Facebook's Joe Hewitt disagrees with Android's openness claim
In the developing debate between Apple's Steve Jobs and Google's Andy Rubin, the two parties are now debating the definition of an open OS. Jobs claimed that Google was using the 'open' moniker to justify their supposedly scattered and inconsistent presence. Rubin then tweeted that their OS is indeed open because the source is available for download.
Hewitt isn't convinced. He argues that the Android OS can't be called an open OS, because the code isn't available until the release. He says that if it really were open, then we would be able to monitor and provide input on the OS as it developed.
Hewitt cites Linux and his own Firefox browser as true examples of open systems. In these, the community shares control with the developers, rather than waiting to have access to a pre-packaged product.
Regarding the debate between Apple and Google, Hewitt tweeted the following: "Point I am trying to make is, Rubin bickering with Jobs is a farce, because both refuse to share the one thing that matters: control."
It seems that Hewitt isn't necessarily complaining about the implementation of Android, but is merely disagreeing with their definition of 'open'. TechCrunch keenly points out that his impatience for upcoming OS codes might be related to his role in developing the next version of Facebook for Android.
1. messiah posted on 20 Oct 2010, 10:46 0 0
"Rubin bickering with Jobs is a farce, because both refuse to share the one thing that matters: control."
2. Juan (unregistered) posted on 20 Oct 2010, 13:58 0 0
Anyway, as a developer I love the Android aproach, I hate the Apple aproach and I can not use the Mozilla one.
I should spend a lot of money to develop for Apple. I do not need to much hard-soft to develp for Android and I can NOT do anything with bare Linux or a Mozilla browser.
Open?, Free?...... Android WORKS.... that's all.
3. InJuxHurYlem posted on 20 Oct 2010, 14:44 0 0
Firefox ceding control to the community has left it with shrinking market share as Google's Chrome grows.