Series of videos purport to show durability of BlackBerry, leaves too many holes and questions
In that vein, Heins must have figured that with the BlackBerry reputation for building a solid handset, posting some official videos showing a BlackBerry model surviving some brutal tests would be another way to keep current 'Berry users from jumping ship. So RIM uploaded three videos. One shows the flexibility of a BlackBerry model getting pushed out of shape in the lab. This "Bend and Flex" test simulates what a handset goes through when it is in your back pocket and you sit on it. The second test shows a BlackBerry model dropping in slow motion while the third test shows a 'Berry getting dropped in urine some water dyed yellow while a RIM employee shows that the dunking hasn't left any damage to the phone.
The problem with all three videos is that there is no way to determine how much damage the tests caused the actual phones involved. In the "Bend and Flex" test, we did not see the handset's display so we can only take RIM's word that the unit still works after bending like Gumby. The "Drop Test" video had more holes than Swiss Cheese. The screen and possibly the whole phone was turned off when dropped and no attempt was made to turn it on after the impact. And while the third video did show a BlackBerry model working perfectly after a dunking, there is no chain of evidence that proves that the phone that worked is the exact same model that got wet.
We have to applaud Mr. Heins and RIM for opening up a line of communication between the Canadian based firm and its fans, but videos like these three must be bullet-proof or else there will be too many questions about the authenticity of the footage. What could have been a strong first step for the new administration at RIM is reduced to wasted time and effort. And the problem is that the credibility of the company is already shot and time is something that RIM might not have much left of.
source: RIM (1), (2), (3)
2. cellphonator posted on 10 Feb 2012, 09:11 2
A BB falls into water, a BB is used by someone. How do I know it's the same device? I want to believe but these videos are just BAD!
3. DannyAves posted on 10 Feb 2012, 11:03 1
I would love to see the same tests done on an iPhone.
4. bvalde09 posted on 11 Feb 2012, 19:36 0
ok first video/ Phone will be useless after bending that much. Whats the point of so much bending if it will be useless after?. Drop Test Second Video. Ok lets go along but if you get the battery out be prepare to waste 5-6 minutes of you life to turn the damn phone on as they take forever to load the OS. 3 Video Seriously??????? agree with @cellphonator