We may earn a commission if you make a purchase from the links on this page.
I have been trying to use a variety of iPads and Android tablets as PC replacements over the years, because like many other tech enthusiasts, I see the potential behind the idea. iPads are much lighter and easier to carry around than a laptop. They're also quiet, with longer-lasting batteries, often much better build quality, and... simply way more fun to use than a Mac or PC!
Apple has indeed been marketing the iPad as a PC replacement for a while now, and considering the newer iPad Pro models are faster than many laptops, iPads are definitely ready to replace your PC, on paper.
But there remain glaring software-related issues that still hold the iPad back from being a competent PC replacement for most users.
Multitasking is still a mess
Multitasking on the iPad looks similar to how it is on Android, but functionally it's worse.
Any PC user who switches to an iPad will immediately be turned off by its mobile phone interface and single-app-at-a-time experience. Yes, you can use Split View, which pauses many apps' playback when you need to go to the home screen and pick a second app. You can also use Slide Over, which is unusably small and tall, often covering way more vertical screen real estate than it needs to, especially when used with apps such as YouTube.
At the very least, iOS multitasking should be as fluent as it is on many Android devices nowadays, where if you're running YouTube and want to launch another app in split-screen, going to the home screen in order to open it won't pause YouTube's playback. Android also allows for windowed apps and vertical split screen, iPadOS still doesn't.
iPads should not only allow for better multitasking, but go the extra step towards how a PC handles apps, with support for app minimizing and switching like on MacOS. It should keep an app active and accessible in the dock even when the user switches to a different app. It seems like a no-brainer to just do multitasking like it is on MacOS, instead of still sticking to a mobile phone solution for multitasking.
Desktop apps need to come to iPad
Procreate is one of the most popular iPad apps for professionals, exclusive to iOS.
iPad already has some amazing desktop-class applications, such as Safari and Photoshop, and a variety of high-quality apps for productivity, like Procreate and LumaFusion.
But to really attract a majority of professional PC and Mac users, Apple has yet to bring its own highly popular desktop apps such as Logic Pro and Final Cut Pro to the iPad. Final Cut Pro alone is many professionals' excuse for owning a Mac, so it's reasonable to expect that porting it to iPad would make the device highly appealing to pros.
More console games should be ported to iPad
There are a few PlayStation 2-era games available on iPad, and some 90's console and PC titles.
Just because Mac can't compare to PC when it comes to its gaming library, that doesn't mean the iPad should overlook "real" gaming too, and stick with just mobile games. If games like Skyrim can be ported to the Nintendo Switch and its inferior hardware, they can be ported to the iPad too. Apple should seriously consider encouraging developers to give that a go.
Right now, on an iPad we can either play 90's console and PC games, such as Sonic The Hedgehog and Doom, or a few games from the early 2000's, namely Max Payne and Grand Theft Auto. And while that's great, and those are fun, they were ported all the way back in 2011. The iPad's hardware has vastly improved over the last 9 years, yet it still only has those, and mobile games.
Recommended Stories
File management still needs work
My music is in the VLC app's folder, because I can't import it into the Music app.
When I wanted to transfer my downloaded music library from a Windows PC to an iPad, I quickly discovered that it's basically not meant to be possible. After a long period of trial and error, the solution for me was to download the VLC Player app on my iPad, and use iTunes on my PC to transfer the music into VLC's folder. So now I can only play my music library through VLC, and not the Music iPad app.
Turns out, the Music app only works for music you bought via iTunes. But, as Apple clearly hasn't figured out yet, there are plenty of other ways for one to build a music library.
This is just one of many anti-consumer experiences you'll stumble upon when trying to use an iPad as your main computer. Another one is – at the moment, the Files app only lets users see the size of a single file at a time, you can't see the sizes of folders or multiple files. Although file management on iOS / iPadOS has improved vastly over the last few years, it still can't be defined as PC-class.
Better widgets for Today View
Today View is a home screen panel containing widgets, that is only available on iPad.
Anytime you see a modern iPad being used, the user has Today View active on the home screen, but with no useful information actually on it. It's often kept on because it looks nice and sells us the promise that in the future, it may become useful.
Let's take the Mail widget. If you've ever used a mail widget on Android, you'd know how it's supposed to work – showing you a list of your latest emails along with their subjects, sender name and sometimes more. The Mail widget for Today View on iPad however shows nothing, you're supposed to "Add VIPs", which means priority accounts. It's a very niche thing to expect from the average iPad user. Most people expect to see their newest incoming emails in a widget like that, so that's what it should be doing, or at least have the option. A Music or Media widget to control more than just Apple Music would be nice too, like we have in the Control Centre.
Better kickstand cases for iPads
Microsoft's Surface tablets come with arguably the best kickstand, and it's built-in.
This isn't about iPadOS per se, but it's still worth mentioning. As we know, Apple is all about the pretty and simple design language. Having that in mind, I doubt the Cupertino company will ever add a kickstand to the iPad itself, like the Microsoft Surface tablets conveniently have. But we should at least have better options for simple, thin and sturdy kickstand cases. If I'm forced to buy an expensive case with each new iPad, just so it could stand up on its own, I'd at least like the case options to not make the iPad thicker, heavier, or worse-feeling. But most case options out there, including those from Apple, just aren't very good.
Apple's own first-party "smart folio" solutions still use the folding "origami" design with weak magnets, which offer nowhere near a decent or secure, adjustable kickstand solution as what we have on Microsoft's Surface tablets. Apple's smart folio cases aren't even adjustable, you get one viewing angle and one "typing" angle, that's it.
This is nowhere near as good as a real kickstand.
We should expect from a computer replacement to be able to stand on its own in several usable positions, or at least for it to have a variety of quality kickstand cases available. I'm aware that Apple's new Magic Keyboard (seen below) has adjustable viewing angles, but that's a $300 keyboard and trackpad accessory, and it's only for the newer Pro models.
In conclusion
Can this replace your computer already, or is it still just a large iPhone?
The iPad is an amazing device, and can already replace a PC for light users. But for many, it continues to be held back by Apple's choice to still treat it as little more than a large iPhone, at least when it comes to its software.
Apple splitting iPadOS from iOS was a promising step in the right direction, but iPadOS is in its infancy, and still too much of a phone operating system. What is your wishlist for future iPadOS versions, and do you think an iPad can already sufficiently replace your computer now?
Rado, a tech enthusiast with a love for mobile devices, brings his passion for Android and iPadOS to PhoneArena. His tech journey began with MP3 players and has evolved to include tinkering with Android tablets and iPads, even running Linux and Windows 95 on them. Beyond tech, Rado is a published author, music producer, and PC game developer. His professional work on iPads, from producing songs to editing videos, showcases his belief in their capabilities. Rado looks forward to the future of mobile tech, particularly in augmented reality and multi-screen smartphones.
Recommended Stories
Loading Comments...
COMMENT
All comments need to comply with our
Community Guidelines
Phonearena comments rules
A discussion is a place, where people can voice their opinion, no matter if it
is positive, neutral or negative. However, when posting, one must stay true to the topic, and not just share some
random thoughts, which are not directly related to the matter.
Things that are NOT allowed:
Off-topic talk - you must stick to the subject of discussion
Offensive, hate speech - if you want to say something, say it politely
Spam/Advertisements - these posts are deleted
Multiple accounts - one person can have only one account
Impersonations and offensive nicknames - these accounts get banned
Moderation is done by humans. We try to be as objective as possible and moderate with zero bias. If you think a
post should be moderated - please, report it.
Have a question about the rules or why you have been moderated/limited/banned? Please,
contact us.
FCC OKs Cingular\'s purchase of AT&T Wireless
Things that are NOT allowed: