Samsung Galaxy S5 takes ice bucket ALS challenge: mocks iPhone, but falls victim to own forgery
0. phoneArena 25 Aug 2014, 02:53 posted on
Samsung seems to have thought that the ALS ice bucket challenge is a great opportunity to promote the water resistance of its Galaxy S5...
This is a discussion for a news. To read the whole news, click here
1. techperson211 (Posts: 961; Member since: 27 Feb 2014)
Nothing beats my Z2 in ice bucket challenge.
4. techperson211 (Posts: 961; Member since: 27 Feb 2014)
No wonder s voice didn't bother to call Sony.
30. itsdeepak4u2000 (Posts: 3428; Member since: 03 Nov 2012)
Mocks iPhone... Poor again iCrap... LOL...
We can cheat anywhere, Sammy is taking pride in this challenge. BTW this could be the normal screenshot or might be widget problem.
40. InspectorGadget80 (Posts: 7005; Member since: 26 Mar 2011)
Nothing beats my Z1 in a ice bucket challenge
47. dushyant (Posts: 94; Member since: 14 Mar 2011)
Nokia 1100 could take on a tsunami, even without wetting its shoes.
49. JC557 (Posts: 1228; Member since: 07 Dec 2011)
And that tsunami was caused by a Nokia 3310 falling into the ocean.
2. frydaexiii (Posts: 1334; Member since: 01 Dec 2011)
Just looks like they had a screenshot up instead of a lockscreen, you can clearly see it swipe to the next picture and the notification bar rolling down. So whats so fake about that? The screen is still awake.
7. Ashoaib (Posts: 2713; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
people are crazy, nerds... thats a simple problem... I downloaded and installed weather widgets on my phone and I had the same problem... weather widget was not updating the time.. lets say if actual time on my notification area is 5:15pm while the time on weather widget might be 4:30pm and it wont update untill I tap on weather widget... I uninstall that weather widget due to this reason... P.S. I dont own any GS5 but I think thats a common problem on some widgets
17. Settings (Posts: 1151; Member since: 02 Jul 2014)
Samsung is clearly cheating. From 64% to 56% battery level in 1 second!
26. frydaexiii (Posts: 1334; Member since: 01 Dec 2011)
Which part of it's a screenshot did you not get? A screenshot takes everything, including the notification bar. Obviously, the screenshot was taken at 2:16 with battery percentage of 64%, then they opened this screenshot at 2:50 while the battery percentage was at 54% and recorded the video. While the ice water was pouring down, it hit the touchscreen and it reacted by slightly swiping the screenshot as well as revealing the real notification bar, this is how the gallery works. So there's no cheating, unless you consider a fake lockscreen to be cheating.
36. Settings (Posts: 1151; Member since: 02 Jul 2014)
Samsung clearly doesnt want to show its flaws. The screen is unresponsive when in water, all the waterproof device does. The flaws? 34 mins after the battery drops 10%. Not so wise to hide its flaws eh?
37. frydaexiii (Posts: 1334; Member since: 01 Dec 2011)
"The screen is unresponsive when in water, all the waterproof device does."
But...the video just showed the image moved when the water hit...So wtf?
"Samsung clearly doesnt want to show its flaws."
So you're telling me if Samsung had used the real lockscreen instead of a screenshot, you still would have known the battery percentage dropped by 10% in 30mins? Are you a jedi?
You're just grasping on straws here...
44. Settings (Posts: 1151; Member since: 02 Jul 2014)
I dunno what they have done in 30 mins to make the battery drop 10%, if they only did was a screen shot or two. Thats like 5hrs battery life. Does S5 got battery management issues?
24. sniper1087 (Posts: 440; Member since: 31 Dec 2011)
did you even bother to etc the video on the notification the time change from 2:16 to 2:50 while the water was falling into the phone.
42. amats69 (Posts: 1222; Member since: 12 Nov 2012)
"P.S. I dont own any GS5 but I think thats a common problem on some widgets"
i dont even encounter such problem with my htc sense 6 clock widget...samsung is so lucky on having you fanboy...coz whatever they do, you still praised/depend them...
45. Ashoaib (Posts: 2713; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
samsung is lucky to have unbiased person who is not its fanboy... who is a fanboy of chinese phones ;)
32. fanboy1974 (Posts: 1313; Member since: 12 Nov 2011)
The phone was in gallery mode viewing a screen shot. When the ice hit the screen it registered as a finger press. You can actually see the picture swipe over when the ice hits. I used a Nexus 7 tab on my motorcycle and just the smallest rain drop would cause a screen touch taking me out of navigation mode. If anything it proves that the phone was on and the transition time from pic to pic is very quick.
And why would Samsung fake it? I've seen the S5 survive a pool drop and washer machine challenge.
9. xperiaDROID (banned) (Posts: 5629; Member since: 08 Mar 2013)
Even though I hate Samsung for using this opportunity to promote their phone, they're not cheating in this video. As you can see in the video, when they pour the water on the phone, you can actually see that the phone swiped itself to the next screenshot due to the water on the screen and the notification bar turned black. So, the 2:16pm lockscreen was actually the screenshot.
27. supa_dupa (Posts: 78; Member since: 21 Dec 2012)
They replaced the damaged phone (due to the ice shower), that's why it is showing different battery level and time. It is just not the same phone...and they need couple of minutes to find a second phone.
35. hurrycanger (Posts: 1492; Member since: 01 Dec 2013)
Haha, for real? It's a water resistant phone, man.
If you have eyes, you should clearly see that the the device was never replaced. Look closely at the water on top of the phone. It was consistent before and after the screenshot moved.
11. jibraihimi (Posts: 710; Member since: 29 Nov 2011)
Didn't we read this news earlier on PA.......????
13. xperiaDROID (banned) (Posts: 5629; Member since: 08 Mar 2013)
No, PA thought that Samsung cheated on this ice bucket challenge so they posted this article.
23. Ashoaib (Posts: 2713; Member since: 15 Nov 2013)
no, I dont think PA necessorily thought that... what I have observed, PA usually come up with the report which is hot in the news and which usually PA users are discussing... this is a good thing to keep your website intractive
19. SemiFinal (Posts: 73; Member since: 26 Jul 2014)
This is also called Lou Goering's disease
22. avirupdas (Posts: 1; Member since: 25 Aug 2014)
it was the lockscreen tht was opened and the image later was the screen shot so it showed different times
25. supa_dupa (Posts: 78; Member since: 21 Dec 2012)
Nokia - connecting people.
HTC - quietly brilliant.
Samsung - always cheating.
28. MINDoSOUL (Posts: 48; Member since: 28 Feb 2014)
I don't understand why is everyone fretting about this, so they didn't shoot the video challenge properly, big deal we all know that S5 and almost every phone can survive the challenge. I am not a fan but u know what it's a very clever idea had they paid attention to detail and execution. you got to love their marketing team.
29. D.Lamore (Posts: 198; Member since: 15 Aug 2014)
I don't understand why apple fans are going crazy all over world about S5 ALS challenge. They said its inhumane what samsung did , but they did the same later even when they know iphone can't resist water, lol. If the time like let it go anti-clockwise, the fact still remains that GS5 is water and dust proof and people can actually proof that at home. But can izombies try that at home?
46. sniper1087 (Posts: 440; Member since: 31 Dec 2011)
even samsung wants you to know that is water resistant not waterproof, the Z2 is overall better in that department. the iPhone is still a good phone that suits the average user as well as some advance users, because it can get the job done, it does not have to be water resistant for the users to want to buy it, there are more accessories that take care of that like life proof off for example.
33. vikas1234 (Posts: 1; Member since: 25 Aug 2014)
The lockscreen actually gives very less time before the screen turns off. Thats why probably they used a screenshot of lockscreen. The ice showed the notification bar and thats how it is i guess.
38. Daytonadave17 (Posts: 54; Member since: 26 Oct 2013)
DONT HATE ON NOKIA WHILE IM SNOWBOARDING AND USING MY OHONE WITH GLOVES ON!! ;-) LOL. DO THAT SAMSUNG! OH WAIT YOU CANT! YOU TOO WORRIED ABOUT PLASTIC PHONES AND WATERPROOF CRAP! LMAO
39. TBomb (Posts: 386; Member since: 28 Dec 2012)
If Samsung was really cheating, dont you think that they wouldve made the catch before airing this? Especially one so obvious?
Also, if the screen did break or got messed up wouldn't they have projected the same image on the phone screen? It can't be that hard to put the lockscreen image in the forground of the video... it's not like the commercial was 30 minutes long.
43. InspectorGadget80 (Posts: 7005; Member since: 26 Mar 2011)
Some people here don't realize Gsv is a water resistant phone. How typical they keep bashing Samsung that the GSV is IP CERTIFIED.
48. hominey_hominey (Posts: 5; Member since: 25 Aug 2014)
I'm going to be that guy, but Steven Hawking does NOT have ALS. He has a related issue, but it is not ALS. 80% of people with ALS die within 5 years of diagnosis. He's been around for a long time.