Apple iPhone 3GS ReviewApple iPhone 3GS 8.5
The battery gets a modest bump from 1150mAh to 1219, but thanks to other hard and software improvements battery life has increased to 5 hours of 3G talk time and 9 hours of Wi-Fi browsing. More talk time is great, assuming you can make a call. While our reception seemed just fine, call quality was awful. Despite showing full 3G signal strength callers complained that we were static-ey, cutting in and out, tinny and just generally poor. Our end wasn’t much better; the volume was low enough that we had a hard time understanding callers even in quiet environments. There were a few calls we had to abandon because the quality was so poor.
Whether or not to get an Apple iPhone 3GS isn’t as clear-cut as it used to be; first, and for many users foremost, is the fact that it just isn’t much of an upgrade from the 3G. If you’re a 2G owner or a new user looking to hop aboard then the decision should be easy. The other issue complicating the issue is the competition. All things considered, we like the Pre better. It may not have the app support yet, but the platform is more advanced. Symbian just announced some monster spec potential and we still haven’t given up on Android. Hell, even HTC is making Windows Mobile look good (OK, that may be stretching it.)
Last year the addition of 3G was a very compelling reason for users to upgrade or jump ship, but this time around we don’t really see anything that will grab the user’s attention. It may entice some 2G owners to finally give up their aluminum back, but save for the gamers 3G owners have very little reason to upgrade their hardware, in our opinion. The new internals make for a faster experience, there is no doubt about that, but we couldn’t justify spending a minimum of $300 (and up to $500) for such a minor tweak. Since 3.0 is available as a free download, the new hardware just isn’t that compelling to us.
We were concerned last year that Apple missed the boat, but the App Store at least brought a software revolution to the table. Let’s face it, it’s still a great phone and will sell like crazy, but there are minimal software improvements and the hardware isn’t head and shoulders above the competition anymore. What once was a truly innovative phone has fallen into a rut, while the competition is breaking out of the box.
Apple iPhone 3GS Video Review:
- Apple finally listened, adding MMS, video recording, voice dialing, A2DP and copy/paste
- OSX 3.0 seems more stable than 2.0
- Improved memory, processing power, 3D rendering and a more friendly price tag
- The excitement just isn’t there anymore. Moreso than ever, it’s more of the same.
- The decreased price point of the 8GB 3G may be good for Apple’s bottom line, but it’s starting to feel like the RAZR all over again.
1. AlaneCzeQ (Posts: 19; Member since: 12 Jun 2009)
camera resolution - 10 when other phones have 8megapixels and get 9 for that ... weird imo
8. Osukaru (Posts: 68; Member since: 02 Jul 2008)
Its the iPhone, everyone /Drools for it..... Sad
13. AlaneCzeQ (Posts: 19; Member since: 12 Jun 2009)
and when im sayin here is a proff : this phone is 3 megapixel one and resulution is 10http://www.phonearena.com/html
s/HTC-Touch-HD-Review-review-r_2060-p_5.html-> HTC HD 5megapixels and score is 8 and I dont talk about quality but RESOLUTION it means HOW MANY MEGAPIXELS it has got it was first example second one: supported formats - 7 HTC HD - 6 what the hell its win mo it plays everything ! and here u need to conver it on your pc ... I know that the quality of screen is 10 but its resolution ist not top notch coz on the market we've got 800x480 so it suppose to be lower I think this review was good about 2 years ago when nokia n95 came out now I think that Iphone sux big time ... why coz everybody supports it and that is why apple hv made so little changes coz all of reviewer loved it and the are giving better marks than the phone deserves i know that people like AVERANGE JOE will love this phone coz its easy but why TECH JUNKIE who would like to get TODAY : AMOLED, flash with cam, multitasking, bluetooth to send files (maybe its possible dont know sorry if im wrong), better screen res, antiscratch surface and some design changes and i can count more. look what have samsung done ... they are cheaper and better ... lg also :) well maybe its only me but ITS still IPHONE the FIRST ONE with FEW CHANGES (mainly in soft)
28. behold--me (Posts: 650; Member since: 22 Jun 2009)
pathetic ........its not even that great I AGREE WIT U
3. Arielnyc2006 (unregistered)
Thats the main reason I have not acquired the iphone, poor ATT call quality.
4. LGVX1993 (Posts: 260; Member since: 27 Jan 2009)
This is one of the few times where ive seen a phone with bad call quality.
5. drewsky (Posts: 147; Member since: 04 Jan 2009)
I agree with who made this review. It makes to sense to get the 3GS, just get the 3G, with the 3.0 software. The camera is a little better, the processor is faster, but thats really it. I expected Apple to change the design s little bit more. And what happend to ATT making the data plan cheaper? Thats the main reason I don't have one. I would hate to pay $30 a month for any phone.
7. vmatikov (Posts: 55; Member since: 28 Jan 2009)
AT&T never said they'd change the price of the data plan lol... Anyway you're right, there's a slim diff between the 3G and 3G S, but I think it's a matter of taste.
10. drewsky (Posts: 147; Member since: 04 Jan 2009)
There was a rumor, that ATT would make a LIMITED data plan for the Iphone that would cost $20. But I just found the article that killed that Idea. oh well, I'd much rather have a Omnia i8910.
11. vmatikov (Posts: 55; Member since: 28 Jan 2009)
Hence, it's a rumor. Lol anyway what diff does it make? In my opinion if you want an iPhone, you're gonna pay what they tell you to. And you clearly aren't that person (not that that's a bad thing btw)
6. vmatikov (Posts: 55; Member since: 28 Jan 2009)
Hey just a little note to the reviewers... You guys mentioned that of the two grills on the bottom, audio only comes out of the left one, and you also mentioned that the two grills would naturally indicate stereo speakers. Idk if you guys know or not but I just wanted to mention that under the right grill is the mic.
12. davidneary01 (Posts: 16; Member since: 25 Nov 2008)
its just suprising that apple the "kings of cool and innovation" have now let this phone go 3 generations with zero and i mean 0 design changes..even the instinct tried to improve itself a little with curvier edges and a sleaker look..no doubt it's a great phone but if you aren't moving forward your moving backwords..
14. MTLance (unregistered)
Lol Apple don't have to do much these days thanks to lazy competitors but now the competitors are working way harder than they would. i.e. Nokia just woke up from iPhone kicking its butt and coming out with E72(Very sexy phone and I'm in love, I just hope there is a good review for it), Palm has an Apple man with Pre totally kicking iPhone butt, and not to mention BB ain't giving that up that easy but with Storm 2 on its way.
15. donchichi (Posts: 1; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
I'm very surprised the review for Iphone is rated so high and the N97 so low. There are advantages on both phones whereas the Iphone is more for viewing videos and music but not a good phone overall. Be a bit fair on the reviews as I have 5800 and iphone and after a while the hype just dies with the iphone. Its like a very beautiful lady but she can't cook, can't clean and can't do nothing. After a short while you'd go for the average girl who can do more.
16. mulda71 (Posts: 42; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
How do you rate a phone so high if you say the phone call quality blows? Because I agree, every iphone I have tried is absolutely unusable as a telephone. I really want to buy one, but I just can't buy a phone that, you know, doesn't work as a phone! How do so many people put up with that?! I mean I know it's cool and all, but...
53. jje1953 (Posts: 1; Member since: 11 Mar 2010)
Well, I think you make the proper point. For a lot of folks, the iPhone is an iPod that you can make calls with. It's fairly apparent, that call quality is the least of Apple's concerns, because they know the typical iPhone buyer is probably more interested in the other features, than they are in the call quality. I'm considering an iPhone myself, and I could tell you, that the other features outweigh call quality, because frankly, I don't make that many calls. Not that I want a phone that sounds like two cans connected by string, but I've always wanted an iPod, and maybe you kill two birds with one stone.
17. sushjames (Posts: 19; Member since: 11 Apr 2009)
well i think reviewer gets paid if they praise the iphone...well i'm not offending anyone but still if you notice reviews about iphone from all the website they only say good thing about it.. i don't understand.. Anyhow can't believe apple just introduced one phone (iphone) now it's taking most of the mobile market.. well it's great for them.. sad for other manufactures because they generate 20 - 30 models per year still they can't compete with this one...can someone please explain me what makes apple product so special ?? .. well thanks for reading my comments.
27. behold--me (Posts: 650; Member since: 22 Jun 2009)
im kinda glad to hear that this scored below a 9 http://www.cellphonesignal.com
/the-pearl-the-best-smartphone-out-there/look at this link BEST SMARTPHONE where do u see the iphone 3G? its below the motorola Zine ZN5 i dont even think that was meant to be a smartphone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
18. madlaw1071 (Posts: 3; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
#16 nails it and I'll go a step further, the 3 most common uses for a cell phone the Iphone excels the least at. It sucks as a phone, has no push email for most providers and still has no MMS(no definitive date). Other than that it's a great phone.
19. martycota (Posts: 28; Member since: 15 Jun 2009)
Is the iPhone taking most of the mobile market? I like to think that most of the millions of people who bought it, are the ones who keep buying them when they release new ones, meaning that overall, 1/3 only equals the total subscribers...
20. Jyakotu (Posts: 829; Member since: 12 Dec 2008)
All these comments are acting like Phone Arena gave the iPhone 3GS a perfect score. Heck, it scored lower than it's previous iPhone counterparts.
21. sprntfanboi02 (Posts: 41; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
yeah plus we know how much better this phone is than the previous iphone.....oh wait thats right its the same phone....oh wait thats right apple finally put cut and paste in their phone....didnt my htc 6700 have that
25. behold--me (Posts: 650; Member since: 22 Jun 2009)
doesnt every smartphone have that my phone from 2006 had some of the features that the iphone didnt have (video) it was DISCONTINUED IN 2007 AND STILL BEAT THE IPHONE WITH THAT ok uh appple get real it shouldnt take 3 yrs to get video capture or QWERTY on a full touch....... my behold? 5mp landscape qwerty almost 8 months before the iphone video and pic editing
26. behold--me (Posts: 650; Member since: 22 Jun 2009)
oh wait and the all original MMS MESSAGING dammit apple get with the program haha
45. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
DISCONTINUED should be the key word in your entire paragraph...There is NO smartphone to this day easier or more fun to use than the iPhone, thats why its selling like hotcakes.. Unlike your Moto Q or whatever other Discontinued JUNK you were carrying around...
22. theman414 (Posts: 132; Member since: 08 Jun 2009)
I'm so glad I got rid of vx6800 for this today!
23. rshackindian (Posts: 21; Member since: 11 Apr 2009)
scored lower than the sprint palm pre. ha ha
34. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
Yet it has sold more than double..hahahahahaha stick with the ghetto i mean sprint service....lol
41. hereticcavi (unregistered)
ghetto? your ghetto, ghetto
46. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
^^^ let me guess sprint customer...lol...typical...Must be why they have to have security guards in all the retail stores...You know for all the high class people that pay their bill on time...oh wait...maybe thats why sprint is about to go belly up..hahaha OK on a lighter not, can we even consider sprint a cell company now that they have sold off all their towers?? lol... Whats next??
24. behold--me (Posts: 650; Member since: 22 Jun 2009)
i watched on the news when they announced the FIRST iphone i thought omg HOW AWESOME!!! the iphone 3G came out and the apps upgrade was cool but those BASIC FEATURES WERE MISSING now the iphone 3GS (notice no space lol) and it looks EXACTLY THE SAME AS THE 3G AND REALLY CLOSE TO THE FIRST GEN. never a fan............ there's been no design change! people get bored with it if u put the same phone out over and over (moto razr) switch it up a little bit like EVERY OTHER MANUFACTURER DOES imagine this....do u think that if t-mo released another G1 that looked EXACTLY LIKE IT but had a faster processor and maybe a few more apps n crap that people would buy more of that second one than its predecessor? wel apple used to be the king of innovation and multimedia, but starting to fall behind. sony ericsson is making its multi-media phones and camera phones aka walkman and cyber shot series........ nokia is changing their xpressmusic phones LG has second and 3rd gen. of older phones and they look different!!!! (i.e. enV, shine, viewty, etc.) even samsung is changing their phones appearances and even has specific lines to meet the needs of buisness or just music ppl htc has those phones that just look professional.......and get the job done right which manufacturers have good cameras? all of them! oooh 3mp!!!! samsung has the behold and omnia=5mp the pixon=8mp and even the pixon 12=12 mp sony e. has 12, 8, and 5 on most of their new high end phones and even the mid range ones nokia was slowest to get in the camera buisness but even they have 5 and 8 mp lg has 8mp phones htc has 5 and a rumored 8mp phone oh wait, wheres apple? 3mp......wow
29. AlaneCzeQ (Posts: 19; Member since: 12 Jun 2009)
3mp......wow but its like apple is sayin : it takes SUPERB pictures DEAL with it fanboys where are you know ? is it 3g or 3gs ? which is better compared to money u have to pay for it ? this is my question to fans :)
47. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
The answer is neither because you probably cant afford them...lol
52. AlaneCzeQ (Posts: 19; Member since: 12 Jun 2009)
only child would reply like this ... sad but true
31. mullaihno (Posts: 1; Member since: 26 Jun 2009)
come on guys he phone is better it has a better camera, video recording, stronger 3g, faster processor and graphics, longer battery, voice dial, memory and ram, more durable body and display and better bluetooth all that and it looks sexy.
33. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
Agree...The best device period=iPhone....All others are imitations...
35. mulda71 (Posts: 42; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
sure, if you could just place a phone call on it, it would be.
40. sprntfanboi02 (Posts: 41; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
are you saying they are imitations because apple is constantly updating their phone to get basic features that my smartphone from 2006 had in it? cough cough cut and paste cough
42. hereticcavi (unregistered)
also remember when att got live tv last year.....Didnt sprint have that for like almost 5 years....AWESOME 3g speed d00d
43. sprntfanboi02 (Posts: 41; Member since: 25 Jun 2009)
i do remember that.....do you remember when att charged $50 more a month for their everything plan.... oh wait they still do......and oh yeah dont you have to pay an extra $10 just to get turn by turn navigation on the iphone.......wow.......that comes standard on the pre
44. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
Standard on the Pre is the video camera...oh wait.... hahaha what a joke..the Pre feels like its made from some of the cheapest plastic there is... ITS JUNK on a carrier that is bleeding at every seem..Not to mention Palm is about 3 months shy of going belly up...hahahaha JOKE!!!!!!!!!!!!
49. FU2 (Posts: 11; Member since: 27 Jun 2009)
Yeah they did and their still going belly up..hmmmmm Live TV must be important somewhere....lol
36. sensei_phn (Posts: 6; Member since: 17 Jun 2009)
They would prefer the Pre over Apple's latest attempt at screwing everyone in price and network coverage. Fianlly someone gets it.
37. AZNphoneGeek (Posts: 200; Member since: 15 May 2009)
ya know what on tthis whole apple thing... if apple made a car, people would buy it. if they started a food chain, people would eat there and they would buy the car and eat at the restraunt even if were the worst junk on earth cause it was made by apple. from a business and product standpoint, they are silly good. personally i hate everything about them. i even hate my own ipod but i still use it because it's an awesome mp3 player. sad. whats even sadder is the fact that the iphone hasn't changed in 3 generations. oh wait it has... it's multitaskless-ness (is that even a word) is now UP to twice as fast. thank goodness for the compass eh. i'll stick to my blackberry curve because i can listen to music, web browse, and text all at the same time. oh yeah, and it was free. oh yeah, it's tough as nail too. god i hate apple stuff so much.
39. SmartPhan (Posts: 1; Member since: 29 Jun 2009)
How is it that the category point totals are so much better for the N97, but IPhone's overall score is higher? You don't even seem to be that impressed by any of the iPhone's specific features. It seems like more fan-boy appreciation for the iPhone's design over "smart-phone" functionality... and don't say that they're in different classes when an unlocked iPhone is just as expensive as an unlocked N97.
51. uphaillife (Posts: 2; Member since: 01 Jul 2009)
FU2 is an obvious fanboy. anyways, the thing is: strip the apps and you got a normal smart phone with horrible limitations. 3 mp camera? horrendous screen?http://tinypic-com/view.php?pic=2cyr5w2&s=5 (replace - with .) bad music/sound quality. it sucks as a phone and a media player. wifi is the only thing i like about it
54. lacrymosa (Posts: 6; Member since: 25 Mar 2010)
when you think about it. the iphone seems just like an att version of the tmobile sidekick. a new overpriced version comes out every year with the smallest change and everyone who had the older model jumps on bored with it and starts bragging about the one new feature the phone should've had in the first place