Remembering the Motorola ATRIX 4G, the phone that was too ahead of its time


Coming back from covering this most recent Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, I've been reminiscing about past shows – about how mobile used to have stronger presence. In the last several years, however, that hasn't been the case at all! Nowadays, most companies reserve their major flagship announcements for Mobile World Congress, which makes perfect sense when you consider it's THE showcase event for mobile.

Going back to this most recent CES, checking out Razer's Project Linda concept made old memories rush back into my mind. For those of you that are unaware, Project Linda is basically a laptop dock designed to work with the company's latest gaming-centric smartphone, the Razer Phone. After docking the smartphone into position where the trackpad is normally situated, it becomes the brains behind the operation for the laptop 'shell.'

Frankly, there's nothing original about the concept, as many other devices have employed implementations that are very similar. In particular, I remember how the Motorola ATRIX 4G first wowed me with its interpretation back at CES 2011 all those years ago. And the more I began thinking about that smartphone, the more it began to dawn upon me that it was just one of those things that were too ahead of their time.



The first true high-end Android offering on AT&T


Exclusives were still all the rage during that period, but for AT&T, the arrival of the Motorola ATRIX 4G finally blessed the carrier's lineup with its first truly high-end Android smartphone. Prior to the ATRIX 4G, they had forgettable and quirky devices like the Bravo, Flipside, and Flipout – none of them were really powerhouse Android smartphones. The specs for the ATRIX 4G were undeniably drool worthy, featuring things like a 4-inch qHD display, dual-core NVIDIA Tegra 2 chipset, 1GB of RAM, and a 5-megapixel rear camera.

You know what else it managed to pack along? At a time when video chatting was still in its infancy, the ATRIX 4G did flaunt a 0.3-megapixel front-facing camera for the occasion. In addition, it was one of the first phones to offer HSPA+ connectivity, which was regarded as speedy for the time before LTE.

Everything about the ATRIX 4G was favorable, but it was especially gratifying for AT&T to extend its Android lineup with a real high-end offering. Motorla already made headlines much earlier with the various Motorola DROIDs it released with Verizon, but all of that didn't take away from the thunder that was produced by the ATRIX 4G's arrival.

Fingerprint sensor before the iPhone 5s


While fingerprint sensors were found on a multitude of phones prior to the Motorola ATRIX 4G, it was nonetheless a pretty rare sighting – more so considering that the iPhone 5s was still 2 years away from launching. Yes, the implementation employed by the ATRIX wasn't as intuitive as today's fingerprint sensors, mainly because it utilized older technology that forced users to slowly swipe their finger in a downwards direction for it to work. It wasn't perfect or responsive at all times, but the ATRIX 4G was one of the few phones that added an extra layer of security.



Today we take fingerprint sensors for granted, but it was undoubtedly something seen as a luxury back in 2011. The Motorola ATRIX 4G to its credit was one of these rare phones that offered a fingerprint sensor, making it somewhat more advanced than its contemporaries.

It featured extended docks before anyone else


As I briefly mentioned earlier, Razer's Project Linda is a cool concept – and even more so when the laptop implemented there is fashioned like Razer's laptops – but the premise is nothing really new in the space. In fact, you could say that the Motorola ATRIX 4G was the first Android smartphone to offer this astounding feature! Along with a standard multimedia dock that connects to a display/monitor via its HDMI connection, there was also a laptop dock available that leveraged all of the ATRIX 4G's capabilities. These docks extended the typical functionality of a phone, showing us that it was possible for our smartphones to be the main source to power all of our mobile computing needs.



When the Motorola ATRIX 4G was docked, there was an option to run its unique 'Webtop' experience. Essentially, you gain this sort of faux-desktop environment with its Ubuntu-like interface. Not only do you get a virtual phone in this mode, complete with access to all of the phone's functions, but it even featured a handy Mozilla Firefox browser with Adobe Flash support.

Current phones like the Huawei Mate 10 Pro and Samsung Galaxy Note 8 both offer similar 'desktop' experiences when they're connected to displays or television sets. However, it's just mind-boggling to know that the Motorola ATRIX 4G was doing something very similar 7 years ago!

So what happened to this forward-thinking smartphone?


When the Motorola ATRIX 4G was first announced at CES 2011, I recall how enamored I was with the phone's vast capabilities – it really was a forward-thinking device at the time of its announcement. The features it packed were unheard of, but despite all of its advancements, the phone never reached the same kind of notoriety that followed other handsets – like the iPhone, Moto's own DROID line, Samsung's Galaxy line, or even Google's Nexus.

Taking into consideration its then-normal price point of $199.99 with a 2-year contract, you'd think that it would've sold like hot cakes. But in practice, except for the addition of the fingerprint sensor and support for HSPA+, the phone itself wasn't dramatically superior against the competition.

As for those 'useful' docks, the main issue with them was that they were overpriced – $190 for the multimedia dock and $500 for the laptop. Those prices are tough to swallow, more so when most people already did most of their computing on existing laptops and desktops. While Samsung's implementation with DeX still requires a separate dock, which retails for $150, it offers extended functionality over what we saw with the Motorola ATRIX 4G – like an actual, real desktop experience complete with Microsoft's Office suite and a versatile web browser.

Comparatively, Huawei's interpretation goes the extra step by eliminating the dock altogether, only requiring an HDMI connection to your display/monitor.

The ATRIX 4G won't be forgotten


So yeah, Project Linda is eerily similar to what the Motorola ATRIX 4G delivered back in 2011. Even though the smartphone has long been discontinued, it will be remembered as one of those gadgets that was cool and forward-thinking, but just too ahead of their time. Locking down all the basics we expect to find in any smartphone, combined with some features that were uncommon at the time, the Motorola ATRIX 4G was without a doubt one of the most advanced smartphones back then. We owe a lot to what it helped to establish.

Sometimes we take for granted the fingerprint sensors in our phones, the speedy data connections we have access to, and even the extended experiences that we get from these desktop-esque docks. The Motorola ATRIX 4G was truly a phone that was ahead of its time! When you try to fathom that it was released almost 7 years ago, it's a shame to see that very little has changed since then. Sure, phones have gotten better in terms of the hardware, but meaningful innovations have been tough to find. The ATRIX 4G's legacy is undeniable, but it's a shame that the ride lasted only two generations.

Related phones

ATRIX 4G
  • Display 4.0" 540 x 960 pixels
  • Camera 5 MP / 0.3 MP VGA front
  • Processor NVIDIA Tegra 2, Dual-core, 1000 MHz
  • Storage 16 GB + microSDHC
  • Battery 1930 mAh(9.00h 3G talk time)

FEATURED VIDEO

10 Comments

1. Back_from_beyond

Posts: 1376; Member since: Sep 04, 2015

I owned a Razr Maxx which also featured Webtop. Motorola was ahead of the times, the hardware wasn't always up to the challenge. Motorola tried to stay ahead of the competition, first with Active Display, first with coprocessors to offload tasks from the CPU, were planning to use the touch FPS first until Apple bought the company to shut them out, had a smartwatch/activity tracker long before others. When Google shoved 'em off to Lenovo the company lost its magic. They still make good phones though at very reasonable prices.

9. buccob

Posts: 2963; Member since: Jun 19, 2012

I had this Atrix 4G and it was a good phone the first year... I also had the Multimedia dock that enabled Webtop in an external display... had 3 USB-A ports and a microHDMI... This device was ahead of its time, and I think now is the best time to play with this design once again.... Snapdragon 845 is making its way to Windows 10 laptops and a phone with a laptop accessory is neither crazy nor truly experimental anymore... I always wished the Atrix laptop was designed like Razer's one, with the device as a touchpad... it would be a lot cleaner and better positioned... The Asus PadFone was also a great concept of this... but the BIGGEST issue with this general idea is that either the phone or the laptop accessory will be obsolete way sooner than the user would intended it to be. Also the phone wouldn't be able to change much of its design, with similar limitations to recent Moto devices + Mods. After all of this experience I decided to invest on a device that wouldn't have accessories that will go obsolete in 1 generation, so the Sony Xperia Acro S was perfect for me, as it had pins for a charging dock (included in the box), a microHDMI port for external monitors, a microUSB port besides the charging port (that allowed USB OTG, mouse, keyboard and external storage), microSD slot, and headphone jack... This device was awesome for mirroring to the TV and using it as a "portable desktop" for light work. I do think there is a future here, and maybe very soon.... but the offers have to be good enough not just for niche tech lovers, but also with schools, small business or so.

2. bucky

Posts: 3776; Member since: Sep 30, 2009

I loved my atrix. I even bought ito the laptop and all of the docks. It was laggy though.

4. fiji.siv

Posts: 95; Member since: Nov 25, 2015

I loved my Atrix too. I bought the car dock which I think was ~$40 and it was worth it. The Atrix would change the interface when docked with multimedia controls and huge icons. After hearing me brag about it for a few months, one of my co-workers went to the same store to pick one up. They weren't carrying them anymore because too many customers were returning them with problems. Hmm, I wonder what they meant? Oh ya, I found out. In the 2+ years I ended up with 5 different phones. AT&T kept replacing them and they kept breaking. On my first, the flash LED stopped working. On the second, the wifi didn't work (I owned that one for 2 whole days). The third had a strip across the display that didn't register touches. The display went wacko on the fourth. The fifth also lost touch sensitivity but this time the top half, and after the warranty had expired.

3. fiji.siv

Posts: 95; Member since: Nov 25, 2015

Also the first phone with a multi-core processor. At least, that's what Motorola said at the time.

5. Furbal unregistered

Yep. Brother has this I had the HTC inspire

6. SyCo87

Posts: 297; Member since: Sep 19, 2013

I was a fan of the Bionic. Those were truly great times for discovery. I wish TI OMAP were still around.

7. Crispin_Gatieza

Posts: 3122; Member since: Jan 23, 2014

Sorry John V. Though never officially released, the Palm Foleo was the first companion device and it had its own Wi-Fi onboard. Also, the Motorola ES400 series EDA had a fingerprint scanner before the Atrix as well as a built-in barcode scanner. Your statements would be accurate with the caveat being "for the general public".

8. ijuanp03

Posts: 566; Member since: Dec 30, 2014

Agree with John V here. Motorola was (and still is) an innovator but the phone was way ahead of its time. The processor can't keep up to what the features demanded of it.

10. antmiu2

Posts: 550; Member since: Jun 19, 2011

This concept need to come back!!

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.