Samsung Galaxy S5 vs Note 3: first look
Samsung lifted the cover off its new ‘big thing’, the Galaxy S5, yesterday, and one thing that it really is is literally bigger. How big? We took the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 to MWC to give you a first look comparison between the new, 5.1-inch Samsung flagship against the 5.7-inch Note 3. Suddenly, the difference between a regular smartphone and a phablet doesn’t seem that big, does it?
The Galaxy S5 is also newer than the Note 3 and while it didn’t get that much-hyped Quad HD 2560 x 1440-pixel display, it packs newer silicon and a brand new 16-megapixel camera with new features. Are these good enough reasons to pick one over the other? Let’s find out.
The Samsung Galaxy S5 brings a fresh new design language with a perforated dimpled back with a soft touch feel. It’s plastic, but nothing like the oft-criticized glossy one on the Galaxy S4 and we actually like its in-hand feel. The Samsung Galaxy Note 3 features a different, faux-leather finish, but the two are similar in their soft touch feel. We’d say that Samsung has learned from its mistake, and while it’s not shooting for the stars with premium materials, both the S5 and the Note 3 look good and feel nice in the hand.
The elephant in the room is clearly the size difference. The difference between phablets and regular smartphones is growing smaller every year, but it’s still noticeable. The Note 3 is much larger and much more awkward to use single-handedly. For ergonomics and single-handed use, the Galaxy S5 is the much better device. Moreover, the Galaxy S5 is ruggedized and protected from water and dust, a feature the Note 3 does not have.
In terms of buttons, you have the lock and volume keys located in the same places on the S5 and Note 3, and they are similarly good - clicky and easy to press. The Galaxy S5, however, adds two new features. The first one is the swipe fingerprint scanner bundled in the home key and the second one is the heart rate monitor below the camera. The heart-rate sensor is a bit finicky and it took a couple of tries to get it to work, while the experience with the fingerprint reader was better. On the flip side, the Note 3 features the S Pen that the S5 obviously lacks.
We have a 5.1” 1080 x 1920-pixel display on the Samsung Galaxy S5 and a 5.7” 1080p one on the Note 3. Samsung has been improving hugely on its AMOLED displays over the years, and the Note 3 already was a step up from all earlier ones with a brighter than usual screen.
The S5 takes that to the next level with a 500-nit bright display (and that’s very bright, great for outdoor use). Colors on the Note 3 were definitely oversaturated and unrealistic, though, and at first sight the S5 is an improvement with better color accuracy. This is just what our eyes are telling us, though - we’ll be looking forward to testing the two displays in more detail soon.
The Galaxy S5 is rocking the latest Android 4.4 KitKat out the gate and that’s great. What’s even more interesting is the new TouchWiz interface that Samsung puts on top of it. It’s revamped with simpler, flatter icons, and has just become more visual - long text lists are replaced with large round icons, and it feels friendlier to first-time users. Samsung is also focusing on health and fitness with a hugely improved S Health application that now not only tracks your steps and movement throughout the day, but also stores data about your heart rate. Samsung still includes its suite of Android applications that we like - apps like the S Calendar, S Notes, File manager and so on. Overall, though, Samsung seems to have focused on less gimmicky software features and more meaningful innovation.
The Galaxy Note 3 will likely get the new interface via a software update, so here the two devices are on par.
Processor and memory
The Note 3 is by no means an old device, but the Galaxy S5 is just fresh off Samsung’s factories and it’s getting the royal treatment with the latest Snapdragon 801 system chip, while the Note 3 has the slightly less powerful Snapdragon 800. The Note 3, however, ships with more RAM - it has 3 gigs, while the S5 only has 2GB.
In real life, both devices run perfectly smoothly, and on the S5 you can notice less of that typical ‘Samsung TouchWiz’ lag. We’ve seen KitKat bring some speed improvements, and hopefully Samsung’s has done the same with its skin. The real technical difference between the two is in the clock speed of the processor - the S5 one runs at up to 2.5GHz, while the Note 3 - at up to 2.3GHz, and the Adreno 330 graphics on the S5 can also run at slightly higher clocks than the (otherwise same) one on the Note 3.
The Galaxy S5 ship with 16GB of Internal storage, while the Note 3 is much more generous when it comes to storage, bringing in 32GB out of the box. Neatly, both devices feature microSD card extension slots, but the Galaxy S5 is the first that we see supporting up 128GB cards (the first 128GB card has just recently been unveiled). At the same time, the Galaxy S5 enforces Google’s new guidelines (limitations) for recording to microSD cards, so it’d be less versatile in this.
Camera is something Samsung was particularly proud of in the Galaxy S5. The new flagship packs a 16-megapixel shooter with a nearly 20% larger sensor than the one on the Note 3. The exact size is 1/2.5” for the sensor on the S5, and 1/3.06” on the Note 3. The Note 3, in contrast, features a 13-megapixel camera.
Samsung has updated and enhanced its camera user interface with new shooting modes and even allows you to download new ones, plus HDR is now not just for still pictures, but for videos as well. Good news is that all of this should be coming to the Note 3 in the very near future.
For video, both handset can record 4K UHD at 30 frames per second, and that’s absolutely mind-blowing - we have seen 4K recordings on the Note 3 and we came away impressed. Samsung also supports a new Selective Focus feature that allows you to pick the area of focus after you capture an image. It’s a bit finnicky, but when it works it can create a neat bokeh effect to pictures. We don’t expect the Selective Focus feature to come to the Note 3, as it might require the new system chip in the S5, but Samsung has not yet denied this officially.
Samsung Galaxy S5 vs Note 3: first look
Still pondering which one you should get, the Samsung Galaxy S5 or the Note 3? Don’t over-analyze it - the Galaxy S5 introduces tons of nice improvements, but they are mostly gradual, so essentially it boils down to you picking the right phone size for you. If you want a larger screen that’s better for reading and watching videos and checking out images, the Note 3 looks like the better choice. For those who value better ergonomics and live the more active life, the Galaxy S5 is clearly a better fit. So which one is it for you?
4. PapaSmurf (Posts: 8093; Member since: 14 May 2012)
Powerhouse vs Powerhouse
1st comment is a troll comment. Not surprised.
9. maherk (Posts: 884; Member since: 10 Feb 2012)
I won't upgrade from my Note 3 for 2 reasons, one is that I am loving the 5.7" screen, and two since I invested so much in it. I got myself 1 white and another black carbon fiber battery doors, leather one, aluminum, and recently I got the tempered glass with champagne gold aluminum sides(check it on ebay, your gonna love it), plus 2 batteries and their charger. Are you planning on upgrading smurf?
19. PapaSmurf (Posts: 8093; Member since: 14 May 2012)
Yup. I made a commitment to myself that I was going to buy the S5, iPhone 6 and Note 4 this year. If the M8 sounds good enough, I might pick that up too.
12. Ashoaib (Posts: 1805; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
Ok for instance its a troll comment, can you plz explain how?
22. androiphone20 (Posts: 1405; Member since: 10 Jul 2013)
Don't bother yourself asking he's just way too sensitive about anything Samsung
23. PapaSmurf (Posts: 8093; Member since: 14 May 2012)
Look who's here! Rehashing the same comments over and over again!
Did you bring my cookies like I asked?
7. nokia12 (Posts: 320; Member since: 19 Nov 2013)
last time samsung paid for fake reviews badmouthing competitors and cheat in benchmarks to sell gs4 don't know what will it do this time with gs5
8. PapaSmurf (Posts: 8093; Member since: 14 May 2012)
Last time Nokia used a pro camera and claimed it was theirs for a commercial.
11. maherk (Posts: 884; Member since: 10 Feb 2012)
If you have CVS close to you, let your dada drive you there and ask for a cure for hemorrhoid.
15. Ashoaib (Posts: 1805; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
S5's back cover looks ugly no matter what we fans of Sammy says... no matter how we bash the criticism
17. Ashoaib (Posts: 1805; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
Samsung will be saving QHD glory for note 4... I hope they will launch note 4 little earlier as well
25. qerimm (Posts: 3; Member since: 24 Feb 2014)
Phonearena got paid from samsung to cover s5 ugly face
30. Ashoaib (Posts: 1805; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
I dont think so... bcoz I were commenting almost something same when they were bragging wonderfulness of iphone 5 & 5s... I think its their job to fully present a top dog although its something called over coverag... but it keep their news section updated
2. networkdood (Posts: 6267; Member since: 31 Mar 2010)
Is it me or this just a poor comparison - a phablet and a smartphone? Is PhoneArena getting desperate now?
5. PapaSmurf (Posts: 8093; Member since: 14 May 2012)
Samsung's flagships (S vs Note) comparison seems logical in my book.
6. JMartin22 (Posts: 848; Member since: 30 Apr 2013)
A phablet is just a big smartphone. It's not like you're comparing it to a tablet.
20. darkkjedii (Posts: 10887; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
How are they getting desperate? It's a great new device vs a great current device form the same maker, it's logical.
3. imyourpapi (Posts: 65; Member since: 04 Jan 2014)
I'd take the note 3 over s5. Can't wait to see what's in tow for the note 4
14. hellonerds (Posts: 207; Member since: 27 Aug 2013)
Yeah I have a note 3.. im sure we will se this on the note 4.. cant wait to get note 4 as im done with my contact with att this year and going back to t mobile. .
16. darkkjedii (Posts: 10887; Member since: 05 Feb 2011)
Awesome combo. Cut yourself with your note 3, and put a galaxy s5Bandaid on it.
21. PorkyBurger (Posts: 217; Member since: 18 May 2013)
Wait, like you can cut yourself with Note 3~?! AWESOME.
24. antonioli (Posts: 173; Member since: 08 Sep 2013)
"the Galaxy S5 introduces tons of nice improvements"?
34. Phonecall01 (Posts: 119; Member since: 02 Apr 2009)
Hulk is pretty strong...But Captain America won't get hurt.
27. ffaarrooqq (Posts: 64; Member since: 26 May 2011)
Samsung please work on design.
S5 back is looking so cheap against note 3.
29. kanagadeepan (Posts: 664; Member since: 24 Jan 2012)
Looking cheap is not the main issue, its looking ugly also...
33. Bioload25 (Posts: 202; Member since: 12 Nov 2012)
I dont think it looks cheap,but undeniably ugly....
Also,how did they manage to make a TALLER,THICKER and HEAVIER device only by incleasing the screen diagonal by 2.5 mm and tossing a bigger battery?? Engineers and designers were fired after the s4 release? --'
28. Jeradiah3 (Posts: 996; Member since: 11 Feb 2010)
I'd still say that the Note 3 is a better phone than the S5. You'd think that the S5 would be larger than the S4......and for it to be only .1in bigger makes no sense to me. SInce the Note 3 has 3GB of RAM, why not have the S5 have the same thing??
I may be one of a few thats not impressed by the debut of the S5, but thats ok because there aren't alot of phones that are better than the Note 3 right now anyway
31. Taters (Posts: 2801; Member since: 28 Jan 2013)
They made it way too big but not as bad as the Z2. That thing is laughable xperia z ultra level of big.
32. itzmando (Posts: 114; Member since: 17 Oct 2011)
The S5 is seriously not attractive at all, seeing those concepts for the next iteration were awesome, but the final product was a disappointment.
Sad to say that Samsung is slipping in staying competitive with design and hardware. I am sure they will sell tons of S5's but I would never upgrade from my Note 3.
I really am waiting for the Note 4 though.
35. Blazers (Posts: 200; Member since: 05 Dec 2011)
I'm actually happy that the S5 doesn't outshine the Note 3. It makes me feel good about my purchase, and none of this new phone envy. I can now patiently wait for the Note 4 without second guessing if I should get an S5 in the meantime.
36. mgerreyn65 (Posts: 2; Member since: 28 Aug 2013)
They have made the design even more uglier, it looks like its getting more bulkier and more wider. They should have tried making this like the Lg G2 as the screen is even less wide with not much of mm left. And also who ever wants to buy a phone please buy the Samsung Galaxy Note 3. Its really better, Trust me. Thanks
37. SebasCvdB (Posts: 3; Member since: 18 Feb 2012)
I was really having high hopes for the GS5 but was less impressed as I was when the GS3 and 4 were announced. I'll stick with my Galaxy Note 3 for now since it's pretty up to par with the GS5 and i'm in no need of a Heart rate monitor or Fingerprint scanner. What I do like is the back cover design though. That's really about it.