iPhone 5's terrible letterbox show Apple's apathy for developers
0. phoneArena 21 Sep 2012, 18:15 posted on
Apple has always prided itself on design. That's why every year, we get to hear in very minute detail what goes into the process of making the iPhone look the way it does. Unfortunately, Apple hasn't been so exacting when it comes to iOS design, and it shows with the iPhone 5's letterboxed apps...
This is a discussion for a news. To read the whole news, click here
1. Captain_Doug (Posts: 976; Member since: 10 Feb 2012)
What a joke. I'd take terrible tablet apps over letter boxing any day.
30. Droid_X_Doug (Posts: 5993; Member since: 22 Dec 2010)
Sad to say, this is not Steve's program any more. He would have put the squeeze on a group of developers to deliver native resolution apps for the iP5 on release date. The letter-boxing with a dearth of apps that provide native resolution is just chickens*t.
31. Droid_X_Doug (Posts: 5993; Member since: 22 Dec 2010)
At the risk of getting banned, there is an op-ed on nytimes that talks to Apple's decline (http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09
/22/opinion/nocera-has-apple-peaked.html?hp). The Cliff-Notes version is that once a company gets so successful that its business model is focused on protecting the franchise that it was able to build, that is the beginning of the end. The company may remain profitable (MS), but it is no longer the innovator that got it to its position of profitability.
The perfidious lash-up that is the Apple Maps application and this stupid letter-boxing is proof of Apple passing its zenith.
41. whysoserious (Posts: 318; Member since: 20 Jul 2012)
I've used four android phones for the last 3 years. WTF is a letterbox? Is that a new innovation Apple has come up with for the new iPhone 5?
iFans, thumbs up if you're excited with this new innovation! Woohoo!!!
44. Droid_X_Doug (Posts: 5993; Member since: 22 Dec 2010)
Letterboxing is a set of black panels on the right and left sides of the display that indicate un-filled space from the image being projected on the display (as occurs when a 4:3 image is projected on a 16:9 display). If you look at the picture of the iP4 next to the iP5 in the article, you can see two black 'bars' on the iP5. The white iP5 shows the bars more than the black one.
46. whysoserious (Posts: 318; Member since: 20 Jul 2012)
Sorry bro, forgot to wear my sarcasm mask when I posted that. Lol!
57. Hemlocke (unregistered)
Scaled apps are garbage, especially on a tablet. Wonder why Android tablets don't sell? "Design once, run everywhere" is a poor compromise, and if you are paying $500 for a tablet, scaled apps just suck.
58. toplinetony (Posts: 2; Member since: 30 Oct 2011)
That statement perfectly encapsulates what responsive design is meant to solve. Except you got it the wrong way round; Android promotes it, Apple and iOS do not.
2. Pings (Posts: 303; Member since: 19 Dec 2008)
Hmmm wonder how many things at Apple are an after thought.
4. justaphone (Posts: 6; Member since: 19 Aug 2012)
I guess there's not much more that could have been done when developers never had to worry about screen size on an iOS device before this release... A lot of anger in this article ;)
5. PhoneArenaUser (Posts: 5498; Member since: 05 Aug 2011)
"A lot of anger in this article ;)"
6. rusticguy (Posts: 2828; Member since: 11 Aug 2012)
Apple is not a Software company so why blame them :)
14. lasp24 (Posts: 3; Member since: 21 Sep 2012)
because they were the ones that decided only to stretch the screen height-wise and so all of the apps that they had previously will now have black bars. It is Apple's fault, not the developers of the apps.
22. tedkord (Posts: 9007; Member since: 17 Jun 2009)
Apple absolutely is a software company. What do you think iOS, OSX, their new maps app, etc...are?
39. cso26 (Posts: 10; Member since: 01 Aug 2012)
oh .now i come to know that ios is hardware.lol.
53. noim1 (Posts: 297; Member since: 15 May 2012)
Well ofcourse a.pl is a software company.. They don't make hardware they only take the best from the best hardware manufacturers in the world like Samsung, Sony, sharp etc.. They cherry pick the best things and put them all together and put inn their dumb iOS software.& wala dumb ppl with too much money here is your iPhone.... And they call it innovation. Yesi admit they once used to innovate but now they just seem derailed...
54. bhsolace (Posts: 5; Member since: 12 Aug 2011)
they dont take hardware from other manufacturers, and although they havent innovated much in a physical sense, the software has been approved. to answer your question, no im not an apple fanboy, i appreciate technological advancements. theres no such thing as an apple fanboy, theres good things about apple and there are some bad things. Myself, being competent, can appreciate apple for its innovation and comment on its mistakes. But i can see your one of those ignorant hipsters that think, because they're successful i should hate on them. you think your cool because you stand out from "the crowd" that likes apple, but your really aren't. you're a fool, if android had been on top, and it was apple trying to get noticed i bet you a million dollars you would back apple 100%.
***Your opinions do not matter at all, please stay out of future comment sections, thanks.
56. baustin4 (Posts: 1; Member since: 26 Sep 2012)
1: Competent? Ex. See "software has been approved" try improved.
2: No such thing as an apple fanboy? No comment.
7. timtimity (Posts: 196; Member since: 13 Aug 2012)
Why hasn't the keyboard been stretched to fit the entire width of the screen when in landscape mode? Surely one of the biggest benefits of a larger screen is more room to type. One of the reasons why I want a phone with a bigger screen is that I'm constantly mistyping because of the small keyboard on my iPhone.
8. PhoneArenaUser (Posts: 5498; Member since: 05 Aug 2011)
Did you pre ordered or maybe already bought iPhone 5 ?
9. timtimity (Posts: 196; Member since: 13 Aug 2012)
No, I was looking at my brother's iPhone 5 today. I'm moving to Android within the next few weeks. I'm not anti-Apple or pro-Android. I've had iPhones since the 3GS and I fancy a change. Also, in my opinion, I think I can get a much better phone for a lot less than the cost of the new iPhone.
10. timtimity (Posts: 196; Member since: 13 Aug 2012)
Also, because I've been with my carrier for so long I've negotiated a really good tariff so I'm going to buy a phone sim-free as I want to keep the tariff I'm on. I've worked out that for the total amount of money it is costing my brother for a 2 year contract with his new iPhone (including his tariff, the handset cost and insurance) I could buy an Xperia T, One X or S3 sim free and use it for 7-8 years before it came to the same amount!!!
11. PhoneArenaUser (Posts: 5498; Member since: 05 Aug 2011)
Then it is good that you have noticed that keyboard hasn't been stretched to fit the entire width of the screen. :)
25. PapaSmurf (Posts: 10312; Member since: 14 May 2012)
Welcome to Android. Here, you have total customization to your liking. Enjoy your phone!
52. TalkingTechy (Posts: 97; Member since: 05 Dec 2011)
I had the iPhone 4...I fancied a change and went to the Samsung Galaxy S3...I lived with it for 1 month and determined the following:
Read on and decide for yourself which pros and cons weigh more for you.
12. wendygarett (unregistered)
Thank god I haven't bought the iPhone 5 yet...
What a shame Apple... Most of the apps still stuck at th 3.5inches...
13. wendygarett (unregistered)
Nice article Michael, especially that picture 'i do not like the shame of cones'
I really need to wear one in front of the fandroid :(
Really really as shame :(
45. Droid_X_Doug (Posts: 5993; Member since: 22 Dec 2010)
Didn't you want to have the coolest iPhone yet?
48. wendygarett (unregistered)
I'll wait for the fix 1st...
15. lasp24 (Posts: 3; Member since: 21 Sep 2012)
Nokia Lumia 920 doesn't have black bars on the sides of apps, and working maps, and NFC and wireless charging, and Optical Image stabilization, and an OS that is actually customizable. After much though, I am getting the Nokia
16. PhoneArenaUser (Posts: 5498; Member since: 05 Aug 2011)
I also like Nokia Lumia 920, but Windows Phone 8 is stopping me from buying it so, I say maybe in the future when there will be Windows Phone 9. :)
18. 12Danny123 (Posts: 87; Member since: 18 Aug 2012)
Well. There's nothing wrong with Wp8 it's just like IOS but more free and much less restricted than IOS 6. and it's definitely not a horrible upgrade like IOS 6. which turned out awful. While I think an Android user will get used to Wp8 for the specs. But Honestly I think Wp8 is a very good alternative to Android and IOS
20. PhoneArenaUser (Posts: 5498; Member since: 05 Aug 2011)
I agree with you 100%, but I still think that WP need a bit more time. I will refrain maybe till WP 9. :)
34. haseebzahid (Posts: 1853; Member since: 22 Feb 2012)
yes WP8 is a total rework of WP seriers from very bottom line its not a patch its new OS
17. infernal88 (Posts: 113; Member since: 08 Jun 2012)
reading this "Assuming you're using a browser that's competent (read: not IE)" ... made me LOL XD
19. 12Danny123 (Posts: 87; Member since: 18 Aug 2012)
I Think tones of people will not like the black bars. and I never see people updating their apps at all. So I think people will think it's stuck like that forever. It will leave a bad taste in their mouth and the apps and especially IOS 6
21. TheRetroReplay (Posts: 254; Member since: 20 Mar 2012)
That's pretty much Apple to a T, adopt/invent/steal new standards and abandon the old ones and screw everyone else because it's their problem, not Apple's.
23. Savage (unregistered)
Apple should use a PPI calculator or something similar for their devices. Fragmentation in iOS is just getting started.
24. stealthd (unregistered)
How are they terrible exactly? Apps function exactly as they do on a 4/4S. Same size same everything. How is that terrible?
27. johnbftl (Posts: 273; Member since: 09 Jun 2012)
It's terrible because Apple is selling millions of customers on the premise of having half an inch more real estate to use in apps and such when in reality, it will be blacked out. If you had a 52" tv and upgraded to a 70" only to find out that extra 9" on each side was blacked out, I'm pretty sure you'd be pissed off.
28. fanboy1974 (Posts: 1345; Member since: 12 Nov 2011)
The best article I've ever read on this site. Finally someone not kissing Apple ass. I'm sick and tired of people saying that Android is nothing but a fragmented mess. Just look at what Apple is doing/not doing. Apple had this prime opportunity to redo the entire freaking operating system and come out with a phone that was totally different. Instead we get some $hitty maps app and upgrades that Android users have been using for close to 2 years.
29. mrllano (Posts: 91; Member since: 20 Aug 2012)
It's difficult to be a known both in hardware and software.. That is why up to this point, we still have a good competition. Apple, Google, Microsoft, even Blackberry is known for a specific part, but not on both aspect.
32. pikapowerize (banned) (Posts: 1869; Member since: 03 May 2012)
since when the iPad's size is 10.1? its true.. hate that letterbox.... i think they should be unified with 16:9 ratio
33. haseebzahid (Posts: 1853; Member since: 22 Feb 2012)
new licence for the updated tools pay up Mr.Developers so u can adjust this thing easier :P
35. haseebzahid (Posts: 1853; Member since: 22 Feb 2012)
that makes APP count for IOS6 from 750k down to like 300k apps being 100% fit in screen hahaha head shot Apple
36. AppleConspiracy (Posts: 637; Member since: 18 Oct 2011)
This is the problem I was talking abouth five months ago. I couldn't think of the way Apple will resize iPhone's screen without sacrificing lots of things.
When I have read first wave of rumors that say there will be 176 pixels taller screen, I thought they will use those pixels for virtual Home button and make iPhone butonnless for new generation of apps. Because 176 pixels in 326 ppi is exactly the space needed for Home button that is physical on all previous iPhones.
I knew there will be problems if they didn't do that. And there is no alternative except keeping the same screen, which is not possible for Apple anymore considering the pressure for the market. They did perhaps the biggest mistake in iPhone era.
And iPad Mini... I doubt there will be iPad Mini. But, since they already did one big mistake, why don't they make another? However, if Mini should have 1024x768 resolution, there will be no problems for developers.
37. plyfulgentleman (Posts: 43; Member since: 17 Jul 2008)
Oh me oh my! How the mighty havd fallen! Fragmentation on iPhone 5, say it aint so. God rest his soul, but if Jobs can only see this now. Certainly the cyclical theory is in effect once on top inky way to go is dowm. Just like apple to put the blame on developers on the letterboxing. One can only imagine whats in store for 5s? NFC perhaps? Safari on Ios able to link search on mac? Sounds like someone is playing catch up here...honestly folks not to sound like a phanboy but wake up. All these features were on gingerbread...but hey some people gotta learn the hardway...deuces everyone
38. princysharma1990 (Posts: 1; Member since: 22 Sep 2012)
I am using iPhone 3GS and was really looking forward to iPhone 5 but its release is very dis-appointing. Its cost is not worth its services. :(
Now, I think I have to switch to Samsung or LG android phones.
40. RyFry (Posts: 6; Member since: 16 Sep 2012)
Wait.... Who the hell could name a lead designer for any company. Bet you close to 98% of people couldn't even named apple's lead designer.
Sorry but Jony Ive is not a common know name. Maybe Tim Cook, but not Jony Ive.
47. paulyyd (Posts: 338; Member since: 08 Jan 2011)
lol I don't see how letter boxing is a big deal, its not like developers can't update their apps to fit the new screen size. Yet again another issue blow out of proportion. Doesn't matter, this phone is selling like hot cakes. The consumers don't seem to mind
49. johnbftl (Posts: 273; Member since: 09 Jun 2012)
It's not a matter of JUST updating the app. You didn't even read the article did you? Developers essentially have to rewrite the app for the new screen size. Then there becomes the issue of the applications being in the app store multiple times. If you don't pay attention, and most people don't (not saying Apple users, people in general) you're probably not going to notice if it says for use with 3.5", 4.0", iPad, or iPad mini. Meanwhile Apple will just boast that they now have 2.8 million apps instead of 700,000.
50. Windsponge (Posts: 92; Member since: 01 Nov 2009)
I am using 4s now my next will be note2 or new lg coming out. Who cares what phone you or I buy. People just tell features leave personal feeling at home.
51. Astri (Posts: 3; Member since: 23 Sep 2012)
I disagree with is article.
When apple doubled the resolution from 3gs to ip4 the only thing developers had to do was to add high resoloution images to their project. Same naming with a @2x at the end. Same case with ipad and new ipad.
View controllers has auto resize properties so i guess all you have to do, is to add support for iphone 5, recompile and you are done.
The only difficult case might be the games and the custum UI apps. But for android also those cases are handled by the devs.
Im android user by the way but developing for iOS is much more fun
55. MichaelHeller (Posts: 2693; Member since: 26 May 2011)
This isn't as simple as making high res images for the art in your app. This is rebuilding all of the art for your app with a different aspect ratio. For some apps, that may not be a problem, but for a lot of apps, including most games, that can be quite a big task.
59. burkminipup (Posts: 1; Member since: 26 Apr 2013)
Yeah, I hate letterboxes. *opens widescreen video on GS3*, oh wait, back to iPhone 5.. Pretty sure the selling point for many of the android devices is that they are better for video. Seeing as I keep my iPhone on portait lock for anything other than videos, I'm glad it's not wider. I agree that apps that are basically just scrolling in the middle, could easily be automatically adjusted, but that puts some more pressure on the phone's processor, and lazy app developers wouldn't bother optimizing.