Siri - could Apple's humble personal assistant reshape the way we use our phones
We wanted to spend some time thinking about this new service, analyzing what it actually is, what it still isn't, and maybe even throw a quick glance forward, trying to predict if it would prove to be a hit with consumers.
What Siri is
It turns out Apple wants us to see Siri as something more than a simple voice control functionality. After all, the iPhone already featured basic voice controls. This time around, however, Cupertino is aiming for something bigger – it's trying to create a personified digital assistant, living inside your gadget, kind of like in Sci-Fi movies. It's a character that will be able to take control of not only your basic phone functions like calling and texting, but also its advanced abilities to look up info on the web and fetch it to you, provide you with suggestions for nice restaurants in the area (courtesy of Yelp), tell you if you should get a raincoat today... The best part is that you won't need to use a number of specific phrases for it to understand you. According to Apple (and the live demonstration they offered), Siri is capable of understanding the context behind your words. So, for example, if you want it to tell you what the weather is today, you can ask “What's the weather like today?”, but you might as well go for “Is it going to rain today?”, and in both cases, Siri will bring up today's forecast.
A typical usage scenario
how the feature works with a scenario of our own. Say, you're at home, and you suddenly receive a new text message. Now, of course, you can just reach for your phone and read the message, but how about just holding the home button down, until Siri is activated, and saying “Read my new message!”, which will be followed by Siri's predominantly robotic female voice reading your latest message aloud.
In this case, it's up for debate which method, the old or the new one, of checking you message will be faster, but with the next examples, it becomes evident that you can save quite some time and effort by using Siri.
Let's have dinner at 7PM?”, but you don't remember if you had already planned something for 7PM. What you'll have to do is just tap on the mic icon, which will be visible, because you've already activated Siri by holding down the home key, and say “Do I have any appointments for 7PM today?”. Alternatively, you could say “Do I have something planned for 7PM today?”. In both cases, Siri should understand that you want it to check your calendar and tell you if you have any appointments set for that time. For the purposes of this scenario, you won't have any appointments set, and Siri will respond accordingly.
Next up, you'd like to add that dinner as an event in your calendar. You can now do that all by using your voice, with a little help from Siri. All you have to do is tap on the mic icon and say “I'll have dinner with Mike today at 7PM.” Upon saying that, Siri will simply add your appointment in the calendar, without you doing anything else. Setting calendar appointments and reminders just got way easier, eh?
What's the weather going to be tonight?” - Siri will tell you what the weather's going to be, as well as bring up an hourly forecast.
Finally, you'd want to actually respond to that message, so that your friend Mike knows if you're going to have dinner with him. Note that you don't have to say something like “Send a text message to Mike, telling him that I'm available for tonight.” Nope. It looks like Siri will have a little brain of its own, so it will remember who sent you the last message, and thus, you'll only have to say “Reply – Sounds good!” Since voice recognition has never been perfect, and neither is Siri, it will bring up your response, the way it heard it, and ask you if you want to send that message. Then, all that's going to be left to do is to mutter “Send”, and you're done. Reading about this might make it sound like a slowish process, but in really, it will happen pretty fast. Most probably way faster that doing it the traditional way, involving going to the calendar to create an appointment, using the on-screen QWERTY to type, etc. Speaking of the QWERTY keyboard, now, with the help of Siri, you'll be able to use your voice to dictate text whenever that keyboard pops up, awaiting your input.
What Siri isn't
Naturally, we shouldn't expect Siri to be perfect. First before most, we're far from thinking that it will understand our words correctly all the time. We guess there will be many failed attempts, which might even drive us crazy at times, especially if we aren't articulating in the best possible way. Imagine appointments being set for the wrong time, or incorrectly transcribed messages – you'll have to do the same actions multiple times, which would be an annoying experience indeed.
Right now, language support is a bit limited. At first, Siri will know English, French and German, which isn't that bad, but the omission of widely-used languages such as Spanish, for example, is something that should be dealt with quickly.
Finally, although it does seem like Siri will be able to go pretty deep into iOS's various functionalities, Apple itself admitted that you won't be able to ask about everything, so you won't be able to do everything just by using your voice. In addition, by the looks of it, at least for now, Siri will be integrated with iOS's built-in apps only, and developers won't be able to use it for their third-party apps. This means you won't be able to create notes in Evernote by voice, or you won't be able to update your status through the Facebook app. But our guess is that when the right time comes, and if users happen to adopt Siri, Apple will open it for integration with third-party apps.
Still, Siri, the so-called humble personal assistant, isn't looked upon as being all that important yet. That's because we all have our habits deeply rooted inside us. Even with such a profound voice recognition service on board, most of us will still reach for the calendar app, in order to add an appointment, or open the browser, in an effort to look up a word. But if Apple pulls this one flawlessly, many users will gradually learn about, and eventually switch to the new, voice-based way of interacting with their device. The benefits are obvious – saving time and effort on the user's side. And who knows, maybe we'll soon be walking down the street, giving instructions to our phones, without all the people around thinking there must be something very wrong with us.
1. G-Reg (unregistered)
Watch your step apple. Youve made buko bucks by apealing to the tech impared with simple user interfaces. Granted this is the easiest and possible the best voice system to date..... but is your market of hipster, slang speaking youngsters, and oldies that want something simple going to adapt so well to this... or just see it as a hassel. This is more or less something that would mean alot more to android users. Maybe this wasnt the right basket to put all your apples in to...
Awesome leap forward... just watch out for that ledge..
9. shafboy (Posts: 179; Member since: 26 Sep 2010)
I know but it is a good feature nevertheless, I thought the iPhone 4S was useless until i saw this..
39. choupino (Posts: 69; Member since: 28 May 2011)
Hey Buddy... IT IS NOT EXCLUSIVE TO 4S... It is a feature of iOS5... That means previous models will have it.
3. Jeex (unregistered)
I've had something similar on my Samsung Galaxy S2 since June: "Voice Talk". To be honest, it's more of a gimmick than really useful - perhaps if I used a car more often.
Most of the time I'm either in the office, outside, or in public transportation, so not too many opportunities to use it really.
6. G-Reg (unregistered)
The best use i have found with voice talk is the auto google search by voice when you hold down the search button.
That one feature gets some people drooling over droids when them come to look at phones. Toss in the "navigate to" on non bing droids and it automaticly kickes in the navigation to where ever you said.
Biggest downfall... more so than not, people are dumb googlers.
iPhone requires very little I.Q. to do what little it can do.. For the droid users, we can turn our phones into classic game consols hooked up to a tv useing wireless remotes.
People are (hopefully) getting smarter, and thus apple, you better start stepping up with some amazing sh!t that follows your proprietary mind set to keep your loyalty where it needs to be.
You've done a great job planning for the future, but will the lifeline mirror that of your computer business? If the ipod,pad,phone saved the your computers, whats going to save the iphone in 5 years?
4. jjxhdb (unregistered)
WTF!!! Dosent the sgs2 have this
33. NeXoS (Posts: 278; Member since: 03 May 2011)
Yes, it does, but in the iPhoneArenda world, features don't really exist until Apple gives it a TRENDY NAME.
36. NVPMOTHAF (Posts: 78; Member since: 28 Sep 2011)
No phone....Let alone android phones have this complex of a feature that intigrates with 90% of the OS. You droid users can say whatever you want, but to compete with the perfection and complex features of the Iphone when released at launch, the android OS has a looong way to go
5. asrr62 (Posts: 56; Member since: 14 Sep 2011)
wow this software update should say android 2.3 lol. copying everything from android. the iphone is for trolls.
7. remixfa (Posts: 14255; Member since: 19 Dec 2008)
this isnt different from android in many ways. Its still the same voice nav system (though android's is still more robust in its uses and able to interact with non stock apps). The only difference is that its able to pick out key words in what your saying to figure out what you want instead of having to say a preprogrammed phrase. It IS an evolution of current voice systems in that way, but its not revolutionary.
With ICS reportedly bringing facial recognition in tow with it, I would hope they figured out a way for it to try to "read your lips" as you voice command it to make it more accurate with what it thinks your saying. Of course that tech might be a few years off.. thats just my pipe dream.. lol
8. SuperAndroidEvo (Posts: 4681; Member since: 15 Apr 2011)
This sounds like HAL 9000 from 2001 A Space Odyssey. One day Siri will tell you to f*ck off. lol No I don't want to set that appointment. No you type that text message...... nah just kidding. There are rumors that Android Ice Cream Sandwich will have an even better voice recognition software. We all know Google is the leader in voice recognition & I am excited to see what improvements Android Ice Cream Sandwich will make to that! I really think I am just going to buy the Google Nexus Prime. I love my HTC Evo 3D but that Super AMOLED HD screen has me mesmerized, I dream about that screen. lol Also if indeed the 1.5 GHz Exynos chipset is included then I WILL get that phone plain & simple! Hey I can always sell my HTC Evo 3D on Craig’s List for $200.00 or more!
10. remixfa (Posts: 14255; Member since: 19 Dec 2008)
lol you should be able to get 300-350 for it, its still a new phone off contract. :)
12. SuperAndroidEvo (Posts: 4681; Member since: 15 Apr 2011)
Hey that is fine with me, with the extra money I may buy a 64GB Micro SD Card, that would be cool! I would essentially trade phones & get the micro SD card for almost free. I would love to get my hands on the Google Nexus Prime, especially if it has the rumored 1.5 GHz Exynos processor. My wife's Samsung Galaxy S II Epic 4G Touch's 1.2 GHz Exynos processor is the most beautiful piece of technology I ever had the grace of using.
18. taco50 (banned) (Posts: 5506; Member since: 08 Oct 2009)
Hey did you know this is an Apple article? Why do you keep spamming Apple articles with nonsense about ice cream sandwich
21. SuperAndroidEvo (Posts: 4681; Member since: 15 Apr 2011)
taco50 I talk about Android Ice Cream Sandwich because the iPhone 4S is finally as big a joke as you are. You must be so excited about the iPhone 4S huh? Also Siri is Beta, who knows when it will do what they say it will do. Also like what remixfa said Google is working on facial recognition technology & that is going to make Siri obsolete like the iPhone 4S. Google has been & still is the leader in voice recognition. So if you really think that your half-baked Siri (beta) is more robust, then just wait until Android Ice Cream Sandwich! lol
22. Penny (Posts: 1434; Member since: 04 Feb 2011)
Facial recognition in its current form will not be able to track movements of the mouth to accept commands. Who knows, maybe they develop this after a while, but don't expect it anytime soon.
24. SuperAndroidEvo (Posts: 4681; Member since: 15 Apr 2011)
Let's wait until Android Ice Cream Sandwich comes out. You maybe 100% correct. I would rather wait until next week to make my final comment.
37. NVPMOTHAF (Posts: 78; Member since: 28 Sep 2011)
The funny thing about the facial recognition is, like the 2.3, it will probably not work and cause a crap load of issues. I would love to troubleshoot those issues when it releases to the Verizon droids. It will just bring back the memories of 2.3 release date.
23. Penny (Posts: 1434; Member since: 04 Feb 2011)
Taco, I really dislike Apple, but I too am getting tired of the sheer number of fanatic Android users here. Nobody is looking at anything objectively and I feel like my f---ing IQ is dropping simply from the frustration.
29. SuperAndroidEvo (Posts: 4681; Member since: 15 Apr 2011)
Penny, taco50 had this coming. Just talk to anyone here on PhoneArena.com you will see. Objective is definitely what taco50 is not!
40. Jeff (unregistered)
31. gallitoking (Posts: 4704; Member since: 17 May 2011)
SAE... dude "Super AMOLED HD screen has me mesmerized, I dream about that screen."... remember the article about people making love to their phones and found that article was misleading..hmmmm until now.....
ps. just come to pHX so we can hung out and put the phone away... lol
17. taco50 (banned) (Posts: 5506; Member since: 08 Oct 2009)
Let's be honest remix, Apple's voice controls are a lot more robust than Google's. Google can't make calendar appointments or comprehend everyday language.
Apple by the way has had voice controls since 3GS.
11. fatakboy619 (Posts: 9; Member since: 03 Oct 2011)
simply the best this time nice work apple :)
13. dlo52 (unregistered)
I was really excited for an iPhone 5 release, so Apple only releasing the 4S was pretty disappointing. Apple has seriously failed this time...No 4"+ screen, no 4G, no NFC! Apple is beginning to sell based upon brand and not their product. I mean seriously, there are at least 3 other phones that have better specs than the iPhone 4S...and they've been out for months now! I think "Siri" looks nice and sounds good but really, who is gonna actually use it on a day-to-day basis? Can't wait for the Nexus Prime now!
14. Mobile-X-Pert (Posts: 565; Member since: 20 Dec 2010)
Doesn't WP7 Mango do all this already??....What about Vlingo???
16. darth8balI (banned) (Posts: 18; Member since: 30 Sep 2011)
I'm really impressed with Apple's Siri assistant. I have to admit it's way ahead of what google has.
19. Sniggly (Posts: 7282; Member since: 05 Dec 2009)
The only two things Siri really has above traditional voice recognition are its memory and ability to pick out the key parts of a phrase and match it to a preprogrammed response. It's still a simple matter of programming multiple pathways to the same reaction, so the "context" feature isn't magic and can easily be introduced in Google.
Google's addition, of course, would be to make a "Siri" like "personal assistant" which is customizable and has a personality. For instance, it allows you to create your own name by typing it in and then telling the phone how that name is pronounced. Then you can activate the whole phone simply by speaking your assistant's name. And sometimes the assistant may get snarky with you (an option you can turn off) but still do what you want.
20. taco50 (banned) (Posts: 5506; Member since: 08 Oct 2009)
well wouldn't that make google a copycat?
27. Sniggly (Posts: 7282; Member since: 05 Dec 2009)
Only if yanking over the air updates, wireless activation and drop down notifications from Android makes Apple a copycat.
What was that percentage again, Taco? Was it 52? Or are you ready to admit that you were not only wrong, but an arrogant douche about being wrong?
34. taz89 (Posts: 2014; Member since: 03 May 2011)
same could be said that siri is a copy of google voice control just been tweaked to recognise more words...as i always say there has to be some form of copying to improve on existing features...am sure all google need to do is change some bits to put it on par with siri but with access to 3rd party apps to which at the moment siri cant do...either way voice control is not really for...should hopefully get siri on a jailbroken iphone 4 soon as apple always like to hold back on certain features
25. AppleFanboy (Posts: 142; Member since: 07 Jun 2011)
That sounds wack and like a little too much for just a phone Sniggly lol
28. Sniggly (Posts: 7282; Member since: 05 Dec 2009)
It wouldn't be too much if it made me feel just a little bit more like Tony Stark. ;)
32. AppleFanboy (Posts: 142; Member since: 07 Jun 2011)
LMAO, when I can have a convo with someone across the world and a 3-D Image of them pops up from my phone, I'll feel like Tony Stark, until then, I'll keep my iPhone....
26. andro. (Posts: 1990; Member since: 16 Sep 2011)
this feature is useless to be honest and has been around for years,only islaves will rave about it being world changing much like apple tried to claim video calling was last year.
Can you imagine a bus full with idiot isheep repeatidly talking to their iphone 4s to get siri work?! How painfull is that for the public!
30. 10aera (Posts: 31; Member since: 02 Mar 2011)
A simple question: can Siri work without an internet connection for simpler functions just as answering to text messages, set appointments, check alarms, play music, etc... And other not-web-related-searches???? I just wonder because in many countries, such as mine (Costa Rica), wifi is the most common internet connection, but it is only available on very specific times and places, such as when staying at home in the evening. Thank you
35. taz89 (Posts: 2014; Member since: 03 May 2011)
i think you need internet connection for everything