Samsung Galaxy S III vs HTC One X
0. phoneArena 16 May 2012, 08:15 posted on
The HTC One X was the first new-generation Android smartphone to come out this year. It introduced us to a new kind of Android experience – one powered by an ultra-fast quad-core processor. With the recent introduction of the Samsung Galaxy S III, though, things are going to get much more interesting. Take a deep breath, people, as what follows is the most epic Android clash for the first half of the year – the Samsung Galaxy S III is facing the HTC One X!...
This is a discussion for a review. To read the whole review, click here
118. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
So what? It has not done Apple any harm that one would notice! The HTC One X is a beauty, I do not need to remove the battery, it has a gorgeous premium feel and 32gb is plenty for my purposes, I have 5 movies on at present, tons of pics and a hell of a lot of my music plus 59 apps and still have 16gb free! Not sure what the criticism is about, the Galaxy Nexus had only 16gb of memory with no way of adding to it!
119. thelegend6657 (unregistered)
only no real multitasking on the OneX
But whatever i still like it more
88. AustinPaul (Posts: 25; Member since: 13 Dec 2011)
Last time I removed the battery? Last weekend, and the week before that, and the week before that...
Ask me how many times my panicked friends have looked for a charger for their iPhone when away from home? More times than I can count.
It happens with the best of them...
123. dhruba (Posts: 27; Member since: 18 Oct 2011)
well i will soon need to change the battery of my galaxy 551 cause I charged it very irregularly over 2 years and now it gives one day back up with moderate use. As I m out of warranty what would I do if I could not change the battery? Change the phone? You should be using Apple products then
149. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
say it again say it again aand few times more and you may believe it
86. wonderlandintw (Posts: 1; Member since: 17 May 2012)
well, S3 may be a good device.
but in some blog and phone forum, I found some performance testing is fake.
for example, photo test, the blogger use S3 to take photo in a sunny day, but use HTC one X in a cloudy day.
the picture exetremly shows S3 is better than HTC, but at the end of article, only a small place to identify that photo is taken in different time.
use this tricky, mean way................poor S3 fans or unfair testing wirter.
90. 1701nino (Posts: 228; Member since: 07 Dec 2010)
Hey Borat next time you make a review be sure to play fair!!! Alright because i think you were right on crapsung's side overhere.Htc makes phones faarr superior to crapsungs. Display is much more amazing on htc and the UI on crapsung is uuuuggglllyyy.
97. remixfa (Posts: 13902; Member since: 19 Dec 2008)
you know samsung makes the display for the oneX right? LOLOL
105. thelegend6657 (unregistered)
very true .
Samsung makes everything in-house
thats why their R and D is so high
158. SherlockHolmes (Posts: 125; Member since: 10 Apr 2012)
L.G. Makes the Display for ONE X !!
Still remains a Mothefuker Remixfa !!
150. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
that is you opinion and it is not true. Inspite of the RGB the amoled is superior and if you talk about the bad feeling in the hand of the one x then you didn't hold the s3, and not a word about the ugly energy hungry Sense UI.
100. sumit919 (Posts: 7; Member since: 10 Jan 2012)
Is it just me or u too think that PA is a bit harsh with the One X??
101. jackhammeR (Posts: 1548; Member since: 17 Oct 2011)
Why harsh. Everyone knows that Ray is an iphone lover but he just prefers samsung to htc.
That's his review and he has got rights to evaluate them.
He pointed the most important differences. And many revewiers after using S III claimed that when it comes to power and fluidity (final software execution ) SIII is just better.
Conslusion was extreme similar:
Appearance: ONE X
The rest: S III
It's like the first galaxy and desire.
Almost the same but different. Both of them have fans.
102. vtngmmk (Posts: 1; Member since: 18 May 2012)
In term of user experience, S3 win out One X. Battery test by GSMarena on S3 win double on Video play, 1hour plus more on web browsing and 10.5 hour talk time all fry down One X and some more S3 removable battery just continue the sing song with spare battery while One X plugging sucking juice. Some more One X web browsing so laggy consider super?
103. topbabas (banned) (Posts: 6; Member since: 15 May 2012)
My choise is HTC ...Design of Galaxy S3 is more girlish kindaaaa .....
112. greatGreekGeek (unregistered)
Samsung Galaxy S III: its not just a smartphone, its a genius phone.
151. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
i mean thumb up :D my fault S3 is the best
113. henrickrw (Posts: 403; Member since: 16 Sep 2011)
MEET THE BEAST GS3 IS IN COMPLETE COMMAND
114. b1acktiger (Posts: 203; Member since: 19 May 2012)
Congrats Ray.S !
He is really trying so hard to make Samsung stronger than HTC. In every dept. SGS3 wins ! Oh yEah.. In camera, Display with a Non-Pen tile, polycarbonate is a waste, Plastic is better. Now wat ? You better tell that i Love Galaxy S 3 ! Lol
116. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
Not sure there is any point in reading PA reviews as there seems to be a heavy bias in favour of certain manufacturers. The point of a professional reviewing an item is a degree of objectivity to inform readers about their potential choices! I own and use the IP4s, have owned the IP4, Sony Xperia S, SGS2 and both variants of the HTC Sensation/XE and none of those phones are a patch on the HTC One X in my humble opinion. Since acquiring my ONE X, I have sold my Xperia S,(sadly), IP4 and SGS 2. I am in no position to comment on the merits or de-merits of the SGS3 but to score the One x so low is truly a JOKE! The SGS3 may very well be better, I doubt it as other reviewers on other magazine find it too close to call but conclude it will be a matter of individual preference ultimately. On that note, I am sorry, but I cannot take PA reviewers or PA seriously. I want an unbiased opinion before I purchase my next handset, probably the Sony Mint, if it is quad core, and unbiased is something PA does not DO! Bye bye!!
132. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
did you play with both phones to say such things if you are not then don't say such things because s3 feels, looks and performs better. The only thing is that YES the RGB matrix of one x is better compared to the pentile, but there is almost no difference. Inspite of that the hd amoled is better and everything else is better.
120. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
Well, this review is "yawn" making!. The screen on the One X is generally rated as better by most sites who have reviewed both phones. In terms of the average user, I doubt any marginal perception that the S3 is better would make a single jot of difference so it will come down to aesthetics. There is nothing wrong with the One X, with reference to its alleged faults, that a software update can't fix! Two software updates have been released, possibly 3 depending on where you are.
There is a noticeable camera improvement since the second update and the performance and the pictures are superb. Personally, not being a "geek"/expert, the One x is blazingly fast and quad core is presumably more about future proofing the phones. In terms of my next handset, this is more likely to be the Sony Xperia Mint if it is quadcore than the SGS3 as the design/aesthetics are not enough to grab my attention and whatever perceived advantages it has over the One X, real or otherwise, are not enough to sway me. Personal preference exercised.
Finally, a review should never be about personal opinions but about objectivity and facts. Ray.S - your personal opinion does not qualify on that front.
133. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
there is no such thing as objectivity in smartphones area and your comment proves it. your opinion is that the one x is better OK mine is that the s3 is better. One x's display is actually a bit better because of the RGB and this is noticeable when you compare both side by side, inspite of that i prefer the amoled. In every other way the s3 is better.
154. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
That is the problem with people who get so defensive they don't even take the time to understand what they have read. My post does not suggest the One x is better than the S3, pay attention please as it clearly states that it is likely the S3 has better performance! I always get top end phones and I will probably end up with both, if I can't decide. By the way, I doubt anyone has played with the S3, apart from journalists since it has not been released yet.
For my part, all I want is someone to lay out the pros and cons of each so as to make an informed judgement, not some idiot journalist's opinion.
121. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
One last post - for those wanting to make up their own minds about whether to buy the One X - nsuggest you read Phonedog's review by Taylor.Link to the review below.
122. theniner (Posts: 2; Member since: 20 May 2012)
The Bias in this video is really, really bad. Literally everything, save the design, went in the Galaxy S III's favor. I'm not saying the Galaxy S III is a bad phone but I feel that he should have done a less biased video. The interface for one is something I feel HTC nails.
134. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
so why do you think that if you think that the video is biased everyone think this way. Where is the bias if you can tell if you didn't hold the both phones in your hands. Everything in the video is true. s3 feels better, looks better (the one x is really ugly), the photos are better and everyting is better if you prefer the sense ui that is your opinion
126. RORYREVOLUTION (Posts: 2927; Member since: 12 Jan 2010)
While the Exynos processor does play a very big part in making the SGS3's web browser the best there is. It also has to due with Touchwiz's browser. Even on lower end devices like the Exhibit 2 which ran Gingerbread Touchwiz's web browser, it was suprisely quick and responsive, even with flash on and that device only had a 1ghz processor with 512mb or RAM.
127. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
I suggest Ray.S takes a leaf out of Engadget's reviewers and would suggest if you want a honest opinion about these 2 beasts, then you go and take a read of it! On balance, it seems at best they seem to think it is about even but leaning to the One x as the best overall package. Conclusion below in quotes
"The worst thing about the GS III? No matter how hard it tries, it just isn't greater than the sum of the HTC One X's parts. That's not to say it falls short, but merely to emphasize that times have changed since last year's Galaxy S II, which landed on an unsuspecting world that was largely devoid of predators. The Snapdragon variant of the One X has similar computing power, battery life and photographic credibility, but it also has a much better user interface that sticks more closely to the guiding ethos of Android 4.0. The One X also has a more forward-looking physical design, while the GS III clings to the tried and true styles of old. Perhaps the biggest sacrifice you'd make by going for the One X over the GS III is the loss of the cheap storage offered by the microSD card. That's a painful thing to give up, but given how deeply we feel about the need for Android to move forward and not get stuck in a Gingerbread-flavored groundhog day, we might just take the hit".
No bias, just a thoroughly professional job. Oh, by the way, for those who love to make judgements on performance/benchmarks and such things, they both came out about even, however, the lesser spec'd One S shines brightly...make of that what you will. In a nutshell, the two best phones out there are the One X and SGS3, once released. THE CHOICE WILL BE DOWN TO PERSONAL PREFERENCE!
Enjoy/debate or whatever.
128. hung2900 (Posts: 769; Member since: 02 Mar 2012)
No bias? Have you read the comments below this article? Although that many of them were deleted, you can still see many complaints about the quality of this review. It ignored a ton of advantages belonged to S3 and with 21 times comparing S3 to some bias/subjective features of One X, can it be not bias?
Have you recognized a strange thing that engadget always tries to underestimate Galaxy S3 by using suck benchmark scores? At the first day that S3 releashed, they shew a linpack score that S3 had olny over 100 points in multi-thread (which actually is about 170) and now only 4400 points in Quadrant (which all oher reviews show more than 5300). They ignored the fact that Antutu, BrowserMark, GLBenchmark Offscreen, Smartbench and CFBench are more reliable than the things they focused like BS Nenamark/GLBenchmark Onscreen (Limited V-sync), Vellamo (Qualcomm product) and Linpack (40 years old benchmark tool).
And finally, why were comments complained about this article deleted? Have you seen these things on other websites?
129. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
That is exactly the point dude! I am not even going to speculate whether something from the article was deleted or not, there are plenty of complaints about PA or more accurately Ray S' "review"! The S3 may or may not be better and will probably sell loads more as it is the more popular Samsung brand.
An article or review is meant to be objective rather than subjective and bottom line, choice of phone is ultimately down to personal choice! By the way, I could not care less about BENCHMARKS, they are numbers on a paper, I doubt the average user on the street cares about them.
The reason iFruit sells so many handsets is not down to spectacular benchmarks but because they know about marketing and make aesthetically pleasing products. Most will go with one of these two, undoubtedly the best phones on the market, based on the same principles and not because they will ask the shop keeper about benchmarks. You will be aware that GSMArena also felt it would be about personal choice when they compared the two!
152. hung2900 (Posts: 769; Member since: 02 Mar 2012)
I totally agree, everything you said is correct (in my opinion). The only point I mention here is the quality of Engadget's review abt S3. I don't care much abt the review of PA or Ray S, just like the entertainment ( although i think this review is better than others before, especially the reviews of Iphone)
135. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
you just can't say that the sense ui is better. For you is better for me it is NOT. I don't like the shiny pictures of the sense and it annoys me. This is personal preference and this is not a "BIAS". And s3's hardware is better. In the quote is said "The Snapdragon variant of the One X has similar computing power, battery life and photographic credibility" NOT BETTER BUT SIMILAR which means s3 is the best for now
130. nthnbrckn (Posts: 3; Member since: 27 May 2012)
the reviewer is an idiot or a paid reviewer...... the reviewer job is to clarify the differences between two phones n let him choose what he wants in his phone what he dont
and he said market browsers work below par on HTC one x..... this idiot hasn't tried anything..... i have downloaded opera and chrome n dey both work silky smooth and opera works like a dream.... pinch to zoom double tap, never crashes even if I open 20 tabs.....
n he said Samsung screen is better....well htc has better pixel density..... it's using rgb instead of pentile...... produces more natural color in contrast to amoled screens.....
htc looks much better any day..... s3 does feel premium at all
htc has 4 + 1 chip....... which addresses battery issues.... i must say htc has done a huge improvement in providing more juice...... Samsung lacks it
Samsung has provided some nifty features lyk smart say...... v ol know tht it will use the front camera.... c'mon its gona use so much juice n i bet 90 % of ppl won't gona use whn u can simply touch the screen......
plus htc comes with beat..... earlier I had s2 n used philips headphones..... the sound was average but with htc one x.... its so clear.... it might not v the loudest bt the sound clarity is unbelievable
htc sense has always been better than Samsung crap touch wiz...... highly customisable n much much visually appealing..... touch Wiz is so ugly.....
yeah it does nt have memory card but 9 out f 10 ppl dun need it whn u hav 32 gb f storage on board...
n i rally dun understand how the f**king hell u use htc one x..... my phone has never crashed so far n it has been a month n i use it very heavily.... N lastly yeah I was disappointed by htc keyboard... so I downloaded swift key.... its the best keyboard I hav ever used....... still I think htc did a much better job in keyboard rather then providing ics stock keyboard d way Samsung did....... n htc swype keyboard I used sumtym in night whn I dun wish to use my both hands n. It works perfectly... so I would say htc keyboard is better...... though it shd be personal preference..........
both phones has pro and cons.... U shd not tell wat dey shd go for and not...... U jst bring out the differences n ppl decide what dey want out frm Their phone.......
GS3 MIGHT BE A BETTER PHONE THOUGH BUT HTC ONE X ISNT BAD THE WAY U HAD DESCRIBED...... INFACT IT'S NECK TO NECK....... ONE THING'S FOR SURE U WILL NEVER BE DISAPPOINTED HAVING ONE X..... I DINT NEITHER DID MY COUPLE OF FRENS..... V LOVE OUR HTC ONE X!
136. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
first of all both chrome and opera aren't as good as s3's stock browser. Second the RGB is better but overall the s3 display is better and that is what he said. Third the colors of the amoled are prettier. Fouth one x is very ugly and it doesn't look better and it even doesn't feel better. Fifth the battery life IS better on the S3. The fifth core of the tegra doesn't make huge difference. Sixth - Smart Stay isn't turned on all the time and the front facing camera isn't so power hungry. Seventh even the one x is beats audio branded it doesn't mean it comes with beats earphones (actually it doesn't comes). Eighth the audio quallity of s3 is better in the earpeace and through the earphones. Ninth Sense UI isn't better for me. For you may be but not for me so this is personal choice. Tenth - if you repeat enough times to you that lacking a SD card slot is not a big deal maybe you will believe it. the keyboard is also personal choice but on s3 IS better and writing is easier. Both phones are great and if I had a chance to own them I will never regret that but I personally prefer S3.
131. Dark4o90 (Posts: 205; Member since: 20 Feb 2011)
the display of s3 looks pixelized in some moments. if you compare s3 xperia s and one x the displays of the xperia and one x look better in pixel density although i saw the white s3 aaand it looks reaaaally really amazing and actually feels better in the hand than the one x. I can say even that one x is really ugly and the rear bump for the camera is awfull. When you put the phone on the table it stays on that bump and i think that the camera will be scratched a lot
153. nthnbrckn (Posts: 3; Member since: 27 May 2012)
that wht I really meant...... its a matter of personal preference........ n well I dun keep saying tht 32 gb is more than enough..... its really more than enough...... n i hadn't seen s3 stock browser but it's way better than s2 Web browser...... n i m nt a gr8 fan of stock browser n keyboards.... dey dun seem to address the bugs n r slow..... yeah it does nt come with beats headphones.... but it has a chip n software installed on phone..... n we can upgrade to it any tym. n i used a simple headphones n the difference can be easily experienced.... Samsung touch wiz is crap n had always had been.... color of amoled are unnatural..... i had used s2 over a year n when I switched to one x I really loved the sober and elegant natural colors produced on one x...... now I swear I will never switch to amoled screens.... they produce over the top unnatural colors.....
so u c its a choice of personal preference...... both are gr8 phones...... for me s3 looks lyk a Chinese phone..... its ugly to the core.... the flagship device should never look lyk dis...... compare I phone, Sony experia and obviously htc......... it does nt feel premium and luxurious lyk d one x for sure...... n it shd also be a matter of personal preference......
what really meant tht the reviewer shd bring you the best of each phone Warning to all girls:
If you don't treat your bf well, someone else will !
Never criticize ur bf's faults. Remember it may have been these little imperfections that stopped him from getting a better girl.
:-P :-D n leave it to d ppl to decide..... he surely is nt doing tht.... htc one is nt tht bad phone the way he had described.... n d points given is a testimony f that.......
155. nthnbrckn (Posts: 3; Member since: 27 May 2012)
n its a well known fact that rgb is better than pentile...... n htc has higher pixel density n produces natural color....... so how the hell Samsung screen better?????
162. jackhammeR (Posts: 1548; Member since: 17 Oct 2011)
hts one x camera suxx...look how laggy it is when you're moving your phone trying to focus on sth...dropping frames and sloooooooowmotion
164. gwuhua1984 (Posts: 1237; Member since: 06 Mar 2012)
I didnt have the problem, whether it was straight from the box on stock Rom or custom rom. the video recording was great with no frames dropped and steady fps. Unless you actually handled a non faulty one x, you shouldnt be going around saying it sucked.
163. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
Just bought the S3...I've got OCD and like to have the latest gadget! Having used both, in day to day use, it really does come down to personal preference. Sense 4.0 makes a big difference and is pulling me to favour the One X! Also the attention to detail and available options when customising the home screen with widgets, in respect of which the One X offers more attractive options. The S3 does feel a tad smoother on certain functions and the keyboard is a dream. Can't say I have noticed the pentile issue but then again, I am not all that savvy on the tech front nor particularly inclined to be interested. Also not about to stare at the screen until I notice!
Bottom line, I love both handsets and my iP4 has been relegated to the drawer and houses my pay as you go SIM so will see the light of day occasionally but not all that often.
165. bstringy (Posts: 1; Member since: 07 Jun 2012)
What would be really great in the photo comparisons, if both shots from each camera were displayed side by side as a single image. Or better yet, display one photo that changes to the other upon mouse-over. Otherwise, it's really hard to compare shots here the way the windows are drawn even with the cumbersome magnifying glass.
166. rowlin (Posts: 2; Member since: 14 Jun 2012)
So the S3 doesn't re-flow the text to fit so you have to constantly scroll back and forth to read a web page, and that's a better browser than the One X that automatically fits the text? Sounds like a very biased review, not really believable.
167. SunMa_ (Posts: 7; Member since: 01 Mar 2012)
Oh.cmon Phone Arena!It is very clear that you favorize S3 more than HTC.Yes in some ways S3 is more practical but One X has also advantages over S3.In the past i was Samsung boy (i had Note,S2,S1).This is my first time with HTC (One X) and i love this phone.I see S3 every day and i have no desire for getting one.They are both powerhouses and bye the way-HTC One X takes better pictures than Galaxy S3!
169. sniper1087 (Posts: 331; Member since: 31 Dec 2011)
not even closed i had the s2 and tested the one s and one x camera and the s2 has a way better camera and the s3 is even better.
168. SunMa_ (Posts: 7; Member since: 01 Mar 2012)
I have no lags or other issues you mentioned!Samsung is becoming another Apple like-but people out there must realize that HTC One X is good as S3!
170. chocolaking (Posts: 428; Member since: 22 May 2012)
Samsung Galaxy S3 battery light on fire.
I guess the battery is too big or too powerful. lol
Good thing I did not buy a S3, but I love my One X
171. SunMa_ (Posts: 7; Member since: 01 Mar 2012)
I was also choosing between S3 and One X and i LOVE My One X!!
173. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
Having lived with the LG Optimus 4X HD for a week now, I think I am going to have to say goodbye. This is not that the phone isn't all its cracked up to be but it does not, simply, offer me any more than my S3 or One X! Will sell to Cex as soon as I am able, given it is not out in England yet and this being one bought from Amazon.de, so it is not on their website yet! The S3 is probably the best phone of all 3 but the gimmicky stuff does not elevate it above the One X in everyday use. The One X gets my vote as you simply cannot beat the Sense 4.0 experience!
174. ricky0702 (Posts: 11; Member since: 09 Jul 2012)
I'd select the Samsung GSIII since it has a removable battery and expandable memory.the Galaxy S III camera is definitely the superior camera. Many people who've had extensive time with comparison of the One X and Galaxy S III have agreed Galaxy S III better than the One X camera in terms of overall quality. I heard that Galaxy S III and iPhone 4S used the same 8M pixel image senor from Sony.
175. TMach (Posts: 348; Member since: 29 Dec 2011)
Sold the 4X at a loss....ouch! As for the S3 and One X, the One X gets my vote and to suggest the S3's camera is better is neither here nor there as I don't find that to be the case. The user experience overall, build quality, Sense 4 makes it the One X all the way.