Google Play hands your personal info to each developer with every app purchase
0. phoneArena posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:19
Since it appears to be by design, it would not be called a flaw, but does digital media require disclosing personal info...
This is a discussion for a news. To read the whole news, click here
1. Ninetysix posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:27 12 19
Bad Google..bad. Let's hear some comments from the loyal fandroids please.
This is going to be good /popcorn
32. SamsungFan posted on 14 Feb 2013, 20:09 5 1
Anyway Google is not tracking users as the rotten apple did... :-D
50. Mxyzptlk posted on 14 Feb 2013, 23:16 3 7
That was an issue blown out of proportions. This is way worse than that. Your address is being shared with developers whether you consent to it or not. Does that not bother you?
53. Nadr1212 posted on 15 Feb 2013, 00:18 1 1
Stupidity is traveling among Google these days.
60. anywherehome posted on 15 Feb 2013, 06:33 3 0
surprise: I give my personal info to every e-shop when I buy something!
or maybe should I give there fake name and delivery to Alaska?
and in Android I CAN put there fake name ;)
61. anywherehome posted on 15 Feb 2013, 06:52 0 0
this is much much worse: very very poor iToys security:
goo [dot] gl/s8Ykw
14. joey_sfb posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:02 4 0
Good that these is made known. Google do need to justify why delivery address is reveal to developer. It will open us to spam if the developer is a popular one and choose to do so.
17. Mxyzptlk posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:09 6 12
This is getting ridiculous. Google is seriously starting to piss me off with how they handle users' private info. They shouldn't have escaped the FTCs probe with a slap on the wrist if they're doing this. I do not want my gf's info being given out every time she buys an app off the Play store.
42. Jonathan41 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 22:12 3 2
How does it feel to get some thumbs up for a change? Your like the Fox News of phonearena right now. Trying scare everybody by exaggerating on something thats not really a big deal.
69. Berzerk000 posted on 16 Feb 2013, 23:52 0 0
Come on, this is what happens with ANYTHING bought with any form of payment except for cash, and you can't buy apps with cash. This is by no means bringing harm to the consumers, and if it is, please show me something about Android users being harassed by a developer in some way with this information.
39. RaKithAPeiRiZ posted on 14 Feb 2013, 21:39 0 4
not a conspiracy theorist , but i smell that this is a very bad decision...too bad i get most of my apps in apk format
45. jroc74 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 22:44 4 0
Funny...I get the same info about the developer....except a real name. Some cases I do. Whats the problem again?
Hey, do any of you have a credit card? Bank card? Ever buy something on Xbox Live, PSN?
Ever buy anything online?
Have a Paypal or Ebay account? Ever sold anything on Ebay? Ever used Paypal to buy or sell something?
Its called....a merchant...account. Geniuses.
54. Nadr1212 posted on 15 Feb 2013, 00:21 0 4
And thi s is called VIRTUAL purchases that probably wont b delivered to your door, GENIUS!
58. jroc74 posted on 15 Feb 2013, 06:21 2 0
If thats the case.......GENIUS....why do I get the developers address and email info...and in some cases their real name...in my transaction info?
Or did you NOT read the very first line in my post?
You must have never bought anything online before...its possible.
55. Topcat488 posted on 15 Feb 2013, 01:19 0 0
If you don't know by now, let it be known... Google has been rumored too be a illumi-nutty participant... And NWO New World Order... It's FREE, the App is FREE... Think about it, now install the App, and get in line. ^(T-T)^ Big Brothers Watching.
illuminate : illumi-nutty
2. Sniggly posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:29 10 8
The question is: what can be done with this information? The answer: nothing explicitly harmful. I don't know why such information is provided to devs, but it's not like it's being publicized.
In short, I'm not fond of this action by Google, but it's not the worst thing I could hear about them.
7. lolioslol (banned) posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:33 8 3
Because people are f*cking retarded when it comes to their personal info. I have had people refuse to give me the last four of their soc so I can look at their acct to upgrade their phone/add a line/even just access it. It's like
"hey dipsh*t you gave us the info when you started the account, what's the problem? I couldn't do anything with that info if I wanted to, and f*ck you for the implication!"
13. UrbanPhantom posted on 14 Feb 2013, 17:40 6 4
So, your information is being doled out to an infinite number of so called developers, some of which are probably not even legit, and you don't think it's a problem? I guess Android users are so accustomed to having their data stolen they don't get bothered anymore ;o)
35. Droid_X_Doug posted on 14 Feb 2013, 20:45 1 1
The information is not doled out to all developers. Only those you have purchased an app from. Or visited their app page. If you don't want information shared while you are visiting a developers app page (but before purchasing), don't log into the Play store and use anonymous browsing.
19. Mxyzptlk posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:11 4 6
Sniggly why do you continue to defend controversial actions like this? Have you forgotten how many rogue apps have made it into the Play Store? Imagine all of that personal info leaking out into the hands of a crook.
They only need a few pieces to commit fraud.
You need to see past your preference to Google and see the huge wrong here.
22. samystic posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:32 3 6
so much for 100000+ apps bragging by fandroids... most of them are rogue and useless
25. VZWuser76 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:05 2 1
Have any proof to back up that claim? I'm not saying Google is in the right here, far from it. But as someone else said, it's not any different than any other time you buy something over the phone or internet with your credit card. They may have a reputation to maintain, but that doesn't mean they can't or won't do it. Hell, all it would take is one disgruntled employee who takes down your number and your bank account is lower.
But to make a claim that most apps on the play store are rogue is baseless. Are there some that are? Sure, but does that mean that most are? I don't know and neither do you. If you were to make baseless claims like that about a group of people, it's called slander.
While I don't like that they're doing this, the only ways to effect change would be to 1. Not buy apps, 2. Start a petition, or 3. Contact the BBB or your elected officials. And if you think that Google is the only company doing this, your in denial. Along with them are Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft, & even Apple. The amount of info they have may vary, as is the amount they share. But if you were able to determine what they actually have on you, you'd be surprised, and probably frightened and angry as well.
26. VZWuser76 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:16 4 0
Here is a screenshot of what the developer receives when someone buys their app. As you can see, it's no different than what any merchant would get when you purchase over the internet. And as someone else in that comment section said, the only anonymous way to buy anymore is with cash. If you use a check, money order, credit card, bank transfer, etc., they will have at least that amount of info. Even using paypal, they still get your name, address (to ship the product to), and your email. So if this really turns you away from dealing with Google, you better only purchase your stuff with cash in a physical store.
Here's the screenshot:
46. jroc74 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 22:47 1 0
How do ppl that buy things online think its done, magic fairy dust?
Do they somehow thing iOS devs ...dont...hve access to the same info? Either the iOS devs do....or Apple does...one or the other.
47. samystic posted on 14 Feb 2013, 22:55 0 1
rogue??? please read the news again... and i m not selectively mentioning anything
useless??? please generate a list of 10 apps that are required everyday (irrespective whether you have internet connection or no)... i do not consider games as apps... so please deduct 50% from that list
52. VZWuser76 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 23:43 1 0
You called the apps rogue in your comment, saying that most of the apps in the playstore were "rogue and useless". When I said baseless (not useless), I meant that you had no proof of your claim that MOST of the apps are rogue and useless.
As far as the apps being useful or not is irrelevant. What's useful to you may not be to me, and vice versa. In reality, NO apps in ANY app store (Google's, Apple's, Microsoft's, Blackberry's, etc.) are NECESSARY for everyday. That implies that a person can't survive the day without them. And there is not a SINGLE app that will mean someone dying if they don't use it.
ALL I was saying was that you had no proof of your claims. It would be no different than me saying that most people from New York are rude. I can make the claim but I have no proof that it's true. Unless you can show me facts that say that over 50% of Play Store apps are rogue, you are making a baseless claim. Anything else is your opinion, which like a**holes, everyone has one.
30. D_Tech-tive posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:49 0 0
Most are the same apps on Apple but at least most we don't have to pay for.
If most were rogue or useless there wouldn't be no Android Eco system you see today which covers more phones and people than Apple.
Android fans don't just accept stuff like Ifollowers cause Apple says so.
My apps work fine! Now I have come across some that didn't work properly but that happens when you have so many different phones with different specs using the same software.
Not a problem for Apple since choice is VERY limited to say the least!
24. Sniggly posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:01 4 1
Did I defend the move? No I didn't. I just noted that the danger is relatively minimal.
27. Mxyzptlk posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:22 1 6
I detect a hint of denial in your comment.
28. Sniggly posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:34 4 2
And I detect hypocrisy in yours.
38. Mxyzptlk posted on 14 Feb 2013, 21:39 0 5
I detect backtracking in yours.
57. techtruth posted on 15 Feb 2013, 03:46 0 0
4. dsDoan posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:32 4 3
I don't know why devs are sent this info, but if you gave permission when you agreed to the ToS, then Google hasn't done anything wrong.
23. NexusKoolaid posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:46 2 2
Illegal and wrong are two different things. The ToS gives them legal protection, but still doesn't make this a good idea.
74. donked posted on 20 Feb 2013, 15:28 0 0
They have to be able to provide proof of purchase. No different than paypal.
5. Android4u posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:33 5 2
6. Tele7 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:33 2 4
Since the apps always warn about what it can use from the personal datas, I don't care what else the developer get. What can they do? Nothing big, why would a developer mess with my, little ant citizen's information anyway?
34. joey_sfb posted on 14 Feb 2013, 20:37 2 0
Do you see what i see? Apple fan boys in full force. Most of them might not use Android device to begin with.
9. appanji posted on 14 Feb 2013, 16:50 2 5
thanks to illegal apps, so google can kizz my azz getting my info, all my apps and downloaded outside :), so as long as u dont pay for the apps, ur info is safe.. NICE !!!
15. joey_sfb posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:06 1 2
Yup! Good luck to you, that how 99% of android device get infected by malware.
Besides, those information is hardly detail enough compare to your stealing everything about you through a trojan horse
10. jdubis posted on 14 Feb 2013, 17:03 2 2
Its for legal reasons. This information is needed in the event of a lawsuit or patent infringment case. For example look at instagram.
11. Owlet posted on 14 Feb 2013, 17:12 4 3
You know what, when I go and buy something in a store, they have A LOT more information about me than just my name and email. They have my credit card numbers, my address, my name, my telephone number, depending on what I buy, they also have my SS number.
Maybe we're being a little overexcited here?
12. UrbanPhantom posted on 14 Feb 2013, 17:32 2 4
Nice comparison, but not quite, as the majority of companies have something called a reputation to protect. Small time developers are not exactly a trusted source, comprende? Scrawl your personal info and credit card numbers on the seat of a city transit bus, and then you'll begin to understand..
16. joey_sfb posted on 14 Feb 2013, 18:08 3 1
The screen shot does not show credit card information to developers. Are you sure about what you are saying?
49. jroc74 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 23:15 1 1
Yea....it never said credit card info. Another example of this guy....not posting facts..but posting...something else.
The article said name, address, and email address.
29. jacko1977 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 19:48 1 0
i dont see anything wrong ? can someone point out where the problems are ?
31. UrbanPhantom posted on 14 Feb 2013, 20:05 0 2
Relax: there is no problem! Now please excuse me while I use your name, addy, and banking info to distribute fake cheques ;o)
48. jroc74 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 22:57 1 0
If people are paranoid of people having name, addy and banking info from purchases from your smartphone or website....they better not buy anything online.
Better not buy anything from iTunes...or buy iOS games. No matter what OS or platform you use, desktop or mobile.....there is a chance for wrong doing with your info.
51. jroc74 posted on 14 Feb 2013, 23:17 0 0
Btw....this article is about name, address and email adress. Not credit info, Not banking info.
Nice try trying to add extra fuel to the article tho.
65. UrbanPhantom posted on 15 Feb 2013, 11:23 0 1
The reality is that Android is inherently insecure, and personal data is being hijacked and stolen on a regular basis without the knowledge of the victims...
The only fuel being added is by diehard Android fans attempting to defend irresponsible or negligent actions by Google and individual Android developers.
68. jroc74 posted on 15 Feb 2013, 17:13 0 0
So....every body that uses Ebay and pay pal...are irresponsible?
I suggest you sell something on Ebay...and try to have this conversation again. I'm pretty sure there are ways Google can take the necessary steps in case any wrong doing happens...just like with Ebay. You can put your bank and credit card info in a site you think is fine....only to have fraud happen.
But thanks for being concerned about Android users... :/
73. donked posted on 20 Feb 2013, 15:25 0 0
Your point is that SE linux is insecure? Is that where you're going with this? Is it any less than secure than having your iPhone decrypt itself? Or how about the program that decrypts iCloud information? Is that less secure?
Users make the devices insecure. And as far as I know both apple and android both have users. And to a large extent the applications are the same across both platforms.
72. donked posted on 20 Feb 2013, 15:21 0 0
You're using Google wallet when you purchase through the Play store. Which in turn creates a virtual cc number. Nice try though. Even if they wanted to try and rip you off they wouldn't be able to. On top of which CC info is not delivered, only enough information to show proof of sale. This is no different than paypal. Not even in the slightest. What's even more interesting about these apple fanboys is that they troll posts like this when they bought their macbook on ebay, using paypal, because the industry standard hardware was to too expensive to buy new. Congrats even account on ebay definitely has a reputation to uphold, certainly wouldn't be ANY malice there.