HTC Windows Phone 8X vs Apple iPhone 5
0. phoneArena 09 Nov 2012, 02:53 posted on
Now that Windows Phone 8 is finally here, we guess some users (not many, but some) will think about purchasing a WP8 handset. So, here we are, bringing you in-depth comparisons between the leading WP8 handsets and the iPhone, as well as the major Android handsets. In this article, we'll take a look at how the HTC Windows Phone 8X stacks up against the iPhone 5. Both devices are pretty popular right now, so it will surely be interesting to see who's going to come out on top once we're done with them...
This is a discussion for a review. To read the whole review, click here
1. darkskoliro (Posts: 953; Member since: 07 May 2012)
and now there can only be one winner. PhoneArena i dont get your smackdowns, they just arent consistent.
7. MeoCao (unregistered)
I have not read the article yet, is it another draw?
9. neutralguy (Posts: 1152; Member since: 30 Apr 2012)
no, there's a clear winner. Just read the first page and you'll know which one, and it's not an HTC.
30. darkskoliro (Posts: 953; Member since: 07 May 2012)
ill be damned the day HTC wins ONE smackdown. Just one. But some reason I dont think Ill live to tell the tale..
15. B3BLW29 (Posts: 237; Member since: 02 Mar 2012)
Can iPhoneArea get any more biased, I mean Author did't say anything about the purple tint in Iphone 5 camera samples, Maps Duh!. They dont have battery figures for HTC but the author sure knows Iphone's RAM is better than HTC although both have 1GB on board, may I ask how??
Phonearena is running on Apple money confirmed.. Ray...Sir! you are dumb.
20. shandesilva (Posts: 73; Member since: 28 Mar 2012)
arent you guys at phonearena damned ashamed of yourselves?....how could you lead a normal life after writing such biased s**t & after reading the comments...or are you guys so dumb assholes as not to realise what you are writing? or are you a subsidiary of apple?
if not for the community of readers who give valuable feedback i would have stopped reading this icrap site long ago.
29. amircajlani (Posts: 5; Member since: 24 Feb 2012)
damn man...i was about to say exactly the same thing...hhaha.. yea dude ...ur completely right...this article is so baseless...sadly seems phonearena got sold to a new owner...thats apple...too sad
36. hectoprotecto (Posts: 1; Member since: 10 Nov 2012)
AMEN to this post and all the replies to it. Super bias smackdown, especially clear when they review the interface. smh, disappointing
49. loyals (Posts: 129; Member since: 10 Nov 2012)
RAM .... the actual spec r not out but ....u can say iphone ram is like ddr3 and 8x ram is like ddr2....i mean to say clockspeed is different so does the perfomance . see benchmarks bros
22. -box- (Posts: 3749; Member since: 04 Jan 2012)
With Ray S reviewing, of COURSE the apple device will win. He could find a way to make an iphone that's been smashed to pieces win against anything. Heck, you could put an apple logo on a rock and he'd hail it as the most amazing magical thing in the world and say it had premium natural design and a great solid feel to it and perfect weight.
Anyone else for Ray S NOT doing any more reviews until his bias is eradicated?
31. PhoneArenaUser (Posts: 5471; Member since: 05 Aug 2011)
PhoneArena.com, is there any reason to compare every phone with iPhone? In my opinion it clearly shows that iPhone for PhoneArena.com is an etalon...
2. AnTuTu (Posts: 676; Member since: 14 Oct 2012)
Just imagine if HTC would have introduced the same phone with end to end display, this phone would have beaten the hell out of iPhone 5. I think those bezels on HTC are too thick.
But still front of HTC 8X, iPhone 5 falls by the way side :)
3. tiara6918 (Posts: 1353; Member since: 26 Apr 2012)
"If we have to factor in their physical designs, there can be no argument at all, as there can be only one winner, and it's not an HTC." Really? Does apple have the color Blue,Red and Yellow for their iPhone?
4. lsguntu (Posts: 67; Member since: 06 Aug 2012)
Very nice review. Whoever did the review.. do you eat food or is**t?
5. neutralguy (Posts: 1152; Member since: 30 Apr 2012)
i really want to read it, but the first page was really like an advertisement written by an apple inc employee. Sorry, that's just my own honest opinion.
16. sadaivadai (Posts: 156; Member since: 22 Nov 2011)
"it's undeniable that the iPhone 5 is a work of art that no mass-produced phone on the market can currently rival"
After reading this line i stopped reading the review ..
I think Apple iphones are his s*x partners .. Don't ask me how !! thats why he loves them so much ..
42. webOSlove (unregistered)
I couldn't agree more. The LG Nexus 4 is much prettier than the 2010 inspired design of the iPhone 5. I rarely read the iPhone comparisons on here because Phone Arena seems to put Apple on some sort of pedestal, when iProducts are just repetitive boring products, and nothing about then catches anybody 's attention anymore.
6. gabe92 (Posts: 27; Member since: 25 Oct 2012)
IPhone 5 is a fkn over rated ass piece of crap
8. CX3NT3_713 (Posts: 1676; Member since: 18 Apr 2011)
Smh,,, iphone 4/4s/5 are overrated.. lets see how the lumia 920 does, against ifone
23. -box- (Posts: 3749; Member since: 04 Jan 2012)
Depends on the reviewer. I'd be willing to trust Michael H's review, but not Ray S or John V. As long as they don't constantly complain about the slight weight issue (and most honest reviewers who use the phone for a few days or don't hold something else to compare it to state they don't really notice it much) and give it a fair evaluation, I think that'll be satisfactory. More SlashGear, less gizmodo.
10. JamesHunt (Posts: 37; Member since: 01 Oct 2012)
Still phonearena should underline the negatives of the Iphone , and not just shrug it off by declaring it irrelevent. Iphone is not God's own creation,so it also has its flaws.
11. mydi.maus (unregistered)
i guess both won,cuase i like them both..
12. Ueliton (Posts: 34; Member since: 29 Aug 2012)
This Ray S is the WORST reviewer PA has. Seriously, this guy is ridiculous. I fell ashamed after reading such article.
21. shandesilva (Posts: 73; Member since: 28 Mar 2012)
i second that...there is no such biased, dumb, ball less writer in internet!
38. oldhamletman (Posts: 35; Member since: 03 Sep 2011)
screen: the iphone5 is still 15%-35% smaller in screen area even though users have been buying large screen phones in droves.... winner windows
case: with iphones light metal and glass and the HTC and Nokia phones with their high impact polycarbonate cases will endure being dropped many times while the iphone needs glass or case repair everytime... winner windows
weight: while I didn't notice the weight of windows phones in use... it doesn't matter as you need to buy a 50-80g case to protect your fragile iphone 5 in use, making it heavier than both the HTX 8x and the Nokia 920 which don't need bumpers / cases... winner windows
browser: IE10 on WP has been embarrassing safari with consistently better performance scores, 3rd party browsers and apps, has had full html5 compliance for years, and has unique features like session and video streaming sharing on your home xbox using Smartglass.. winner windows
OS: while apple stays mired in the past with non informational icons and lack of screen customization available with WP, beginning with windows 8, now users can have a completely unified desktop from phone to tablet / surface to PC... Apple is 5 years behind on usability
verdict: WP is easy to use and brings social integration to a very high level... skydrive / hotmail allow you to take EVERYTHING with you at all times on all devices...and WP allows you intuitive simplistic use that iphone is nowhere near being able to offer.... windows phone continues to embarrass iphone with no end in sight.... and the Lumia 920 32GB is $99 and the Iphone 5 32GB is $299 and the HTC 8X with 16GB is $199..... $100 - $200 apple tax to use IOS on a phone that breaks if I drop it.?...
13. jackhammeR (Posts: 1548; Member since: 17 Oct 2011)
IOS looks way to inferior to Win 8. So so 2010.
Guys from Cupertino should implement two modes. One for those who wants pure simplicity and the second one, for those who would like to dig slightly deeper.
I believe Windows will become a new standard how simplicity should look like not forgeting about eye-candy factor.
Saying that Iphone 6 is the best looking or crafted device is on a baby side.
Lumia 800 or 900 looks much much better. Smooth, plain design, yet not dull. Not to even mention fragility of cupertino's device. But that's only my opinion.
Every single comparison iphone vs the rest of the world is the same. The are either equal or apple is a bit better which is mentioned at the end of each page. Silly.
14. JamesHunt (Posts: 37; Member since: 01 Oct 2012)
Also wp8 with black background and more vibrant colour would put IOS 6 to shame...thats why they used a lot lesser appealing colour combination.
17. Heatfan316 (Posts: 362; Member since: 21 Aug 2011)
Ray S. as far as I'm concerned you have no credibility as a phone reviewer, I've seen both screens side by side and the HTC 8x has more natural colors iPhone 5 has washed out colors the 8x has a brighter screen and is more visible in direct sunlight I'm calling you a liar and biased reviewer!
24. darkkjedii (Posts: 10505; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
The iPhone 5 isn't the slouch that some try to say it is.
26. brandonrana (Posts: 57; Member since: 04 Nov 2012)
Who is this dum8 reviewer? I think i have 100000000 times better knowledge about these 2 phones then him. But i won't work for iphonearena!
27. oldhamletman (Posts: 35; Member since: 03 Sep 2011)
This review was largely biased toward apple..... worse, the reviewer didn't know basic features of WP8 ... he made assumptions about IE, third party browser integration, and a bunch of other things that are wrong....
- he played down the difference in screen size between 4 and 4.3 .... when you use them it's a major difference in usability... 13% larger surface area... line up both phones bottom screen edges and youll see what I mean
- he called the case 'plastic' and inferred it's cheap... the case is polycarbonate, which is a plastic, but it's not run of the mill stuff... very durable, flexible, resists impact da,age much better than metal... it's the same stuff the F22 canopy is made out of... it's not cheap and honestly if drop both of these phones onto a tile floor, the Iphone is gonna be jacked up and the HTC is not
- IE10 does operate in full screen mode, has better rendering numbers than safari by a long shot, and you can use other browsers... and it's been fully html5 compliant long before apple was
- he plays down live tiles, doesn't mention new sizing customization and info options on WP8
- HTC has released much higher talk and standby numbers, and they are posted on this site... LOL, maybe this guy should read his own site....
this author doesn't know what he's talking about with WP8, is clearly biased, did no research to make sure he was correct, and played down huge advantages of WP8 and HTC.....
this review damages phonearenas name.... if you just let appleheads take over, then nobody will take you seriously
41. sadiqhashim (unregistered)
After any review with Apple products they must send the results to Apple and Tim Cook will go through and cross some lines before they can publish it just the way it should be. You see? Apple is always ahead.
28. cdgoin (Posts: 367; Member since: 28 Jul 2010)
So from what I can read, an Apple Fanboy was given a HTC 8X to compare to his love.
32. droiddomination (Posts: 203; Member since: 01 Dec 2011)
ray s is a dip schit. chrapple blows he just can't admit it. 4 inch screen? less ppi? bwahhhaaaaaahaaa!!
34. alcheng (Posts: 7; Member since: 10 Nov 2012)
phonearena.com has always been one of my favorite gadget website.
But this article changes it all.
I've never read some piece of crap like this.
The writer is obviously bias to iphone5, the writer just favor iphone5 on every category by saying "the iphone5 is better....", but without a solid reason/analysis to back his satement.
I cannot believe the editor would allow such a low-class comparison article to be published.
I suggest the writer please just simply go to work for apple instead of trolling in here.
37. oldhamletman (Posts: 35; Member since: 03 Sep 2011)
I agree..... I respected phonearena in a big way until this review..... I would bypass all other cell blogs for this one....
no more.... posting fanboy stuff like this .... jeez
35. ubarua1 (Posts: 2; Member since: 10 Nov 2012)
That was the one hell of a biased review.
"it's undeniable that the iPhone 5 is a work of art that no mass-produced phone on the market can currently rival".. Really you think so?
39. FranksGT (Posts: 167; Member since: 29 Aug 2012)
FAIL FAIL FAIL, you guys love the color reproduction of the IOS apps look. Are you retarded? They are Bland icons put on a ugly background. What is pretty about that Ios? Even though the Iphone 5 is the winner and preforms better your review was retarded!
Camera samples once again quit taking 1000 pictures with Iphone 5 to get it perfect and only taking the first one with the HTC!
40. sadiqhashim (unregistered)
Apple iPhone is a phone that has more from the outside than the inside, is designed by Apple in America, so I expect it to have a home advantage when it comes to review like this, but in Taiwan things are so different.
44. loyals (Posts: 129; Member since: 10 Nov 2012)
Well 8x looses in benchmarks big time against ip5. N wp8 phones Doesn't even have APPS properly worse than symbian. It's better to buy an ip5 than 8x for sure.
46. RichieRich379 (Posts: 21; Member since: 23 Mar 2012)
iphone has a worst screen, worst batter life, bo beats audio, inferior maps>?????? how about that
50. loyals (Posts: 129; Member since: 10 Nov 2012)
have u actually compared the audio of two ?? iphone has the est audio decoding chip . i have one v with beats audio of htc . it really cant beat iphone 5 .
45. RichieRich379 (Posts: 21; Member since: 23 Mar 2012)
im getting tierd of these apple fanboy reviews, its so stupid, he saids the design in htc x is a regular industry design as oppose to the iphone, but he doesnt mention how iphone has an old boring ui as oppse to window 8 live tiles. i can go on and on but this review is complete bulls**t
47. meowcenary (Posts: 187; Member since: 13 Apr 2012)
I would not call phonearena or any reviewer fanboys, unless it is obvious. Reviewers are entitled to their opinion and I respect that. After saying that, I love my HTC 8x and really have to say MS took the phone to the next level. If MS and the telecomms push the WP platform it would be a plus. However it's sad to know that my t-mobile store only carried three WP8 phones and selling two constitutes as a huge deal.
Folks go out and try all the platforms, ask yourself what you need and not what people say....unless something is really Asinus.
51. HDee89 (Posts: 9; Member since: 10 Dec 2012)
Not a terrible review, but definitely needs somebody who understands the hardware better. The Windows Phone's Beats Audio is not a software enhancement, it's an onboard soundchip on the pcb that's REALLY high quality for a mobile device, listening to music on the HTC 8X for me was incredible, the sound quality, is absolutely brilliant, the iphone 5 also offers a very good sound quality, I would in no way say that either sounds better, and comparing the iphone earphones is irellevant, you pay a much higher price for the iphone 5 and these earphones are part of the reason, you could quite simply buy a high quality pair of earphones for much less than the price difference of these 2 devices.
Also, you completely disregarded reviewing the battery life of the iphone, I think that speaks volumes about your objective whilst writing this review, which was to completely leave out any flaws with the iphone5, as I'm sure you were aware after reviewing both the devices, the 8X is a CLEAR winner when it comes to battery life.
Thirdly, you are a reviewer, so don't be a coward when it comes to reviewing things. You can't say "It's up to the user to make the decision" People have come to this comparitive review specifically to understand which phone outperforms which in each category. You must come to a conclusion for each category of review, otherwise there is no reason to include the category whatsoever. Without a doubt the iphone 5 is a better phone overall, but most people look at phone reviews to understand the concept of "Value for money" with these devices. The iphone 5 is a better phone, however the prices between the 2 handsets are VERY different, and this should be taken into account when understanding the value of the devices.
53. Skiman (Posts: 15; Member since: 10 Jan 2013)
After using both, the HTC 8X is the better phone overall
The OS is the main part, and WP is so much better than iOS, which really has grown to repulse me now, just so old and stale
52. dougiefresh181 (Posts: 5; Member since: 12 Dec 2012)
the htc is much more egonomic, and the rubberized plastic backing feels better to hold than the iphone. ive held both, and the lcd display in the htc beats the retina display hands down, plus he got the htc all greased up, and a rag would take it right off. the edges are also rounded than the iphone, he has the brightness on the htc down. he is very subjective about the ui, and bangs wp8 about tile shape? really? the landscape keyboard changes app to app in wp7. iphone is clocked at 1 ghz not 1.3. htc also has much better battery life, even with live tiles.it also has better cloud storage and syncs across all of your windows devices without syncing. very subjective comparing browsers. camera on htc is much sharper, clearly, and more saturated. htc has beats audio and the same headphones have to be used to compare sound. just punching holes in the argument on youtube
54. Skiman (Posts: 15; Member since: 10 Jan 2013)
HTC 8X wins hands down, the OS is just so much better, I can't actually use apple products anymore, because the boring GUI now repulses me. They really haven't updated it since 2007