Samsung GALAXY Note Review
0. phoneArena posted on 02 Nov 2011, 10:17
Have you ever wondered how big could phone screens get? Of course, we're talking about the Samsung Galaxy Note. This beast of a phone actually carries a 5.3” display – the biggest you can find on a device, marketed as a “phone”. We can already see the debate over whether the Galaxy Note should be considered a giant phone or a mini-tablet...
This is a discussion for a review. To read the whole review, click here
1. Eingild posted on 02 Nov 2011, 12:00 35
A 7? Seriously? This tablet/phone hybrid is a beast.
28. shayan posted on 02 Nov 2011, 16:55 5
and galaxy note is the top phone right now in gsmarena.com user ratings...
30. xtremesv posted on 02 Nov 2011, 17:47 3
Yeah true but none of them has had it in their hands. That's the only credit I can give to this review but everything else is totally out of place. They should have reviewed the Note as the niche device it is, not as a normal smartphone or an iPhone 4S wannabe.
29. buggerrer posted on 02 Nov 2011, 17:05 16
who is Ray S. anyway to review such great device and give it 7/10 !
33. xoatomxo posted on 02 Nov 2011, 18:29 5
I want this phone and cant wait until this phone launches in America. What other phones did Ray S. reviewed anyway. I am very curious.
55. HTCiscool posted on 03 Nov 2011, 07:08 7
What every1 is ignoring is the price, I would rather have an iPad 2 32GB than this thing. It's too small to be a tab and too big to be a phone, its very expensive, it sucks at being a phone, and it doesn't have the size advantage of a tablet.
60. xtremesv posted on 03 Nov 2011, 11:23 13
You said it right, YOU don't want it. The Note is a niche product not meant for everyone. It's a concept phone.
90. mills0806 posted on 13 Nov 2011, 13:08 1
I know seriously just buy a galaxy tab if you want to take notes or whatever. Then when you want to use a phone, just use your smartphone.Not that hard to sync data between your tablet,and whatever devices you use.
68. tmcr7 posted on 03 Nov 2011, 23:38 5
Looking at his video, he hasn't even shown why typing on the Note is poor because of the big screen. It really doesn't make sense. But in this video,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AKk9RZLmoBw
The reviewer clearly demonstrated how thumb-typing on the Galaxy Note is very, very easy. He can also easily touch the keys in the middle of the keyboard without any problems.
And the video also showed how the browsing experience is significantly better, just by holding the device in a landscape position.
2. hunted posted on 02 Nov 2011, 12:08 1
Does this mean no use in buying this phone? The mark says SII is better
3. AppleSux (banned) posted on 02 Nov 2011, 12:26 21
well, i have read the other reviews, where they say that the call quality, and speaker performance are awesome, n very impressive, even engadget (which is considered pro-apple) talked abt the impressive call quality, and speaker performance of the Galaxy Note. either iPhonearena is totally biased (which it is most of the time), or they have got a faulty unit. one other thing, when phonearena talks about the battery life, they just mention the manufacture's stats, but they should mention the battery life according to their own experience and usage and their own special battery tests. simply quoting the official stats cant be cosidered a good review. dont trust phonearena reviews ever. techradar and gsmarena reviews are way better and comprehensive.
6. Mazhh (banned) posted on 02 Nov 2011, 12:49 14
Ray S is on apple's payroll.. !!! phonearena sucks !!!
13. Vinopantoz posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:34 18
They are not phonearena..they are iPhonearena...
63. bucky posted on 03 Nov 2011, 16:09 2
or maybe you cant handle the truth
8. leftheodo posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:01 16
If it's not Apple it's not good enough, right? This is getting annoying and iDiotic!
10. snowgator posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:29 10
That's just crap. They rated the $99.00 Atrix 2 a 9, ahead of the iPhone 4S. They ooze all over themselves over the Samsung Galaxy 2 series. Let it go- they just didn't like this guy.
27. xtremesv posted on 02 Nov 2011, 16:38 11
Actually, no. PhoneArena clearly stated on their iPhone 4S review: "Right now, we believe the Apple iPhone 4S is deserving a rating of 9/10, when we consider its overall quality, features and price (...)".
That sounds to me like “we desperately want to give a 10 (overall quality?) to the iPhone 4S but we cannot because we would lose our credibility as reviewers”.
Someone commented that if the Note had an Apple logo on its back then it would have got a 10. Perhaps he is right after all.
I think PhoneArena should disclaim what phones they personally own.
9. ph00ny posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:02 14
Shouldn't there be at least a whole page or two dedicated to all the functionalities tied to the stylus (S-pen)? Isn't that point of this device?
11. snowgator posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:30 3
Totally agree. Maybe if it does come stateside, they will.
12. snowgator posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:32 7
Told my Wife about this beast, and she drooled all over herself. She WANTS a tablet/smartphone hybrid, and I would jump all over an unlocked version of this as a Christmas surprise for her. Here is hoping I get that shot....
14. snowgator posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:38 1
Also notice they mentioned the HTC Sensation at 4.7" as an alternative, but not the 4.7" HTC Titan, the Windows Phone. I can understand it as this is an Android Tablet... er, phone.. um - whatever. I just had to throw it out there!!
15. saiki4116 posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:39 3
they have released in india today for 35k which translates to ~700$
16. Sjael posted on 02 Nov 2011, 13:50 7
The stylus on the Note is NOT capacitive. It uses electromagnetic resonance. EMR blows away capacitive styli for accuracy and features.
17. anirudhshirsat97 posted on 02 Nov 2011, 14:03 5
It costs 35k in india and knowing samsung trends,it will fall to 30-32k in a few months...for 30-32...theres nothing better..
103. Jshrd posted on 02 Jan 2012, 05:27 1
Are you insane or what...? Seems like Paki to me lol.. FYI...I am from US and have no problem with India...
18. Muhannad posted on 02 Nov 2011, 14:15 11
Very under-rated score, they should seriously have someone better to review it.
19. redmd posted on 02 Nov 2011, 14:28 9
totally biased review.
you did not put the awesome screen quality and resolution as pros. but after seeing your preview, I was kinda expecting this.
Now why is typing messages and emails on a large screen too much of a hassle? Please do your job right. Some trolls here make more sense than this review.
I'll be waiting for gsmarena's take on the note.
20. 10aera posted on 02 Nov 2011, 14:57 13
Ha, ha... Put an apple logo on the back of the Note and it will get a 10 in the review!
21. RORYREVOLUTION posted on 02 Nov 2011, 15:14 13
"Our opinion is not affected by any relationships we may have with phone manufacturers, carriers, developers or any other party." Lol really Ray S? Or should I say Ray 4S?
22. Commentator posted on 02 Nov 2011, 15:15 7
Why do you list "screen size" as a pro, and then list it as a con because "it only brings marginal improvements in certain areas"? Even if they're only marginal improvements, shouldn't it still be a pro?
23. mctcm posted on 02 Nov 2011, 15:47 10
Someone fire this reviewer and get someone who can objectively examine & review mobile hardware. What a joke
31. JGuinan007 posted on 02 Nov 2011, 17:53 8
Seriously poor review I should remember not to read anything by Ray S.
34. itsius1 posted on 02 Nov 2011, 18:40 3
hold one ray, why are you beeing so negative as giving a 7 where all i see is just a measily 3 page review, and those 3 pages arent exactly what i called a in depth review. the main part of this phone is the pen, where i dont see an in depth part about in... i think PA should just stop with the preview and just stick with a single full review so that there is no excuse to skip a full indepth length video...
35. weishin92 posted on 02 Nov 2011, 19:03 3
Initially when pa posted this it was only 6, then they changed it to 7.
36. redmd posted on 02 Nov 2011, 19:48 7
Just for the lol, Ray 4S got girly little hands, hated the fact that the 5.3-inch screen is the exact opposite of his beloved 3.5-inch 4S.
37. unspec1fied posted on 02 Nov 2011, 20:07 2
I have huge hands. If I don't get a 9900, I'd get this simply because text/email is a chore for hands that can palm a basketball or small child's head.
38. tmcr7 posted on 02 Nov 2011, 20:30 7
Hi Ray S. Your review is certainly not agreeable. Why did you say that typing on the Galaxy Note is poor due to its large screen? Common sense dictates that thumb typing on a bigger screen is easier. The keys are just bigger as compared to an iPhone which has a smaller screen, and therefore, the keys are cramped up.
39. andulas posted on 02 Nov 2011, 22:34 4
i actually got it and it I recommend! Everything about it is FLAWLESS except for the voice which is not the best but its more than enough to get by. I'm in high school in the states and about 5'4 but texting is awesome on the phone even though i'm pretty small especially in portrait. Its AMAZING!!!
92. RamyAbdelbadea posted on 19 Nov 2011, 13:40 0
So Please Come On Give US more information about this phone .. The screen, How do carry it ?? Cause this review is ... ( let us say Incomplete )
40. ngo2dd posted on 02 Nov 2011, 23:47 3
Wow, people because you feel that this product should a higher score don't mean that you are right and he is wrong. Have any of you use the phone before? Okay then STFU and phone arena being biased. It is funny because all the top of the line Android phone been rated around a 9 or how are they being biased? And for call quality it base on a group test not the one reviewer. You people need to read the review first.
42. Retro-touch posted on 03 Nov 2011, 00:37 5
Giving a 7 is downright biased. Comparing the specs and performance of the galaxy note to those high end should give you a clear indication that it deserves a similar score.It provides the same package as the S2 in a larger package,faster stock processor plus stylus in tow. Just cause the reviewer couldn't understand how it would be successful and is at best a niche product. All his opinions btw, his analysis doesn't represent reality as everyone in the iPhoneArena office could agree with him but ultimately its success will depend on consumers and 99% of them don't come to phone arena.The small minority that decide to research before buying might have their opinions swayed by this crappy review.
Great device, challenging the boundaries between smartphone and tablet that provides great performance and good (acceptable) call quality,deserves and 8 or 8.5
47. tmcr7 posted on 03 Nov 2011, 03:47 1
@ngo2dd, Are you blind? The guy on top of you just answered your question with a resounding YES, so shut up!
41. tmcr7 posted on 03 Nov 2011, 00:36 1
Are you blind? The guy on top of you just answered your question with a resounding YES, so shut up!
93. RamyAbdelbadea posted on 19 Nov 2011, 15:42 0
yeah that is right .. all the guys who have this phone tell how it is so awesome .. i Know someone had some problem with the phone but still can't Give up that phone !!
43. Mozarrt posted on 03 Nov 2011, 01:13 4
People getting all worked up because their precious Android only got a 7. I thought the review was okay.
56. HTCiscool posted on 03 Nov 2011, 07:10 2
You my friend are one of the few people here with a brain.
50. AngusNG12345 posted on 03 Nov 2011, 04:21 0
lol it dosent work for me too.
"Your post contains banned words. If you believe this is due to a mistake, please email us, copying your whole post. Thank you."
51. longhairbilly posted on 03 Nov 2011, 06:37 2
Please bring this to the United States Samsung.
52. HTCiscool posted on 03 Nov 2011, 06:56 2
Hmmmm, if you are interested in this then you are one of two people,
1. Those who should get a GSll or other 4"-5" phone
2. Those who should get a galaxy tab 7.7
And could they have not been a little more original with the design?
I think Mr. S makes a point, you're paying little under $850 for this beast, if i I were making that investment, I'd be wanting something a lot bigger such as an iPad2 or a 13-inch notebook.
Hell! for that price you can get a good ultraportable let alone a small tablet.
57. HTCiscool posted on 03 Nov 2011, 07:13 2
It's funny how a lot of the commentors think they will die if the Galaxy Note didn't get a good score.
-
Samsung Galaxy Ring
-
HTC Desire 200
-
Huawei Ascend P6
-
Samsung Galaxy S4 Zoom
-
Samsung GALAXY Ace 3
-
ZTE Vital
-
Nokia EOS
-
LG Optimus L4 II
-
Samsung Galaxy S4 vs Samsung Galaxy Note II
-
Samsung Galaxy S4 Review
-
Samsung Galaxy S4 vs HTC One
-
Camera comparison: Samsung Galaxy S4 vs HTC One, Sony Xperia Z, iPhone 5, Nokia Lumia 920 and Galaxy S III
-
Screen Comparison: Galaxy S4 vs iPhone 5 vs Xperia Z vs One vs Galaxy S III vs Lumia 920
