Samsung Memoir Review
Samsung has tried to bring innovation with its TouchWiz UI, but at times it can be clunky and gimmicky. If used in the right way it can be useful; we preferred to keep the homescreen clutter-free and use the side bar much like you would the launcher in OS X. We have a feeling this isn’t exactly what Samsung had in mind, but when you start dragging widgets onto the homescreen there just isn’t enough room, and since most of them act simply as launchers themselves they’re not particularly useful. Some of the better ones are the Weather widget, which pulls info from The Weather Channel and the music player widget.
widgets are helpful on-screen, for instance if we are using it as a music player we would drag the music widget out during that time which allowed us to easily control playback. It was almost like being a little kid: when we were done playing with something we would put it away, dragging it back onto the launcher. Since the launcher itself could be hidden we were able to maximize screen real estate for wallpapers.
At the bottom of the screen are four static items: Phone, Phonebook, Web and Menu. These are fairly common items, but given that the phone can be launched simply by pressing the Talk button and Web is on the launcher by default we would have liked to see some customization options here as well. This is a relatively minor gripe, however.
The menu is pretty much what you would expect. There the user can tweak his settings, create a message, launch the web and music player or pull up the full list of applications. With the TouchWiz sidebar we couldn’t help but feel that a traditional menu was there just for the sake of tradition, as these items either are or could easily be incorporated within the launcher similar to how Android handles it.
One issue we had is that placement of the sidebar. On the left side of the screen, most users will have to reach their thumbs across the screen to access everything. This may seem minor, but when reaching across the screen then is partially obscured by your hand. It really feels as if this UI was set up for lefties, and we feel moving the bar to the right- or at least giving users the option- would feel more natural.
The phonebook on the Memoir is pretty great. It gives users plenty of options, and while the Memoir is not a smartphone the phonebook would suggest otherwise. First off, there are dedicated first and last name fields, something we’ve seen before but still very uncommon for dumbphones. It allows you to save a nickname for the user, mobile home, work and “etc” numbers along with other standards such as a custom ringer, caller ID picture, URL and up to 4 emails. It goes beyond this however, with spots for an AIM, ICQ (seriously, people still use this?), Windows Live and Yahoo Messenger names, birthday and anniversary dates, address field and last but not least notes. There is even a widget that pulls the birthday information, giving you the option to call or text the birthday boy right from the homescreen. To top it off, your phonebook is automatically backed up online (through T-Mobile) every time you make a change. Nuance handles voice dialing as well as ever. We like this phonebook!
calendar is also pretty darned good, allowing you to do most things as you would on a smartphone such as set recurring events and add locations. The big drawback is that there is no computer sync, which is key to a good calendar. Still, for users who don’t care about this the Memoir proves to be very smart. You’ll also find tasks- which can be sorted by priority, status and due date- and a simple memo pad. Other standards, like a calculator, world clock and converter are also present. All and all a very solid effort by Samsung on a media oriented device.
1. rtimi26 (Posts: 41; Member since: 16 Mar 2009)
hi i can see that good shot of easton town center and columbus state community college. I would like to meet up some day maybe we can discuss possible collaboration. email me if you are the administrator please.
2. luisandres58 (Posts: 20; Member since: 16 Mar 2009)
I don't know how you really rate but if you add and then divide the numbers you get a 7.8 rating. How can you give a 9.5 as a phone ( unless is a mistake)? As a camera I understand, but as phone in your review you killed it!
4. PhoneArena Team (Posts: 238; Member since: 27 Jun 2006)
Hey, please check our "How do we rate?" page.http://www.phonearena.com/html
s/howdowerate.phpAlthough it has its cons, this camera phone scores excellent in its class.
3. Charlie (unregistered)
No Wi-Fi = poop. End of story.
5. LessthanZach (Posts: 106; Member since: 29 Apr 2008)
"Unfortunately call quality was downright abysmal. Callers frequently had to ask us to repeat ourselves, and told us that this was the worst phone we’ve ever tested. " Rated 9.5 out of 10 by phonearena.com I can see the advertising campaign now...... This might have been a different story if the camera by itself was rated on a different website (i.e. dpreview.com). But on a phone web site when a phone is said to be "the worst phone we ever tested", it is safe to say that it does not deserve a 9.5 rating. Just my 2 cents.
6. Pr0cl1v1ty (Posts: 60; Member since: 26 Oct 2008)
lessthanzach you probably had a defective phone, were in a loud area, or your signal sucks because i have the phone and everyone says its BETTER than my iphones and never had one complaint
7. LessthanZach (Posts: 106; Member since: 29 Apr 2008)
I don't have this phone, Pr0cl1v1ty. I don't even have T-Mobile. What I made was a sarcastic remark that involved QUOTING phone arena's review. Notice the lovely QUOTATION marks which elegantly indicate my reference to the relevant article that we are discussing. If you would please take the time to read phonearena.com's review of this device, specifically the performance section, then return and re-comment it would be much appreciated. Thank you and have a nice day.