Apple has a change of heart and approves an app that finds net neutrality violations

Senate Democrats are frantically searching for the one more vote from the other side of the aisle they need, which would guarantee the passage of a resolution to restore net neutrality. The Trump FCC has repealed net neutrality and the Senate has 30 days left to overrule the FCC's decision. For those unfamiliar with the concept, net neutrality prevents carriers/ISPs from charging more for subscribers to visit certain websites or to favor certain content.

Speaking of net neutrality, Apple originally rejected an app that would have allowed users to determine if net neutrality is being violated. Developed by David Coffnes, a researcher at Northeastern University, Wehe can detect if certain apps are being throttled by a mobile carrier or an internet service provider. The user first signs an online consent form (Coffnes is collecting data for his research) and clicks on "run test." Wehe computes download speeds from seven apps: YouTube, Amazon, NBCSports, Netflix, Skype, Spotify, and Vimeo.

A screenshot of the app being run reveals "Differentation" over Verizon's network for YouTube, Netflix and Amazon. That indicates that these apps are being throttled by Big Red. Developer Coffnes says that this is the sort of information that people would like to know. With the data in hand, consumers can opt to switch carriers, or they could complain to the FCC.

As we noted, Apple first rejected Wehe with one App Store reviewer telling Coffnes that the researcher's app "has no direct benefits to the user." But the company had a 180 degree change of heart, and has now approved it for the App Store.

How carriers go about throttling data speeds

Video streaming content is usually the prime example when we discuss carriers' throttling practices and net neutrality. However, after a lot of testing and investigation, David Coffnes and team eventually found that carriers typically don't throttle content based on type; for example, the rule doesn't look like this: "if video, then throttle". Instead, it turns out carriers look for specific meta data – keywords somewhere inside the data stream that may, in some way, describe the content as video, and thus – a potential target for streaming speed management. Such keywords could be "video" or "netflix".

For example, in one of the examples provided by Coffnes, in a test data stream that initially included the text "", he found that throttling occurred right away. After changing just this piece of text to "", throttling was disabled and streaming speed returned to normal.

This discovery, of course, isn't meant to reveal a technique that could be eventually used by certain content providers to 'escape' throttling, but is a valuable insight into how carriers currently go about throttling nonetheless. In the future, tools similar to what Coffnes' team has created may prove instrumental to revealing provider throttling practices, providing a much needed level of transparency into the issue, and helping users be more informed as to which content or service providers would better suit their needs.

source: Motherboard



1. AmashAziz

Posts: 2934; Member since: Jun 30, 2014

It should have been approved in the first place. Coz it’s users’ right to know about this issue.

4. lyndon420

Posts: 6915; Member since: Jul 11, 2012

Agreed. But good on apple regardless. This will open some eyes and (hopefully) spark some much needed change in the industry.

17. cmdacos

Posts: 4388; Member since: Nov 01, 2016

They just needed to make sure apples own services wouldn't be called out here...

2. worldpeace

Posts: 3135; Member since: Apr 15, 2016

He actually want to say "has no direct benefits to Apple.". But Apple in a s**tty condition now, and they need to calm their customers and stock holders..

3. AmashAziz

Posts: 2934; Member since: Jun 30, 2014

Why do you think Apple is in that condition?

6. Phullofphil

Posts: 1846; Member since: Feb 10, 2009

People that like Apple as a company are not going to care about this article people that don’t like them are in the people that care about the situation are probably just going to be relieved that it got passed but at the same time I don’t know the whole reason why it wasn’t in the first place always stuff that is not talked about receiving that would make sense for Apple to do this I would think

5. Subie

Posts: 2444; Member since: Aug 01, 2015

Why did Trump repeal net neutrality?

7. newbey123

Posts: 704; Member since: Mar 19, 2012

to give more welfare to the big corporations.

9. makatijules

Posts: 835; Member since: Dec 11, 2017

To lets corps have the upoer hand iver everyone else simply because they have mode money. After all, since a Corp like Netflix has more money, than say an Xfinify customer, then why shouldn't he be able to pay for faster better access? Now in fairness I say, yes a person should get more or a better option. If they are willing to pay. But the Internetis a public highway, and we all should have the same equal access to it. The problem. Is, Comcast and other Risks, wanna limit us to drive the rich corps better access and that's wrong.

14. AceNJ

Posts: 26; Member since: Sep 29, 2015

i'm not able to find "wehe" in the app store. just me?

16. BullDozer

Posts: 160; Member since: Dec 18, 2015

Most probably Apple needed some time to remove or alter their own differentiation rules.

18. ssallen

Posts: 218; Member since: Oct 06, 2017

Apple didn't have a change of heart. Apple saw that they were getting bad press on this and pivoted to stifle the bad press. Apple does *not* support Net Neutrality outside of one limp-wristed press release. In reality, Apple actually stands to benefit from overturning it. Stifling competition with its deep pockets Apple can afford to out pay and get top priority traffic lanes over any upstart that comes along that challenges iTunes. Apple has a ton of money and no where to spend it.

* Some comments have been hidden, because they don't meet the discussions rules.

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit for samples and additional information.
FCC OKs Cingular's purchase of AT&T Wireless