Pandora and others are subpoenaed in a federal privacy investigation

Pandora and others are subpoenaed in a federal privacy investigation
Most consumers understand that even free apps have to make money somehow. In most cases it's simple advertisements, but there are increasingly more cases of app-makers obtaining and illegally distributing users' personal information to third parties. Pandora Media Inc., the maker of the free Internet radio application, has been subpoenaed.

On Monday, Pandora announced, via an SEC filing, that they received a subpoena for a federal grand jury. That grand jury will investigate whether Pandora and others are distributing customer information without proper disclosure. That kind of abuse could bring criminal charges, in violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.

Pandora clarified that they are "not a specific target of the investigation," which appears to be industry-wide. But a Pandora spokeswoman declined further comment. Out of 101 apps that the Wall Street Journal tested, 56 transmitted the device's unique identifier, 47 transmitted the user's location, and 5 sent information like age, gender, etc. What's more, 45 of the 101 apps didn't provide a privacy policy either on their app or their homepage.

The Pandora app for iOS and Android does send the user's information (i.e. gender, age), but their use won't likely constitute a misuse of user information, as they have a well-defined privacy policy. But we expect other app-makers to be found in clear violation of users' privacy.

While criminal charges are an option, they are unlikely. Experts say that the companies found in violation will most likely incur civil suits, or be required to make monetary payments. The real goal appears to be to encourage more respect for users' privacy.

source: Wall Street Journal via Gearlog



4. Dadler22

Posts: 243; Member since: Dec 11, 2008

When I had android OS I would never download anything that was free, unless it was from a reputable company I knew. I think almost everyone who has a smart phone has pandora, except you windows phone lol. To hear that they are sharing your information too is quite unsettling, but it is good evidence to push towards keeping your app count very low.

1. snowgator

Posts: 3630; Member since: Jan 19, 2011

Here is hoping this not a headline grabbing dog and pony show. It would be nice to find out who is misusing the information from their Apps and educate people through the exposing of these parasites how to protect themselves. I absolutely believe it is each users responsibility to protect themselves, but I have no problem watching crooks fall on their own swords either.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.
FCC OKs Cingular's purchase of AT&T Wireless