Smartphone camera comparison: you choose the winner (Results)
posted by Ray S. / Jul 29, 2011, 4:01 AM
We picked some of the hottest phones out there: the Samsung Galaxy S II (appearing as Device 4 in the outdoor test and Device A indoors), the iPhone 4 (dubbed Device 2 and Device D), and the HTC Sensation (known as Device 1 and Device B). The digital camera we used was the Canon PowerShot SD870 IS (Device 3 and Device C), an 8.0-megapixel point-and-shooter released in 2007.
Outdoor test results:
The first question we wanted to answer was: “Can a contemporary high-end smartphone perform on par with a common point-and-shoot camera?” The results give a negative answer – the digicam swiped competition away in outdoor tests, but the advantage was most obvious indoors with artificial light or nearly no light at all. We'd like to give props to our user emmarbee who was the only one who managed to approximate the used devices in the first test.
With that said, though, there are three smartphones left fighting for the second spot. In our outdoor test, you ranked the iPhone 4 first among them with a combined total of 1975 votes. The HTC Sensation was a close runner-up, while the Samsung Galaxy S II ended up last.
You can check out the images from our outdoor test again here.
Indoor test results:
When it comes to our indoor blind test, things looked very differently. An unanimous decision pin-pointed the digital camera as the best performer again, but this time nearly equally eloquent was the people's vote against the iPhone 4. The handset failed to capture adequate images in some of the cases with colors looking unnatural when the LED flash fired. Although the HTC Sensation easily grabbed the second place here, there was a close fight in the strictly detail-centric department, where it managed to slightly edge the Galaxy S II.
With a nearly forensic fever, jiezel91 rationalized about the devices we've used in the second test and deserved a special mention for the way they reached the conclusion that device C is a digital camera. This is just one example of your brilliant analysis, and we were particularly happy with your comments, so we extend our humble thanks to all of you who chimed in the discussion.
You can check out the images from our indoor test again here.
So, it turns out most of you did find the iPhone 4 a better cameraphone compared to Android powerhouses such as the Galaxy S II and Sensation in the daylight test. Not once have there been negative comments with regards to how the iPhone performs, but it has now come out on top of this comparison, thanks to your votes.
We give credit where it's due. That's why we should note the excellence demonstrated by the Sensation when it comes to shots taken in low-lit, indoor conditions. HTC's offering proved that it's a much better solution for such scenarios, compared to the iPhone 4 and Galaxy S II. Actually, if we have to average all the results from the outdoor and indoor tests, it appears that the HTC Sensation performs best from all three phones, being a relatively close runner-up outdoors, and an undisputed leader indoors.
Finally, it has become clear from your votes that even one of the hottest smartphones out there are still pretty far from being as capable as dedicated point-and-shoots are. We can compromise to an extent of course, that's why some of us are already willing to leave their cameras at home, but if we have to judge pure quality, it's evident that cell phone manufacturers still have a long road ahead of them.
Posts: 174; Member since: May 27, 2011
Great...here comes the Apple fanboy army... -.-
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:06 AM 17
Posts: 14605; Member since: Dec 19, 2008
nah. Great idea though. The only thing I take issue is with us voting on the canon. Yea, i voted for it too, it was by far the best. But since we were only picking 1 winner and not putting them in order, that doesnt mean that the other phones are in order of best to worst. On the inside test camera#4 was horrid though, so it being last is well deserved.. lol My point being, if the canon was the control and not part of the vote, would the other cell cameras have come out in the same order or would it have changed? The digital camera sucked up 3/4ths of the votes.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 7:09 AM 16
Posts: 252; Member since: Mar 03, 2011
lol...one of the rare occasions i agree with what u r saying, about the canon.. Although I still feel there should have been Nokia N8 included in this test as it is absolutely the best phone-cam in the market and i would have loved to see how it fares against the SGS2! and i don't see a freakin point in why the iP4 was even put to comparison with the other good cams LOL
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 8:05 AM 12
Posts: 14605; Member since: Dec 19, 2008
While I would have liked to see the N8 in the comparison too, this comparison was for the "major phones", not just phones marketed as awesome cameras. Otherwise the Sony Xperia whatchamacallit should have been in the comparison too. iwebdroid, the SGS2 didnt lose to the iphone. they all lost to the digital camera (who didnt see that comming). Since there was no way to say who was 2nd best this is all just votes for which pic they thought was "best". So there isnt really a 2nd,3rd, and 4th place with the way they had it set up. There was first.. and everyone else. Honestly, I think some people were just random voting or voting for the phone they "thought" was their favorite phone. The camera was a huge difference between the others.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:29 PM 1
Posts: 858; Member since: Jun 09, 2009
i do think the test is quite flawed. it should include a nokia and a sony device and have some way to rank the photos. maybe they can redo it when the new iphone launches.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 8:35 AM 5
What they need to do to accurately create a test is to take a very high end DSLR and snap the pic and say, this is what the scene looks like through a DSLR (colors are neutral). 1)Which of these camera phones presents the closest most accurate image to the DSLR. 2) Which of these images looks the best to you? ( this may not always be the most accurate image, some people like having oversaturation. I do a bit, but not much).
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 9:07 AM 5
Posts: 326; Member since: Jul 18, 2011
I can believe that the HTC sensation had the best camera among smart phones! you should have had an N8 in the comparison
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:10 AM 9
Its not htc sensation,its the conon mobile.the percentage of the votes are displayed at the top not at the bottom
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:25 AM 1
I agree that the N8 should have been included in the comparison. If you are going to compare the camera on phones, you should have included a phone whose camera is one of the big selling points. I was hoping the N8 would be one of the phones because I really wanted to see how well it compares with other phones.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 12:59 PM 3
i would have liked to see the n8 as a fourth phone in this vote. but this was a great idea to compare these devices, though i didnt expect my sgs2 to do poorly as in this test.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:12 AM 8
me too. Also the Xperia arc. I don't understand the choice of devices here to be honest... I'd taken Xperia arc, Galaxy S2, Nokia N8 and the compact digital cam. Maybe the iPhone4 as a fifth contender, but frankly the iPhones camera is nothing more than average.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:57 AM 3
i'm sorry to say, but these results are bulls**t. Anyone with good vision would've chosen the Canon camera as the winner in both tests, it was very clear to me which of the four is not a smartphone camera. So those who voted for any of the smartphones really need to change their glasses. The results would've had some relevance if you had to chose the best two cameras.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:13 AM 5
Posts: 67; Member since: Jul 28, 2011
Wow. I can't believe I got a special mention from Phonearena! Well thanks for that! And this time around, I registered. ;) But then again, I was wrong to think that there was an N8 on the test. Still, I correctly predicted that Camera C is the digicam.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:17 AM 7
I thing test was OK... but we there are few things to learn from this.... 1) compare only phone cameras or dedicated cameras or/and 2) let the viewers to chose 1st, 2nd and 3rd (3/2/1 points) and 3) more photos/more crops are needed anyway, thanks a lot for test which was very original
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:23 AM 7
wow, ok the results are totally unexpected. I'm very cautious though over the fairness of the test. I've seen countless other examples where the Iphone and sensation photos are much below the quality of the Galaxy S2.
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:39 AM 2
Posts: 77; Member since: Aug 26, 2009
But these are practical tests, mate :)
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:45 AM 0
Posts: 77; Member since: Aug 26, 2009
Waow! HTC Sensation indeed is a flagship! x) Thanks for the amazing test Phonearena! Would have been better though, if it had Nokia N8 in it... Nevertheless, it was great and looking forward to more of such tests :)
posted on Jul 29, 2011, 4:43 AM 3
Send a warning to post author
Send a warning to Selected user.
The user has 0 warnings currently.
Next warning will result in ban!
Ban user and delete all posts
Message to PhoneArena moderator (optional):