Data concerns: YouTube under fire from child advocacy groups

In a week swirling with news regarding privacy concerns, an alliance of child advocacy and privacy groups have filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission against Google. According to one of the groups Commercial Free Childhood, the complaint was filed on April 4, 2018. The complaint alleges that Google is violating the Children Online Privacy Protection Act, which requires parental consent prior to data collection for sites that are aware of children using that site. The document claims that YouTube is aware that children regularly access the site based upon public statements by its own executives, disclosures and of course the creation of a kid friendly app. It also notes that the second most popular channel on YouTube is a channel for children. YouTube makes money off the ads on the site and the data collected from viewers is used to create profiles. These profiles are then targeted with ads that are tailored for that user. The complaint also points out that YouTube in fact does not have a child privacy notice posted on its site. There are directions for creating kid-friendly content but that does not keep the content from being posted on the regular site. 

What sort of data can be collected? 

The complaint cites YouTube's own privacy policy and claims that even without an account it still collects data. They claim that according to the policy, YouTube collects geolocations, IP addresses and persistent identifiers. Persistent identifiers use different information such as IP addresses, device serial numbers, customer numbers in cookies and other bits of information a user transmits to identify that person as a unique user. That user is then targeted by ads for which Google receives large amounts of money. According to the protection act in question, collecting this data means a company needs parental consent if they know children are the users. 

So, what will these groups hope to gain? 

The documents filed with the FTC are requesting future compliance oversight of Google by the FTC as well as civil penalties. The act allows up to $41,484 per violation and the complaint cites sources that say over 75 percent of children between six and twelve use YouTube. If Google were found to be in violation of the Children Online Privacy Protection Act, the damages could be enormous. The coalition is seeking tens of billions of dollars in penalties which they say will deter any future wrongdoing by the company. It remains to be seen where this complaint goes and what the outcome will be. 



1. afrohoxha

Posts: 254; Member since: Mar 13, 2014

So, in other words, companies which create animated series targeted for children, shouldn't sell or contract goods that represent various characters on those series... The series is basically an ad for such goods. And almost every site on Earth tracks and profiles you based on your ip and whatever data it is allowed to collect. The advocacy groups sound worse than Google itself by trying to get profit from the privacy concerns aroused lately and from such a delicate demographic as children. I mean YouTube is not free although you don't pay for it. Even if the audience are children , the content costs money to be maintained, streamed , converted and keeping data integrity on servers. It costs more than general content to curate since it involves children.

2. sepkid

Posts: 7; Member since: Jan 16, 2018

Will the money be giving to the kids that are violated. If not. This group should shut up and go back to vilage.

3. sepkid

Posts: 7; Member since: Jan 16, 2018

I want my share because I myself is violated. I just saw an ad. My parents never signed any documents

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.