Would you prefer an Optimus G over a Galaxy S III, if there was no marketing?
Now, having put ourselves in this most unimaginable situation, we wonder if this would make any difference in our preferences. Actually, it's pretty hard to imagine that it won't. With absolutely no marketing tricks being played on our minds, we'd have to judge devices solely by what we see. Still, since the specs sheet isn't a part of marketing, it'll also have to remain a factor here.
Interestingly, we recently made a similar experiment, and it proved that if users were to choose a handset based on specs alone, the LG Optimus G, which is LG's upcoming flagship model, easily wins in comparison with the Samsung Galaxy S III, which is one of the very best Android smartphones right now. This isn't a specs comparison here, though. We already know what both devices looks like, and what features they are going to pack. Sure, the Optimus G hasn't been released globally yet, but it's fairly easy for all of us to imagine what it's going to be like - super-fast and powerful, with a superior specs sheet and a different design. However, there's more to a phone than this. What about the software experience? LG has never been particularly awesome in this respect, while Samsung has made some substantial advancements lately, optimizing its software and adding a bunch of features to expand the functionality of its devices. LG has also added some cool software stuff, but there simply hasn't been that much excitement surrounding its products.
So, LG Optimus G, or the Samsung Galaxy S III? Remember, no TouchWiz, just a user interface; no HD Super AMOLED, just an AMOLED screen; and no Crystal Reflection for LG, just an oddly textured material that should be glass, or something like it. Which one are you going to choose? Will it be the Optimus G with its newer Snapdragon S4 Plus processor, or will it be the Galaxy S III with its slightly bigger screen and intriguing software features?
This here should be the right moment to mention that we've chosen this titled for the post and poll, because although the Optimus G is clearly superior to the Galaxy S III, we're still convinced that it won't sell as much as Samsung's device. We're not saying that the Galaxy S III doesn't deserve it, we're just saying that a significant part of its success has to do with Samsung's overwhelming market presence.
Trying to forget who Samsung and LG are, and solely focusing on the actual devices, which one are you more likely to pick up from the shelf?
1. bloodline posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:16 23 0
I prefer the spec and build of the LG but the software of Sammy.
If it was an LG optimus Nexus vs Galaxy Nexus III, I would most definitely pick LG
11. Mittal posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:51 9 1
THANK U PA for that thought
ive thought that out many times and wondered at the power of Marketing
I will prefer the optimisation on the S3 and i also like its UI. And the better update support from Sammy will seal the deal for me.
(but this choice here is a bit prejudiced as i have never held the G im my hands yet. That could change things)
16. Retro-touch posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:23 0 0
I think the G will be a great device, I'll wait for the Nexus devices announcement before making a decision whether to buy an S3 US version or the latest Nexus devices. The S4 sources being available and updated (fully working custom ROMS) makes the S3 a great buy, no to mention I like Touchwiz. I'll go with the next Nexus if they have a better camera (8MP or better) and a S4 pro dual or quad with at least 16GB and 2GB of RAM, those were my main issues with the Galaxy Nexus
36. ZEUS.the.thunder.god posted on 10 Oct 2012, 08:45 2 1
S3 for design and killer optimisation by Sammy
46. PhenomFaz posted on 10 Oct 2012, 11:35 2 0
totally agree! Its not only the hardware and spec sheet, almost every manufacturer will give you killer specs in their flagships, its actually about your experience with the phone which is largely governed by the software and UI. The UI of Sammy is great and Sammy has done a wonderful job in the optimizing its TouchWiz with Android not to forget adding more than a few great enhancements!
17. TylerGrunter posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:25 3 1
Sure, I voted the Samsung Galaxy SIII, but it's just about the bad name LG has with the software updates and the horrible UI.
Both get solved in a Nexus Device!
48. The_Innovation posted on 10 Oct 2012, 12:47 0 0
No, that's a prototype, you have to understand that. It'll have 16.
50. thunder18 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 14:01 1 0
I sincerely hope the talk of 8 and 16GB of memory in a Nexus device with no microSD slot are disinformation. Without a memory card, that would be ludicrous.
51. Berzerk000 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 14:17 0 0
Yeah, the device all of the leaks are based off of is a testing device. Not intended for consumer use, when the final product releases it'll most definitely have 16-32 GB storage, maybe an 8 GB option just for those that are price conscious.
55. The_Innovation posted on 10 Oct 2012, 15:11 0 0
Yea, but it won't have a SD card storage though. That we already know.
56. The_Innovation posted on 10 Oct 2012, 15:11 0 0
Won't have a SD :/
63. remixfa posted on 10 Oct 2012, 22:39 0 0
as long as it has at least 16 gigs of internal, I'm fine with that. The vast majority of users will never fill that.
67. moroninc posted on 11 Oct 2012, 05:06 0 0
As a nexus user 16GB is enough, extra storage is helpful but not a necessity.
54. The_Innovation posted on 10 Oct 2012, 15:09 0 0
Add a Nexus to that Optimus and you'll be happy ;)
64. jroc74 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 22:48 0 0
The LG phone just looks better to me. Based on looks alone I would pick LG.
71. Hlorri posted on 11 Oct 2012, 18:41 0 0
Without marketing, we would all be using the Nokia 808 PureView. :)
Oh... I mean without marketing OR pundits. Or Stephen Elop.
2. andro. posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:17 5 2
Galaxy s3 any day. I had several lg phones in the past and while they always seems to have some features ahead of the curve like the screen quality they always feel like a toy phone for some reason in actual design styling and ui icons. Granted you can use a customer launcher and icons for the menu and ui but the outside appearance cannot be changed
4. Fayeznoor posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:18 9 2
no way, its now about specs anymore. its all about software goodies. By far, Samsung Nature UX is the best Android Skin. and it has feature that no one can match. it has more unique selling points than any other phone in market...even many smartphones combined cant match features in Nature UX.
44. Jericho posted on 10 Oct 2012, 10:45 2 0
Yes,the optimus G can compete with the nature ux just go to youtube and watch phonearena's video review of LG Optimus 4X HD and check the mediaplex, quick memo etc and with optimus G now the optmius UI works in Landscape Too.
And Dude its personal preference Some like Nature UX Some Like Moto's New(and awesome,near to stock) UI. Some Like Xperia Ux, Some like Sense 4.0. So dude stop hatin.
5. phil2n posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:21 1 0
if the software is pure android, there's no way for s3 to win
6. bobfreking55 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:22 5 5
Weird that the Samsung Galaxy S III had a low score in the poll. I'll be frank, I kind of like the design of the Galaxy S III and the software really wins it. The Optimus UI now looks and would feel like the first Galaxy S' skin - very cartoon like. Asides that, Samsung phones feel better in the hand. I don't care if it has 2GB of RAM and a better processor because Samsung optimizes the hardware well.
61. someones4 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 19:17 0 0
Are you the bobfreking designing the concept phones? Anyway, i agree that s3 has a marginally better overall package.
7. terter posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:28 2 1
No, never. I’m still waiting for ICS on my Optimus 2x. Apparently LG waits for that update to become irrelevant. And the real problem is that the gingerbread has to many bugs to make any satisfaction. Very disappointed, will never buy a LG phone again.
43. Jericho posted on 10 Oct 2012, 10:37 0 3
Root it! Why wait? its easy.
OR maybe you your too chicken to try something NEW(like rooting).
49. CanYouSeeTheLight posted on 10 Oct 2012, 14:00 1 0
Research it! Why not? It's easy.
Or maybe you are too du.mb too research before talking about stuff you don't know, my Optimus 2X is rooted and on CM7, we can't have ICS because we don't have drivers, it's that simple, we do have ICS but without HWA and with a faulty camera that can't record videos.
8. tedkord posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:37 6 1
Be honest. LG will find some way to crap up the Optimus G.
9. kaliil10 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 03:42 3 8
you Guys don't disappoint samsung its the manufacturer who changed the world of smartphone.otherwise we would be Apple slaves.
13. rizevnarastek posted on 10 Oct 2012, 04:11 0 4
I fail to see One X(+) in the pool... why is that so?
14. serge327 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 04:40 1 1
if SONY get the high spec as LG optimus G, I will choose SONY, because of its nice design, nice user experience, Nice camera, sound and etc XD
18. OpTiMuS_BlAcK posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:25 0 0
LG optimus G, I love both the hardware and software. It's not as bad as some people here say.
34. joey_sfb posted on 10 Oct 2012, 08:25 1 0
True for now. But in 8 month time when google release Android 5, key lime pie would you still wish that you have own a Samsung or a LG?
Read both LG and Samsung Facebook user postings to decide.
I have both LG and Samsung phones, now i only wish i have bought Samsung and something else...
LG Optimus 3D is struck at gingerbread, a 2010 Android OS for a late 2011 phone.
40. OpTiMuS_BlAcK posted on 10 Oct 2012, 09:46 1 0
I am more drawn to hardware features than software, ROMs can provide the software needs while getting the good hardware isn't as easy as rooting a phone.
62. joey_sfb posted on 10 Oct 2012, 20:33 0 0
Thanks for bringing it up. Check xda site on the number of rom available for LG phone vs Samsung phone. LG phone are not widely support by the community, why?
1) lower user base
2) Custom API such as real3D make it impossible to port optimus 3d to higher android version such as ics or jellybean without lg inputs.
3) Custom chipset make roms lose functionaility compare to original lg rom.
Problem lie on LG mentaility. They only want to sell new phone and don want to support them. They have always been like that pre android days. When customer report a bug they keep mute and quietly launch a new series of phone in a few months time. I been that customer before just seem that a lepoard wouldn't loses its spots.
70. OpTiMuS_BlAcK posted on 11 Oct 2012, 16:42 0 0
Yes, what you said is true, but it can't apply to all LG phones, some get good support(including mine), while some don't get as much(as you said).
It's just a matter of preference and forethought, if you think a phone will be a hit, surely it will get a lot of support, if not, just don't get it. Some other manufacturers have also cancelled updates and nobody even rants but if it is LG, people say all the bad stuff.
Problems also lie on a customer's mentality bro. Have a good one :)
19. loken posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:36 1 2
I'd Choose Xperia V , It has everything! wateproofness , removeable batt , new technology ...etc
20. jan25 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:37 4 0
well let's see.. SIII has 1) non removable battery 2) expandable storage 3) a far more superior UI 4) better support 5) better design (subjective may be) VS Optimus G which is superior only for its chipset and the 13 mp camera that we haven't tested yet? /case closed
30. Retro-touch posted on 10 Oct 2012, 07:23 2 1
4)exynos chips are closed source, they only release kernel source but newer Android versions are always dependent on leaks from Samsung to get everything working right (or good enough),so not true, S2 doesn't have a properly working CM10 because of this issue so gotta wait for Sammy leaks. S3 does have more custom ROMS but it came out months ago
38. jan25 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 09:07 1 0
yeah i meant removable battery. as for support, i was referring to Samsung's updates. the S3 is among the first well known flagships to receive jellybean. i get what you are saying though that's why i am a big Nexus fan.
21. weinerslav posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:43 2 1
LG optimus G without marketing and with marketing, LG has always nice designs, they may not appeal to everybody but to me they do. I really don't like the SIII, only started considering it an option since I saw there is a brown version (I really hate the white and the blue doesn't do nothing for me)
23. lallolu posted on 10 Oct 2012, 05:55 5 1
Phonearena gets this wrong.
Most people will choose LG because the specs and desgin are wonderful but due to the bad user experience with their non-chalant attitude towards updating software, people including I will choose samsung.
It is not about Samsung's marketing, it is about customer's previous experience.
25. Anymal posted on 10 Oct 2012, 06:11 2 0
its pride and prejudice all over again, as everything in our lives ... for the f**k sake, please dont crap it up LG
26. xray174 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 06:15 2 0
this poll makes no sense the gs3 came out in june and the lg optimus now so basically the gs3 and older device still competing so why not make the poll galaxy note 2 vs lg optimus g or any newer device coming out
27. cocote177 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 07:08 0 1
Camera on the LG Optimus G (even if a 13 MP camera) sucks. Check a post on CNET that ressembles this fact.
29. Ragnarockd posted on 10 Oct 2012, 07:22 1 0
Sometimes its not all about specs but software optimization is a key factor and that's where Samsung triumphs. I have to say that touchwiz nature UX in sgs3 is better than sense,optimus or timescape.
31. champ_vl posted on 10 Oct 2012, 07:53 2 2
You can't forget who Samsung and LG is !! The ending of the article is a little silly. These brands are who they are because of their quality and success due to their performances and providing us with good phones. So, there's no surprise that Samsung sells better because their products are more durable, more advanced, have more feedback and support from XDA developers, have a lot more accessories designed for them and so on. I will always chose a Samsung phone over a LG phone (in the same range) for these reasons. They built their reputations around their products so that's why they are better. (oh and btw Samsung phones tend to hold on their high prices when sold as SH so that's a huge advantage for most of us smartphones addicts)
Samsung Galaxy S III the Winner !! No doubt.
33. Seymur posted on 10 Oct 2012, 08:23 1 0
Why manufacturers are so blind, their UI looks very bad.
I choose SGSIII.
35. shammont posted on 10 Oct 2012, 08:40 0 0
Sammy GSIII but it is hard to say. I have never held an Optimus in hand.
37. someones4 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 09:02 0 0
i still say Samsung. expandable micro sd card. obviously lg has superior specs but Samsung just....has it all i guess
41. pkiran1996 posted on 10 Oct 2012, 10:03 0 0
This is probably going to be thumbed down. The specs on the Optimus G are amazing, but the Optimus UI is just poor.