iPhone 4S vs Droid Bionic vs Galaxy S II vs Amaze 4G: camera comparison57
In another test to expand their prowess, we took shots of a neon clad Applebee's restaurant and the subtly more neutral tones of a Chase bank – all at night. Such images are rarely taken, but we gave them a try.
Paying attention to the macro shots of the seashell on the ground, we're astounded to find all handsets capturing plenty of luscious fine details. Luckily, we can definitively say that the HTC Amaze 4G is blessed with the best shot – thanks to its perfect balance of sharpness and exposure to profoundly showcase details. On top of that, colors appear to be the most saturated out of the bunch, which again manages to catch the attention of our eyes. Shining next to it, is the image captured by the Apple iPhone 4S, which easily pleases our eyes, but lacks the sharpness of the HTC Amaze 4G. Take a look at its colors though – an example of a color inaccuracy problem. The macro shots from the Motorola DROID BIONIC and Samsung Galaxy S II have softer details. Yet, they're arguably passable enough to still be considered better than average – especially when they're compared to some other high-caliber smart phones.
Ease of use and speed:
Without question, when it comes to the camera layout and functionality, the iPhone 4S is the epitome of simplicity at its finest. Sure, This comes at the price of having almost zero options with its camera application. Meanwhile, if it's manual controls and settings you're after, the HTC Amaze 4G is adorned with plenty of them – thanks to its deep controls, abundance of shooting modes, and fun options. In fact, for things like panoramic shots, it's such an easy feat to accomplish because of its intuitive and straightforward instructions. Then there are the Motorola DROID BIONIC and Samsung Galaxy S II, whch are far superior in terms of deeper options and settings then the iPhone 4S, but they still lack the refinements and intricacies found with the HTC Amaze 4G.
Of all the devices, it's painfully obvious that we truly despise the lengthy snapshot speed of the Motorola DROID BIONIC. Naturally, if you happen to have a lot of patience, it isn't much of a problem, but when you're trying to capture the moment, it's rather unnerving to find the handset taking the longest to snap a photo. Even after focusing in on the object for couple of seconds, it takes another 5 seconds to actually snap the photo and get us back to taking another one. By then, we can miss out on those opportunities to snatch some candid shots. Fortunately, it isn't as bad on the Samsung Galaxy S II, since it's fairly swift in shooting a photo and getting us right into another one. To show off their capacity to continuously shoot photos, both the iPhone 4S and HTC Amaze 4G are almost instantaneous with their shutter speeds – so yeah, there is a minimal amount of delay between each shot. Therefore, when it comes to capturing the moment, these two won't miss a beat – honestly!
Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ40 Sample Video:
Samsung Galaxy S II T-Mobile Sample Video:
Apple iPhone 4S Sample Video:
Motorola DROID BIONIC Sample Video:
HTC Amaze 4G Sample Video:
One year later, one year better. That's exactly what we find with this new class of smartphones, as they seemingly close the gap between them and dedicated point and shoots. Seriously, they can replace those once perceived mandatory gadgets – especially when they continue to excel. After meticulously looking over all the shots, we believe it is a tie between the iPhone 4S and the HTC Amaze 4G. They both have the best details, color accuracy and low light performance. They are also the snappiest.
Although it's not terrible by any means, the Motorola DROID BIONIC simply lacks the polished quality of its rivals. It's painfully slow to capture images as well.
One shouldn't choose a phone only because of its camera. That said, whichever you decide to go with, we can assure you that you can kick that traditional point and shoot to the curb, if you are not too picky about photo quality. However, we are looking forward to the moment when the high-end smartphones will really mimic the images of a stand-alone camera.
UPDATE: You can now read our One X vs Galaxy S II vs Nexus vs N8 vs iPhone 4S Camera Comparison!