x PhoneArena is hiring! Reviewer in the USA
  • Options

Samsung Galaxy S5 and HTC One (M8) compared against rivals

0. phoneArena 15 Apr 2014, 02:21 posted on

Two of the most anticipated devices this year, the Samsung Galaxy S5 and HTC One (M8), have arrived with a splash, but are they any better than currently existing top phones?…

This is a discussion for a news. To read the whole news, click here

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 02:24 11

1. Anshulonweb (Posts: 430; Member since: 07 Feb 2014)

well the main competition of these phones is xperia z2...... waiting for detailed comparison between Samsung s5, HTC one and xperia z2...

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 02:46 1

2. Doakie (Posts: 2212; Member since: 06 May 2009)

Is the Z2 going to be released to all carriers or just T-Mobile? I'm yet to hear anything about all carriers. If it's T-Mobile only it won't be competition at all. On paper it will compete, but in the real world your average US citizen will never know it exists. It'll just fade into the background just like the M7 did behind the GS4, only even more so because now it has to even get out of the M8s shadow which isn't very big. Maybe globally it'll make a splash but I have a feeling it won't even make a ripple in the USA.

posted on 17 Apr 2014, 01:38 2

37. 0xFFFF (Posts: 3806; Member since: 16 Apr 2014)

Hopefully Sony can sort out their terrible problems with shipping product. I'm looking forward to finding out if the Z2 has a high quality headphone output. It does have onboard noise cancellation which may be quite useful. More useful than a half baked heart rate monitor, anyway. Maybe the Z2 camera will be better than the Z1. The Z2 got a good review from DXO recently.

The One M8 is a great phone other than the terrible camera. Unfortunately, it is what you get from a company almost out of money with a warehouse full of 4MP sensors.

The S5 is a competent phone, but market/cost engineered too much. Samsung should have put an OIS camera on the phone.

posted on 06 May 2014, 01:11

42. Jinto (Posts: 436; Member since: 15 Jan 2014)

T-Mobile for sure, probably for Verizon too

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 02:49

3. Mr.Torture (Posts: 24; Member since: 15 Apr 2014)

Comparing both phones with old Xperia flagship makes so much sense... Well, at least to Phone Arena. Although Z2 is revealed even much earlier than these phones.
If nothing, it tells us how far Xperia line has gone, compared to, for example, three years ago period. One can only salute to job Sony has done with recent offerings.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 02:58 1

4. v3n0m (Posts: 8; Member since: 01 Mar 2014)

PA. Where is the Sony xperia z2? Don't you guys have one to test? Come on....

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 03:21 3

6. maherk (Posts: 4630; Member since: 10 Feb 2012)

why test it against something that isn't competing in the market at the moment? those tests were published when the S5 and M8 went on sale, their purpose is to help buyers decide what to go for.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 03:16 6

5. PapaSmurf (Posts: 10457; Member since: 14 May 2012)

S5 takes my vote. Only the Note 3 can challenge it.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 03:41 1

7. bodzio1809 (Posts: 357; Member since: 28 Aug 2013)

Often I laugh when I see your comments, but I need to agree that as overall device S5 is the best phone on the market.

I would change only few things on it. Obviously design. It don't look bad, but it don't look very good. Materials aren't bad, but I would pick better quality plastic. Also I would change gimmick heart rate sensor to dual tone led flash.

As more personal opinion I would like bigger screen in the same body (around 5,3') with onscreen buttons and stereo speakers on the front of device. Also I would like to have touch type(iPhone like) fingerprint scanner under screen.
The best thing is that it could happen in premium version. I just hope that they will stay with fullHD.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 04:48 1

13. bodzio1809 (Posts: 357; Member since: 28 Aug 2013)

And this is how S5(F) should look like :D http://imagizer.imageshack.us/a/img836/1539/903e.jpg

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 11:44

25. MamaSmurfy (Posts: 4; Member since: 14 Apr 2014)

I take you

posted on 01 May 2014, 02:11

41. ihavenoname (Posts: 1693; Member since: 18 Aug 2013)


posted on 06 May 2014, 01:12

43. Jinto (Posts: 436; Member since: 15 Jan 2014)

I also laugh when I see his comments

posted on 06 May 2014, 01:13

44. Jinto (Posts: 436; Member since: 15 Jan 2014)


posted on 15 Apr 2014, 03:48 1

8. Karriope (Posts: 103; Member since: 07 Jun 2013)

Regarding the Z2, the probable answer is Pa hasnt got one. Surely you want some honest comparisons of physically in their hands stuff rather then speculation, no?

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 04:03 2

9. gigaraga (Posts: 1454; Member since: 29 Mar 2013)

The Samsung Galaxy S5 is the most balanced device therefore it is the best, next to the Note 3...which on virtually on par with it, while having more functionality. I don't see other smartphone manufacturers producing that solid of a handset like the GS5.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 04:12 6

10. rizevnarastek (Posts: 349; Member since: 06 Sep 2012)

The HTC One M8 is currently the best smartphone out. It's the best jack of all trades. It's exquisite design, those ear pampering BoomSound speakers, it's great feel in hand, it's snappy and clean Sense 6 and that fantastic camera. It would only need a bit bigger screen and wireless charging to be the ultimate, perfect phone. Sadly there is no such thing as perfection.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 04:32 1

11. PapaSmurf (Posts: 10457; Member since: 14 May 2012)

Fantastic camera? M8?

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 07:27 1

16. true1984 (Posts: 829; Member since: 23 May 2012)

to him, smurf, to him.

posted on 18 Apr 2014, 21:26

38. Neo_Huang (Posts: 1067; Member since: 06 Dec 2013)

It is actually the jack of no trades except for audio quality and appearance (I say appearance and not design because the bezels are way too big, it is too slippery and it has on-screen buttons even though it has more than enough space to fit captive buttons). The M7 was much better (compared to the phones of its time).

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 04:44

12. 1ceTr0n (Posts: 549; Member since: 20 May 2012)

Proof that people would prefer a phone that bounces and gets lightly scratched from droppage then a permanently dented $700 tinfoil anchor

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 05:10 3

14. papss (unregistered)

You are assuming it only gets a light scratch but the other gets destroyed? Way to go to the extreme left and right for both.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 07:16

15. dexter_jdr (Posts: 1163; Member since: 28 Jun 2012)

samsung galaxy S5 is like the STABLE version of an android device

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 10:13

19. true1984 (Posts: 829; Member since: 23 May 2012)

i hope you arent basing this on the stability of the s4...

posted on 16 Apr 2014, 03:07

34. dexter_jdr (Posts: 1163; Member since: 28 Jun 2012)

hmm. i think im basing it to all samsung android devices with their videos regarding build quality.... the high-end ones.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 09:00

17. Slammer (Posts: 1515; Member since: 03 Jun 2010)

---"Two of the most anticipated devices this year, the Samsung Galaxy S5 and HTC One (M8), have arrived with a splash."---

This is subjective. The difference of anticipation for both devices is highly dependant on public buzz and hype. While most tech sites were celebrating and salivating on HTC, mainstream consumers have been interested in what the S5 had to offer.

When public demand and interest is far greater than what the tech site's opinions are, all bets are off and articles shouldn't perceive contrary reports by propping up paper tigers.

In short, the anticipation for the HTC was not highly anticpated. The future iphone is. The galaxy S5 is. Two of my friends were leaving Apple to purchase an HTC(M8) only to find out that it didn't offer removable battery that both had grown tired of with the iphone. Both ended up in line with me and all others Friday that waited almost 3 hours in to purchase our new S5s.

This device is a great compilation of what was hyped by Samsung and what was delivered to the consumers waiting for it. Those that want to claim cheap are ignorant of what should be expected out of a device. Samsung nailed another great product. This is coming from someone that hated Samsung and supported HTC for many years.

John B.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 10:12

18. true1984 (Posts: 829; Member since: 23 May 2012)

hold on, i dont know anyone who wanted the gs5 either. i do know a lot of people who were waiting on the m8 though. maybe you dont know anyone who was excited about the m8, but that doesnt meat they didnt exist. and of course the s5 isnt cheap, the 16gb version is $700

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 10:19 2

20. python111 (Posts: 12; Member since: 25 Mar 2014)

Really, really. You actually think S5 is better than M8, Removable battery was the problem?-Hmmm, so you and your buddies got sucked into Lagsung's marketing and opted for S5 instead of an M8 or Z2, buddy, that is your choice but I have to tell you that it is wrong. To lose all the great things both HTC and Sony offer in now 2014 is ridiculous, Galaxy s3, s4 and s5 are practically the same phone, I mean come on change something make it beautiful and make it premium, you pay a lot of money for a cheap thing, if you are a spec junkie you can get oppo and for much less or you can get the following OneplusOne, all great alternatives for a Samsung product. In my view, Iphone 5s Xperia z2 HTC one m7 and M8 are all better than S5 and people should get off the fanboy bandwagon and open their eyes. Samsung is making money off you and yet they do not deliver a premium phone that is worthy of 600+ price. The marketing will fool a lot of people but it won't do so for long, same as HTC was the leader in their prime Samsung will lose their edge and another company will take over, very soon .

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 10:30

21. jellmoo (Posts: 1931; Member since: 31 Oct 2011)

What exactly is the M8 better than the S5 at though? Outside of the boomsound speakers, which are nice, no doubt, what does the M8 actually do better?

Don't get me wrong, I'm no real fan of the S5, but I for the life of me don't see why the M8 is better.

posted on 15 Apr 2014, 10:43 1

22. papss (unregistered)

Geez John.. Get off the removable battery comment. I've NEVER had a battery fail me in all the years of using a phone.. Never.
Also your friends that iPhones didn't have removable batteries before so why was it all of a sudden important?

Want to comment? Please login or register.

Latest stories