How much mobile data do you need, and can you ever have enough?
Last week we briefly lost our internet connection, and turned on the mobile tethering feature of our smartphones. It was remarkable to watch the data counter keep track of how much data we were using, even as the computer sat idle checking email and synchronizing several email boxes. In less than an hour, we managed to rack up over 250 megabytes, or almost 15% of the total 2GB monthly data allowance for the phone used, just checking email.
This brought up the question, how much does someone need? For each user the answer is a little bit different. Some smartphone users enjoy the freedom to download movies on the go, a bandwidth consuming action if done over the wireless carrier's network. Others enjoy streaming music such as Pandora or iHeartRadio. We've heard many people who have racked up large data usage bills because the user enjoys live streaming GPS applications that consume large amounts of data downloading maps real-time while driving across the country.
Here's some interesting facts about what the carriers say users can do with 2GB of data:
- Download up to 10,000 plain text emails
- Download up to 1,500 emails with documents attached
- Visit 4,000 web pages
- Post 500 photos on social media sites like Facebook
While the carriers market the statistics showing how much users can do, we felt it fair to also post the realistic limitations of the same 2GB of data allotment. With 2GB data, a user can:
- Download 2 high definition 720p movies
- Post 40 videos on social media sites like Facebook
- Download 285 high quality MP3s
- Stream high quality music for as much as 4 hours a month
- Use a live updating GPS app to drive from Los Angeles to Seattle
We think it's very interesting to see the difference between the carriers' representation of what a user can do with such amount of data, and the representation of what many smartphone users can do using the features popular on advanced devices. Before smartphones, the carriers' list of things 2GB can do was representative of an average user, but many users new to smartphones don't realize just how data hungry these devices are, and find themselves facing data cutoff or throttling, or worse, overage charges when the user surpasses the monthly data allotment on the plan.
What do you think is a reasonable data allotment for a modern smartphone? How much data have you used in any given month? Do you think it's fair for a carrier to sell a phone by advertising features that when used can exceed your data allotment in such a short period of time?
1. CommentBoxEnforcer (Posts: 78; Member since: 13 Feb 2012)
I think unlimited is reasonable....if u paying why not offer unlimited even if it will cost u a arm and a leg every month
2. draconic1991 (Posts: 24; Member since: 27 Apr 2012)
It is wrong of the carriers to promote their data plans in such a fashion cos those people new to the smartphones can definitly be fooled.
The amount of data sufficient...its actually kind of impossible to determine..once u get used to the internet or worse get addicted to it, even if there was a limit of a 100 gb it would still not be enough and would still bother u..
32. vincentguariglia (Posts: 13; Member since: 28 Apr 2012)
My first smartphone was on AT&T with the unlimite data plan. I then went over to Sprint but there was no service in my area so I picked up Verizon with unlimited data. I currently have T-Mobile with 2Gb data plan and at first I thought it wouldn't be enough and I was always using wifi. One month I decided to use no wifi and just my data because T-Mobile would only throttle me. Turns out I used less than half of 1Gb. As long as you don't do a lot of video and music streaming everyone should be fine on that standard 2Gb plan.
33. draconic1991 (Posts: 24; Member since: 27 Apr 2012)
ya thats what i said...once u get used to it or addicted..otherwise its absolutely upto each person...a person using net on the mobile solely for business purpose may be happy with 1 gb (say) even on lte because he;l only be downloading some small but important files..
3. rawbow (Posts: 362; Member since: 30 Mar 2012)
Interesting article I must say.
I am from India and we have had 3g services here for quite a while but it is still not very popular here. Most of the flagship owning crowd here still use edge and I can barely afford a 3g data plan here with a cap on 2 gb which costs around 12USD ..and that is excluding talk time and SMS... ...and for smartphone users even 10 gb ain't enough if you have such high speeds.
4. TheRetroReplay (Posts: 227; Member since: 20 Mar 2012)
I have unlimited data on my Galaxy Nexus and I've used about a gig of data in a month and that was with heavy usage. My Xyboard however, I've come nowhere near the 2 gigs of data that I've been allotted and I've downloaded lots of apps and done a tone of websurfing and watching videos on YouTube.
However I think that data caps are going to be replaced with unlimited or that caps will get bigger and bigger at lower and lower prices to the point where it doesn't matter because our rapidly evolving technology will require it.
26. Markizzle21 (Posts: 30; Member since: 28 Dec 2011)
You aren't doing anything crazy if you come to one gig a month. I can easily sit on top of 30gb a month. Especially if someone likes netfilx from their phone. 1 hour of that and say bye bye to a gig. Carriers are ripping off customers with this stupid gig stuff especially with the 4g LTE out there. With the capabilities to do so much they limit you to hardly anything.
I'm a verizon rep at a retailer and I don't even feel comfortable pitching 4gb of 4g lte a month because now a days its garbage.
28. miles16852 (Posts: 167; Member since: 20 Oct 2011)
Aint that the TRUTH Markizzle!! THIS ity bitty 2g and 5gb is a flat out JOKE!!!!! for LTE,,,, 2 & 6gb is for toddlers! preshoolers!
5. Tajeshwar (Posts: 8; Member since: 02 Dec 2011)
1GB is enough for one month usage under 2G
2 to 5 GB under 3G ...
thats enough and will fulfil all your smartphone needs
17. 14545 (Posts: 884; Member since: 22 Nov 2011)
I would sort of agree. 5gb for 3g, and 7-10 for 4g. I consider myself a heavy user, but I rarely go over 6-7 gb. I stream music all the time while I'm in the car, I use GPS at least 2-4 times a month. And occasionally tether about 1 gb of data when out and about. I watch hulu, and netflix probably once every two days. So I would be ok with a 10 gb cap if I didn't have unlimited. And I consider myself an extremely heavy user. I don't like the unlimited plans for the data hogs that use it as their primary internet service. That I do have a problem with.
30. miles16852 (Posts: 167; Member since: 20 Oct 2011)
14545,,, NOT sure what EXACTLY your watching on NETFLIX 'once every two days' LOL, with only reaching 6 or 7GB, you must be watching 10min of everything you watch, especially if its ONLY once every 2 days!! yah right! , it should be 25GB MINIMUM for LTE! and nothing less! and you are NOT by NO means a HEAVY user! LOL
29. miles16852 (Posts: 167; Member since: 20 Oct 2011)
Tajeshwar , i DONT think so, not under 4G LTE!!
6. Droid_X_Doug (Posts: 4727; Member since: 22 Dec 2010)
Based on PA's 'real world' experience, I suspect that 2 Gb/month for a smartphone is probably on the low end. I am running around 2.5 to 3 Gb/month on my RAZR with a mix of e-mails with attachments, GPS use, web surfing and occasional tethered hotspot use with my notebook. I signed up for the 4 Gb/month for the price of 2 Gb/month promotion that VZW offered when I purchased the RAZR; so for me, 4 Gb/month @ $30 is kind of the sweet spot.
7. Shubham412302 (Posts: 276; Member since: 09 Nov 2011)
i cant think of using 2 gb a month even on edge network i use more
8. jroc74 (Posts: 3455; Member since: 30 Dec 2010)
I have unlimited and tiered data. 2GB isnt enough if you really use the web and do other things that require data. 10GB might be enough. 5GB...maybe.
I do have LTE tho. On 3G..2GB....maybe...
9. jaytai0106 (Posts: 490; Member since: 30 Mar 2011)
I think this question really depends on the person. I have 2GB plan on AT&T but usually only use about 300mbs-500mbs a month. However, my phone usually connects to wifi at home and while at the gym. Some people can probably hit 5-10GB easily and it really depends on what you are doing with your phone on the go.
10. gp284 (Posts: 120; Member since: 25 Feb 2012)
I got a 4G phone when Verizon had their 4gb promo thing going on. I've never gotten past about 3.6 gb, and that only happened when I downloaded ten 23 min tv shows, and that was around when my data cycle restarts. I usually only use about 1gb a month.
11. shadowcell (Posts: 300; Member since: 28 Mar 2012)
Tiered data plans is a punishment not a better business model. I believe everyone's situation is unique but with more and more smartphone capabilities becomes accessible, we can only hope our carriers are paying more attention.
My everyday lifestyle now involves heavy audio/video streaming and I can tack on up to 4-8GB a month. I'm not abusive but I do enjoy having access to Google Music, Netflix, Hulu Plus and Youtube on my smartphone.
Why should I be penalized just because I'm using whatever my smartphone could do?
35. PlayboyPenguin (Posts: 3; Member since: 30 Jul 2004)
If your "everyday lifestyle" involves such heavy streaming why do you not have wifi? Why should a company providing cellular coverage be expected to cover all your entertainment needs for an extra few dollars a month? Do you feel they owe you a particular lifestyle just because you pay for a phone and a mobil data plan? If you want more then pay for more and stop expecting to be subsidized by the people who use less and do not hog all the bandwidth.
12. Captain_Doug (Posts: 729; Member since: 10 Feb 2012)
I reached 10GB this month with a 3G phone. I would definitely say that that is a lot and way more than i usually use but if i want or need to use more data, I don't wanna worry about it. Having unlimited data(grandfathered) is one of the biggest selling points for me to stay with Verizon. I don't have too many reasons to not leave but I don't even look around anymore. If I can use 10GB with a 3G phone, I'm sure I'll use more with a 4G phone. On the other hand, my wife uses no more than 500mb a month. I'd say 50% of all people with smartphones don't go over 500mb. There's definitely room for those that use it to have unlimited data.
13. remixfa (Posts: 13882; Member since: 19 Dec 2008)
I have a 3g phone and i average 7-14gigs a month most months. if i didnt have true unlimited i would use wifi a lot more, but i dont want to. :)
downloading ROMS, ebooks, stuff from the play store
constant internet usage (how do u think im always on the site when im bored lol)
14. -box- (Posts: 3470; Member since: 04 Jan 2012)
I think tiers are a good idea, but there should be more variety and lower prices. I see data consumption the same way I do gasoline or other consumption of purchasable goods. "If you want to play, you gotta pay" the saying goes. Want to use your phone for watching movies instead of a TV or computer? Pay extra for the convenience. Want to take a road trip across the country? Pay for the gas, tires, and other vehicular upkeep. Want to get a home theater system and have friends over every night to use it? Gotta buy the equipment, pay for the programs or movies, and pay the electric bill.
There's smart ways of lowering billable data usage. Sideloading videos and music are a huge help, as well as playing games just over WiFi, which allows the phone to act as mostly and e-mail and internet access device, which tends to use the least data, being mostly text-only (and can be all text, depending on browser). Speaking of browsers, having a data-friendly browser helps as well, such as Opera which compresses the data for the user making browsing times faster and data consumption lower
18. 14545 (Posts: 884; Member since: 22 Nov 2011)
While I agree to a certain extent, 2 and 4 gig caps are wayy to low. We already pay a premium for having "internet" on our phones. My home internet costs 35 a month for 8down 4up. My mobile data costs me 60 a month for two phones. So I am already paying said "premium". They were making killer money with the unlimited plans, so what changed? The demand increased, but enough to chop the plans off at the ankles?
And you talk about side loading, well I can't really "sideload" from hulu or netflix. Not to mention, then I have to "predict" what I am going to want to watch in the future. So my point is that we already "pay extra" for "convenience". If my "data" had been capped in 07 when I first signed up for it, I wouldn't have gotten it. Unless it was a reasonable car of 5-10 gb. 2-4 gig is completely unreasonable.
One more comment about sideloading, the manfacturers are trying to get us to move away from this, just look at apple and google, they want you to purchase from their "stores". So they are limited access to removable media, as well as doing away with it all together in some cases. So that feature will soon be a thing of the past. Which means we will be more reliant on that data connection than ever before. At a time when we can't use it. While I agree that caps are necessary to prevent abuse, THEY NEED TO BE REASONABLE. 2-4 GB IS NOT REASONABLE.
15. jimjam (Posts: 225; Member since: 28 Jun 2011)
about 50mb is fine for me for email and browsing some webpages now and then. Not sure what everyone else is doing all day on their phones.... perhaps I have more of a life.
20. 14545 (Posts: 884; Member since: 22 Nov 2011)
I stream music going to and from work and school. That adds up to about half of my normal 5-6gb a month usage. Then I use netflix and hulu when I am on my breaks at school and things of that nature.
But I still don't see how you are only using 50 gb a month. My fiancee does no multimedia whatsoever, and mainly only reads news sites, and has one push mail account, and she uses 800 mb to 1 gb a month.
16. Das70 (Posts: 124; Member since: 05 Jan 2011)
I myself would not pay any of the outrageous prices that the big 2 (att and verizon) charge for their limited data. I would not even pay the $25 for the unlimited data Verizon used to charge. It all depends on the user I suppose.
Lets face it realistically most people use their smartphone data mostly for entertainment purposes. As long as people are addicted to watching youtube clips, tvshows, listenting to mps, tethering etc. on their smartphones data is not going to get any cheaper.
I decided a long time ago that I needed unlimited minutes and Verizon and at&t were not up to the task of offering an affordable plan on minutes. I am now on metro pcs. Unlimited minutes and text and of course data for $50. Works good enough for me. I can do almost anything on my phone that a LIMITED data/text/minute verizon customer can do at less than half the price. Yes its a little slower but dooable IMO. I am not about to pay $120(with 2 gb) on verizon for the same I can get on Metro just because they have faster download speeds. Thats $840 more per year. Equals FOUR car payments to me.LOL
Foolish way to spend money IMO.
19. Hildy (Posts: 33; Member since: 23 Nov 2011)
Unlimited. Watching video just sucks up too much of a data plan. I don't watch movies and I don't need HD, but I would like to be able to watch various sites that stream current or archived TV shows without worrying about how close to my data limit I am.
22. rui-no-onna (Posts: 2; Member since: 10 Apr 2012)
With companies pushing for cloud everything, I don't think there'll ever be enough. Cloud Storage + Tiered Data just don't mesh.
23. ScelesticSteve (Posts: 26; Member since: 29 Mar 2012)
I have an unlimited data plan with AT&T. I get throttled after 3GB, but I've never used that much, even during months when my personal data usage was extremely heavy. The most I have ever used is about 2.3GB in a billing cycle.
I understand that unlimited should be unlimited. When you have jackasses' streaming full movies over the cellular data network, it slows the speeds down greatly and affects the towers'. Sometimes other people's surfing might be more important, such as being used for work, or to make a phone call without dropping it due to extreme congestion. I understand why they done it, and if you use more than 3GB per month, you should probably be on a 5GB plan.
24. 14545 (Posts: 884; Member since: 22 Nov 2011)
Unlimited is "unlimited" no matter how VZW or ATT try to spin it. They shouldn't be throttling anyone that is grandfathered on to those plans. That being said, your "work" usage is no more, or less, important than me streaming a movie or music. While I agree that some abuse the system. (those that use it as their only source of internet and rack up 70-100 gbs a month) att and verizon should have looked over the curvature beyond that of "right now", and saw that it wasn't a viable business plan. If they can't/won't do it with minutes, then what made them think it was a good idea with data? That being said, I'm ok with caps, as long as they are put in place ahead of time. IE tmo. Their unlimited has always had an asterisk. But the BS of coming back after the fact is outright theft. As you payed for "unlimited" with no asterisk. That would be the same as me selling you a car and then coming back a year later and saying "oh, the market value increased so I need you to give me another 1k for that car I sold you" (bad example, but I think the point is clear.
In summary, while yes, I do agree that caps are fine. They shouldn't be excessive. and by excessive I mean under 5gb a month for 3g, and probably 10 for 4g/lte. I know if I get kicked onto a plan less than that for the same money as I am currently paying, I'll go back to a dumb phone. As at that point it has lost it's entire value to me. I don't mind adjusting my usage a tiny bit, but when you cut it in half or expect me to pay double(which would move my phone bill from 205-275) then I quit. Plain and simple.
Actually a better example would be VZW saying "Yeah, we know we give you 1400 minutes for 100 a month, but if you want to keep that it's now going to be 200. Or you can downsize to 700 minutes."
Would you be happy about that?
25. nohomad (Posts: 4; Member since: 27 Apr 2012)
I have 500 mb, here in Portugal mobile internet its expensive i have the second most expensive data plan for 10€, the most expensive one it 27€ and is 4g, i dont know what do you guys do on your smartphone, but i stream almost all day music and browse the web, most of the time i dont use all of the 500 mb
27. atlvideoguy (Posts: 12; Member since: 24 Feb 2012)
First off its not about the infinite source of data, its about money. getting you to get a smartphone which has a higher etf money, people are very good at managing minutes now so where else can carriers make more minute you guessed it data, data use is never the same.
31. belovedson (Posts: 807; Member since: 30 Nov 2010)
there are people who have lte enabled tablets. a combination of streaming, netflix, and all the other norms of using a tablet. a bare min is 50gb a month
34. OpenHeart (Posts: 1; Member since: 06 Aug 2012)
Sounds like a class action lawsuit waiting to happen. They obviously do not know what the word "unlimited" means. I took this straight out of the dictionary....
not limited; unrestricted; unconfined; boundless; infinite; vast;
without any qualification or exception; unconditional
It's time someone put a stop to this HUGE lie that they are perpetrating!
36. arjuna (Posts: 1; Member since: 16 Feb 2013)
2 GB is the bare minimum cut-off for a regular internet user. Most webpages these days are 1 MB. I figured out that if I get/send 30 emails a day, use facebook for 10 minutues, browse the web for 10 minutes, watch youtube videos for 10 minutes, stream 10 minutes of music and make 5 minutes of skype calls I will still require 2.57 GB of data per month. If I upped my web-browsing from 10 minutes to 30 minutes a day I will now require 4 GB per month !!!