The iPhone X home button "dongle" is bizarre: A journey through the strange world of aftermarket Apple accessories

This article may contain personal views and opinion from the author.

It's not easy to let go of things that we are convinced are important to us, in some way or another, be it for their perceived practical or sentimental values. This holds true for many things in life, even when it comes to otherwise inconsequential in the grand scheme of things material possessions, such as souvenirs, old photographs, and other mementos of days past. But the same also holds true not only for items of sentimental value—the merits of which can be defended by their owners, and rightfully so—but also for thoroughly utilitarian things as well. Things like, say, technologies.

And it's an interesting affair this, considering how technology is constantly moving forward—although it may not always seem like it to the impartial observer—which necessitates leaving things behind. This could be due to a variety of reasons, be it the existence of improved iterations of already existing technologies, or purely user experience-related concerns that often times force engineering and design teams to pull at each other's hairs until they achieve an equilibrium of sorts – a golden mean at the intersection of functionality, aesthetics, and user experience, where you have a "balanced" product, so to speak.

The hardships of future-proofing


Unfortunately, designing an innovative, functional, and easy to use product is a burdensome task, and one that doesn't always pays off in the end. We've all heard the phrase "ahead of it's time," tossed at products that curiously scratch that futurist itch possessed by many a tech lover, but at the same time fail to be practical enough at the time of their release. Such is the case, in my opinion, with the iPhone X and the complete removal of Touch ID in favor of Face ID. Don't get me wrong, the new system works, but seeing as how fingerprint scanning technologies are being taken in exciting new directions, Apple may have been too quick to ditch the tech this time.

And, you know, it's not like the two technologies can't co-exist, but Apple being Apple, it is very unlikely that we'll see fingerprint scanning make a return anytime soon, if ever, in an iPhone. This is nothing new for the company, really; in fact, it's been going on for decades, with the most recent example being the 3.5mm jack, against the removal of which people are still railing. But if we think back, as far as the late 90s, Apple has been spearheading innovation in tech, precisely by knowing when to kill old technologies, and it's been heavily, uncompromisingly criticized for this by people who just don't want to let go. This was the case when the iMac G3 hit store shelves in 1998 – it was the first major desktop computer to ditch the floppy disk drive in favor of an optical disc drive, and it did that at a time when 3½-inch disks were crazy popular. This, of course, proved an extremely controversial move on Apple's part, one that caused such raucous, that looking back at headlines from 1998 seems quite funny today. Especially when you fast forward a couple of years and everyone had given floppy disks the boot and had moved on to CDs and DVDs. The G3 also adopted the USB standard when it was still in its infancy.


In 1998, this quirky computer stirred controversy by abandoning the 3½-inch floppy disk drive. This, of course, gave way to a plethora of external USB floppy disk drives by third parties. Not surprisingly, however, the G3 far outlived these add-ons when the industry was ready to move forward in a few years' time. The G3 also spawned the spectacularly flawed "hockey puck" mouse, but that's a topic for a different time and place.

Short of a decade later, after it had already revolutionized personal audio with the iPod, Apple then "killed" phones with keyboards—a decision, which at the time seemed quite ludicrous to me, for practical purposes alone— and then went on to kill optical discs with the MacBook Air a couple of years later. This constant drive forward, perceived by many as something bad, has paved the way for an entire industry of aftermarket products, aimed at "mending" the company's "glaring omissions," as labeled by critics. And this market has been evolving in interesting ways, indeed, granting fertile soil for all sorts of products – from the somewhat useful to the outright bizarre. But most of these products have generally been of a corrective nature, designed to "fix" by going back, rather than improve by moving forward. In a sense, the vast majority of these accessories have been designed to appease people who don't own, and don't intend to own, Apple products, when the easiest fix for this is to, well, just continue not owning Apple products.

Complicating simplicity


There are so many options these days, so many offerings from such a wide spectrum of manufacturers, that there's just no point in blaming a company for sticking to its guns while at the same time buying its products, only to try to "fix" them later through a whole bunch of third-party accessories that, for the most part, serve only to bog down user experience. And it's not like Apple itself is completely exempt from this practice; the company has released its fair share of "dongles", as many people like to call them, to offer a sort of a middle ground for consumers who can't let go of a certain tech. But for all intents and purposes, these are nothing more than temporary crutches to be ditched in a year or two when the "bad" changes and exceptions become commonplace, as tech moves forward.

image source 9to5Mac

Such is the case with the iPhone X home button "dongle," unveiled at CES by a small Chinese company. Yes, it is finally upon us – a cheap-looking apparatus, built from glossy white plastic, and looking suspiciously like a skewed iPod Nano, the home button dongle connects through the iPhone X's Lightning port, offering users not only the dubious (we'll get to that in a moment) commodity of having a clickable hardware home button, but a 3.5mm headphone jack as well! All packaged neatly in this little, light-as-wafer add-on, vaguely reminiscent of Apple's design language from a decade ago, and completely ruining the portability of your mobile phone.

But the worst thing about this home button dongle is not its cheap built quality, not the hollow click it gives as you push the brittle plastic button in, not even the fact that it ruins the phone's design and portability. No, the problem is that this tiny add-on is the embodiment of being hung up on something without a proper reason. Ask yourself this, what do you miss about the home button the most? Was it the button itself? The click? The ease of use? I've been using Android phones with on-screen navigation for years, and I just don't feel any nostalgia for the physical home button. In fact, I don't see the point of wasting precious space with a button, unless it's combined with a fingerprint scanner. And this is where the iPhone X home button dongle caves in – it's just a plastic button, it doesn't support Touch ID, and it never will. That's it. You're buying this tiny white piece of plastic to stick it in your iPhone X so you can have a simple home button, when the gesture-based UI is just fine for closing and switching between apps. Not that it doesn't have its quirks and downsides—believe me, I've got a lot to say about that—but as far as basic home button functionality is concerned, swiping from the bottom to minimize an app, or swiping diagonally to get to your recent apps works just fine.

Accepting that the perfect product does not exist


I just don't get why there is such great demand for products like this. Why buy an iPhone X if you so desperately need a physical home button? Why buy it if you can't live without the audio jack? This isn't even remotely useful. It isn't like buying a battery case that actually prolongs battery life, it's just being hung up – using a dongle to do stuff you can already do for the most part without it.

But hey, if some people are going to buy a Lightning to 3.5mm jack adapter, they might as well go all in and get this thing, right? Or, or, here's anоther idea – just buy a device that meets all your requirements out of the box, without the need to strangle it in cables. I know that's the conclusion I arrived at after owning many Apple products over the years.

FEATURED VIDEO

56 Comments

1. drifter77

Posts: 402; Member since: Jun 12, 2015

Steve Jobs would be turning in his grave right now. That man was a visionary and hit the right buttons. After he passed away, the whole scene with Apple has changed for the worst.

3. afrohoxha

Posts: 258; Member since: Mar 13, 2014

Abomination

4. SIGPRO

Posts: 2817; Member since: Oct 03, 2012

iphones.....most horrible phones ever made!

13. bucky

Posts: 3790; Member since: Sep 30, 2009

I don’t think I’ve seen you post on anything other than an Apple article.

19. darkkjedii

Posts: 31258; Member since: Feb 05, 2011

You simply can't be serious, when they're easily among the best phones out there. Sure Apple holds them back, by trickle feeding us features, but iPhones are no where even remotely horrible...in fact they're very good devices. Apple just needs to make better use of the chipset. In my experience with them, and that experience goes back from 07 to this morning, all they lack are about 10 killer features to make them equal to anything else out there. My list is well known, be need to post it.

31. makatijules

Posts: 835; Member since: Dec 11, 2017

It's simply his opinion. Doesn't make him wrong because you don't agree. After all Apple fans claim the same about other products. Right? Anyone is entitled to their opinion even if it is stupid, or we feel it's stupid. I agree him on some level, they are terrible in many ways. But they are also good phones.

32. darkkjedii

Posts: 31258; Member since: Feb 05, 2011

Get lost.

40. maherk

Posts: 6926; Member since: Feb 10, 2012

DJ, did you forget that "Julius" also loves and uses Apple devices.

50. makatijules

Posts: 835; Member since: Dec 11, 2017

Even when you try to be decent to people they have to act ignorant. Sad. I've never done anything to up. Hanging around the sheep is s teeing with your mind. You don't need fa me friends to stand behind you when God gave you 2 feet of your own. FYI I don't hate any phone. Some are simply better than others. I stated many times I like the iPhone which I didn't judge during the leaks. I only didn't keep it because my apps I wanted to use were all 32bit and unsupported. It is Apple best device, yet it's full of fee making it terrible to use. So basically because I didn't kiss up to you like suck up Maherk, you decided to act ignorant. Lol. Hey you ever read the story of David and Goliath? Real or not it has a principle. Brains are always and be better than brawn.

28. maherk

Posts: 6926; Member since: Feb 10, 2012

How about no?

6. tokuzumi

Posts: 1919; Member since: Aug 27, 2009

Dongle will not be usable during one handed operation. Lying on a table, not too bad. But that's just going to put too much stress on the charge port, and the connector on the dongle. Those things will break within days, especially if people leave the dongle connected while in their pocket/purse. I could see Apple using an in-screen fingerprint sensor, assuming the technology is reliable. Apple doesn't really experiment with technology. They wait until it's stable before adding the features onto their hardware. They are just now adding NFC, which has been on Android phones for years.

7. Anonymous.

Posts: 423; Member since: Jun 15, 2016

"Apple doesn't really experiment with technology. They wait until it's stable before adding the features onto their hardware" More like they wait until the cost if implementing features drops down. "They are just now adding NFC, which has been on Android phones for years." NFC has been stable on Android handsets for years... Are you for real?

51. makatijules

Posts: 835; Member since: Dec 11, 2017

Apple waits until a better version of the same stuff we had on Android, and then try to act like they have something better. Example, even though Apple rush to have an FPS, and 3D camera, Android had those already, but didn't take them anywhere. But even though they have a newer form, they aren't doing anything more. Look at Face ID. Other than th3 stupid Animoji, Face ID isn't doing anything they didn't do with the FPS, or what Samsung was doing with the Iris Scanner. Linking biometric to a pay service is what they had already. But they made items secure because potentially anyone can unlock your phone with their face and use it. But Android is the true most adv .ca operating system because we get to have both 32/64 apps that work together. Apple failed t his. We have 6 ways to secure a phone, matter, iris, Face, finger, password and pin. While they only have 3. We can theme until out hearts content and they can basically still just change wallpapers. Apple gives the illusion of perfection, Android has achieved it.

8. jjface

Posts: 247; Member since: Jun 07, 2017

Bad dongle idea. But I like the home button on iphones. Not something that should be considered unnecessary at all just because you can make do without it. It is convenient. Just like I can make do with the lack of a 3.5mm jack it is something else apple should bring back. I can make do without a mute slider and volume buttons too but should we get rid of those and accept it? No.

9. darkkjedii

Posts: 31258; Member since: Feb 05, 2011

You have got to be kidding me. On one hand, it looks hella silly, on the other hand, it does show just how catered to the iPhone is, and that’s always a good thing.

10. vananucho

Posts: 83; Member since: Jun 01, 2011

They well could made that thing into a case and also fit an extra batería, but it looks half assed af and breaks the (yet to find) purpose of the iPhone of being Bezeless. I like it adds the audio port and a universal charging port, neat idea, bad execution.

14. makatijules

Posts: 835; Member since: Dec 11, 2017

Maybe some buyers like the X, but still want the jack and home button? But maybe we should be like Apple and just forget about those people.

27. tedkord

Posts: 17387; Member since: Jun 17, 2009

Because there's a large group of consumers who buy based entirely on the brand name. They don't buy other brands, they don't research or compare.

34. kiko007

Posts: 7497; Member since: Feb 17, 2016

And there's no problem with that. If said non-appealing brands want recognition... work for it. Expecting regular consumers to know or care about your existence as an organization is asking for failure.

52. makatijules

Posts: 835; Member since: Dec 11, 2017

People who.use Apple products know about other brands. They just don't care about or for them. It's like Eve. They were hypnotized by the fruit and simply can let go. Once you've tasted the poison, and see both good and bad, nothing else matters. After all, as many times as Apple has been busted screwing consumers, they keep on taking more bites of the Apple. It's an sad addiction.

53. kiko007

Posts: 7497; Member since: Feb 17, 2016

You know what's an even worst addiction? Your addiction to phonearena. Find a life or STFU.

54. Anonymous.

Posts: 423; Member since: Jun 15, 2016

Sorry, but you're just as addicted to this place as how you claim he is. Look at the amount of comments you have, and how you comment on this site every day. Do you ever stop being a hypocrite?

44. kennybenny

Posts: 216; Member since: Apr 10, 2017

What would happen if someone pushes the home button too hard and the dongle breaks off?

56. fartmasterflex

Posts: 1; Member since: Sep 28, 2019

This quagmire is easy to solve. Just never upgrade from iPhone 6s. TouchID, home button, headphone jack. There are no compelling features on the many iPhones that came after it, save for maybe the camera.

* Some comments have been hidden, because they don't meet the discussions rules.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.