HTML5 beats Adobe Flash at video playback, falls behind in everything else

HTML5 beats Adobe Flash at video playback, falls behind in everything else
It is really awesome seeing what an extensive comparison has been made between the graphical performance of HTML5 and Adobe Flash when running on a variety of mobile devices. Software architect Sean Christmann took his time and set up a number of benchmarks testing how well each platform performed in different scenarios ranging from vector and bitmap rendering to HD video playback.

Nine different smartphones and tablets were used for the test, all of them running the latest official version of their respective operating system. Even though HTML5 has been quoted by some as a potential Flash replacement, the end results were mostly in favor of Adobe's platform. Could it be because Adobe itself partially funded the research? Well, this doesn't seem very likely because identical source codes were being used for every type of test.

When all the testing was done, it turned out that Adobe Flash had no troubles rendering simple and complex 2D graphics at high framerates, yet HTML5 was a clear winner when it came down to playing HD videos in H.264 format. Most devices were dropping a considerable amount of frames when rendering them with Flash, while using HTML5 for playback gave much better results. Just to be sure that all data was correct, Christmann decided to go for overkill and actually counted every frame rendered with a high speed camera.

So, it looks like Adobe Flash is not anywhere near becoming obsolete, but there is still a lot to be desired in terms of video rendering performance. Hopefully, future software updates will be able to do something about it.

source: Craftymind via GigaOM

FEATURED VIDEO

30 Comments

1. SuperAndroidEvo

Posts: 4888; Member since: Apr 15, 2011

If you notice Flash did bad on single-core devices. With dual-core devices Flash did well & for the most part it's only going to get better because quad-cores are JUST around the corner. HTML5 is a clear winner in the single-core area, but with multiple-cores becoming the norm the differences will be minimal to non at best. Flash is not going anywhere, HTML5 is the future like by 2019 or so, unless Flash makes some changes. Flash's HUGE install base makes them too formidable & I am sure Adobe is working to make Flash even more efficient. So Flash & HTML5 look to be sharing the spotlight for a VERY long time! Did you see Apple's results with Flash, ohh yeah Apple doesn't run Flash! So in the mean time Apple users won't be able to enjoy the internet as much because of Flash’s dominance in the World Wide Web!

2. AppleFUD unregistered

couldn't agree more. html5 standards won't even be set for a long time. too see just how far behind html5 is just look at IE9--the new modern MS browser. . . It doesn't matter what html5 can do if the browsers don't support it and that's why no one should be using a browser supported/owned by MS & apple--they don't want to see the web truly succeed. back the browsers that are pushing the web forward, supporting standards, and open-source so the web remains THE open platform it was designed to be.

12. 530gemini

Posts: 2198; Member since: Sep 09, 2010

Thanks to users like you. We're moving forward slowly :)

15. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Its like the 64bit desktop scenario. If companies want users to adopt 64bit more, get rid of 32bit, phase it out. Its not up to the users...

3. gallitoking

Posts: 4721; Member since: May 17, 2011

you two lovebirds.... make me laugh...

4. vette21man

Posts: 351; Member since: Apr 06, 2011

In an unbiased answer, could someone reply with what I'm missing by not having flash on my phone? And please don't say "games," I have 100 games from the app store installed. I can only think of a fancy animation that is supposed to play on my bank's website. I can't really say that I'm upset I don't have flash capability, but I'm possibly just ignorant to its "killer app" features. Anyone?

6. SuperAndroidEvo

Posts: 4888; Member since: Apr 15, 2011

This is one example of many, I can't load up a MLB.com site for a certain baseball team. Without Flash it limits my viewing pleasure. I am relegated to pure text. I can't see the LIVE Gameday function of the website, I can't see the up to the moment stats, video clips of run scoring plays, homeruns, stolen base, great defensive plays and so on. With Flash the diving play that I was reading about in text form is actually illustrated to me in real live gameday video which adds to the dynamic of the text. THAT is what is missing from a Flash less device. I can go on & on but my post would almost be infinite. The World Wide Web is so full of Flash content that there is not enough room to even state them all! Imagine Flash game sites, the user created original Flash content community, so on & so forth. I hope this helps to understand why Flash DOES make a difference. Some people will say “well I don’t need that”. Then essentially you are just reading a newspaper. You are missing so much of the wonder the World Wide Web has to offer through Flash!

8. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Another site is radiotime.com. Its a music streaming site for live radio, probably the best site for live radio. The phone app JUST got updated to where you dont need to visit the site on your device anymore. But, Flash was my best friend most of last year. I dontr know if it cant run on iDevices. I asked some folks on Engadget and never got a response...lol. But I know for Android phones it needed full Flash to work, not Skyfire.

10. SuperAndroidEvo

Posts: 4888; Member since: Apr 15, 2011

Exactly we are talking about the pleasure side of Flash on phones. There are even more business & school reasons why Flash is so important. People like myself for instance, needed a laptop to do certain tasks for work but now that my phone or tablet runs Flash that is one less thing I need to carry. Without getting into too much detail of what I do, I can access client information through our company's Flash website almost instantly with my phone. I would have to turn on my laptop let it load & then access it. So Flash essentially save me time also. In the business that I am in time is money. Again there are just too many reasons why Flash is important. This is something that is very common thinking, every MAJOR mobile company HTC, Samsung, Motorola, Nokia, RIM, LG, Sony, Pantech, ZTE, & the list goes on, has or will have Flash. The only one that doesn’t is Apple.

23. NeXoS

Posts: 292; Member since: May 03, 2011

www.southparkstudios.com among millions of others. :D

5. cc16177

Posts: 312; Member since: May 09, 2010

It depends on what you use your device for. I bought my Motorola XOOM strictly to do scheduling and to access my patient files... the website we use for that relies heavily on flash, and I would still be forced to do this on my laptop if my Thunderbolt and XOOM could not run flash. I also read quite a bit of news articles on my tablet/phone, so being able to play the embedded flash videos is much easier than having to load it via my youtube app. Like I said, it all depends on what you use your devices for, but what it boils down to is that any device with flash is more capable than a device without. At least if you are trying to remove the need for a regular computer.

9. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Yea my girlfriend found out about Flash trying to do online classes for school. It worked great on my Droid X. With my phone she could do school work on her job during breaks. Its not always about fun n games with needing and wanting Flash.

7. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

I keep saying....once HTML5 becomes the standard, norm then fine. Until then....I will use Flash while its available.

11. smalltank

Posts: 19; Member since: May 26, 2011

im staying with flash as like windows..the most universally known and available...this new moto dual core smartphone from Verizon..amazingly does both HTML5 ANG flash based on every sites settings..wow

13. 530gemini

Posts: 2198; Member since: Sep 09, 2010

Again, I'm surprised that fagroids haven't heard of Skyfire browser that allows the ipad and the iphone to view flash contents of a website. Also, they admit that html5 is the future, but it seems like they want to hold on to flash for as long as they can. Why? Because of their pride, and the thought that flash is something that android devices offer natively while idevices don't (unless you download skyfire) It's amazing how fanboys will delay the very obvious coming of html5 just because of their silly pride. Tsk, tsk, tsk.

14. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Are you even reading the posts.....Skyfire isnt the same as full Flash. Are you even reading the posts.....So do you want everyone to think and feel the same? Is that it. In case you missed my earlier post....when HTML 5 becomes the standard, the norm, fine. Until then....

16. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Edit.....dont wanna waste my time or energy even replying.

17. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

................

19. Whateverman

Posts: 3295; Member since: May 17, 2009

I know how you feel jroc74, but I'm feeling pretty antagonistic today. Please, allow me! :)

21. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Be my guest...lol Have fun...

18. Whateverman

Posts: 3295; Member since: May 17, 2009

gemini? You feeling inferior with your shinny little glass phone? Or are you just pissed because you are starting to realize you made the wrong choice of OS. I'm sure if you keep that phone another 5 years, you will see just how much better HTML5 really is. Just hang in there little girl! No one bashed your OS, you started this BS and I'm sure its because you have a real inferiority complex about how little your phone does and how much money you have to shell out to make it do anything. It's not Googles fault that Steve Jobs didn't want you to have flash on his phone. Get a different phone next time and STFU! Don't attack Android users for having features you will never enjoy. Just say what's on your little under developed mind, and keep it movin! Because your little girly attacks are annoying as hell!

20. protozeloz

Posts: 5396; Member since: Sep 16, 2010

I had skyfire and it does not work the same as flash.... though it was going to be a breeze... but no skyfire lacks stuff that allows you to fully use flash (for example try going to a page with several flash content and you will found yourself either running only one video or having a hard time to get other flash things to work (on last version I tested I have to say) so no skyfire is good for that occasional video on the web plus it wont replace flash.... but talking to you is a wait of time isnt it.... since you end up re sousing on calling other people idiots... also How its our fault that the places we visit use flash? how enjoying web content the same way we do on a computer something related with pride? flash is dying for sure... but while its alive and running on the places I go then having it its just nice...

22. jroc74

Posts: 6023; Member since: Dec 30, 2010

Didnt you get the memo? Choice is a bad thing....unless that choice is related to the iPhone.

24. protozeloz

Posts: 5396; Member since: Sep 16, 2010

I never get my office memos...

25. John Dowdell unregistered

Hi, video performance is mainly related to the availability of hardware acceleration. Device manufacturers naturally want to open that up to Flash, but not all got it in the first iteration. For prior work on how acceleration dominates video results, see Jan Ozer last year:http://www.streaminglearningcenter.com/articles/fl ash-player-cpu-hog-or-hot-tamale-it-depends-.html jd/adobe

26. PassyPibrasap unregistered

Emily Discusses Her Karen Millen Office Lady Dress Karen Millen Office Lady Dress show out your confident clavicle. Also, it can make you more attractive. Regardless if you are taking part in meeting or wherever you are, wearing Karen Millen Outlet can create a memorable image for you personally.You'll find very good price for top product on our website here. People who wear the Karen Millen office lady dress will appear filled with spirit and energy, the simple and decent design also cause you to solemn.Emily is a very capable girl, after she entered that company 2 yrs, she was promoted the person in control. She's so young that she takes control of lots of people who are older then her, obviously, it's not a easy thing. She knows clearly, if she wants to make all those her underlings follow her, she must has the leader prestige. She is capable but she looks not mature enough. Karen Millen Dresses make you preferable. If you're taking part in ceremony or getting involved in party, wearing Karen Millen dress will provide a wonderful image for you. Emily wears Karen Millen office lady dress, she become more popularity, she get more perfect, and much more successful. Please arrived at our web store and purchase discount Karen Millen dress. In our online shop, Karen Millen dress is not the patent of starts. Any girl who loves beauty can enjoy the concession of Karen Millen. karen millen new dresses

27. PassyPibrasap unregistered

The Brand Clothes of Karen Millen Purchasing a chic dress cannot be in a hurry, prior to making a decision, you should try on shoes carefull and fully feel them, to see whether or not they are extremely tough to wear or they're suitable for wearing. There is no deny that cloth are our intimate friends, since we have to wear them every single day, thus it is essential for all of us to choose an appropriate and fashion dress. However, so many people are always centered on the outlook of rather than its comfort degree when shopping, which might become a painful thing. Image that you're going to a party, to make a deep impression on people; you purchase a brand new Outlet Karen Millen you ought to dress and a pair of high-heeled shoes. You do look beautiful in that, however, after standing a long time, the feet begin to feel hurt and also you ca not enjoy the part any more. Then you definitely become aware of the significance of comfort degree of shoes and regret having bought an inapposite pair of shoes. I think this is the most shining point of any girl. Regarding me, she's very beautiful and she or he includes a good taste for cloth. Whether she's in an evening dress to go to some activities or perhaps in casual dresses within the daily life, she could always inject us having a a feeling of energy and fresh air. I am very such as the Karen Millen Dress big red color perfectly reflects her white skin, unique design of the flower on her behalf right shoulder reveals a beautiful shoulder carve and the collarbone. karen millen curvaceous one shoulder satin dress

28. PassyPibrasap unregistered

Karen Millen Clothing Is Original Option for Womens During Shopping Attention all bargain ladys!Brand Karen Millen Dress Clearance Sale is being held once more this July 1st and 2nd at our Karen Millen Dress Outlet Store. With every item once more heading out the doorway, patrons are sure to find a most sought-after item. The quality of the Karen Millen Dress is more superior than ever with donated clothing being brand, factory or second hand but in excellent condition. Using the local economy still attempting to make ends meet on a household level, any savings that can be made are a blessing. Lifeline Sunshine Coast Business Manager Ian Ezzy said new clothing is an expense that many households just can't entertain or it is often at the end from the household budget. Karen Millen have constructed a range to help you get more closet with some key pieces which are wearable through the seasons. Order Cheap Karen Millen at reasonable price here, they are simply worth every single penny. Amy seemed to be enjoying the opportunity to be featured in the magazine, pouting and posing her way through the shoot - and also at one point sitting precariously on the bollard on the street while resting her feet on the crate. karen millen.co.uk

29. tryecrot unregistered

Yes there should realize the opportunity to RSS commentary, quite simply, CMS is another on the blog.

30. PassyPibrasap unregistered

A tale about Karen Millen & Students Like a student,i didnt know more about the fashion dress,but by some dress,i knew the Karen Millen Dress. Someone call a crazy girl for dress. Maybe. no matter it is lace dress, chiffon dress, or dress with hollow out, all they're my favoriate. in fact in recent days, I like the style of dress that your fair maiden usually wear, but sometimes, I wish to try the design and style of Europe and America series, however i don understand what the design and style of Europe and America is precisely, so it just like that, like the mixture of Jeans, T-shirt, leather clothing? sometimes, I want to try differnt style of dress, like the British style, or the grace French, or recover the classic style, but I cann grasp their connotation. so hope you guy could help. however the dress is my speciality. Almost a lot of women still are wild about purchasing new dress, new clothers. still remember when I did some shopping in the street, then went into a karen millen dress shop, there's a young lady who had been trying a skirt and looked into the mirror, up and down. Now i've interest in Karen Millen item, and purchased it on the website. And often introduce this dress to my mother and my aunt.Additionally they vey like it. Karen Millen dress is devoted to shaping the women's physical beauty lines have demonstrated a sense of femininity silhouette. Karen Millen of clothing everywhere are near to the body from the cutting. karen millen sale dresses

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.