Apple iPhone 11 vs XR vs 8 Plus battery life test, should you upgrade?

Apple iPhone 11 vs XR vs 8 Plus battery life test, should you upgrade?
The new iPhone 11, just like its predecessor the XR, have a ho-hum display resolution of 828x1792 pixels, returning 326 pixels per inch density, or just enough to be called "Retina." The 5.5" iPhone 8 Plus, in comparison, has an "average" for today's standards 1080p display which still sports higher 401ppi pixel density than the 6" iPhone 11.

Given that the pixel density of a mobile display is perhaps the biggest single culprit behind battery life differences, all other things being equal, that comparatively low screen resolution of the 11 works to one undeniable advantage - the phone's battery life.

Apple listed official battery life stats in the form of "up to" 15 hours of Internet browsing and 16 hours of video-binging for the XR. Not only that, but Apple was so proud of what it achieved with the iPhone XR's battery life, that it cites the "lasts up to 1.5 hours longer than iPhone 8 Plus" tidbit everywhere, as this was its previous marathon runner to aspire to.

Apple iPhone 11 battery life vs iPhone XR vs 8 Plus


Enter the iPhone 11 with its larger battery and more efficient A13 processor which, sure enough, one-ups the XR's battery life, according to Apple's own internal testing, albeit by just an hour in video playback. Unfortunately, this year Apple stopped issuing the Internet browsing test, so that it can brag with the "5 more hours" battery of the 11 Pro Max compared to the XS Max

Browsing typically means a lot of text on white background, and displaying white is the worst case scenario for OLED displays in terms of power draw, so the difference between the Pro Max and its predecessor would have probably been much smaller than the 5 hours advertised. 

That is why we decided to run our own browsing test, where we loop popular websites snapshots offline and mimic scrolling behavior, to gauge the real battery life advantage of the iPhone 11 before the XR and 8 Plus. Let's not forget that all of these are with LCD displays, which don't have the same challenges as OLEDs when showing white, so going in we expected the difference between the 11 and XR to be more significant in browsing than what Apple lists for the video playback test.


As you can see, the mere 6% bump in battery capacity between the iPhone XR and iPhone 11 results in a comparable slight increase in browsing endurance. Our YouTube playback test, however, resulted in Apple's advertised hour of battery life more, and change. 

In mixed usage, as in our legacy battery test, the iPhone 11 also outlasted the XR by more than an hour, hinting that there might be more to its endurance than the measly 2942mAh vs 3110mAh battery pack increase.

Battery life (hours) Higher is better
Apple iPhone 11 13h 29 min (Excellent)
Apple iPhone XR 11h 1 min (Excellent)
Apple iPhone 8 Plus 10h 35 min (Excellent)
Charging time (minutes) Lower is better
Apple iPhone 11 213
Apple iPhone XR 192
Apple iPhone 8 Plus 178

What's behind the better battery life of the iPhone 11 compared to the XR? Given that we have the same LCD display, and a negligible battery capacity growth, it most likely boils down to the new A13 chipset built with the second-gen 7nm process. 

Anandtech recently put the two chipsets to the test, and found out that the A13 is about 25% more efficient than the A12 on average, even though it is slightly faster than its predecessor. Granted, processor efficiency weighs less in the overall power consumption of a phone, compared to the screen draw, but it's enough of a difference between the A12 and A13 to eke out gains in battery life across the board for the iPhone 11 over the XR.

Should you upgrade to the iPhone 11?


The iPhone 8 Plus, on the other hand, is a good deal disadvantaged over the newer handsets - its display, albeit smaller, has a higher pixel density, its battery capacity is smaller, and the processor is a 10nm one vs the two 7nm chipsets in the XR and 11. 

Oh well, the whole point of this battery life comparison is to show you what you gain if you are coming out of your two-year iPhone 8 Plus payment shackles, and jumping to the new iPhone 11 would be a significant upgrade in endurance on a charge indeed.

FEATURED VIDEO

7 Comments

1. cncrim

Posts: 1590; Member since: Aug 15, 2011

I didn’t read the article and you asked should you upgrade if you have 3 years iphone regardless model then the answer is NO. Speed pump, improve camera etc and all that but all that not worth to shell out at least $800.

2. mackan84

Posts: 609; Member since: Feb 13, 2014

iPhone 8 starts at $449, XR $599 and 11 $699. I think the article is aimed to anyone with a older model then these.

3. SanDiegoFreddy

Posts: 49; Member since: Oct 27, 2014

"Oh well, the whole point of this battery life comparison is to show you what you gain if you are coming out of your two-year iPhone 8 Plus payment shackles" It's specifically aimed at people that have an iPhone 8 Plus. I have a 6S, and still wouldn't want to shell out close to a thousand dollars on a phone considering mine still does everything well and had the battery replaced for free due to battery-gate.

4. mackan84

Posts: 609; Member since: Feb 13, 2014

Well look at that. If you don’t want that new camera at that price hold on to it another year. iPhone 11 will probably go down to $599.

5. Alcyone

Posts: 533; Member since: May 10, 2018

Agree. My co worker still uses a 5s, and i never here a gripe about anything about it. Battery replacement is better than a 1k phone, imo.

6. Vokilam

Posts: 1343; Member since: Mar 15, 2018

I have a 5s as well. Awesome phone. iOS 12 made it as fluid as the day it was released.

7. Rahulkaw001

Posts: 32; Member since: Oct 22, 2019

why apple never gives information about battery capacity?

Latest Stories

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers at https://www.parsintl.com/phonearena or use the Reprints & Permissions tool that appears at the bottom of each web page. Visit https://www.parsintl.com/ for samples and additional information.