Google Nexus 6P vs Samsung Galaxy Note 5

55

Introduction


When it comes to the phablet domain, Samsung’s Galaxy Note smartphones have consistently been the frontrunners in its class ever since the segment’s inception. This year’s latest iteration, the Samsung Galaxy Note 5, sees a tremendous shift in its design – while also improving on what it does best. That, of course, consists of being incredibly spec’d to the roof, and accompanied with a diversified portfolio that caters to the everyday professional.

Interestingly enough, it has a strong competitor in a newcomer to the space. The Google Nexus 6P has been one of the biggest surprises this year, showing that Chinese maker Huawei can dish out high-caliber devices on a global scale. With an original looking premium design, combined with the most up-to-date vanilla Android experience, it seemingly might be the new phablet king.

Design


Outstanding! When we think of phones that impress with their designs, these two undeniably have the qualifications – thanks in part to their sturdy constructions, high-quality materials, and slick aesthetics. It’s a battle between the Note 5’s all-glass chassis and metal trim, versus the Nexus 6P’s unibody aluminum metal construction. Not only do they look exceptionally well to attract our eyes from afar, but they also match their visual appeals with their meticulous and solid constructions.

Specs aside, we do like how the back edges of the Note 5 are curved, ensuring for a more ergonomic feel, but the Nexus 6P’s metal body is quite resilient to smudges and fingerprints – whereas the Note 5’s glass body is a notorious offender. Still, the way light bounces off the Note 5’s body is compelling and entrancing at the same time.

It’s really a tough call on which of the two has the better designs. When it comes to visual appeal and ergonomics, we like the Note 5, but sturdiness and originality goes to the Nexus 6P.

One of the many things we love about the two handsets is that they both offer fingerprint sensors, which gives us an alternative option to securing them. Between the two, however, we have to give credit for Samsung endowing the Note 5 with some additional amenities – like its S Pen stylus, and built-in wireless charging. It’s truly a Swiss Army Knife of sorts in the smartphone kingdom.


Google Nexus 6P
Dimensions

6.27 x 3.06 x 0.29 inches

159.3 x 77.8 x 7.3 mm

Weight

6.28 oz (178 g)

Samsung Galaxy Note5
Dimensions

6.03 x 3 x 0.3 inches

153.2 x 76.1 x 7.6 mm

Weight

6.03 oz (171 g)

Google Nexus 6P
Dimensions

6.27 x 3.06 x 0.29 inches

159.3 x 77.8 x 7.3 mm

Weight

6.28 oz (178 g)

Samsung Galaxy Note5
Dimensions

6.03 x 3 x 0.3 inches

153.2 x 76.1 x 7.6 mm

Weight

6.03 oz (171 g)

See the full Google Nexus 6P vs Samsung Galaxy Note5 size comparison or compare them to other phones using our Size Comparison tool.


Display


Highly regarded as being at the top of the food chain, both handsets live up to that argument with their Quad-HD displays. The two of them measure up at 5.7-inches, have resolutions of 1440 x 2560 pixels, and employ AMOLED technology. In earnest, they look beautiful in every facet, as they exhibit all the qualities typical of the technology – like their phenomenal clarity at wide viewing angles, high contrast, and true deep black color reproduction.

Needless to say, they amaze and impress when it comes to watching videos, surfing the web, and even browsing through photos.

Both phones can produce pumped-up colors, but they can also be set to a more natural-looking state using the appropriate screen modes.





Interface and Functionality


The battle between the Nexus 6P’s stock Android 6.0 Marshmallow experience and the Note 5’s TouchWiz UI on top of Android 5.1.1 Lollipop is an interesting one, mainly because they appeal to specific users. Obviously, you can’t go wrong with the Nexus 6P and its stock, most up-to-date Android 6.0 Marshmallow experience, seeing that it has the simplicity and straightforwardness to cater to almost everyone. The visual appeal is there as well with Material Design’s presence throughout the interface, but the single and most important part about everything is that the Nexus 6P will always be on tap to receive the newest Android updates – way before its rival here.


Sure, the Note 5 might take longer to get updated, but seeing that it’s such a popular thing, you know Samsung will be working hard in getting it updated ASAP. While TouchWiz’s look and feel isn’t quite as clean as stock Android, it hinges on its productivity-centric features to appeal to users who just need to get more work done on the road. Not only is it the best when it comes to true multi-tasking, but the S Pen adds a whole different dimension to using the handset – one that can’t be matched by the Nexus 6P.


Each experience has its perks, so it’s a matter of which one appeals to you more. Samsung clearly has a comprehensive experience with TouchWiz, one that’s been fine-tuned and optimized in almost every way imaginable, so it’s a great experience for the professional user. Conversely, though, the Nexus 6P favors an experience that might be light on the multi-tasking features, but it comes without any frustrations or complications.

System Performance


The Samsung Exynos 7 Octa 7420 chipset inside of the Note 5, which is paired with 4GB of RAM, is undeniably a beast when it comes to the benchmarks – where it’s always near the top of the ladder in many tests. Never one to be counted out, the Nexus 6P’s octa-core Qualcomm Snapdragon 810 SoC with 3GB of RAM isn’t one to be messed around with either. Even though it trails the Note 5 in many of the benchmark tests, its real-world performance is a completely different matter.

We will certainly say that the Note 5 is responsive, but the Nexus 6P is quite frankly snappier with its movement. In fact, the way we’re able to navigate around the platform in such an effortless, fluid motion with the Nexus 6P is unbelievable by itself, showing that there’s a benefit to running vanilla Android as well.

Over on the graphics processing side, we’re satisfied by how swell these two Quad-HD screen packing phones are able to maintain solid frame rates when the action becomes intense.

AnTuTuHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P60007
Samsung Galaxy Note567207
Vellamo MetalHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P2361
Samsung Galaxy Note52532
Vellamo BrowserHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P4703
Samsung Galaxy Note55476
SunspiderLower is better
Google Nexus 6P1079.7
Samsung Galaxy Note5677.7
GFXBench T-Rex HD on-screenHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P36
Samsung Galaxy Note537
GFXBench Manhattan 3.1 on-screenHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P17
Samsung Galaxy Note515
Basemark OS IIHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P1894
Samsung Galaxy Note51765
Geekbench 3 single-coreHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P1265
Samsung Galaxy Note51431
Geekbench 3 multi-coreHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P4561
Samsung Galaxy Note54717




Camera


This year, we’ve seen several outstanding camera phones that have impressed us for their performances – these two included! The Note 5 from a specs aspect might appear more attractive, seeing that its 16-megapixel sensor is attached with an f/1.9 aperture lens, BSI, and optical image stabilization. However, as we’ve seen time-after-time, specs alone aren’t indicative of a camera’s potential, which is what’s evident with the Nexus 6P’s 12.3-megapixel camera sensor.

Beyond the hardware, it’s necessary to briefly talk about their camera interfaces. Quite frankly, the Note 5’s interface is the more favorable of the two, just because the Nexus 6P’s package is rather light in comparison to what the Note 5 delivers. Not only do we have a diverse set of shooting modes at our disposal with the Note 5, but it even manages to go beyond by providing us with a useful manual mode – one that gives us finer controls to various parameters of the camera.


Image Quality


Before we dive into the specifics, we have to say that they’re both pretty snappy at taking a shot – so you’ll never miss an opportunity. Onto their performance, we have to admit that it’s a close one. At times, the favor tips the scales towards the Note 5, but in others, it’s the Nexus 6P. We will, however, say that they snap highly detailed and sharp photos when the lighting conditions are good. There’s a difference in their megapixel counts, but the Nexus 6P shows that it’s capable of producing just as much detail, with a slightly better handling of exposure.

Using them under low light, we’re quite accepting of how compositions come out bright, exposing details that would otherwise be lost. Sure, there’s a significant decrease to fine details, which is expected, but for the most part, they produce better-than-average nighttime shots. The Note 5, though, comes with less digital noise, but colors appear more vibrant with the Nexus 6P.

It’s honestly a tough call here, since we can’t complain about their phenomenal performances. Not only do they achieve better results than the majority of phones out there, but they continue to handle low light extremely well too. Overall, however, hardcore shutter bugs will probably gravitate to the Note 5 – mainly because its top-notch performance is accentuated by its rich shooting interface.


Taking a picLower is betterTaking an HDR pic(sec)Lower is betterCamSpeed scoreHigher is betterCamSpeed score with flashHigher is better
Google Nexus 6P2.2
2.9
346
464
Samsung Galaxy Note52.1
2.7
842
No data

Video Quality


When it comes to recording videos, you’ll want to stick with the Note 5, not only because of its stable footage capture, aided by its built-in stabilization, but also because there are more shooting modes and resolutions at its disposal. Without question, there’s plenty of details captured when using both handsets’ 4K UHD modes, but the Note 5 stands above for its stability and quick focus. The quality is almost on par with the Nexus 6P, but it’s clearly just lagging behind by just a smidgen – albeit, it does capture more natural sounding voices with its microphones.



Multimedia


Granted that the Google Play Music app comes preloaded on the two phones, the Note 5 complements it with its very own, homemade TouchWiz music player. Functionally, it suffices, but in the greater scheme of things, it doesn’t necessarily take the punch out of Google’s venerable player.

Between them, we prefer the dual speaker configuration of the Nexus 6P, which are front-firing, but it lacks the substance and depth that the Note 5’s single speaker produces. Yes, the Nexus 6P churns out a higher 78.4 dB of audio power, in comparison to the Note 5’s 70.7 dB tally, but its dual speaker setup just sounds insignificant and light – whereas the Note 5 has a broader appeal with its punchiness.


Over on the video watching side of things, we have very little complaints about the two, just because their Quad-HD screens are ideal for the situation. On top of that, they handle all sorts of videos and codecs with very little strain to their performances. Still, we need to point out that the Note 5 benefits from having a multi-tasking element in its portfolio – allowing us to continue watching a video in a separate window, while doing something else entirely different.

Headphones output power(Volts)Higher is better
Google Nexus 6P0.34
Samsung Galaxy Note50.609
Loudspeaker loudness(dB)Higher is better
Google Nexus 6P78.4
Samsung Galaxy Note570.7




Call Quality


Neither phone is actually perfect when it comes to phone call performance, seeing that there are some unsavory qualities present in the two. In particular, you have the artificial sounding voices through the Nexus 6P’s earpiece, and the amount of crackle that’s evident when the Note 5 is placed on its loudest volume setting. Granted there are some challenges, their strong volumes enable us to comprehend voices under noisy conditions, but their overall qualities are nothing more than average performing.

Battery


For being the one with a lower capacity battery, the Note 5’s 3000 mAh cell delivers superior performance over the Nexus 6P’s beefier 3450 mAh one. That’s quite surprising, honestly, considering that we’d think that stock Android would bear significant optimizations to give the Nexus 6P some serious longevity. At the very least, we get a solid one-day of normal usage out of the Nexus 6P, but the Note 5 can at times get us close to 1.5 days.

The disparity between the two becomes more profound in our custom battery benchmark test, where the Note 5 reaches an impressive time of 9 hours and 11 minutes – versus the Nexus 6P’s mark of 6 hours and 24 minutes. Regardless of all that, we’re certainly content by how little time is necessary in getting them recharged. In fact, the Nexus 6P requires 89 minutes to achieve that, but the Note 5 beats it marginally at 81 minutes. Besides that, we have to also point out there’s the added convenience of wireless charging with the Note 5.

Battery life(hours)Higher is better
Google Nexus 6P6h 24 min(Poor)
Samsung Galaxy Note59h 11 min(Good)
Charging time(hours)Lower is better
Google Nexus 6P1h 29 min
Samsung Galaxy Note51h 21 min

Conclusion


Much like anything, a phone’s value and worth hinges a lot on its price, and in this case, there’s more of a compelling argument going for the Google Nexus 6P. And why’s that? Well, for being the newer of the two, while also packing a premium design that’s original, its price of $499.00 for an unlocked model is mind-boggling. Meanwhile, the Samsung Galaxy Note 5 fetches for a premium at roughly around $650 to $750 depending on where you look.

Knowing all that, price conscious consumers tight on a budget can’t go wrong with the Nexus 6P, since you’re getting a quality performing phone that takes good photos, is extremely responsive, high-spec’d, and comes with the latest version of the Android experience. However, the higher price point of the Samsung Galaxy Note 5 is justified by its rich set of additional amenities, great productivity portfolio, and its updated design language. Sure, you’re spending more money picking it up, but in the process, you’re getting more with your money – like its built-in wireless charging, heart rate sensor, S Pen stylus, and longer battery life.

Power users will undoubtedly appreciate what the Note 5 has to offer on the software side, seeing that it comes with the best multi-tasking experience in a smartphone. You can still get plenty of work done when you’re not at your desk with the Nexus 6P, but the Note 5 is remarkably more equipped for the task. Then again, stock Android has its perks as well, so that’s something to remember.

Whatever you end up choosing, you can sleep knowing that both smartphones are arguably at the top of their game. The Note 5 isn’t a surprising candidate for that phablet of the year title, considering that the Note series by and large has always been highly acclaimed, but for Huawei and its Nexus 6P, it’s the first time they’ve struck gold on a global scale – so for them, it’s surely a long time in the making.

Google Nexus 6P

Pros

  • Lower cost
  • Stock Android experience
  • Original looking design that’s premium
  • Incredibly snappy performance in daily use

Samsung Galaxy Note 5

Pros

  • Updated premium design that’s comfortable to handle
  • Added productivity features
  • S Pen for drawing and note-taking
  • Built-in wireless charging






Recommended Stories

Loading Comments...
FCC OKs Cingular\'s purchase of AT&T Wireless