Do you use your cell phone while driving and for what?
posted by Ray S. / Dec 16, 2011, 10:06 AM
What has driven (no pun intended) the NTSB to make such a suggestion? Not that the numerous accidents that happen every month aren't enough of a reason, but the main catalyst can been seen in a tragic accident from last year, which involved a pickup truck, two school buses and a 19-year-old driver who managed to send or receive 11 text messages in 11 minutes, with the last one being sent just moments before the crash, which had two fatalities and 38 people injured as a result. Now, in this case it seems like there isn't something else that we can blame for distracting the driver, except for their cell phone, doesn't it?
However, what makes the NTSB's request interesting is that it targets electronic device usage as a whole (though we're most concerned with cell phones), and not a specific action such as text messaging, which is what other similar undertakings go for. For example, it was recently reported that Florida wants to become the 36th state in the country to have a law against texting while driving. So, as a whole, most accusations have always been towards texting, and not towards phone use in general.
Well, the question is how far are we willing to take our actions against any possible distractions that may occur behind the wheel. When you think about it, is it the interaction with the device when having a phone call, or the phone call itself which is distracting you more? Aren't you still distracted in a way, when using a hands-free headset? You are still required to take actions to answer the call and then to dedicate a part of your mind to the conversation. In that line of thoughts, there is some sense in banning cell phone usage in cars altogether. However, whether such harsh measures are indeed necessary is hard to say, because it's unclear if, for example, talking via a Bluetooth headset is distracting enough, or if such a ban would actually help reduce those accidents. That's what's making such proposals like the one by the NTSB difficult to approve, as it's hard to prove your point.
Still, it's appreciable that even if such a law ever sees the light of day, we'll be allowed to use our smartphones for things that are "supporting the driving task". Wohoo! GPS navigation, anyone? Alright, having said all that you're probably dying to voice your opinions on the matter. Of course, feel free to share your thoughts in the comments below, but don't forget to vote in our poll - let's see how many of you guys are using your cell
phone in the car and for what!
What do you use your phone for while driving?
Calling, texting... whatever I want.
Texting... (guilty face).
Calling via a Bluetooth headset.
Listening to music.
No phone usage at all. Safety first!
Posts: 4888; Member since: Apr 15, 2011
I will be really honest. I try my best not to text & drive. If I get a text I will reply at a stop sign or light. Now if there is no light or stop sign, then I will call those people back. When I have my kids in the car I won’t even grab my phone unless I am at a light or a stop sign. My worst fear would be to get into an accident & put my 2 boys in harm’s way because of a stupid text. The state where I live there is no law against using a mobile device while driving. I kind of wish there was a law because it will make me think twice about using it when I am driving solo. I see people on a daily basis, swerve into my lane because they are texting. I would hate to have someone smash into me because they are texting or surfing the web while driving. I am not saying that what I do is right, but at least I wait until I am stopped to answer or send any texts, but to drive & text is very dangerous.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 10:18 AM 6
Posts: 858; Member since: Jun 09, 2009
texting while driving is no more dangerous than any other small distraction. the danger is that people are idiots and awful drivers.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 11:32 AM 3
Posts: 4888; Member since: Apr 15, 2011
That is exactly my fear. I know what I do is not right, but atleast I wait until the vehicle is fully stopped. In the 2 minute wait I can send at least 2 to 3 texts before the light turns green. I am not proud of that & I will stop just for my own sake. I will never do it with my children even at stop lights. I would forever hate myself if anything happened to my boys because of my selfish need to text & drive. It can wait plain and simple.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 12:54 PM 2
Posts: 1457; Member since: Mar 09, 2010
Honest, but stupid statement.....Why Should I who is responsible have a law made for a few irresponsible people like you.....Since 1989 I have had a cellular phone and driving , while being real responsible never ever have I had any incidents. I think talking on the phone with a headset is no more distracting than listening to a radio or having someone in the car with you. Too bad 300 out of 200 million people is causing a law to be made in which I truely believe is just a way of increasing revenues without causing a squawk form the masses! Never trust the crooks that make laws for you, and I without hidden agendas today!
posted on Dec 18, 2011, 9:41 AM 1
Posts: 279; Member since: Oct 19, 2011
I think calling is fine but texting is not fine at all.. okay i do received call but NOT dialing What about woman put on make up or lipstick while driving? not to mention most woman are horrible when come to driving (they simply left their sense at home or somewhere when on wheel)
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 1:02 PM 3
Posts: 34; Member since: Jan 18, 2010
Baloney!!! What are you smoking??? Texting and driving is extremely dangerous and the data is there to support it. People definitely do other things that are also very dangerous: women putting on makeup; drivers eating while driving; etc. Texting, which requires looking at the phone and not the road, is not a small distraction. The biggest idiots and awful drivers are the ones texting while driving.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 4:09 PM 0
Posts: 328; Member since: Jan 08, 2010
People, please look at TALKING and TXTING as two different arguments. Banning txting has some merit since it takes atleast one hand off the wheel and (in most cases) requires taking your eyes off the road. If you want to still make it illegal, so be it BUT if you nah sayers haven't noticed, the cell phone industry has responded with apps like Siri and Google Voice Command to help keep people's focus on the road. It is a real issue, but people are addressing it. Please, give it time. The argument for banning talking on the phone really doesn't make much sense outside of the simple act of holding the phone up to your ear. Under that circumstance, one hand is off the wheel (unless you're doing that "ear-to-shoulder phone taco" move which isn't any better) and the range of motion for your head is limited. However, if you own a headset, have a bluetooth speakerphone, or own a car with a bluetooth speakerphone function built into the radio, than there should be no issue with you using the phone in your car. All of those options allow you to keep both hands on the wheel and maintain full range of head motion. So the only argument left is, what, the talking part? If you have a driver's license in the US, you are guilty of talking to someone in the car (driving exams have instructors after all). Besides, there are plenty of things more distracting than talking in a car, such as drinking something, eating, dealing with unruly kids, putting on make-up, etc etc etc. What it comes down to is wanting to penalize distracted driving and cell phones happen to be a convenient excuse. Sure the fatality numbers will drop ever so slightly and the overly-cautious will declare a "major victory" over recklessness, but it won't be because of their actions... Automotive fatality rates have been steadily dropping since the late sixties and that's all thanks to better design, not banning convenience. In the US, speed limits have actually gone up since then, bucking the same logic the "cellphones are bad" people are trying to pitch. By that logic taken to an extreme, building small round single-seat cars out of foam, cutting the speed limit to a crawl and forcing everyone into helmets while driving would be justifiable since it would save lives. Progress is scary. Let the industry catch up to the problem instead of just trying to stop everything with one big band-aid fix. We have viable solutions in place for talking on the phone in the car. If you want to ban txting and driving with the phone up to your ear, so be it, but let those of us that have alternatives use them instead of just trying to make broad reaching nebulous laws.
posted on Dec 17, 2011, 2:58 PM 1
Posts: 455; Member since: Sep 20, 2011
I text and call when I'm in the car....that's because I'm 15 and can't drive yet.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 12:16 PM 8
Posts: 37; Member since: Oct 21, 2009
Here is the truth of the matter: if they start to ban texting while driving it could actually cause MORE accidents. The reason? People no longer would be holding their cell phones up on top of the steering wheel or up towards where your eyes aren't wandering that far from the road to down in a person's lap so that they can avoid being caught. I have seen it first hand because there was recently a ban on texting while driving where I live, and people are now just putting the phone in their laps and doing it.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 5:38 PM 1
Posts: 304; Member since: Nov 09, 2011
i dont use my phone when driving... use Sprint Drive First app... you cant use your phone because phone senses when you are driving...
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 10:23 AM 2
Posts: 858; Member since: Jun 09, 2009
or riding. its a good app for teen drivers. no one else.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 11:30 AM 2
Posts: 162; Member since: Jan 05, 2011
only for mp3s and if i dont have that song i use youtube as a backup..i hate CDs..sometime i use the phone as gps aswell but NO TEXTING
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 10:29 AM 0
Posts: 1436; Member since: Jul 11, 2008
I tend to lean toward the side of letting people use Bluetooth. I know conversing can be distracting but is talking over a Bluetooth. More distracting than talking to the person in the passenger seat who may actually divert your attention enough to turn your head? Also as a father I know kids in the back are way more distracting than my phone. That said, im guilty As can be. When i drive by myself I've been known to text and call at times while driving...sometimes posting to social sites and even....gasp...reading phonearena at red lights. I'm probably the worst of everyone.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 10:37 AM 0
Posts: 24; Member since: Dec 14, 2011
I physically touch the phone only for navigation while driving; at RED traffic lights, I glance at any notifications once in a while. For Texting, most of the phones now have voice to text features.. while driving, that's the only thing I use (handsfree).. WP7 has very good voice to text for texting.. with the new Iphone 4s, that feature is available as well...
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 10:49 AM 1
Posts: 99; Member since: Sep 09, 2011
With the phone in a handsfree dock on my dashboard, and bluetooth speaker/FM transmitter connected, I make calls, listen to music and perform navigation. I also set up my phone before setting out so that i have quick access to the features I will need without many screen taps. I don't text/email when driving, except if i'm using my Windows pHone, which , when connected to bluetooth, will read your texts automatically, and you can dictate a response - therefore it makes these texts completely hands free. I am a firm believer that using a phone mounted on the dashboard for functions like these is no more dangerous than tuning the radio, or adjusting the AC, or changing CD (probably safer to switch track on a phone than to change cd manually in many cases). Also if people want to wear a wired or wirless headset and put the phone in the door or something and answer calls on the headset is fine. I am also a firm believed that holding your phone in your hand in a call, or jamming a phone between shoulder and ear are really bad because you limit your physical ability to control the car while in a call. Texting and emailing when moving is just bad, especially on touchscreen phones when you have to give it your attention to compose a coherent message (on physical phones, you might be able to feel the keys to know what you are pressing). Therefore, I am all for a ban on any phone use when driving that means your phone is in your hand or aginst your ear for a call, but headset use and docks should be allowed. I.e ban activities that physically impair your ability to control a car.
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 11:01 AM 1
I do not text, browse, or navigate to begin with... I have, in the past, taken a phone call or two on the road, but usually via Bluetooth (navigated too when I had the Nokia E75... mmmm, loved that phone); however, I no longer use a Bluetooth-capable phone, and as the law here has now precluded anything but hands-free phone calls while driving, I simply do not use or otherwise answer my mobile phone while driving. When driving these days, my phone stays in my pocket...
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 11:21 AM 1
Posts: 858; Member since: Jun 09, 2009
i text while driving. i do it when in very low risk driving situations and type 1 or 2 letters at a time (or just look down once per word to situate myself when using swype). texting requires no more distraction than countless other things people do when they drive. the difference is that people take their eyes off the road for too long. this is because they are stupid and bad drivers. there is already legislation for poor driving. there does not need to be legislation to limit the cause of poor driving (especially when it is nearly uninforceable)
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 11:38 AM 0
Posts: 7305; Member since: Dec 05, 2009
Well, the government loves to criminalize activities, especially if there's potential for them to make revenue off of fines and such. I can see it now... ROUTINE TRAFFIC STOP 8:30 A.M. Officer O'Shea: Yeah, we have a guy here who didn't use his turn signal when he made a right. I'm going to go check it out. (Gets out and walks to the door) Officer: Evening! Do you know why I pulled you over? Kid: N-no sir! Officer: You didn't use your turn signal back there. Little dangerous of you, don't you think? Kid: Oh man, I knew I forgot something! I'm so sorry, officer. I'll be good, promise! Officer: You forgot? You forgot. That's a pretty big thing to forget. You weren't... distracted, WERE YOU? Kid: N-n-no! I swear I wasn't! Officer: Step out of the car please. Turn around. Hands on the hood of the car. That's it. Legs apart. Good. (Pats him down). Ah ha! What is this? (Pulls cell phone out of kid's pocket) Kid: it isn't mine, I swear! It's my friend's! He asked me to hold it for him! Officer: a likely story. Let's go, punk. Maybe you'll sing a different tune in county lockup!
posted on Dec 16, 2011, 12:37 PM 4
Send a warning to post author
Send a warning to Selected user.
The user has 0 warnings currently.
Next warning will result in ban!
Ban user and delete all posts
Message to PhoneArena moderator (optional):