better||Minimum brightness Lower is better||Contrast Lower is better||Color temperature Lower is better||Gamma Lower is better||Delta E rgbcmy Lower is better||Delta E grayscale Lower is better|
|Sony Xperia Z1 Compact||82.5%
|Apple iPhone 5s||86.7%
The CIE 1931 xy color gamut chart represents the set (area) of colors that a display can reproduce, with the sRGB colorspace (the highlighted triangle) serving as reference. The chart also provides a visual representation of a display's color accuracy. The small squares across the boundaries of the triangle are the reference points for the various colors, while the small dots are the actual measurements. Ideally, each dot should be positioned on top of its respective square. The 'x: CIE31' and 'y: CIE31' values in the table below the chart indicate the position of each measurement on the chart. 'Y' shows the luminance (in nits) of each measured color, while 'Target Y' is the desired luminance level for that color. Finally, 'ΔE 2000' is the Delta E value of the measured color. Delta E values of below 2 are ideal.
This measurements are made using SpectraCal's CalMAN calibration software.
The Color accuracy chart gives an idea of how close a display's measured colors are to their referential values. The first line holds the measured (actual) colors, while the second line holds the reference (target) colors. The closer the actual colors are to the target ones, the better.
This measurements are made using SpectraCal's CalMAN calibration software.
The Grayscale accuracy chart shows whether a display has a correct white balance (balance between red, green and blue) across different levels of grey (from dark to bright). The closer the Actual colors are to the Target ones, the better.
This measurements are made using SpectraCal's CalMAN calibration software.
1. darkkjedii (Posts: 15195; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
iPhone could use a bigger screen, sony could use more beauty. Both are highly functional, fast and smooth. Something about sony just doesn't quite grab me like apple Sammy, and HTC do though. It's like Beyoncé, Alicia Keys, J-Lo, and Kaley Couco. Somebody's gotta come in fourth. Sorry J-Lo er sony.
4. alterecho (Posts: 1095; Member since: 23 Feb 2012)
Hmmm... Coincidentally, Sony is the only company thats not involved in any patent dispute, in the mobile realm.
32. Feanor (Posts: 485; Member since: 20 Jun 2012)
I think they have an agreement with Ericsson to have access to their huge portfolio of patents which is crucial for mobile telephony. I don't think anyone can threaten them....
38. b1acktiger (Posts: 216; Member since: 19 May 2012)
Seriously, i don't think they were a threat to the competitors till 2012.
43. SonyPS4 (Posts: 308; Member since: 21 May 2013)
No one would dare to challenge Sony in patent war without any good reason. They have patent in pretty much every single segment of electronics
5. Arirank (Posts: 40; Member since: 19 Jan 2014)
Agreed. I dont know why.. there are just apple, sammy, n LG tht always invites me in..
9. darkkjedii (Posts: 15195; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
I know man, I can't put my finger on what turns me off about sony, just doesn't float my boat.
15. Sauce (unregistered)
I'm not fond of their phones, but oh my, I'm loving everything about my PS4 ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
20. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
it surprises me because having had Moto, Sammy, and Sony (and for moments LG) I think that Sony phones are the closest to an "Apple" experience on Android (but with android advantages)...
Walkman app is actually very simple, polish, good looking, and feature rich...
Album interface is also simple with pinch integration and organized automatically
Notifications and shortcuts are nicelooking unobtrusing... Small apps is a good alternative to multi-window...
I really like Sony for taking cues from apple, without limiting android.
31. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
Well yeah.. that actually might be something other manufacturers do better with a few exceptions like the Xperia SP, Z1.... Specially for big phones... though Music battery times is a lot better in my Xperia compared to Samsung and Moto...
However, the Z1 Compact promises great battery life...
And with apps such as Llama or SmartConnect, I barely turn my screen on to specifically toggle BT, WiFi, dim screen, and even change a sound profile... so it helps battery life quite a bit.
40. __0__ (banned) (Posts: 242; Member since: 07 Jan 2014)
I agree , xperia devices has better user experience than samsung phones
12. yudi.nemesis (Posts: 1127; Member since: 14 Mar 2013)
Try using your iphone without any accessories,
when you're wearing thick gloves in the winter.
After that let me know if your iphone can still
14. darkkjedii (Posts: 15195; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
Dude go somewhere with that stupid a$$ crap. I'm not gonna let you know a damn thing, cuz informing you doesn't matter to me, and you factor into my life absolutely zero. Now after reading this get lost. My iPhone 5s works just fine, and when it comes time to sell it and get the new one in sept. I guarantee you, it'll be worth a helluva lot more than that sony mess will be.
16. Sauce (unregistered)
You said that right lol. My girlfriend's brother just made off with $5000 USD from 3 iPhone 5s's.
27. darkkjedii (Posts: 15195; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
Exactly Sauce, apple resale\3rd party value alone makes it a best buy.
22. yudi.nemesis (Posts: 1127; Member since: 14 Mar 2013)
Hahaha.... It seems that my question made you so angry, I just wanted to know if the iphone is still able to function well in certain circumstances.
Because some high end phones from samsung, nokia, sony and even some chinese phones have features that are very useful in everyday life.
I strongly agree with this
"when it comes time to sell it and get the new one in sept. I guarantee you, it'll be worth a helluva lot more than the mess that Sony will be"
And now I'll do what you ask "Now after reading this get lost" I'm sorry if I hurt your feelings goodbye :)
56. sgodsell (Posts: 2257; Member since: 16 Mar 2013)
So is that whats makes the iPhone great these days, its resale value. Thats what I should be looking for out of every phone I buy. Lord knows that's what makes the iPhone great these days. So is that why the iPhone 4 is not selling well in india for instance. They started selling it for rs 22000 and then dropped it to rs 15000. Everyone wants those old iPhones because they sell so well. Yeah right. Drink more of that koolaid your drinking there.
2. Commentator (Posts: 2854; Member since: 16 Aug 2011)
"The only thing that you need to decide is what type of device you want: a curated and mature phone that's slightly limited in its functionality, or a more open and flexible one that's just slightly less perfected."
Wow, with that conclusion I'm sure glad I didn't read the whole comparison.
17. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
What did you expect from so call "experts"... let me summarize:
- Keyboard: "There's a bit of a trade-off here, as the Compact's keyboard features some additional keys that aren't present on the iPhone 5s..."
Actually the Keyboard on Xperias can be customized right out of the box, so you can add or remove unused buttons such as smilies, punctuation, you can choose secondary function for each key to be displayed, AND you can even change the color to match samsung's keyboard, apple's keyboard or simply a mix of dark and light colored keys...
- Conectivity... the "expert" admits the Z1 has more (NFC, DLNA, WiFi ac) but then goes on saying that there isn't much use for it right now!!!! WTF!!!!
the device is being futureproof and even if not many people use it, you have the option... I occationally use DLNA and NFC, the former to play music directly to my TV (since movies may stutter) and NFC for easy pairing with other devices.... But either way it is useful to have and it is wrong to just make it sound like it is not important just because the author do not use it...
- Camera: Kind of a fair review here...
- Multimedia: The Walkman app is times better than Apples Music app... adding extensions, customizing, looks that change based on album art, mp3 tags editor, full 5 bands equalizer (not just preinstalled ones), and NO ClearAudio is not the feature that makes it louder, xLOUD is... and with the equalizer you can make it sound louder customizing it.
For movies there is always more and better options with Android, not mentioning that you can use a USB OTG cable and reproduce movies and music files directly from there... and with MX Player, any video format. Period.
Album, actually I thing the new iPhone's gallery is better... though I like how I can pinch to zoom up to single photos in my Sony... and down to 7 for each row... and under "My Album" you can see organized a Map view, Globe view, Facebook pics, etc...
- Battery: still waiting for a formal battery test... but since you guys are just taking announce numbers... Hey the Z1 seems to be overall better in terms of battery... and remember that THIS IS THE NUMBER 1 FEATURE THAT SMARTPHONE USERS ARE CRAVING FOR TODAY.
This review... like all past reviews related to Sony... are BS and totally uninformed
29. miso519 (Posts: 1; Member since: 27 Jan 2014)
could not agree with you more...author is clearly messed up iSh..p is he finds NFC, DLNA irrelevant:D...
also bugs me "tone" of this article: Z1 is good at this...but iphone is better anyway.
sorry, but only reasonable iphone owner for me are those people who get it with some speeecial discount...otherwise its just too expensive and its no worth it!
42. Kaiser2007 (Posts: 163; Member since: 16 Nov 2013)
I read the conclusion only, just like you. And the rating. Now, waiting for "user reviews" to come out. Let's see how they match up.
3. majp89 (Posts: 123; Member since: 18 Jun 2013)
Well, nice to see an Android phone with a decent camera. It outperforms the iPhone in low-light especially. I think the pictures look better and more vibrant from the iPhone in daylight however. If this supports T-Mobile LTE I might have to pick it up in a couple of months. I have the Z1S right now and I think the camera is amazing.
6. camera531 (Posts: 266; Member since: 30 Jun 2012)
The only thing holding the Sony back is the permanent, heat treated plastic film (screen protector) that is over the screen and back glass. It scratches very easily and fingerprints are hard to remove, unlike the clean coated glass on the iphone (and every other OEM screen). Sony says it uses scratch resistant glass, but what's the point when it's permanently covered with cheap plastic that scratches and scuffs just by looking at it. Huge blunder!
18. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
Wrong... actually this is what makes Sony smartphones less cracking prone on the screen...
I have seen it first handed and I will always try to get a Sony for that uses those Shatterproof films... (SHATTER, not Scratch)
I simply apply an additional scratchproof sheet on top and if I am not mistaken, Sony is providing this as well in the new Z1 Compact...
But the shatterproof layer really helps keeping the screen from shattering... go look some Drop Test on youtube vs other phones...
41. __0__ (banned) (Posts: 242; Member since: 07 Jan 2014)
Extra layer makes the phone's touch screen slightly less senstivive , I notice it when browsing through photos at the album app . ZL owner here. Would like to remove the rubbish anti shatter thing but failed
46. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
That is weird, it didn't happen to my Acro S. I can actually place about 5 sheets of paper on top of my screen (with double layer) and still register good touch input
53. KennethM27 (Posts: 1; Member since: 29 Jan 2014)
i place 2 glass file above the screeof my sony xperia v and it still recognize it correctly
7. AfterShock (Posts: 3698; Member since: 02 Nov 2012)
How does the retina display gets the nod?
I don't see it.
8. jellmoo (Posts: 849; Member since: 31 Oct 2011)
Higher maximum brightness, lower minimum brightness and better colour representation.
The Z1 Compact is the first Sony device in a good long while that doesn't have a wretched display, so it is absolutely a feather in their cap. They still have a little ways to go though.
10. AfterShock (Posts: 3698; Member since: 02 Nov 2012)
Kudos to Sony as you said too, this is a step in right direction.
11. CanYouSeeTheLight (Posts: 1075; Member since: 05 Jul 2012)
Well i find it odd that PhoneArena talked about the Apple's screen so much but ignored the much higher contrast compared to the Sony (iPhone 1:1007 Sony 1:1648)
19. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
not only that, but the viewing angles while "decently good" actually outperforms the iphone's in their chart...
30. JerryTime (Posts: 468; Member since: 09 Nov 2013)
Why would you find it odd that Phonearena shows apple biased in their reviews? They do it every time one of these comparisons are made.
21. Amir1 (Posts: 291; Member since: 20 Aug 2013)
the z1 compact SH**S all over iphone 5s. there's nothing to compare. z1 won.
23. tasior (Posts: 262; Member since: 04 Nov 2012)
"NFC and DLNA are only available on the Z1 Compact, though right now there isn't really that much use for them."
WTF? There isn't much use for them? I thought USA is a developed country, and this sentence sounds, like it came from third world...
24. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
I am from a third world country and probably use it more than Ray, and sadly that is the opinion that "represent" the whole smartphone users in this review
25. starkiller306 (Posts: 58; Member since: 13 Nov 2013)
Another article by "Iphone Arena" trying to convince themselves that their beloved iphone can compete with the Z1compact. It's pathetic actually. they're not trying to convince anyone else but themselves. why else would you need 3 articles comparing the Z1compact to the iphone5s? and all these so called articles say the same bloody bullsh*%. Z1compact has many things the iphone doesn't have, but, "you don't really need them" so you can go buy the precious "fingerprint scanning jewel". Also, saying "That's the cool thing when you're dealing with cutting-edge products – there are no compromises or drawbacks that you have to take into account before making the move. The only thing that you need to decide is what type of device you want: a curated and mature phone that's slightly limited in its functionality, or a more open and flexible one that's just slightly less perfected." is like practically begging people to buy an iphone. I mean, that conclusion deserves some new type of new insult...a galactic face palm maybe, i donno...
33. Leonis (Posts: 337; Member since: 08 Jan 2014)
Sony wins. iphone 5s looks a bit better both outside and inside but z1 compact does not look bad and the fact that it is android means you can change UI quite a bit.
34. Sauce (unregistered)
You can't change the UI of the iPhone 5s?
35. Leonis (Posts: 337; Member since: 08 Jan 2014)
yeah with jailbreak you can but I am talking about not jailbreaking devices. Even if you jailbreak it the tweaks are not as good.
36. Sauce (unregistered)
You must be lacking first hand experience. You don't know how ridiculous you sounded just now. Anyway, that's all I have to say. I don't feel like having a drawn out argument on the interwebz again.
39. Leonis (Posts: 337; Member since: 08 Jan 2014)
I own the iphone 4s. the amount of customization with the UI in iphones is a big joke.
37. livyatan (Posts: 867; Member since: 19 Jun 2013)
Reality distortion has hit the wall this time!
Sony wins this without breaking a sweat.
Better OS, camera , stronger build, waterproof, memory expansion.
The only thing iPhone has going for itself are 64 bits and the fingerprint scanner.
48. number29 (Posts: 185; Member since: 25 Jan 2013)
Of course hugely subjective matter of opinion there (I'd say iOS is the better OS) but the waterproof nature of the Z1 Compact is definitely fab, it's just a shame it means inconvenient port flaps on the USB port.
50. buccob (Posts: 2011; Member since: 19 Jun 2012)
In my opinion, iOS is still very inferior both in built-in features and flexibility, customization....
And about the inconvenient flats.... Well at least you have a second option for charging, which is the principal use of the USB port...
When I get the Z1 Compact I will definitely get the magnetic dock, or at least the EC21 Cable that comes inside... because not only you protect the flaps from wearing, but also it seems more convenient and secure... kinda like MacBooks magnetic plugs
44. .KRATOS. (Posts: 177; Member since: 15 Mar 2013)
I don't know what's the special in the iPhone design all praise, it's jst have the same boring design since the iPhone 4 but in different materials.
49. __0__ (banned) (Posts: 242; Member since: 07 Jan 2014)
Its not , different materials makes it different . Aspect ratio is different , thickness and the bottom of the phone is different
45. mmmanuuu (Posts: 358; Member since: 05 Nov 2013)
SOny's compact phone is bigger than apple's largest phone ! lol
51. fireblade (Posts: 716; Member since: 27 Dec 2013)
Beautiful device. I don't mind if it's 1 mm thicker as long as it has bigger battery capacity
52. Taters (Posts: 4633; Member since: 28 Jan 2013)
Funny how screen size and ppi doesn't affect quality as much as brightness and dimness according to all ifans. The iPhone 5s screen is s**t and I don't see how the z1 compact screen can actually lose to it.
54. tazos87 (Posts: 5; Member since: 01 Feb 2014)
Vote for Android!
55. COZMAN (Posts: 99; Member since: 28 Nov 2013)
Let us all face it. Even if you are not an iphone lover there is something about the phone nobody else can match. They are so branded as thee phone it will never change. I used to think Android ruled but as the population ages? They want a phone, not a toy.
57. 21babydoll12 (unregistered)
To rule out the baised theory. PA should have an article of what phones each editor owns (past/present/future). It should make things a little bit more even all around. Either way I love both phones. My opinion matters more to myself. Cheers and good night.